Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Military conscription

662 replies

Donotpanicoknowpanic · 09/01/2026 10:25

There is lots of talk about if ww3 happens then military conscription will happen

This is basically people who sit in an office safely saying we need to either send ourselves or out children to fight and die in horrible conditions

Am I unreasonable to think that anyone who thinks this is a good idea

They should be the first ones to sign up and to lead by example

Any politicians who think this is a good idea, there children should be the first to go

Russia is literally sending troops in wheel chairs and crunches to the front line

So age, disability and gender will not be a problem for anyone who supports any conscription policy's, they can go first

Also the UK will not be invaded, we are not Ukrainian, If we were more like Ukraine I would be more in favour of this as the country itself is under threat

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Loopylalalou · 23/01/2026 15:36

moonlitmeadow · 09/01/2026 11:33

I wouldn’t fight for this government, I’ve seen how they treat war veterans.

You wouldn’t be fighting for this government, you’d be part of the fight against an oppressor, a challenge to this nation’s national identity and a threat to your life, or at best, being able to continue living a life as you choose.
People are so naive it beggars belief. As if they’d be able to exercise any choice in accepting or rejecting a military threat. Grow up.

Tinnybinnylinny · 23/01/2026 14:37

Donotpanicoknowpanic · 09/01/2026 14:28

That sounds like a very poor excuse

Russia is sending people on crutches and wheelchairs

And it's people like you I am referring to

At least I am being honest

You criticise other people and expect someone else to go in your place

But then refuse to go yourself

You talk about sending other people

But when it comes to it, you personally would run and hide

Why is your life more precious than your neighbours?

Age is not an excuse.....ask Russia

I have no strong feelings either way.

just on the wheelchair and crutches point, won’t the wheelchairs get stuck in the mud? Surely this is a liability? Do you have verified images to share.

I am not being obstructive - genuinely would like to see pictures!

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:36

Carla786 · 23/01/2026 14:29

I think I read many Russians came to Donbas when sent by Russia some years ago, with a view to enabling annexation?

What I’m saying is that lots of native Ukrainians speak Russian as a first language - for example, Zelenskyy. This is about Ukrainian adults who have lived their entire lives in Ukraine and who grew up speaking Russian. I’m not talking about Russians sent by Putin to live in Ukraine, speak Russian and Russify it.

LlttledrummergirI · 23/01/2026 14:35

Carla786 · 23/01/2026 14:28

The point is more what will happen if he wins Ukraine. Will Poland be next?

They are very brave but Russia has far more numbers & a lot of war resources left.

He won't and Russia don't.

Sanctions are starting to take effect and the death toll is high.

Despite what his best buddy Trump is doing, the rest of the allies are sound.

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:34

LlttledrummergirI · 23/01/2026 14:32

He won't go anywhere else fo now because thanks to the bravery of Ukraine, it's leaders but most importantly it's soldiers Russia managed 40meters a day in it's effort to invade. That's why the cowards in Russia particularly the leadership are bombing homes and energy infrastructure.

Its why Trump gets on so well with Putin- two shit back cowards together.

I agree he won’t go anywhere else for now.

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:33

Carla786 · 23/01/2026 14:28

The point is more what will happen if he wins Ukraine. Will Poland be next?

They are very brave but Russia has far more numbers & a lot of war resources left.

He’s very, very far from winning Ukraine though.

LlttledrummergirI · 23/01/2026 14:32

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:21

Which country are you in? I don’t think Putin will go any further than what he’s currently doing for now because he is so focused on Ukraine. I have no idea though - I’m just an interested bystander and not any kind of military specialist. What do you think Putin will do?

He won't go anywhere else fo now because thanks to the bravery of Ukraine, it's leaders but most importantly it's soldiers Russia managed 40meters a day in it's effort to invade. That's why the cowards in Russia particularly the leadership are bombing homes and energy infrastructure.

Its why Trump gets on so well with Putin- two shit back cowards together.

Carla786 · 23/01/2026 14:29

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:19

I don’t understand what you’re trying to say.

The reason why lots of Ukrainians speak Russian as a first language is because Ukraine and Russia used to be part of the same nation (the USSR). Putin is wrongly using that to justify invading Ukraine.

England is not invading Scotland right now and saying it can because lots of Scottish people speak English.

I think I read many Russians came to Donbas when sent by Russia some years ago, with a view to enabling annexation?

Carla786 · 23/01/2026 14:28

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:21

Which country are you in? I don’t think Putin will go any further than what he’s currently doing for now because he is so focused on Ukraine. I have no idea though - I’m just an interested bystander and not any kind of military specialist. What do you think Putin will do?

The point is more what will happen if he wins Ukraine. Will Poland be next?

They are very brave but Russia has far more numbers & a lot of war resources left.

Carla786 · 23/01/2026 14:27

Natsku · 23/01/2026 06:15

Its not about being brave, its knowing there's no alternative, and there really isn't - only the rich and well connected will be able to flee if widespread war breaks out in Europe, and at some point even they won't be able to.

I'm not advocating migrating just when war breaks out, of course that would not be possible.

What I'm saying is that people should monitor the situation and assess whether immigration to a country less likely to be involved is a better option if it appears to be escalating and they are able to do so. At the moment this is not the case but our forces and government do seem very concerned about the possibility for conflict.

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:21

Natsku · 23/01/2026 13:20

For the time being isn't very reassuring when Russia is building up its troops near your border and is constantly engaged in hybrid warfare and keeps cutting communications cables. We're already at war with Russia really, just not a physical one. Yet.

Which country are you in? I don’t think Putin will go any further than what he’s currently doing for now because he is so focused on Ukraine. I have no idea though - I’m just an interested bystander and not any kind of military specialist. What do you think Putin will do?

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 14:19

SerendipityJane · 23/01/2026 13:49

Lots of Scottish people speak English.

I don’t understand what you’re trying to say.

The reason why lots of Ukrainians speak Russian as a first language is because Ukraine and Russia used to be part of the same nation (the USSR). Putin is wrongly using that to justify invading Ukraine.

England is not invading Scotland right now and saying it can because lots of Scottish people speak English.

notimagain · 23/01/2026 13:58

@JennyWren5

In terms of Ukraine being ‘Russian land’, it was of course part of the USSR

It was...but of course the USSR doesn't = Russia.

I think in the opinion of many (certainly the likes of historians/regional experts in the west such Timothy Snyder) what Putin is after is a land grab, dressed up as restoring the Russian empire to it's former glory..but I do agree that doesn't justify what he is doing.

SerendipityJane · 23/01/2026 13:49

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 13:45

What do you think will happen? Do you think Putin will invade Poland?

In terms of Ukraine being ‘Russian land’, it was of course part of the USSR. That is why Putin can say it was ‘Russian land’ and also why many Ukrainians speak Russian as a first language. I, and plenty of others, don’t agree with Putin that this justifies him invading it now though.

Lots of Scottish people speak English.

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 13:45

notimagain · 23/01/2026 12:20

Not convinced but I do know there will be some who will object quite strongly to the idea that Ukraine was ever "Russian land".

Edited

What do you think will happen? Do you think Putin will invade Poland?

In terms of Ukraine being ‘Russian land’, it was of course part of the USSR. That is why Putin can say it was ‘Russian land’ and also why many Ukrainians speak Russian as a first language. I, and plenty of others, don’t agree with Putin that this justifies him invading it now though.

SerendipityJane · 23/01/2026 13:25

Natsku · 23/01/2026 13:20

For the time being isn't very reassuring when Russia is building up its troops near your border and is constantly engaged in hybrid warfare and keeps cutting communications cables. We're already at war with Russia really, just not a physical one. Yet.

I don't really think 250,000 dead means you are building up troops so much as just replacing them, With lower quality ....

Natsku · 23/01/2026 13:20

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 12:16

He’s shown an interest in other countries besides Ukraine, but I don’t think he’ll invade them for the time being because he’s so focused on trying to get Ukraine.

For the time being isn't very reassuring when Russia is building up its troops near your border and is constantly engaged in hybrid warfare and keeps cutting communications cables. We're already at war with Russia really, just not a physical one. Yet.

SerendipityJane · 23/01/2026 13:19

notimagain · 23/01/2026 12:20

Not convinced but I do know there will be some who will object quite strongly to the idea that Ukraine was ever "Russian land".

Edited

Scotland was at one point a lot more "English" than it is today ....

SerendipityJane · 23/01/2026 13:18

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 12:13

Do you mean by this that he wants to expand Russia as much as possible? I agree, but I think he wants to focus on taking former Russian land (e.g. Ukraine, to start with) rather than just occupying as many of Russia’s bordering countries as possible.

The 1725 version

Military conscription
MO0N · 23/01/2026 12:48

notimagain · 23/01/2026 12:42

FWIW The latest HMG bright idea of pushing post service reserve commitment out to age 60 has met with howls of "you've got kidding me" (well, actually stronger language than that) by many who have served or are serving.

It might work for some enabling roles - MT driver, medic, admin, if working in the rear echelons but by 60 many peoples' eyes/hips/knees aren't really up to running around for hours on doing end doing the sort of stuff the military, especially the army, sometimes needs doing..

Thank you.
Don't get me wrong I would rather sacrifice my life than see my children slaughtered. But I'm not going to be much use in a fight at 60.

notimagain · 23/01/2026 12:42

MO0N · 23/01/2026 12:29

So you think that if it all kicks off we should send the oldest people, the ones who are least able to fight effectively?

Edited

FWIW The latest HMG bright idea of pushing post service reserve commitment out to age 60 has met with howls of "you've got kidding me" (well, actually stronger language than that) by many who have served or are serving.

It might work for some enabling roles - MT driver, medic, admin, if working in the rear echelons but by 60 many peoples' eyes/hips/knees aren't really up to running around for hours on doing end doing the sort of stuff the military, especially the army, sometimes needs doing..

MO0N · 23/01/2026 12:29

EmeraldShamrock000 · 23/01/2026 12:23

I doubt anyone thinks this is a good idea and hopefully it won’t be a necessary one.
If it happens they should start at 60 year olds and move backwards, I’m 46 I’d prefer that my children and other young people were spared.

So you think that if it all kicks off we should send the oldest people, the ones who are least able to fight effectively?

notimagain · 23/01/2026 12:26

Most 60 year olds don't tend to wear very well in combat roles.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 23/01/2026 12:23

I doubt anyone thinks this is a good idea and hopefully it won’t be a necessary one.
If it happens they should start at 60 year olds and move backwards, I’m 46 I’d prefer that my children and other young people were spared.

notimagain · 23/01/2026 12:20

JennyWren5 · 23/01/2026 12:15

Yes, I did address your point. You said in your post: you're ruling out any possibility of Russia …. invading Poland. I said I’m not sure why Russia would invade Poland. If Russia can’t take Ukraine successfully, why would they invade Poland? It makes no sense. They’d just be setting themselves up to fail.

EDIT: I don’t think Putin will invade the Baltic states either, partly because they’re very prepared for an invasion - which is a disadvantage to Putin - and also because Putin won’t want to spread himself thinly by invading other countries whilst also trying to take Ukraine. If he still hasn’t conquered Ukraine after almost 4 years of fighting, there’s not a chance in hell he can hope to take it whilst also invading Poland and/or the Baltic states.

Edited

Not convinced but I do know there will be some who will object quite strongly to the idea that Ukraine was ever "Russian land".