Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop DS changing his registered carer from me to his GF?

113 replies

Agiraffecalledbow · 06/01/2026 19:00

Pretty much that.
Ds stays at his GFs family home two nights a week. The rest of the time he is home. He has a learning disability and autism.
There has been suggestion recently that GF become his registered carer so that GF can claim carers allowance because she is on on a low income and getting few hours at work. To be transparent apart from accompanying DS on the odd day out and attending one appointment I am doing everything, all forms, all admin, all his household stuff, all appointments, all correspondance with medical teams and the usual things carers do.

AIBU to refuse to remove myself from registered carer unless GF is willing to do all the care he actually needs?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BrokenSunflowers · 07/01/2026 21:30

DiaryofaProvincialLady · 07/01/2026 21:17

Even when he is not here he is constantly messaging me for assistance with things and i am still sorting his things at home.

From tomorrow, message back EVERY TIME and say get GF to do it

If the GF isn’t doing it then she isn’t caring for him and he needs safeguarding not being abandoned.

DiaryofaProvincialLady · 07/01/2026 21:17

Agiraffecalledbow · 06/01/2026 19:21

22 and 26 (GF is the older one).
They have been together around 15 months. No reason she cannot get more hours.

Between their time spent at GF house and her being here they probably do spend 35 hours together (just) if you could hours at night when they are asleep. Actual caring though no. Even when he is not here he is constantly messaging me for assistance with things and i am still sorting his things at home.

DS has started telling me she is going to appointments with him instead of me (which I have zero issue with) but that does not equate to 35 hours of care.

Even when he is not here he is constantly messaging me for assistance with things and i am still sorting his things at home.

From tomorrow, message back EVERY TIME and say get GF to do it

rainonfriday · 07/01/2026 15:06

Agiraffecalledbow · 07/01/2026 06:22

This is the exact situation I am in. Residential Care is an absolute not a chance.
Supported living has been discussed but we have been told it takes years.
We currently have weekly learning disability team appointments at home working on independence and equipment to help with daily living

He is desperate to move out which I understand.

As ever, once he's actually suffering, he'll become a higher priority. An option is for them to move out to a place living together, her to become his carer. When the relationship inevitably goes tits up due to her neglecting him and he becomes homeless, that supported living place will come around a lot quicker when they realise he's a liability in a hostel/b&b/flat. They don't like their properties razed to the ground and will look to prevent that, in a way they won't when it's your home at risk. You'd have to harden your heart and let it happen though. Because obviously everyone will be pushing for you to give up whatever job you've taken on to have him live with you and become his carer again.

but could you still receive the carers allowance, but pay the girlfriend for the hours of care she does?

Not out of the carer's allowance. It's about £80/wk. Min wage is about £12/hr plus employers NI contributions etc. Or she'd have to register as a business to do it freelance on a self-employed basis.

Social services aren't likely to assess him as needing that help because they know he has OP as his official carer. If they did by some miracle assess him as needing a few hours more care, they'd not be willing to pay for someone who's doing it cash-in-hand illegally.

So if OPs DS wanted to unofficially employ her as his carer for a few hours a week, he'd have to do that out of his own income (his PIP etc).

Grumpiest2026 · 07/01/2026 14:54

My sibling has LDs and autism and lived with my mum until her death. She was his full time carer. He has a history of setting fires, which was fully documented with social services. I used to report literally every time he had put himself and mum at risk. You had to be on your best game at all times to stop him letting strangers into the house or causing danger. When mum died social services wanted him to continue living alone but with 4 visits a day from carers. It was only when I said that the house was going to be uninsurable and that the council would have to insure it, and the neighbouring houses for when they burnt down that the situation was taken seriously.

so no. I don’t think the girlfriend should become his carer. It’s a huge responsibility

BruFord · 07/01/2026 13:59

Given your updates about her housing situation @Agiraffecalledbow I.e., she lives with her parents, I can see how impossible it will be for her to be his carer.

At first, I wondered whether he wanted to move in with her, but I assume that’s unlikely to be possible- so as others are saying, how can she provide all his care? You’ll still be doing the majority as he’ll be living with you.

Even the suggested trial run isn’t really possible if he’s living with you -unless she moves in and you’re able to resist helping out- I doubt that you want her moving in!

BrokenSunflowers · 07/01/2026 12:29

Bombinia · 07/01/2026 10:36

I think you should start by just saying "she doesn't provide you with 35 hours of care and you are living with me and I do, so we can't change it at the moment".

Don't say no, just say it's not possible because of the fact he lives with you so you do the care which qualifies.

If he wants her to do it then they need to live together but I wouldn't suggest that, just keep saying "but you live here and I provide the care so it's me who is eligible".

I suspect from what you've said it's impossible for them to live together so that should end the discussion.

And if they do think they can live together then you can support him to look into that.

I'm carer for my daughter and this is what I would do

Edited

I agree this is what OP should say/do, except I wouldn’t mention the 35 hours as even if she manages to scrape in at 35 hours (which she would then aim for) OP will still be doing the majority of care.

BrokenSunflowers · 07/01/2026 12:25

If he lacks capacity (you can have capacity in some respects but not others) then he would need a guardian to make decisions on his behalf. Unless OP applies for this through the courts it would by default be social work. An advocate could help him make his views known to SW but SW would make the decisions.

BillieWiper · 07/01/2026 12:11

twinklystar23 · 07/01/2026 11:00

There's a huge imbalance of power. Often seen in abusive relationships. Of course a non- disabled person could date a person with a disability. However OPs son has LD, his capacity to understand complex issues if this is the case makes him highly vulnerable.

He needs the social worker to assign an independent advocate to support him to make a decision in his best interests.

Yeah I guess if that's severe. It could be abusive. I hope it isn't.

MaloryJones · 07/01/2026 11:33

Mumtobabyhavoc · 06/01/2026 19:05

Grifter comes to mind. I'd be worried for ds.

Absolutely this ^

Shinyandnew1 · 07/01/2026 11:12

He is desperate to move out which I understand.

What possibilities for moving out are there? Could he move in with her?

If so, then I'd consider it.

Do you think she loves him?

twinklystar23 · 07/01/2026 11:00

BillieWiper · 07/01/2026 10:40

You can't see how a non disabled person could date a disabled one?

There's a huge imbalance of power. Often seen in abusive relationships. Of course a non- disabled person could date a person with a disability. However OPs son has LD, his capacity to understand complex issues if this is the case makes him highly vulnerable.

He needs the social worker to assign an independent advocate to support him to make a decision in his best interests.

BillieWiper · 07/01/2026 10:40

TakeALookAtTheseSwatches · 06/01/2026 22:32

I don't see how someone with a learning disability so bad that they need 35 hours of care from someone per week can be in a consensual relationship with someone who doesn't also have a LD, sounds like he's massively being taken advantage of.

You can't see how a non disabled person could date a disabled one?

Bombinia · 07/01/2026 10:36

I think you should start by just saying "she doesn't provide you with 35 hours of care and you are living with me and I do, so we can't change it at the moment".

Don't say no, just say it's not possible because of the fact he lives with you so you do the care which qualifies.

If he wants her to do it then they need to live together but I wouldn't suggest that, just keep saying "but you live here and I provide the care so it's me who is eligible".

I suspect from what you've said it's impossible for them to live together so that should end the discussion.

And if they do think they can live together then you can support him to look into that.

I'm carer for my daughter and this is what I would do

BrokenSunflowers · 07/01/2026 10:34

BernardButlersBra · 07/01/2026 09:08

If it goes ahead then it's fraud. Plus l would make clear to them both she will have to do the actual caring and you won't be doing it anymore. So no more responding to the numerous messages, taking to appointments etc

It is mostly not about appointments and paperwork, it is doing his washing (or overseeing him doing it), cooking his meals (or overseeing him etc), ensuring he has adequate clothes, ensure his hygiene is up to scratch - making sure he washes and changes his clothes, keeping him safe minute to minute, making sure he is not the victim of mate crime or other scams, just day to day stuff. The sort of stuff you do with a five year old child. The sort of stuff OP won’t be able to opt out of as long as he lives in her home,

BrokenSunflowers · 07/01/2026 10:28

Carycach4 · 07/01/2026 08:34

Im not sure what you mean by 'refuse' to relinquish your position as his carer? He's an adult, it's not your choice to make?

It is not clear if he has the capacity to make those decisions. I suspect he has no idea what it would mean for OP to cease to care for him.

BrokenSunflowers · 07/01/2026 10:19

rainonfriday · 07/01/2026 00:39

The problem is, if he can't be left at home alone due to being a fire risk then he's realistically looking at residential care. And as a high functioning person the chances of him getting that is almost zero. There'd probably have to actually be a serious house fire first for the risk to be accepted. Social services might give him some support in addition to what he already has for his work placement, but they aren't going to provide enough support hours that he's supervised 24/7 regardless of whether that's via direct payments or direct provision.

If he's living in OPs home she literally can't relinquish caring duties if nobody else adequately takes over, regardless of whether she's being paid as carer or not. She'd be leaving herself and her home at risk of death/destruction, by fire, if she did.

The OPs DS has learning disability which would mean he is low functioning autistic - functioning levels are often misunderstood but refer to IQ. ‘High functioning’ means normal or high IQ not the impact of autism.

BernardButlersBra · 07/01/2026 09:08

If it goes ahead then it's fraud. Plus l would make clear to them both she will have to do the actual caring and you won't be doing it anymore. So no more responding to the numerous messages, taking to appointments etc

LilyBunch25 · 07/01/2026 08:37

Carycach4 · 07/01/2026 08:34

Im not sure what you mean by 'refuse' to relinquish your position as his carer? He's an adult, it's not your choice to make?

Because OP is providing the care currently, not the GF, and if GF is not able to meet the caring criteria she should not be claiming in her own right as doing so, and OP is not confident that she will.

Carycach4 · 07/01/2026 08:34

Im not sure what you mean by 'refuse' to relinquish your position as his carer? He's an adult, it's not your choice to make?

LilyBunch25 · 07/01/2026 08:19

stichguru · 07/01/2026 07:45

I guess if you had a younger child and worked, you wouldn't have to divert your child benefit to their nursery or childminder, but you'd still have to pay fees. I don't know if you could do this legally, or how easy it would be, but could you still receive the carers allowance, but pay the girlfriend for the hours of care she does? That way the hours that she's caring she'd get paid, but you would still have the benefit and control it. If they do end up being together long term, and if you were gradually paying her more and more, because she was taking on more and more for DS, you could eventually stop claiming as his mum and she could claim as his partner/girlfriend/wife, but if she drifted and never really took on everything, or eventually left your son, there wouldn't be a danger of her running away with the carer's allowance for nothing and leaving you broke.

No, legally that can't be done with CA- the recipient has to be the one providing the required hours of care. CA also gives the claimant class 1 NICs, the rules around it are pretty tight.

Shakeyourwammyfannyfunkysong · 07/01/2026 07:45

If you're confident that he has the capacity to consent to the relationship and to her being his carer then I'd offer to directly pay the girlfriend your share of the carer's allowance for a few months in 2 weekly increments on the understanding that you'll withdraw this if you feel that DS isn't being adequately cared for. I'd sit them down and write down everything that you do for him and explain that you won't be doing any of it. Once you're satisfied that he's safe you allow the carers allowance to go to her directly but keep a close eye and involve ss if needed. As pp have said I'd involve a sw or his LD nurse if he has one for support as well as whatever gf's intentions are this is going to be a big transition

stichguru · 07/01/2026 07:45

I guess if you had a younger child and worked, you wouldn't have to divert your child benefit to their nursery or childminder, but you'd still have to pay fees. I don't know if you could do this legally, or how easy it would be, but could you still receive the carers allowance, but pay the girlfriend for the hours of care she does? That way the hours that she's caring she'd get paid, but you would still have the benefit and control it. If they do end up being together long term, and if you were gradually paying her more and more, because she was taking on more and more for DS, you could eventually stop claiming as his mum and she could claim as his partner/girlfriend/wife, but if she drifted and never really took on everything, or eventually left your son, there wouldn't be a danger of her running away with the carer's allowance for nothing and leaving you broke.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/01/2026 07:28

Have you had a frank discussion with her about what it will actually mean?

I would also be concerned that this is not a healthy relationship, esp given the age gap, and that she now wants to claim CA for him.

However, it could turn out that it’s, and that this is a long term/ permanent relationship, in which case doing all these tasks would be something that transitions to her in the longer term. It’s hard to imagine that promoting a healthy dynamic, but I guess that’s the reality of any relationship he will have.

She would have to understand what is involved and demonstrate she is willing and able to do it before you give up CA, as it would mean you completely dropped the reins to her, and looking for work. So it would be a hard decision to undo. Does your son even understand this?

LilyBunch25 · 07/01/2026 07:26

XenoBitch · 07/01/2026 01:33

Wait, what?
OP gets CA as she provides at least 35 hours of care for her DS each week, and he will have to be on DLA or PIP for her to get that.
Why should she not be getting it? She has explained what she does for her DS.
It is a little over £80 per week.

I don't think they popped in for a reasonable discussion...just to goad.

LilyBunch25 · 07/01/2026 07:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mm. Go away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread