Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend being unreasonable .?

161 replies

Aprilmaymum · 02/01/2026 18:33

Happy new year everyone.
Friend of DP arrived at our house on New year eve saying his wife and him having problems and can he stay the one night. We agreed to one night only as to be honest we don’t have the space. New year day he was still here and still here now. DP explained that with three young children we cannot accommodate him . He is sleeping on our sofa and doesn’t get up on the morning so we are walking around him. DP spoke to him this morning again and he said he would help us out anytime which made my DP feel guilty. I want him gone. Apparently his wife has said she doesn’t want him back and has changed the locks and no one else will have him. One night was fine but I honestly think we should be saying he has to go where as DP said we should give him until after the weekend. What are other thoughts ?

OP posts:
LilyBunch25 · 03/01/2026 08:32

GoldenGail · 02/01/2026 20:24

You wold do that to your friend?

He was supposed to stay one night. Not move in.

PinkPhonyClub · 03/01/2026 00:06

Take him at his word. Don’t keep the kids quiet tomorrow morning. At 8am I would be actively waking him with a cheery smile “hey Bob, lots on today so going to need you to pack up now”.

Sure let him use the bathroom and get a bit of toast but I would be pushing him out the door at 9am.

why? Well otherwise I bet you a quid that the day will drag on, he will be there sitting on his arse eating your food taking up your lounge claiming he is looking for a room and in the evening he will announce he hasn’t been able to find anywhere to stay and it will be tough for to throw him out into a cold night. Any complaints about oh I need to find a room before I go I would say “well I know they have got good WiFi in the library/Costa/Wetherspoons”. Bit bright smiles but firm resolve.

“could I not just stay tonight”
”that doesn’t work for us. Please don’t try to overstay your welcome, I don’t want this to damage our relationship”

Oh and worse case scenario is there a “Severe Weather Extreme Protocol” in place with your council? Mine has one on as very cold here and should enable anyone who would be sleeping rough to have an overnight accommodation.

OriginalUsername2 · 02/01/2026 23:52

Aprilmaymum · 02/01/2026 22:15

He has agreed to go tomorrow. He said he was hoping to stay for the weekend but it is hard enough with the kids without having someone else around. Let’s hope he does

The absolute cheek of him

MySilentLions · 02/01/2026 23:37

I’m just here for the update tomorrow morning. Hoping the recorder playing does the trick.

Dietday · 02/01/2026 23:06

He clearly lied to get in the door.
I would be very pissed off at that, and my husband for not telling me about his previously imposing on someone for 2 months.

10K · 02/01/2026 23:00

DH needs to tell him his time is up. He needs to pay for a hotel/ Airbnb or stay with relatives. This is not your problem.

Betty1625 · 02/01/2026 22:47

SunMoonandChocolate · 02/01/2026 22:45

I can't believe that you actually wrote 'Let's hope he does' OP. It's not up to him, it's your house, and he's outstayed his welcome. How many times have we all read on here that a woman wants to kick her cheating husband out, but people tell her she can't as it's illegal? Just point this out to him, and tell him to go home and sort it out with his wife. If she won't let him in, then he needs to call the police. Obviously no one wants to do this, but in his case if he hasn't got anywhere else, and can't afford to rent a hotel or somewhere, then he has no choice. If he's still asleep when you get up in the morning, take him in a cuppa, wake him up, and say right Dave, you've got until 10.00am, do you need any help getting your stuff out to your car? Make it absolutely clear, that he HAS NO CHOICE!!

Couldn't agree more

SunMoonandChocolate · 02/01/2026 22:45

Aprilmaymum · 02/01/2026 22:15

He has agreed to go tomorrow. He said he was hoping to stay for the weekend but it is hard enough with the kids without having someone else around. Let’s hope he does

I can't believe that you actually wrote 'Let's hope he does' OP. It's not up to him, it's your house, and he's outstayed his welcome. How many times have we all read on here that a woman wants to kick her cheating husband out, but people tell her she can't as it's illegal? Just point this out to him, and tell him to go home and sort it out with his wife. If she won't let him in, then he needs to call the police. Obviously no one wants to do this, but in his case if he hasn't got anywhere else, and can't afford to rent a hotel or somewhere, then he has no choice. If he's still asleep when you get up in the morning, take him in a cuppa, wake him up, and say right Dave, you've got until 10.00am, do you need any help getting your stuff out to your car? Make it absolutely clear, that he HAS NO CHOICE!!

Justmuddlingalong · 02/01/2026 22:28

Whether he leaves is up to you. Not him.
He has no negotiation rights.
Don't buckle if he chances it.

Aprilmaymum · 02/01/2026 22:15

He has agreed to go tomorrow. He said he was hoping to stay for the weekend but it is hard enough with the kids without having someone else around. Let’s hope he does

OP posts:
Cardinalita90 · 02/01/2026 21:29

Could it be that he's feeling bruised/vulnerable and doesn't want to be alone in a hotel? Might be this causing him to outstay his welcome rather than being tight about paying.

Why doesn't your DH take him out for a quiet pint and ask what his plan for moving on is? Is it hotel, family or back home because unfortunately you don't have the space. Help him find a hotel for Sunday - not because the guy needs the practical help, but so he feels supported.

All these posters telling you to be harsh but you can be kind to a friend who is struggling whilst still enforcing boundaries.

whynotwhatknot · 02/01/2026 21:24

tell him she cant legally lock him out if she refuses he shoujld call the police

Shinyandnew1 · 02/01/2026 21:02

He is sleeping on our sofa and doesn’t get up on the morning so we are walking around him.

I would be in there as soon as the kids wake up, curtains open, telly on and kids in asking to sit on the sofa.

Confusion33 · 02/01/2026 21:00

Definitely wouldn't be tip toeing around him
My kids would be encouraged to get out the karoke machine and have fun.
Though mine are up from 6am and loud so no one would really want to stay past one night

MrsChristmasHasResigned · 02/01/2026 20:54

If you are too rural for hotels, check out farms who have cottages for farm stays. This time of year, a lot of have empty spaces and you can get some good deals- my sister stayed in one for a month when over visiting from abroad and it was lovely.

OriginalUsername2 · 02/01/2026 20:53

MrsMoastyToasty · 02/01/2026 18:46

Ask him to leave.
If he refuses call the police.
Make life uncomfortable for him. Use your hoover,put the TV when you get up, have a "slanging match" with your DH at the top of your voices, give your dc recorders to learn to play.

Recorders! 😂I love that! 👏

Whowhenwhat · 02/01/2026 20:42

MummyChocolateMonster · 02/01/2026 19:08

This is his DW’s problem - not yours. Legally she can’t just kick him out of his home. She’d need a court order for that. While she “wants space” you’ve lost your space!
A lot of people live together while separating, often not ideal, but equally it’s not for you to facilitate her space at the expense of yours. You’ve said you don’t think there’s been DV so she’ll just have to put up with him until they’ve formalised everything.
He’s got rights and he needs to exercise them and go back as she’s out of options. If she won’t let him in 101 may well help but otherwise he can use a locksmith to gain entry if he can prove he’s an owner/tenant.

This is sound advice. This isn't your problem. Your dh needs to be firmer with him

YourWildAmberSloth · 02/01/2026 20:33

Aprilmaymum · 02/01/2026 18:44

No quite rural.

Then he can travel. He's a grown-ass man with a wife, kids and a job - surely he's capable of booking a cheap hotel / airBB, even if it means that he has a longer commute than normal. Why are you all infantilising him?

lessglittermoremud · 02/01/2026 20:29

If he’s named in the tenancy/mortgage his wife can’t just kick him out and change the locks.
I would give him until Monday to arrange somewhere else, if he has rights to stay within his own property I’d be telling him to go home tomorrow.

GoldenGail · 02/01/2026 20:24

PInkyStarfish · 02/01/2026 18:39

Pick up his stuff and put it outside. If he doesn’t leave, call the police.

You wold do that to your friend?

binkie163 · 02/01/2026 20:19

I just don't understand why people put themselves in these situations. Let it be a lesson for you and your husband in the future.
You have children, it is not suitable for them having some strange bloke dossing on your sofa. Your husband's responsibility is to you and your children, not random friends.
While you enable his lazy arse to doss at yours he is not dealing with his situation. Shove his bits in a bin liner now ready for leaving tomorrow. It's your home not a bloody YMCA.

Geeseinarowhonk · 02/01/2026 20:18

The absolute brass neck of this fucker! By Monday, I guarantee something else would have come up and he'll be asking for 'just a few more days'

I'd love to know his wife's version of events. Finding herself, aye? She probably found stuff on his phone and it was the last straw.

I'd be hoovering the living room at 6am, followed by noisy kids TV, followed by noisy kids.

WhereYouLeftIt · 02/01/2026 20:02

"He is sleeping on our sofa and doesn’t get up on the morning so we are walking around him."
Unacceptable. You're doing him a favour, he's behaving entitled.

I agree with everyone else who has said to take this out of your husband's hands. His friend is using their friendship to manipulate your husband into agreeing to 'just one more night' - and another, and another. As techniques go, it's effective (as you have observed).

So - stand your husband down and take over the reins.

Have the conversation - and when I say 'conversation' I mean you tell him what's going to happen - where you tell him you agreed to one night and on night only, and that him staying tonight means he is definitely leaving in the morning and not coming back ever. Give him a time - I'd probably go for 10am, certainly a morning departure. Make it clear this is not a negotiation, this is what is going to happen. And then stand over him from 9am onwards tomorrow, ensuring he packs up all his shit and leaves by 10am.

He's able to manipulate your husband through friendship, he can't manipulate you. So take over, and get him out.

Pineapplewaves · 02/01/2026 19:51

He can stay in a hotel, B&B, a holiday let, get a room in a shared house, there are many options open to him, he does not need to stay at yours any longer. I hope you haven’t given him a key so he can get back in once he leaves for work on Monday……..

Aplstrudl · 02/01/2026 19:50

Have you got kids - can you say that you need him gone so they can prepare for school?