Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who will only have Yorkshire pudding with beef

161 replies

isargosaword · 27/12/2025 17:11

Can I ask why? Yorkshire puddings are a nice addition to any roast meat. I’ve just never understood why you would deprive yourself of Yorkshire pudding on a roast because the meat isn’t beef, what is the reasoning? Some people seem to feel quite passionately about it.

OP posts:
sashh · 28/12/2025 15:54

Ohnoitsfinallyhappened · 27/12/2025 17:37

Traditionally a joint of beef sits on top of the Yorkshire pudding on a trivet and drips into the batter, the Yorkshire almost becomes a batter pudding, very thick and tasty and crispy on the edges, very little rise to it and certainly not light and fluffy. It was always served first with lashings of gravy so you needed less meat for the main. (My grandfather was from Yorkshire and would only eat it this way, as a child in the 70s I fought to have it as a "starter" and as part of the main!!).

Nowadays for me, Yorkshire with anything and everything!!

When I was growing up in Yorkshire I was told that they did that in the south of England.

To me they are a starter with gravy, go with any roast, can be part of other meals eg toad in the hole, or cold with syrup for supper or breakfast.

thefamous5 · 28/12/2025 15:53

We dont eat beef. We have Yorkshire puddings with gammon and chicken and lamb.

ScrambledEggs12 · 28/12/2025 15:53

Tradition I guess? As a child we only had them with beef.

My partner has always had them with all roasts, so we do that now too. Life is much better!

TheWytch · 28/12/2025 15:53

It's their choice though isn't it?

Being vegetarian though the issue never arises. 40 years ago when I had my last roast it was with beef only.

isargosaword · 28/12/2025 15:50

@GillyGillyOssenfeffa yeah I get not being bothered to make them, just not the people refusing yorkshires on offer because it’s ’not beef’

@genesis92 common to whom?

OP posts:
GillyGillyOssenfeffa · 28/12/2025 15:49

tilypu · 27/12/2025 18:02

What are bacon rolls?

To me that's a breakfast food item, and doesn't go with a roast!

You don't have bacon rolls and pigs in blankets with your turkey at Christmas? Shock, horror!!!!😱

23Shadows · 28/12/2025 15:49

genesis92 · 28/12/2025 15:43

It’s a bit common to have it with other meats. It’s also what makes a roast beef that extra special. Each to their own though

A bit common?

It's no wonder people from overseas struggle to understand the class system in the UK.

Sixgeese · 28/12/2025 15:47

SilverPink · 27/12/2025 17:13

Mmm…. Love Yorkshire puddings….have them reheated next day with jam 🤤

My Yorkshire Grandad used to eat the leftover Yorkshire puddings with jam for tea.

genesis92 · 28/12/2025 15:43

It’s a bit common to have it with other meats. It’s also what makes a roast beef that extra special. Each to their own though

GillyGillyOssenfeffa · 28/12/2025 15:42

isargosaword · 27/12/2025 17:11

Can I ask why? Yorkshire puddings are a nice addition to any roast meat. I’ve just never understood why you would deprive yourself of Yorkshire pudding on a roast because the meat isn’t beef, what is the reasoning? Some people seem to feel quite passionately about it.

Because the cook doesn't want the bother of making them? It's an extra thing to worry about and if you want them really nice then they need to be cooked at the last minute, with the oven on a really high temperature. We wouldn't give those bought ones room on the plate!
Only having them with roast beef means they are a special treat and are appreciated as such.
Of course, f I go to a cervery I will have Yorkshire pudding with turkey, gammon or whatever else is being served.

isargosaword · 28/12/2025 15:39

Iamthemoom · 27/12/2025 19:15

Nervous to post now but… I have no idea why but we only have them with beef. I can’t give you a logical reason, just that’s how it’s always been. But you’ve opened my eyes to this being highly illogical and I’ll definitely make them with other roasts going forward! I do cook them in the beef dripping but happy to buy a jar from the butcher and serve them up with lamb and chicken! My family will thank you for it I’m sure as they love my yorkshires!

Ah glad to read you’ve been swayed 😁

OP posts:
oncemoreuntothebeachdearfriends · 27/12/2025 19:20

I'll stick to meat & veg, no need for some stodge to fill me up so I eat less of the good stuff.

Iamthemoom · 27/12/2025 19:15

Nervous to post now but… I have no idea why but we only have them with beef. I can’t give you a logical reason, just that’s how it’s always been. But you’ve opened my eyes to this being highly illogical and I’ll definitely make them with other roasts going forward! I do cook them in the beef dripping but happy to buy a jar from the butcher and serve them up with lamb and chicken! My family will thank you for it I’m sure as they love my yorkshires!

XenoBitch · 27/12/2025 19:06

There is a Yorkshire Pudding wrap van in my town at the moment that comes every xmas. It is like a mini roast dinner in a wrap. They do beef, pork and turkey. They are gorgeous, but they are stingy with the napkins. You need a bib really 😅

MargaretThursday · 27/12/2025 19:02

SilverPink · 27/12/2025 17:13

Mmm…. Love Yorkshire puddings….have them reheated next day with jam 🤤

Syrup is nicer.

CorvusPurpureus · 27/12/2025 18:59

The absolute ironclad rule when I grew up was: YP with beef or lamb, stuffing with pork or chicken (or turkey at Xmas).

However, we had a Sunday roast every single weekend - those 4 on rotation - so it meant YPs were served fortnightly.

I'd cheerfully dish them up with whatever now, if I knew people would want them, but I actually like to cook, so our 'posh weekend dinner' is much more varied than my parents would have gone in for. YPs probably only make an appearance a few times a year - more often alongside a vegetarian roast or as toad in the hole type dishes - because none of us love lamb & roast isn't our favourite thing to do with beef.

If I'm honest...I still hear a judgmental little voice in my head muttering that serving them with poultry or white meat is just terribly Toby Carvery naff. But that's my mum's voice, & bless her she's always been a truly rotten cook, so nuts to her & her rules! YPs rock.

XenoBitch · 27/12/2025 18:58

They go with everything. I am having some with pork tonight.
There used to be a pub near me that did giant Yorkshires with meat and gravy inside. All types of meat went into to it.

Dawnintheageofaquariams · 27/12/2025 18:57

ErrolTheDragon · 27/12/2025 18:14

No, I thought it always used to be separate chipolata sausages and bacon (either rolled or just crisply cooked slices) until the supermarkets found a way to upsell the combination.

Sausages wrapped in bacon was a thing my Gran did, so definitely predate the modern supermarket.

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 27/12/2025 18:53

Devilsmommy · 27/12/2025 17:16

What now😮

Really common in our (Yorkshire) family!!

Runnersandtoms · 27/12/2025 18:51

Also beef is way too expensive and hard to cook correctly so we rarely have a roast that isn't chicken!

ErrolTheDragon · 27/12/2025 18:49

@IrisPallida- I get my beef from a local farm shop which is also a butchers, they’ll always give you extra fat. And free beef bones ‘for stock or dogs’.

isargosaword · 27/12/2025 18:49

Quincette · 27/12/2025 18:13

My parents were inveterate snobs and purists. I’m even worse. A Yorkshire pudding goes with roast beef.

I’m the William Hanson of our household. And our household is not a Toby carvery.

But why does it only go with beef? What is the reason?

OP posts:
IrisPallida · 27/12/2025 18:42

Historically beef was the 'cheapest' meat for a household. This wasn't because it was particularly cheap, but because the Sunday roast was the basis of most meals for the week.

It would be roasted on Sunday, and some of the fat would be used to make Yorkshires or baked batter which would be served with gravy as a filling starter. The rest of the fat and drippings were collected and served on bread or toast as a morning or evening meal, and eaten for as many days as it would last - usually up to Friday evening when the meat would run out and fish might be served if it was available and if there were funds. The cold joint would form the basis of sandwiches and cottage pies through the week.

Otherwise the protein for the last part of the week was pork, usually in the form of sausages as they were the cheapest. And yes, they were also sometimes served with a baked batter, as Toad in the Hole.

Chicken and goose was incredibly expensive and eaten only on special occasions. Lamb was generally a second choice to beef for most working class households because cold lamb fat was unpleasant as dripping and therefore it was only the meat itself that would be used to make sandwiches and Shepherds pie etc.

I remember my Grandmother describing how much care her mother took in choosing the beef joint every week. It had to have plenty of fat, and if it didn't have enough, then the butcher would re-roll it with an extra slab tied on. The fat was an incredibly important source of calories for a working household.

I look at the miserable, shit, dry, flavourless lean joints that they sell in supermarkets today and wonder how it is we have lost so much of our food heritage.

Runnersandtoms · 27/12/2025 18:42

MolkosTeenageAngst · 27/12/2025 17:17

Growing up we only had Yorkshire puddings with beef, my mum still refuses to have them with any other roast. We had them for Christmas dinner and she made a big deal about refusing to take one for her plate because they ‘don’t go’ with any meat but beef. I don’t understand it, they’re my favourite part of the dinner for me.

Exactly the same here. My parents served them at Xmas because my kids love them and my son doesn't eat potatoes. But they didn't eat any because 'they don't go with turkey'. Also they always have a whole ham for slicing for breakfasts over Christmas. They were irritated because my kids only want cereal for breakfast but had ham at teatime when everyone else was eating cheese and crackers. 'I mean the ham is supposed to be for breakfast really'. This from people who never ever eat anything savoury for breakfast the rest of the year. 🤷‍♀️

I say eat what you like, especially when it's a special ocassion!

Parker231 · 27/12/2025 18:41

ErrolTheDragon · 27/12/2025 18:30

A good Toby Carvery?Confused
we went to one this year for the first time in several years and it wasn’t very nice. Sad

We went to one a few miles from Heathrow when we had too much time to kill between flights. The food was lovely - piping hot, perfectly done vegetables and everywhere very clean

Swipe left for the next trending thread