Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have not lied to DS about trans actor in Last Christmas?

712 replies

DungOnATwig · 24/12/2025 01:10

Watching above with DD17 (lesbian) and DS11 (straight) earlier today. One scene where a female presenting (long hair + fake eyelashes) but clearly biologically male actor plays a doctor (just Dr). DS says "that......lady sounds like a man".

I said yeah it is a man love. A man who identifies as a sex they are not.

DD paused then typed a wee bit more furiously than usual for 30 secs but then was ok. She knows tbf. She's lesbian and not pan.

It was so distilled down to me at the point of his very innocent (and tentative so as not to offend question) that I am not prepared to lie to my kid about the fucking fundamentals of life and tell them that person is a woman. Fuck that.

Merry Christmas 🍷

Also FUCK THAT FILM 😭😭😭😭😭

OP posts:
Thread gallery
33
Namelessnelly · 27/12/2025 10:57

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:55

Thank you for clarifying that it is utterly pointless engaging in discussion with you on this issue.

To be fair,I'm now just here for the elephant looking lion pictures

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:55

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:51

Men and women are different species. What is this bell curve measuring do you think?

Thank you for clarifying that it is utterly pointless engaging in discussion with you on this issue.

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:54

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 10:54

What? You really think men and women are different species?

Sorry sexes

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 10:54

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:51

Men and women are different species. What is this bell curve measuring do you think?

What? You really think men and women are different species?

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:53

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/12/2025 10:20

@Imdunfer I'm rather missing your point here.

Are you suggesting that since (in your opinion, though FWIW I actually agree with you) there are some people who are reliably mis-sexed, there is no point in ever even attempting to provide sex-specific supports, nor in expecting that individuals, who do know their own sex even if they wish it was different, behave like reasonable human beings and respect them?

Because if that is your point, I thoroughly, utterly disagree.

Female people deal with an unfair pile of shit both because of our sex directly, and because of how society, especially male society, feels entitled to treat us because of our sex. And that does not go away simply because the sex of some individuals may not be immediately apparent.

So it is not fair or reasonable to expect millions, billions of women (original female meaning) to put up with all the shit that comes with our bodies without recourse to female-only provisions and protections, nor to tell us we cannot speak plainly about who is a man and who is a woman and why that matters, simply to spare the hurt feelings of a few.

Edited

If I didn't say it then please don't infer that I think it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/12/2025 10:51

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:26

I'm not even sure what the point of the 'passing' conversation is? What are people saying?

We let men who are deemed to 'pass' use women's spaces? But who decides who passes and who doesn't? And is this not discriminatory to men who want access to women spaces but dont pass?

Or is it that, because some men supposedly pass, then we have to let all men into women's spaces, regardless of how obviously male they are?

That last one.

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:51

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 10:44

Cats and dogs are different species. Men and women are not.

Men and women are different species. What is this bell curve measuring do you think?

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 10:44

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:27

Sorry that should have been 'cats on a bell curve with dogs'

Cats and dogs are different species. Men and women are not.

MyLimeGuide · 27/12/2025 10:38

Im a lady!

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:27

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:23

Almost EVERYTHING in the natural world is on a bell curve

Where are you getting this from? What are you even referencing here? Do you think cars are on a bell curve with dogs are something? What do you think the bell curve is measuring?

Female and male skeletons are put together differently, due to different shaped pelvic bones, with different subpubic angles. The result is different Q angle connecting hip to knee, which impacts the mechanics of walking in each sex.

Sorry that should have been 'cats on a bell curve with dogs'

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:26

I'm not even sure what the point of the 'passing' conversation is? What are people saying?

We let men who are deemed to 'pass' use women's spaces? But who decides who passes and who doesn't? And is this not discriminatory to men who want access to women spaces but dont pass?

Or is it that, because some men supposedly pass, then we have to let all men into women's spaces, regardless of how obviously male they are?

Namelessnelly · 27/12/2025 10:26

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:08

Almost EVERYTHING in the natural world is on a bell curve and skeletal structure and size certainly is.

I have male pattern fingers. Look it up.

Tell NW tonights Annabel Tiffin that women don't have square jaws.

Rtc etc etc etc etc@

So there is a point where some lions look elephant like? Can you show me a picture of one?

Namelessnelly · 27/12/2025 10:25

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 08:21

Charge them with what? It is not a criminal offence to be a male in a ladies loo, so they weren't charged with that. It's not "according to me", it's according to the law.

Edited

So if en can use the ladies toilets with impunity, surely that belies the non cis males claims thst they are unsafe in male toilets doesn’t it? So therefore the only reason non cis males use female facilities is for validation?

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 10:23

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:08

Almost EVERYTHING in the natural world is on a bell curve and skeletal structure and size certainly is.

I have male pattern fingers. Look it up.

Tell NW tonights Annabel Tiffin that women don't have square jaws.

Rtc etc etc etc etc@

Almost EVERYTHING in the natural world is on a bell curve

Where are you getting this from? What are you even referencing here? Do you think cars are on a bell curve with dogs are something? What do you think the bell curve is measuring?

Female and male skeletons are put together differently, due to different shaped pelvic bones, with different subpubic angles. The result is different Q angle connecting hip to knee, which impacts the mechanics of walking in each sex.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/12/2025 10:20

@Imdunfer I'm rather missing your point here.

Are you suggesting that since (in your opinion, though FWIW I actually agree with you) there are some people who are reliably mis-sexed, there is no point in ever even attempting to provide sex-specific supports, nor in expecting that individuals, who do know their own sex even if they wish it was different, behave like reasonable human beings and respect them?

Because if that is your point, I thoroughly, utterly disagree.

Female people deal with an unfair pile of shit both because of our sex directly, and because of how society, especially male society, feels entitled to treat us because of our sex. And that does not go away simply because the sex of some individuals may not be immediately apparent.

So it is not fair or reasonable to expect millions, billions of women (original female meaning) to put up with all the shit that comes with our bodies without recourse to female-only provisions and protections, nor to tell us we cannot speak plainly about who is a man and who is a woman and why that matters, simply to spare the hurt feelings of a few.

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 10:12

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:08

Almost EVERYTHING in the natural world is on a bell curve and skeletal structure and size certainly is.

I have male pattern fingers. Look it up.

Tell NW tonights Annabel Tiffin that women don't have square jaws.

Rtc etc etc etc etc@

Or Steff McGovern.

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:10

ThatBlackCat · 27/12/2025 09:19

Oh yes. Male BO. It's completely different to female BO. Men have a scent that is completely different from women.

Most men don't have BO, and I defy anyone to smell the difference between males and females when both sexes are now drowning themselves in perfume.

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 10:10

Anyone heard of April Ashley? She had a successful career as a model in the 60s and appeared on the front cover of Vogue. No one knew she was male u til she was outed by a childhood acquaintance.

To have not lied to DS about trans actor in Last Christmas?
Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 10:08

ThatBlackCat · 27/12/2025 08:58

Have you heard of SET, FIXED skeletal structure? That, is NOT on a 'bell curve'.

Almost EVERYTHING in the natural world is on a bell curve and skeletal structure and size certainly is.

I have male pattern fingers. Look it up.

Tell NW tonights Annabel Tiffin that women don't have square jaws.

Rtc etc etc etc etc@

Alucard55 · 27/12/2025 10:02

Newsenmum · 27/12/2025 00:04

But it’s not clear at all.

In this case it is. This person is clearly a man to me.

KimberleyClark · 27/12/2025 09:59

ThatBlackCat · 27/12/2025 09:19

Oh yes. Male BO. It's completely different to female BO. Men have a scent that is completely different from women.

If a transwoman is taking female hormones then it might not be so different.

BigYellowBus · 27/12/2025 09:53

ThatBlackCat · 27/12/2025 08:11

It is harder when it's women, but as soon as you turn around and/or speak, it would become obvious.

Nope. I have had conversations with people who don't believe I'm a woman. And the simple fact is, you do not know if you've not realised a woman is trans rather than cis

ThatBlackCat · 27/12/2025 09:19

JellySaurus · 27/12/2025 09:12

And the smell of male sweat.

Oh yes. Male BO. It's completely different to female BO. Men have a scent that is completely different from women.

JellySaurus · 27/12/2025 09:12

MyLimeGuide · 27/12/2025 08:57

And then there's the adams apple 🍏

And the smell of male sweat.

TheKeatingFive · 27/12/2025 09:10

Imdunfer · 27/12/2025 08:48

Have you heard of a bell curve?

It's not a bell curve. It's an absolute difference between how male/female skeletons are constructed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread