Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Man advice please πŸ™πŸ»

31 replies

Imowningup · 23/12/2025 18:22

Background- I’m 42, 2 DC, been divorced for almost 2 years.

Met a lovely, lovely man. 46, he’s been divorced for 10 years and has 3 older DC (22, 18’& 15). I can’t stress how well we get on- shared values, similar communication style, he’s attentive, messages multiple times a day, is thoughtful, goes out of his way to show me he cares, can show vulnerability and has always shared his DC 50:50 which is a non negotiable for me (if a man has children). On top of that there is a strong physical connection. Too good to be true?

My issue- and I’m completely open to being told I need to get a grip- he has a very close relationship with his ex-wife. VERY close. They divorced due to her having an affair. They see each other multiple times a week, he regularly carries out DIY, they have family meals, socialise together etc. Aside from his kids, her name is the name he mentions most. He has been very upfront and said previous GFs found this an issue and it has caused problems before.

Im stuck between a) acknowledging that if he’s a good father, emotionally intelligent etc then it stands to reason he’ll have a good relationship with her and b) wanting to protect myself in case

There are no other red flags. I think he’s wonderful and absolutely know I am falling in love but I’m also not wanting to sleepwalk into a minefield.

Any suggestions as to how I can bring this up and explain my feelings in a kind but constructive way?

OP posts:
MrsLizzieDarcy · 23/12/2025 18:42

He's clearly superhuman if he can spend that much time around someone who hurt him that badly. Or he's still got feelings... I think I'd be a bit cautious here OP, and tell him outright that you're a little guarded because of their closeness. Because it sounds like if you had a row, she'd be the one he runs to.

KarmenPQZ · 23/12/2025 18:38

ForeverPombear · 23/12/2025 18:28

It's a no from me too.

I'm always pleased when ex's can get on for the sake of children but this sounds like too much. For me it wouldn't help either that she had an affair and it might not have been his choice to end it so he might still love her.

It's obviously been an issue with other girlfriends and look at where they are now. He didn't say I understand how you feel, I'll pull it back a bit. He just carried on.

Or maybe he didn’t love her that much in the first place and so he wasn’t that hurt by the affair πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ

KarmenPQZ · 23/12/2025 18:35

Hmmmndivorsed 10 years and haven’t got back together in tha time. Has she been single for any length of it? If so and he hasn’t gone running back I’d say it’s safe and not a red flag. And very healthy to show the kids they can be adults.

if she’s not been single. Ie still with affair partner also possibly safe so long as the ex β€˜s relationship remains intact.

also if he’s not had other long term relationships maybe he’s had too much time in his hands and so helping her with diy and stuff was just normal helpfulness. Maybe he’s now ready for a new partner as the kids are getting older and more ready to move on and gradually cut ties b

MyFairLady22 · 23/12/2025 18:32

No. They need to get on FIR THE SAKE OF THEIR KIDS. Thats it!

ForeverPombear · 23/12/2025 18:28

It's a no from me too.

I'm always pleased when ex's can get on for the sake of children but this sounds like too much. For me it wouldn't help either that she had an affair and it might not have been his choice to end it so he might still love her.

It's obviously been an issue with other girlfriends and look at where they are now. He didn't say I understand how you feel, I'll pull it back a bit. He just carried on.

GoneWoman · 23/12/2025 18:25

That'd be a no from me, he's far too enmeshed with her

Sounds like you'll always be 2nd best and he doesn't seem to have any thought for your feelings by keep mentioning her so I'd be moving on to someone without all of the baggage

Swipe left for the next trending thread