Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One dog too many…AIBU!?

31 replies

OhSoAsd · 11/12/2025 13:07

I know this is a sensitive subject to many, so please be kind.

We had 2 dogs, male and female who we absolutely adore!! They get on great, they’re used to our routine and we have little no issues with them!
We somehow missed her season, she must not of shown, and nor did we catch any odd behaviours or a tie between them!
You know how it works and 8 weeks later we have a beautiful healthy litter of pups!
it was a wonderful, tiring, beautiful, stressful,expensive 9 weeks before they left for their new homes. My partner so desperately wanted to keep one, so with much persuasion we did.

however….said partner works 60+ hours a week so it was ultimately left down to me to raise, train, walk etc.
She is now 6 months old and I’ve been thinking for the past month or so that it was the wrong decision and just too much with also having mum and dad and our own children…I’ll put my hands up and admit having 3 is probably one dog too much for me….pup is an absolute terror.

No amount of training, walking, playing, puppy classes, crate time, time out etc seems to be doing anything. She ignores her name. She ignores commands that she has previously learnt and done excellent with.
She hangs off mum/dad when biting them to the point they’re screaming out in pain and she refuses to let go. She knows toileting, but now all of a sudden it’s wherever whenever she pleases (access to garden every hour or so alone) She has destroyed the kitchen cupboards, tables, chairs and what not. (Yes she has a million toys of all different types, teething toys, soft toys, harder toys, interactive toys, you name it we’ve probably got it)

I just feel I’m at my limit with it now and maybe she would be better suited to a single dog household where she won’t get the distractions of mum and dad?

this will of course upset my partner but ultimately I am the one losing my mind on a daily trying to control her and cleaning up the destruction she leaves. It is a taking a toll mentally, the dread of what will happen today, or popping out to come home to destruction and toileting all over.

AIBU to want to rehome her?

OP posts:
Thundertoast · 11/12/2025 13:28

OP... you might get better responses if you are just honest... noone on earth is stupid enough to believe that you had two dogs, male and female, and deliberately left them both un-neutered, and then it was a total surprise to you that you had puppies. You did it deliberately, you know people will say its wrong and you're trying to soften it so people dont focus on the back you were breeding for profit. You didnt actually need to mention the backstory, you could have just said you got a puppy and its not getting on well.

moanymel6 · 11/12/2025 13:25

First reply is overly harsh but not completely incorrect. If you have a male and a female then you must have known this would happen. You’re not going to have eyes on them all the time. At least one of them should have been neutered and then this would never have happened.

This was your first mistake. Your second was being talked into keeping one by your dh who quite clearly was going to have no involvement in raising it or training it.

I don’t think you’d be unreasonable to rehome it if it’s not working out. It doesn’t seem fair on your older dogs. From your post you seem to want validation that it’s the right thing to do. Just don’t let it happen again.

TheBabyFatmoss · 11/12/2025 13:25

Rescues are on their knees at the moment, who do you think will be rushing to get their hands on your poor puppy?

OhSoAsd · 11/12/2025 13:24

Tootiredforthis23 · 11/12/2025 13:23

YANBU for thinking it’s one dog too many. It clearly is.

YABU for not having your dog neutered. I hope you have since or you’ll just end up in this situation again soon

I probably should have added, dads castration was actually booked the same week this must of happened

OP posts:
Tootiredforthis23 · 11/12/2025 13:23

YANBU for thinking it’s one dog too many. It clearly is.

YABU for not having your dog neutered. I hope you have since or you’ll just end up in this situation again soon

PolkaDotPorridge · 11/12/2025 13:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.