Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Talk me out of having a 4th child

62 replies

UppityPanda123 · 09/12/2025 12:33

Posting on AIBU rather than “larger families” as I’m more likely to get the brutally honest opinions I need without selection bias. I also want to preface this by saying I know that we are lucky to have any children, and I am very sorry that there will be women reading this who are struggling to conceive.

I am 36 and recently had my third child. I have two girls and a little boy. This most recent pregnancy was so so hard - I was exhausted, miserable, often felt inexplicably furious, and felt “trapped” somehow. I couldn’t properly look after my other two children and my husband went part time so that he could do more for us. Truly the moment that I gave birth, I was back to my normal self. It was a dramatic change. Postpartum was a breeze compared to pregnancy. I was certain that I was “done” and have just been really focusing on my health since day 1 postpartum so that I can be the best mum that I can be - prioritising sleep, good nutrition, and regular exercise. My baby boy is now 8 months old, we’ve settled into a good rhythm as a family, I feel fitter/stronger than I’ve been in years and now I still feel like one child is missing from our family . My husband would happily have a fourth (or fifth!) if it was up to him, but after my mood plummeting during my third pregnancy I think that even he is worried about what another 9 months of that would do to us as a couple and to the three children we already have. I feel the same. We can afford a 4th child now and in the future (state schools nearby are ok so we can save for university fees etc), we already have a van with enough space for everyone, and we have enough potential bedroom space. I have returned to work and it’s going fine. My husband and I both work nearby (no commute) with compressed hours so that we have time with our children - he has a Friday off, I have Monday and Tuesday off. My concern is the psychological and physical impact (pregnancy is gruelling for me), and wanting to have enough time/energy for the children I already have, both now and as they grow into teens and adults. My parents had me when they were “older” and are both now deceased, so that also gives me pause for thought when considering bringing another life into the world. I miss them every day and I want my children to have more quality time with me in their lives than I had with my own parents - which is also why I’m focusing so much on my health now.

YABU - do NOT have any more children
YANBU - go on, have another baby

OP posts:
Allswellthatendswelll · 09/12/2025 12:46

user86397409754 · 09/12/2025 12:44

My husband is one of 3 siblings that have a fractious adult relationship. He is very much of the opinion that 3 is a disaster, so he’d tell you to have another one, or probably not to have had the 3rd one, but too late for that!

I think he does have a point, friends that are 2 siblings or bigger 4+ families seem to rub along okay. All the ones I know that are at war or no contact seem to be from groups of three!

I'm one of three, two girls and a boy, and it's great! The thing is you shouldn't keep having kids for some idea of sibling relationship as you really can't engineer these things. The best thing you can do for your kids isn't lots of siblings, its a happy parent.

UppityPanda123 · 09/12/2025 12:46

RhubarbandCustardYummyYummy · 09/12/2025 12:42

Just read your own post back….

This made me laugh!! Yes I know, I just need some sense knocked into me and this thread is doing just that!

OP posts:
toomuchfaff · 09/12/2025 12:45

You know its the "monkey brain" in you that wants another child, the animal that doesnt see sense and only wants to procreate because thats the only thing to guarantee the human race survival. Its not the rational part of your brain.

Sometimes just acknowledging that part exists is enough to understand and overrule its huge drive within you.

Bamfram · 09/12/2025 12:45

There are things that hugely contribute to a peaceful home, a bedroom each definitely being one.
A house big enough to move about, particularly as children are staying home longer even when well paid!
Teens are so seriously expensive, even if you don't need to do private schooling.
I think your 3rd was a warning to mind yourself.
Take it, take your blessings of 3 healthy children.
Being clear of the teen years by mid 50s is really great.
Its hard having teens in your 60s!

Dweetfidilove · 09/12/2025 12:44

You've talked yourself out of it, then put your rose tinted glasses right back on and did a u-turn.
Maybe spend some time thinking about why you ACTUALLY want a 4th (that youbalso think may not be the best idea), and you might find your answer there.

user86397409754 · 09/12/2025 12:44

My husband is one of 3 siblings that have a fractious adult relationship. He is very much of the opinion that 3 is a disaster, so he’d tell you to have another one, or probably not to have had the 3rd one, but too late for that!

I think he does have a point, friends that are 2 siblings or bigger 4+ families seem to rub along okay. All the ones I know that are at war or no contact seem to be from groups of three!

Allswellthatendswelll · 09/12/2025 12:43

Reading this I can't see any reason why you would have a 4th child! Three is more than enough and you said yourself you really struggled in pregnancy. Why would you risk your equilibrium by having another?

Especially as you now do have both genders, which I know shouldn't matter but is a reason for some people.

rwalker · 09/12/2025 12:42

If it was the right decision you wouldn’t even be questioning having a 4th

RhubarbandCustardYummyYummy · 09/12/2025 12:42

Just read your own post back….

UppityPanda123 · 09/12/2025 12:39

Thank you both for your insights. I think you’re right @Katemax82that I need to choose my sanity. You also paint a pretty realistic picture of the future.

OP posts:
handsomeson · 09/12/2025 12:38

As a mum of 4 I don’t recommend it. Mine are older now and it’s not all cute cuddly babies when you have 4 giant men to feed clothe and give pocket money to and generally pay for them to live.
I also highly doubt in this climate they’ll be moving out anytime soon if ever.
Choose your sanity.

Katemax82 · 09/12/2025 12:36

I had a surprise 4th baby recently (I'm 43)
I wish I'd had him earlier, there's like 7vyears between most of my kids (except the middle 2, there's 5 years between them)
All I can say is it's exhausting. But you know deep down what you want for your family