Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband’s attitude towards aging

416 replies

Lolabear38 · 03/12/2025 05:27

I’m 43, DH 41 and we’ve been together 15 years with 2 kids. We both keep in shape but obviously we both look our ages.

A couple of weeks ago, during a jokey conversation with my husband I asked him which of my friends he thought was most attractive (yes in hindsight a stupid question, not the point). He thought for a moment and answered ‘none of them really, they’re all old now’. They’re the same age as me! I called him out on it and reminded him of that, said his attitude was horrible and I found it disrespectful. He apologised.

Tonight, watching I’m a Celeb, I said something like ‘ooh you used to fancy Kelly Brook, didn’t you?’ (I promise neither question was loaded in any way, just casual and typical of a usual conversation between us) and he pulled a face and said ‘yeah, but eww she’s really old these days so not any more’.

I again told him he was being really rude - while yes, all the women in question are getting older - they’re all similar ages to me and it made me feel a bit shitty to think he might think of me like that too. I told him it was demeaning, hurtful and particularly disrespectful considering I’d called him out on comments like this so recently.

AIBU to be this upset? It’s not just the comments, but the face pulling and ‘eww’ when thinking about their ages. I told him clearly what I thought and he initially said ‘well don’t ask questions you don’t want to hear the answer to’. Yep, ok, fair point, but it’s the fact he obviously does think like this that is making me so sad/ angry.

I also reminded him he isn’t 25 any more and not getting any younger himself. We’ve left it with him apologising and saying ‘there’s nothing else I can do now’. I’ve told him to think about his shitty attitude and have some more respect.

OP posts:
Ireallywantadoughnut36 · 03/12/2025 12:02

Yes, it's not good he's seeing women of his own age as SO revoltingly unattractive but he clearly does, so what do you do about it really? Expect him to lie to you, or don't ask the question, or accept that's how he feels. I agree it isn't good, it's not what you'd want him to feel and it's a depressing reflection of how the world has categorised women over 40 as somehow totally past it, but a 40 yr old man fancying a 20 year old has been normalised - no none of that is good. Equally, you can't force him to find certain people attractive. So I don't think there's an easy answer, other than maybe asking him to be a bit more sensitive/respectful when explaining how he feels. If it's literally just the face pulling and eww that upsets you, he can just stop that, but if you want him to suddenly fancy women in their 40s and 50s, I'm not sure you can really force that, unless he just lies to you, which surely isn't any better?

Floundering66 · 03/12/2025 11:59

It’s sad but I think it’s representative of most men unfortunately. We are about ten years younger but my partner used to have Kelly Brook as a screen saver in his teens. He has also said she “looks old” now - but he wouldn’t say “eww” or something to that effect. I think she looks great!

In contrast I thought Brad Pitt and Jude Law looked great in the 90s and still do now. I don’t know if men age better or women are just more kind. Maybe it’s hardwired into men to be attracted to fertile women in their twenties whereas women can be attracted to men at all different stages of life.

YorkshireGoldDrinker · 03/12/2025 11:56

@Disturbia81

I lost the quoted reply, so @'d you instead.

Bit of a case in point, don't you think? I know what you mean, but some decorum wouldn't have gone amiss.

Men's hair recedes and goes grey sooner, leading to them shaving their hair off instead of living with the classic 'Nutty Professor' look and many others to dye their hair. I'd much rather have a meaningful conversation with 'potato heads with ruddy skin and pot bellies' over a high-maintenance man with hair plugs, fake hair colour with slathered on moisturiser and fake six-pack abs.

Emmz1510 · 03/12/2025 11:56

I think you are overreacting.
Yeah he’s being a bit immature to make such comments about women’s ages, but think of it this way. There is so much more to fancying someone than their physical appearance. He fancies you (I assume?) because he loves you and your personality and you have a shared history and he knows all your little quirks. He doesn’t know these women and only has their physical appearance to go on. He’s allowed to not find them attractive.

hotirish99 · 03/12/2025 11:55

So on 2 occasions you asked him a question and both times you received an answer you didn't like and 'called him out' on it.
Why ask the guy a question he can't give an honest answer without been 'called out'?
At least make it clear to him that when he's asked a question, the only acceptable answer is the one you approve.

Bringemout · 03/12/2025 11:54

I do actually think evolutionary psychology has a point here (on average). There do seem to be some differences in men and women that are pretty sticky. It’s kind of freeing tbh. Also it doesn’t mean that men never ever find women of their own age attractive. Fairly sure that DH is still madly in love with Nigella Lawson.

thecatneuterer · 03/12/2025 11:54

MatriarchCaz · 03/12/2025 11:41

Well I dont fancy the same people I did when I was younger lol, they do look old. Female here btw.

Same for me (apart from Hugh Grant - still would 😁 )

divorcinganabsolutewanker · 03/12/2025 11:53

Poor sod.

CasperGutman · 03/12/2025 11:52

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/12/2025 06:08

Apparently a lot of men continue to see young women as the most attractive as they age, whereas women tend to like men closer to their age. I remember this being discussed a few years ago. https://metro.co.uk/2019/02/22/men-regardless-age-will-always-attracted-women-early-20s-8718590/

An important caveat to that article is that, while men continue to identify 20-something women as "looking best", when asked a less superficial question about the age of women they're "most interested in" they stick much more closely to their own age range.

It's almost as if men grow up and realise looks aren't everything!

Bringemout · 03/12/2025 11:52

gannett · 03/12/2025 11:08

I'm always sceptical about how innate any of this actually is. I'm definitely stimulated visually, and so are most women I know. And I know plenty of men for whom emotional security and so on is incredibly important. The difference is what men and women are encouraged to actually say out loud from adolescence onwards. Girls aren't encouraged to objectify boys to the same extent as the reverse; boys are encouraged to objectify girls even when they consider personality more important.

I also think that women's supposedly biological attraction to "security" mostly derives from growing up in a patriarchal society in which they need security more than men. The less a woman needs a man to protect or provide for her, the less important those characteristics are for her when looking for a partner.

And in any case most humans, men and women, can be attracted to other people on different levels. OP's husband being more attracted to 20yo Kelly Brook than 40yo Kelly Brook says nothing about his attraction to OP, just like my attraction to young Ethan Hawke over old Ethan Hawke has nothing to do with my attraction to 40-something DP (or indeed my initial attraction, based entirely on looks, to 30yo DP). It's way too complex to reduce to these bitesize stereotypes.

Studies show that even when women are higher earners they still prefer men to earn more than them.

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167268114003242

Homegrownberries · 03/12/2025 11:51

Your "usual conversation between us" is very appearance based. It might have worked for you both when you were young and naively stupid but it's not going to serve either of you well going forward.

Bringemout · 03/12/2025 11:45

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/12/2025 06:08

Apparently a lot of men continue to see young women as the most attractive as they age, whereas women tend to like men closer to their age. I remember this being discussed a few years ago. https://metro.co.uk/2019/02/22/men-regardless-age-will-always-attracted-women-early-20s-8718590/

I saw this, it amazed me a but tbh, I just don’t find young men attractive. I think it’s preset, I don’t think they can help it, it is what it is. I think most men have the common sesne to not to act on it though.

secretrocker · 03/12/2025 11:43

Disturbia81 · 03/12/2025 11:39

This is such bullshit. Have you seen most older men out there!? Potato heads with ruddy skin and pot bellies. Women generally make far more effort to look after themselves.

Agreed. For every man who looks good in their 50s there are 10 who have aged like sour milk.
Probably the same ratio as for women.

Fireflybaby · 03/12/2025 11:42

You're missing the point that he chose you and loves you for many other reasons than just physical appearance. There's one thing to be attracted to someone purely on physical appearance and an entirely different thing to be attracted by someone you love.

WhatsForDinner100 · 03/12/2025 11:41

It's the kind of comment lots of men would make - I honestly wouldn't take it seriously. Blokes have a very different sense of humour to women, as I've learnt over the years. Men bond by taking the pi$$ out of each other and they aren't great at switching to a more tactful, feminine way of dealing with things - that's what your girlfriends are for, even though in romantic films and novels, the hero gives amazing compliments.

43 is still very youthful, so don't let the number get to you. Keep yourself youthful by walking as much as possible and staying healthy. Vinted is great for good value clothes to keep your look fresh. There are loads of things you can do on a budget if money is an issue.

Plenty of people age well and you have many fun years ahead of you, so embrace it.

MatriarchCaz · 03/12/2025 11:41

Well I dont fancy the same people I did when I was younger lol, they do look old. Female here btw.

Disturbia81 · 03/12/2025 11:39

YorkshireGoldDrinker · 03/12/2025 11:36

Men and women age in different ways. Men generally become more attractive as they age, they mature like a fine wine, some women are capable of the same with decent genetics, but on the whole they aren't so lucky in that way, which, when at the mercy of the tendency for women to be highly-judgemental about their peers, is made much worse anyway.

But we don't point the finger at the judgemental women, we lash out at the 'misogynist men' instead, because they're considered the ones who set the standards for beauty (they don't and never have done).

I'm not a misandrist, so I won't engage in it, otherwise then misogyny is the counter and both are bad as each other.

I do see women letting other women down and pitting each other against one another over how they age in comparison to men. By contrast, men don't do this as they have an uncanny knack for getting along.

This is such bullshit. Have you seen most older men out there!? Potato heads with ruddy skin and pot bellies. Women generally make far more effort to look after themselves.

YorkshireGoldDrinker · 03/12/2025 11:36

Men and women age in different ways. Men generally become more attractive as they age, they mature like a fine wine, some women are capable of the same with decent genetics, but on the whole they aren't so lucky in that way, which, when at the mercy of the tendency for women to be highly-judgemental about their peers, is made much worse anyway.

But we don't point the finger at the judgemental women, we lash out at the 'misogynist men' instead, because they're considered the ones who set the standards for beauty (they don't and never have done).

I'm not a misandrist, so I won't engage in it, otherwise then misogyny is the counter and both are bad as each other.

I do see women letting other women down and pitting each other against one another over how they age in comparison to men. By contrast, men don't do this as they have an uncanny knack for getting along.

StephensLass1977 · 03/12/2025 11:22

Your line of questioning would make any man answer the "wrong" thing. Respectfully, you asked for that. "oooh you used to fancy...!" What on earth were you hoping to achieve?

On that note, I must be the only one who thinks so many women improve with age. Yes, more wrinkles etc., but women are in general so interesting to me, especially as they age. Read, Glenn Close, Gillian Anderson, Patricia Heaton. Many more.

friedeggrunny · 03/12/2025 11:19

Alexadidzammomarryjackie · 03/12/2025 05:44

Given the fact you are using every time he opens his mouth as a lecture learning opportunity, maybe he's now over egging it just to piss you off.

ETA - i am in my 50s. I would far rather a night of cocktails and dancing sex with young Antonio Banderas than old Antonio Banderas. That's not me hating men, or old people, or pretending I'm young.

Edited

😂

itsalwayssunnyhere · 03/12/2025 11:17

This is what we get in a society like this: men think they are undeniable at every age and women are treated like products with expiration date. Sadly, I don't think he'll change his attitude or even think about it properly.

Kubricklayer · 03/12/2025 11:09

Naunet · 03/12/2025 10:58

Are men more shallow than women? Sure.

Based on OP's DH sure. Are women more emotionally volatile? Sure. Again OP's 'silly, fun game' with DH would suggest this.

TorroFerney · 03/12/2025 11:09

Gallowayan · 03/12/2025 06:25

I think you are being disingenuous here, because you setting traps for him to fall into.. He is stupid for falling into them though.

Edited

This. Why are you doing this op? What’s driving it, it’s like you think you are unworthy so you are getting him to reinforce it. Do you enjoy drama or being at loggerheads with him?

Its a really odd way to conduct a relationship, very childish.

gannett · 03/12/2025 11:08

Kubricklayer · 03/12/2025 10:54

Except it's not a fantasy theory that men and women are generally stimulated in different ways. Men are more visually attracted to others, while women respond more strongly to auditory, touch, and emotional stimuli etc, This is backed by scientific data which is a more credible source than your opinion of it being a fantasy theory.

Edited

I'm always sceptical about how innate any of this actually is. I'm definitely stimulated visually, and so are most women I know. And I know plenty of men for whom emotional security and so on is incredibly important. The difference is what men and women are encouraged to actually say out loud from adolescence onwards. Girls aren't encouraged to objectify boys to the same extent as the reverse; boys are encouraged to objectify girls even when they consider personality more important.

I also think that women's supposedly biological attraction to "security" mostly derives from growing up in a patriarchal society in which they need security more than men. The less a woman needs a man to protect or provide for her, the less important those characteristics are for her when looking for a partner.

And in any case most humans, men and women, can be attracted to other people on different levels. OP's husband being more attracted to 20yo Kelly Brook than 40yo Kelly Brook says nothing about his attraction to OP, just like my attraction to young Ethan Hawke over old Ethan Hawke has nothing to do with my attraction to 40-something DP (or indeed my initial attraction, based entirely on looks, to 30yo DP). It's way too complex to reduce to these bitesize stereotypes.

TheIceBear · 03/12/2025 11:07

Howtogetthrough · 03/12/2025 09:36

If it's so obvious to you please give examples as to how OP's H should have responded that would constitute a good outcome.
It's not obvious to me.

Maybe something like “I just don’t see your friends in that way so don’t ask me things like that” or “I don’t find any of them attractive” without specifying that none of them are hot because they are all OLD . 40s isn’t old for one thing .