Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Newly trained doctors-you need to know this

316 replies

2020Raquet · 30/11/2025 04:05

DSS3 is about to be a newly qualified FY2 doctor along without about 8,000 from his cohort (number who qualified this year). There are about 1000 jobs for them to apply for in the NHS this year. So we, the tax payer have paid an average of £250,000 to £327,009 to train these doctors over the past 7-9 years and 87% will not have a job.

A simple google search (appreciate that not be the most accurate, so happy to be corrected if based on facts) show that 20,060 doctors immigrated to the U.K. in 2024.

DSS3 is emigrating because he has little other choice.

The doctors strikes are not based on money, but the fact that they come out of uni with £100’s of £1,000’s of debt in a job apparently vital in the U.K., but with no job prospects!!

AIBU to believe the system has failed.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
olympicsrock · 30/11/2025 06:47

buswheels · 30/11/2025 06:32

Isn’t she stuck paying something to the GMC though?

No - you voluntarily withdraw from the registry ie become not active and can’t work as a doctor but keep your number .

ApiratesaysYarrr · 30/11/2025 06:45

RedTagAlan · 30/11/2025 05:25

Are you not talking about slightly different things here ?

An FY2 doctor is still in training, headed to a training hospital.

The UK doctor shortage is for fully trained and done their specialty. GPs for example. A role that an FY2 can't apply for.

Should your data not be like for like ?

Or have I got that all wrong ?

You are correct in the first part that F2s are still in training, but at the end of their Foundation 2 year period immediately after graduating from university, there are huge bottlenecks to get into specialty training.

The BMA wrote to the government recently to point out that having a PhD and having published medical articles was still not enough to get to the shortlisting cut off to get an interview for IMT (internal medicine training), which is meant to be directly after F2.

Pavementworrier · 30/11/2025 06:37

I mean all of this said one of the stupidest girls I knew at school (properly stupid) is now a consultant at a teaching hospital after starting medicine as a second degree thanks to a dubiously conceived Access to Medicine course so I guess maybe we are screwed across multiple metrics.

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:35

Arregaithel · 30/11/2025 06:32

@Fl0w3rP0w3r

"however unpalatable that may sound" or racist perhaps? smh.

So if you’re receiving poor care very much tied up with language/ communication complexities what do you suggest patients do?

PortSalutPlease · 30/11/2025 06:35

This isn’t true though. Foundation doctors are still training. There’s not enough specialist places for them to go into due to lack of funding, so the competition is fierce. The doctors coming in from overseas are reg and consultant posts which we have a serious shortfall in. The two are not the same thing.

ReplacementBusService · 30/11/2025 06:34

Edited a long post to summarise: it's simply rubbish all round

Arregaithel · 30/11/2025 06:32

@Fl0w3rP0w3r

"however unpalatable that may sound" or racist perhaps? smh.

buswheels · 30/11/2025 06:32

olympicsrock · 30/11/2025 06:22

It’s awful. I’m a consultant. One of our F3s ( probably the most talented of her year too) has been doing locum jobs this year but is struggling to get even locum work.
She has chosen not to pay her GMC and indemnity fees for the coming year and to do a shelf stacking job at Tesco for £1 less per hour until Christmas but without the stress of searching for shifts/ night work/ worrying about patients etc. She will travel in the new year and consider moving to Australia / New Zealand for work if she can’t get a job next August .

Isn’t she stuck paying something to the GMC though?

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:29

Arregaithel · 30/11/2025 06:21

@Fl0w3rP0w3r

"And there you go- the racism accusations"

We see you, so obvious.

Dangerous Dr's are not colour specific

You really don’t

Of course dangerous doctors aren’t colour specific however poor English and communication difficulties are added risks and complications however unpalatable that may sound.

The UK medical training system is envied globally. As a tax payer I’d like to see it kept here.

SatsumaDog · 30/11/2025 06:27

It’s absolutely horrendous op. Quite a few from my son’s year are interesting in studying medicine, so I hope they are aware. I guess there’s always an option to work abroad it seems crazy they can’t get employment in the UK.

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:22

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 06:21

Did you read the article linked?

In a half-hearted effort to head off the strike without conceding on pay, Health Secretary Wes Streeting did offer an additional 1,000 specialty training posts this year, and to increase the number of additional training posts from 1,000 to 2,000 over the next three years: but that inadequate offer has now been withdrawn.

So more training posts?

olympicsrock · 30/11/2025 06:22

It’s awful. I’m a consultant. One of our F3s ( probably the most talented of her year too) has been doing locum jobs this year but is struggling to get even locum work.
She has chosen not to pay her GMC and indemnity fees for the coming year and to do a shelf stacking job at Tesco for £1 less per hour until Christmas but without the stress of searching for shifts/ night work/ worrying about patients etc. She will travel in the new year and consider moving to Australia / New Zealand for work if she can’t get a job next August .

Arregaithel · 30/11/2025 06:21

@Fl0w3rP0w3r

"And there you go- the racism accusations"

We see you, so obvious.

Dangerous Dr's are not colour specific

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 06:21

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:16

What can be done or is it beyond fixing?

Did you read the article linked?

In a half-hearted effort to head off the strike without conceding on pay, Health Secretary Wes Streeting did offer an additional 1,000 specialty training posts this year, and to increase the number of additional training posts from 1,000 to 2,000 over the next three years: but that inadequate offer has now been withdrawn.

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:16

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 06:13

the waste is paying locus due to piss poor planning which had end up in a bottle neck

What can be done or is it beyond fixing?

EleanorReally · 30/11/2025 06:16

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:07

And there you go- the racism accusations.

Worries about patient safety and care alongside a ludicrous system that is wasting tax payers money should not be shut down by racism accusations.

Maybe this is partly why there is a problem. It just can’t be explored. As a patient you absolutely can’t raise concerns and professionally you probably can’t either.

why would you want to raise concerns?

buswheels · 30/11/2025 06:14

Completely shocking as was the fact that the last time my parent went to see their cardiologist they couldn’t understand what they were saying (even more shocking when you know that my parent spent their working life teaching including being TEFL trained and teaching EFL for quite some time so they hardly find accents in general challenging.)
I have a good friend who worked as a consultant in a teaching hospital. While her child was in PICU her trust advertised her job, employed someone from overseas, who promptly announced that she was taking an extended trip back home before she started work and they then asked my friend to locum for her replacement until she returned from her extended holiday!

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 06:13

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:07

And there you go- the racism accusations.

Worries about patient safety and care alongside a ludicrous system that is wasting tax payers money should not be shut down by racism accusations.

Maybe this is partly why there is a problem. It just can’t be explored. As a patient you absolutely can’t raise concerns and professionally you probably can’t either.

the waste is paying locus due to piss poor planning which had end up in a bottle neck

Fl0w3rP0w3r · 30/11/2025 06:07

EleanorReally · 30/11/2025 05:57

i dont understand why this thread had descended into racism,
at a clinic yesterday everyone of these doctors was black,
they were doing their job, employed by the nhs
most of the doctors in my department are asian
why is that an issue. ?

And there you go- the racism accusations.

Worries about patient safety and care alongside a ludicrous system that is wasting tax payers money should not be shut down by racism accusations.

Maybe this is partly why there is a problem. It just can’t be explored. As a patient you absolutely can’t raise concerns and professionally you probably can’t either.

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 06:02

There are over 10,000 doctors vacancies in uk as of November 25

its a disaster of underfunding and planning over the last 2 decades

Newly trained doctors-you need to know this
ByQuaintAzureWasp · 30/11/2025 06:01

It's absolutely ludicrous. I have read about this before.

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 05:58

Newly qualified doctors in the UK are struggling to find jobs due to
a shortage of specialty training posts, which has created a bottleneck in the system. This is caused by a combination of factors, including poor workforce planning, funding gaps, and a high number of graduates competing for a limited number of places. As a result, many are stuck in temporary roles or face unemployment after completing their foundation training.
Key reasons for job scarcity

  • Insufficient training posts: The number of available specialty training posts has not kept pace with the number of medical graduates, leading to fierce competition.
  • Poor workforce planning: A lack of strategic planning by successive governments has resulted in a shortfall of training places, stunting career progression.
  • Funding issues: In certain areas, such as general practice, funding shortages and poor allocation of resources prevent the creation of sufficient doctor roles.
  • High competition: For example, over 30,000 doctors competed for approximately 10,000 specialty training places in one year, a situation exacerbated by unsuccessful applicants reapplying in subsequent years.
  • Rise of non-training roles: Many available positions are "locally employed doctor" roles that do not count toward career progression, or doctors are forced into temporary locum positions that are often hard to secure.
  • Uncertainty in allocation: Some doctors are only informed of their placement weeks before they are due to start, adding stress and uncertainty to an already difficult situation.
EleanorReally · 30/11/2025 05:57

i dont understand why this thread had descended into racism,
at a clinic yesterday everyone of these doctors was black,
they were doing their job, employed by the nhs
most of the doctors in my department are asian
why is that an issue. ?

MikeRafone · 30/11/2025 05:52

A quick google and you’ll find there are

8,000 doctor vacancies

yes there is a problem with newly qualified doctors and them getting employment- but you haven’t told the entire story OP. Would you care to enlighten everyone on the rest of the story?