Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I BROKE TWO PLATES

56 replies

koolkatxx · 22/11/2025 18:51

Went to my friend’s today and honestly I think I need to be banned from other people’s homes for life.

First plate: we were snacking in the living room, I somehow managed to knock it off the coffee table. Smashed. I apologised about 50 times, cleaned it all up, offered to replace it. Friend told me to stop apologising and absolutely not to replace it. All fine.

Then an hour later… I somehow broke a different plate in the kitchen. I don’t even know how. It just slipped like my hands forgot how to function.

Her brother came in immediately, handed us the hoover without saying a single word, and walked out. I wanted the floor to swallow me. I felt like some kind of destructive toddler.

Friend kept saying “it’s fine, move on, don’t mention it again,” and even made me agree not to bring it up. But I STILL feel awful and like she must secretly be thinking I’m a complete liability.

AIBU to still feel mortified?
Or do normal adults just… break two plates in one day and move on with their lives?!

OP posts:
Arlanymor · 22/11/2025 19:00

I would text my friend and say: "So sorry about today. I am not sure what to do - either apply for Greek citizenship or buy you a new dinner service for Christmas?" Unless they were priceless heirlooms, I am sure it is fine. Accidents happen, it's just that sometimes they happen more than once in a row.

Childanddogmama · 22/11/2025 18:59

You cant help having accidents but do think you should buy more as 2 missing from a set is annoying.

koolkatxx · 22/11/2025 18:58

JaneEyre40 · 22/11/2025 18:53

Her brother is a dick, you are having a clumsy day, it happens.

Thanks- such a clumsy day!!! Not sure if I should still buy her a set of plates as an apology though

OP posts:
nomas · 22/11/2025 18:58

I would find that annoying tbh, especially if you broke plates from a set.

Make sure you leave money for replacements.

JaneEyre40 · 22/11/2025 18:54

Also I voted wrong. You are BU to still be mortified.

JaneEyre40 · 22/11/2025 18:53

Her brother is a dick, you are having a clumsy day, it happens.