Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I upset a lady at GP surgery today

432 replies

TheQuirkyMaker · 20/11/2025 21:45

A queue of five people in front at surgery. Waiting room pretty full. Only one receptionist available. An elderly lady at the front was telling the receptionist that she had just picked up meds at the chemist, and they had been changed from her regular ones to different ones. There was back and forth discussion, and every few minutes the lady would say, "but nobody told me they would be changed". I asked the lady in front of me how long this had been going on and she said "about 10 minutes". After a full further 15 minutes I said "Look, this is getting us no where, none of us will get to see a doctor if we can't sign in". I got a bit of condemnation along the lines of "she was entitled to her time", but I said, "this is reception, not a consultation. Just repeating that she wasn't told her medication would be changed is getting us no where. This could go on forever".
People got a bit sniffy with me, and I got a few stares, but I was right, wasn't I?
I get we should be tolerant of older people, but there has to be a bit of give and take.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 18:35

Giraffemug30 · 22/11/2025 17:13

I mean it's literally impossible to know how long it actually was as OP doesn't seem to know, and may have only been a minute or two but its still not OPs job to criticise the woman, and the receptions job to manage any growing queue

Absolutely! I was only pointing out that the OP has now said it was 10 minutes, not 25.

Giraffemug30 · 22/11/2025 17:13

CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 13:18

It was 10 minutes.

I mean it's literally impossible to know how long it actually was as OP doesn't seem to know, and may have only been a minute or two but its still not OPs job to criticise the woman, and the receptions job to manage any growing queue

Brefugee · 22/11/2025 14:02

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 12:32

I'm 70 years old. Let's hope I never become elderly, ay?

Then you should know better.

LaMarschallin · 22/11/2025 13:20

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 12:32

I'm 70 years old. Let's hope I never become elderly, ay?

But Brefugee is right: you still chose to pick on the person in the weaker position.

Usually people who mention someone is "elderly" don't consider themselves to be old, so it's not unreasonable for Brefugee to tthink you have a few years before you consider yourself elderly.

Ageism is rife - maybe the people who tutted at you were thinking "Grumpy, interfering old bat".

CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 13:18

Giraffemug30 · 22/11/2025 12:33

The problem was with the GP receptionists wasn't it not the woman?

You have no idea what changes had happened to this womans medication, it could be a complete fuck up. She could be on important meds where the brand/dose does matter (parkinsons/epilepsy) or is at least stressful if it changes. They could have deprescribed important meds. A medication change can be quite anxiety inducing and it's fair enough for a patient to be informed by a Dr or reassured by a clinician.

You assume she's being stupid, but also describe as her as bright as a buttonHmm

You chose to call out the woman for wasting your time when really it was the receptionist who turns out was just hiding in their booth the whole time?! Why couldn't they have just opened their shutters if the queue wasn't moving for 25 mins?! This is just poor management from the reception team, and you didn't want to call them out because you were worried they would "turn on you".

It was 10 minutes.

Giraffemug30 · 22/11/2025 12:33

The problem was with the GP receptionists wasn't it not the woman?

You have no idea what changes had happened to this womans medication, it could be a complete fuck up. She could be on important meds where the brand/dose does matter (parkinsons/epilepsy) or is at least stressful if it changes. They could have deprescribed important meds. A medication change can be quite anxiety inducing and it's fair enough for a patient to be informed by a Dr or reassured by a clinician.

You assume she's being stupid, but also describe as her as bright as a buttonHmm

You chose to call out the woman for wasting your time when really it was the receptionist who turns out was just hiding in their booth the whole time?! Why couldn't they have just opened their shutters if the queue wasn't moving for 25 mins?! This is just poor management from the reception team, and you didn't want to call them out because you were worried they would "turn on you".

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 12:32

Brefugee · 22/11/2025 11:34

ah you took the easy route of picking on a worried elderly lady.

God i hope that never happens to you.

I'm 70 years old. Let's hope I never become elderly, ay?

OP posts:
IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 22/11/2025 12:13

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 09:10

To be fair, maybe it was 10 mins total. Maybe less. But bear in mind it was reception, not a consultation, reception is for dealing with admin and appointments, not discussing treatments. If she had been with a GP she could have had all the time she needed as far as I was concerned. But the electronic check-in screen was broken, people were queueing up to be registered, and she kept saying "but nobody told me my medicines would be changed". There was a limit to how many times we wanted to hear that. Yes, we get you weren't told, or didn't listen, or didn't understand! We get it! You've said it! Now listen to the answer and let the rest of us get on with our day. GP appoints are precious and we don't want to get cancelled because we were late when we made an effort to be early.

Could I ask what the GP receptionist was saying to her for her to keep repeating “but nobody told me” line.

Brefugee · 22/11/2025 11:34

TheQuirkyMaker · 21/11/2025 22:03

I agree. The simplest and best solution would have been for the receptionist to say to the lady, "take a seat, I'm going to sent a message to your prescribing clinician, in the meantime I'll be booking these people in as our electronic system is down". But it wasn't my place to say that, was it? Then the reception staff would have taken against me as well as other patients in the surgery.

ah you took the easy route of picking on a worried elderly lady.

God i hope that never happens to you.

Brefugee · 22/11/2025 11:33

CelestialCandyfloss · 21/11/2025 18:45

Very obvious that so many people don't understand how bloody hard it is being a medical receptionist. I did it for 3 years and it was one of the worst jobs I've ever had. So many people are rude and vile (rarely the really ill ones). You get paid a pittance for people to shout and swear at you because the NHS is fucked and they can't get an appointment. That was my experience anyway.

Well, some medical receptionists need to learn how to handle some situations. And this is one of them.

"Ms X, just let me check these people in quickly and we'll have a look at that for you"

Agree all the fucking "bright as a button" is the kind of patronising twaddle you use for a toddler.

Brefugee · 22/11/2025 11:31

My MIL is exactly the same. We all make allowances because she has Alzheimers but in all honesty she has been a difficult old coot her entire life.

the vile fucking ageism that gets allowed on this site. JFC

LaMarschallin · 22/11/2025 09:54

There was a limit to how many times we wanted to hear that. Yes, we get you weren't told, or didn't listen, or didn't understand! We get it!

It really doesn't matter how often you or various other random people heard or got it; the person the lady wanted to be heard by was the receptionist as, at that point, she was the only person able to address the problem.
I've waited behind a mother of a baby in the chemist's before now and they've had exactly the same problem (same medication, different name) and kept repeating themselves. This isn't something that only happens to "elderly" people.
It really was up to the receptionist to say that she is not qualified to deal with prescriptions but, if the lady can wait or go home and take a phone call, she'll arrange that.
You're directing your irritation at the wrong person and, given you saw fit to mention that person's apparent age, it's hard to believe that your judgement isn't clouded by ageism, conscious or unconscious.

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 09:44

CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 09:35

Any other little details you misremembered?

I wasn't really at the surgery, I was at home watching TV. And 10 minutes is less than 15 minutes. And I didn't have anything else to do that day. That enough?

OP posts:
Mangledrake · 22/11/2025 09:43

You weren't unreasonable to be irritated. You were unreasonable to be rude.

There's just no reason at all you couldn't have just asked to check in. All the rest about what her problem was and how she was dealing with it isn't relevant.

You could maybe indicate to the management that receptionist needs more training, but now we are down from 25 minutes to maybe 10 I think you should leave it alone since you don't seem to have the facts.

CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 09:35

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 09:10

To be fair, maybe it was 10 mins total. Maybe less. But bear in mind it was reception, not a consultation, reception is for dealing with admin and appointments, not discussing treatments. If she had been with a GP she could have had all the time she needed as far as I was concerned. But the electronic check-in screen was broken, people were queueing up to be registered, and she kept saying "but nobody told me my medicines would be changed". There was a limit to how many times we wanted to hear that. Yes, we get you weren't told, or didn't listen, or didn't understand! We get it! You've said it! Now listen to the answer and let the rest of us get on with our day. GP appoints are precious and we don't want to get cancelled because we were late when we made an effort to be early.

Any other little details you misremembered?

pestowithwalnuts · 22/11/2025 09:14

Been both sides of the desk on this one.
Receptionist should have made a quick call through to the back office to ask for assistance on the reception desk
She could also have asked the lady to take a seat while she sorted out the queue and then got back to her.
Or..rang through and asked someone to come and sort the lady out

TheQuirkyMaker · 22/11/2025 09:10

CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 08:53

25 minutes. If, as you say, it’s true.

To be fair, maybe it was 10 mins total. Maybe less. But bear in mind it was reception, not a consultation, reception is for dealing with admin and appointments, not discussing treatments. If she had been with a GP she could have had all the time she needed as far as I was concerned. But the electronic check-in screen was broken, people were queueing up to be registered, and she kept saying "but nobody told me my medicines would be changed". There was a limit to how many times we wanted to hear that. Yes, we get you weren't told, or didn't listen, or didn't understand! We get it! You've said it! Now listen to the answer and let the rest of us get on with our day. GP appoints are precious and we don't want to get cancelled because we were late when we made an effort to be early.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 22/11/2025 08:53

Sexentric · 22/11/2025 08:37

'you are just one of those entitled people acting as if your time should be more important to the world than this old lady’s time.' But it IS more important than the old ladies time because if the OP is telling the truth the old lady has already taken up at least 15 minutes of everyone's time!

25 minutes. If, as you say, it’s true.

Sexentric · 22/11/2025 08:37

'you are just one of those entitled people acting as if your time should be more important to the world than this old lady’s time.' But it IS more important than the old ladies time because if the OP is telling the truth the old lady has already taken up at least 15 minutes of everyone's time!

Sillyme1 · 22/11/2025 08:34

Don’t kknoww if this is the case here, but I worked at a gp surgery and our prescription clerk was bombarded with people complaining about geomg changed from generic versions from branded. Exactly the same. She should have been diverted to the practice pharmacist. She may have been holding up someone with potentially serious problems such as chest pain, etc

Justthethingsthatyoudointhisgarden · 22/11/2025 08:28

Hons123 · 20/11/2025 23:13

They were delighted, on their phones, checking Facebook, phoning home, thinking, oh, a lucky break. Of course they were hiding in their treatment rooms!

Omg, seriously? You obviously don't work for the NHS. They would have been making their phone calls, checking their message list, looking at incoming medical reports or taking a call from a paramedic or palliative care team.
The general public really don't have a clue

MyMiniMetro · 22/11/2025 08:04

You were the AH in this situation. Either stay quiet or say something helpful otherwise you are just one of those entitled people acting as if your time should be more important to the world than this old lady’s time. Not a good look.

It sounds like the woman had a legitimate concern and staff should have explained the change or booked her in with the onsite pharmacist for a chat if the receptionist didn’t know the answer.

The fault is with the receptionist staff for not handling this better and not getting a second member of staff involved to help everyone else.

What you could have said was something in support of the lady that jogged it along like “If you can’t answer her question, perhaps you could book her in with someone who can? Or are you forcing her to make a subject access request just to get a simple question answered.”

GP surgeries boil my piss because they are not the NHS (they are a private business who charge the NHS per patient on the books, not per appointment given) yet everyone assumes that they are the NHS so when they treat people badly the NHS gets the blame. I wish the government would bring GP’s functions in-house. Many NHS departments allow self-referral and do their own triage because going via the GP has become so difficult and TBH GP referrals can be so poor as to be pointless.

Allisnotlost1 · 22/11/2025 01:40

TheQuirkyMaker · 21/11/2025 22:03

I agree. The simplest and best solution would have been for the receptionist to say to the lady, "take a seat, I'm going to sent a message to your prescribing clinician, in the meantime I'll be booking these people in as our electronic system is down". But it wasn't my place to say that, was it? Then the reception staff would have taken against me as well as other patients in the surgery.

It wasn’t really ‘your place’ to say anything to anyone, but since you chose to why didn’t you direct your focus to the reception staff?

Letloose2024 · 21/11/2025 23:33

You did the right thing.

10 minutes in a local gov call centre if people are still talking to us, we risk trouble and having calls listened into to see where we went wrong of it exceeds time.

Unsure why people think a gp’s receptionist has all day to chat.

TheQuirkyMaker · 21/11/2025 23:11

LaMarschallin · 20/11/2025 23:21

It doesn't work like that. Maybe it does in whatever job you do.
In medicine you just know you've got X number of people to see and increasingly less time to do so if no-one is being sent through, so you'll probably be finishing late.
It's very surprising that the clinicians weren't contacting reception to see what was going on.

I'm very impressed with our local GPs. Yes, there are long waits for routine appointments, and the receptionists triage calls, but in 2020, when Covid was at it's height, I started to pass a lot of blood pr and phoned for an appointment (didn't feel I needed A&E). I was examined at my local surgery the next day (physical, bloods, etc.), three days later I had an appointment at our local hospital and had u/s scans, a consultant did a colonoscopy, it was the NHS at it's finest. I had diverticulitis, not Ca. I think the NHS (and the country's economy generally) has all gone downhill not because of Covid, but because of Brexit. But I know not everyone agrees!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread