Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fiancé asking for a prenup

660 replies

Aquea · 19/11/2025 00:11

Fiancé and I have had a relatively short relationship. We’ve only been together for two years. I basically had to make it very clear that I would not be having children without being married. Just for legal protection. Got a bit of push back on that in the early days but I did say that marriage was a non negotiable for me and if that wasn’t for fiance then he and I should part ways.

Anyway, now we are engaged. Fiancé has asked I sign a prenup. Fiancé has his own successful business. We’re not talking a champagne lifestyle but he is comfortable enough and owns several assets. His business is fairly large - employs 35 people. But the margins are small and the overheads are massive.

I don’t have an issue in some regards as I’m certainly not marrying for the sake of money alone. I plan to carry on working FT.

But the actual concept is extremely cynical and unromantic. It’s really made me feel shit. Like I can’t be trusted. I’m kind of sick of indirectly having to convince fiancé that I am good person to marry.

We plan to have children.

it just feels like it’s one thing after another. Ie having to explain my reasoning for wanting to get married and now a prenup. The path to being engaged just seems already so negotiated.

OP posts:
PollyBell · 19/11/2025 00:27

IvedoneitagainhaventI · 19/11/2025 00:23

The way you describe it OP he has only decided to get married to you because you stood firm on the issue of marriage before children.
And he comes over as very cold and not a loving and caring man. He is protecting his financial position and that is more important to him than love and caring and sharing a life with his partner.

Personally I would be worried about marrying a person like that.

But the op is the one that wants to be married for legal protection. Where is the romance in that?

When a woman wants financial protection it is called being sensible and the dreaded 'ducks in a row', when a man wants it is is considered cold and uncaring

Blueskystoday · 19/11/2025 00:27

OP, have a rethink, he's not worth it.
Are you desperate to marry him?
Because you really would have to be.
There is no love here, just a calculating man being pushed up th aisle.
No thanks.

Bobloblawww · 19/11/2025 00:25

Pot, meet kettle

Aquea · 19/11/2025 00:25

TimeForTeaAndG · 19/11/2025 00:21

I’m kind of sick of indirectly having to convince fiancé that I am good person to marry.

Why are you, then? You've only been together 2 years, it shouldn't be about convincing him. He should want to.

I couldn't have a baby with someone who wasn't absolutely everything in the pot and equal lifestyles. What about while you're on mat leave? Or if you have to give up working because of a birth injury? Will you have full access to all money or will he expect you to somehow contribute and 50/50 on expenses?

What's the pre-nup conditions?

I haven’t got the specifics but fiancé basically says he wants to make sure his business is protected in the event of a divorce.

OP posts:
Aquea · 19/11/2025 00:24

madrush · 19/11/2025 00:19

Why was getting married before having children so important to you? In your words “Just for legal protection.” For your future.

The prenup he’s suggesting is the same the other way, for what he has built in the past. Why is yours acceptable but his cynical and unromantic?

Hopefully you have a long and happy marriage and neither of the legal/financial protections ever need to come into play. But nobody can see the future and, at this stage, legal/financial protections for both of you are sensible in my opinion.

I had a cousin who got screwed with their partner and a mortgage she was paying towards but not on. I would never want to find myself up shit’s creek like she was.

OP posts:
IvedoneitagainhaventI · 19/11/2025 00:23

The way you describe it OP he has only decided to get married to you because you stood firm on the issue of marriage before children.
And he comes over as very cold and not a loving and caring man. He is protecting his financial position and that is more important to him than love and caring and sharing a life with his partner.

Personally I would be worried about marrying a person like that.

PollyBell · 19/11/2025 00:23

So you want to be married for ''legal protection'' but now he has mentioned a similar thought you are upset by this?

They are not legal though

TimeForTeaAndG · 19/11/2025 00:21

I’m kind of sick of indirectly having to convince fiancé that I am good person to marry.

Why are you, then? You've only been together 2 years, it shouldn't be about convincing him. He should want to.

I couldn't have a baby with someone who wasn't absolutely everything in the pot and equal lifestyles. What about while you're on mat leave? Or if you have to give up working because of a birth injury? Will you have full access to all money or will he expect you to somehow contribute and 50/50 on expenses?

What's the pre-nup conditions?

Aquea · 19/11/2025 00:20

It’s left a very bitter taste. I’ll be the one carrying and giving birth to any future children. I’m not exactly asking for a legal contract where we lay out what should happen if my body is damaged via childbirth or whatever. It’s a leap of faith. As marriage also is.

OP posts:
madrush · 19/11/2025 00:19

Why was getting married before having children so important to you? In your words “Just for legal protection.” For your future.

The prenup he’s suggesting is the same the other way, for what he has built in the past. Why is yours acceptable but his cynical and unromantic?

Hopefully you have a long and happy marriage and neither of the legal/financial protections ever need to come into play. But nobody can see the future and, at this stage, legal/financial protections for both of you are sensible in my opinion.