Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Labour's new policies for asylum seekers

994 replies

frommyheadtomyfeet · 17/11/2025 07:51

Are rumoured to follow Denmark's, which include the seizure of valuables from people arriving here to pay their accommodation costs.

Is anyone else disgusted by this?! How will it work, they can take people's jewellery, phones etc., and leave them with nothing? What sort of message does that send?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
EasternStandard · 22/11/2025 15:36

Persecution is not just war though is it? A conflict could end and asylum remain.

It’s women and children excluded by the new policies too.

Leavesfalling · 22/11/2025 15:35

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 15:19

The law is in the process of being changed

Which law?

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 15:32

Also, @EasternStandard , people can be returned even after years if their country is deemed safe.

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 15:30

EasternStandard · 22/11/2025 15:21

Who will be excluded?

The aim seems to be to discourage.

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 15:28

Locutus2000 · 22/11/2025 14:51

Whataboutery is usually all they've got.

Only one party has a politician sentenced to jail for a major crime that the judge has said undermined democracy. He committed this crime as an elected official. The aim was to create a positive impression of Russia, an enemy of Britain but not of his party’s de facto leader, who admires the Russian president very much.

This party is ignoring calls to investigate how this situation came to be.

There is no ‘what abouterey’ here. That would require comparable behaviour somewhere else.

EasternStandard · 22/11/2025 15:21

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 15:19

The law is in the process of being changed

Who will be excluded?

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 15:19

Leavesfalling · 22/11/2025 14:51

The law needs changing as its being abused. The wrong people are claiming asylum.

The law is in the process of being changed

Locutus2000 · 22/11/2025 14:51

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 13:49

You’ve surely seen my post above elaborating on the details yesterday’s story about former Reform, Wales leader Nathan Gill.

None of what you say holds a candle to Mr Gill’s jail sentence of over 10 years. He was convicted of accepting bribes from someone believed by the FBI to be an asset of Russian intelligence. The fact that Nigel Farage is on record saying Vladimir Putin is the politician he most admires as Sir Ed Davey reminded us yesterday should also ring alarm bells.

Reform are resisting calls to investigate how this could have happened. Quite a contrast with Labour’s (rightful) investigation into anti-Semitism within the party. Labour is rightly taking ethics breaches seriously.

If the Lib Dems are bullying people feel free to say more. But any attempt to equate that with undermining democracy by making pro Russia speeches for bribes is beneath contempt.

Whataboutery is usually all they've got.

Leavesfalling · 22/11/2025 14:51

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 13:53

I have nothing against using frontiers as I said above. So what? But it is legal in international law to enter a country however you can and then make an asylum claim.

Stating otherwise promotes radicalisation. That may not kill us tomorrow but it is thought to be a problem in the long run

The law needs changing as its being abused. The wrong people are claiming asylum.

Leavesfalling · 22/11/2025 14:49

Ivelostmyglasses · 22/11/2025 13:30

Will we leave them their gold teeth? We have already crossed the line of Starmer quoting Mosley. Photographs of piles of belongings seem to have no meaning for people now. These headlines literally make me feel sick. It is shocking how easily people forget.

As Zia Yusuf said..its hardly 50 cent and Lil Wayne that are crossing over!

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 13:53

KTheGrey · 22/11/2025 13:23

Pretty sure the legal way in is perfectly well known to you - through passport control.

I have nothing against using frontiers as I said above. So what? But it is legal in international law to enter a country however you can and then make an asylum claim.

Stating otherwise promotes radicalisation. That may not kill us tomorrow but it is thought to be a problem in the long run

poetryandwine · 22/11/2025 13:49

KTheGrey · 22/11/2025 13:21

There is not much point getting into how utterly unfit Reform Politicians are to hold office - the Lib Dems and the Greens habitually bully GC Women, plus the LDs have a roll call of abusive MPs over the years. The Tories have a couple and the Labour Party have lost Petey Manders and Angie and Tulip from the frontline - the possibilities range from ‘public office attracts the very people who should not be in it’ to ‘which of our lives would bear the level of scrutiny public figures are subject to’. Take your pick.

You’ve surely seen my post above elaborating on the details yesterday’s story about former Reform, Wales leader Nathan Gill.

None of what you say holds a candle to Mr Gill’s jail sentence of over 10 years. He was convicted of accepting bribes from someone believed by the FBI to be an asset of Russian intelligence. The fact that Nigel Farage is on record saying Vladimir Putin is the politician he most admires as Sir Ed Davey reminded us yesterday should also ring alarm bells.

Reform are resisting calls to investigate how this could have happened. Quite a contrast with Labour’s (rightful) investigation into anti-Semitism within the party. Labour is rightly taking ethics breaches seriously.

If the Lib Dems are bullying people feel free to say more. But any attempt to equate that with undermining democracy by making pro Russia speeches for bribes is beneath contempt.

Ivelostmyglasses · 22/11/2025 13:30

Will we leave them their gold teeth? We have already crossed the line of Starmer quoting Mosley. Photographs of piles of belongings seem to have no meaning for people now. These headlines literally make me feel sick. It is shocking how easily people forget.

KTheGrey · 22/11/2025 13:23

poetryandwine · 20/11/2025 11:56

Well, what exactly does the phrase ‘if you come here illegally’ mean?

The two ways to claim asylum in the UK are to come on a visa either under false pretences or to overstay that visa, and to claim on UK soil.

I suppose people could be required to claim at recognised frontiers. If the system were scaled up to cope with the numbers - and that is quite a caveat - then sending others back to the extent practicable once the word got out wouldn’t bother me. It isn’t perfect but it would have the advantage of reducing trafficking.

I don’t think we have a particularly sound legal basis for sending them back to France, however. We rely on the French. I continue to think we would be better off participating in the DA.

Another option would be to allow people to apply for asylum from outside the country. But this relies on both technical expertise and timely processing; incompetence risks lives. I don’t know that this is viable.

Pretty sure the legal way in is perfectly well known to you - through passport control.

KTheGrey · 22/11/2025 13:21

poetryandwine · 21/11/2025 13:19

It is a matter of public record that Reform has already lost over 5% of the councillors elected to local government just 6 months ago.

The former leader of Reform in Wales has just now been sentenced to 10.5 years in jail for accepting bribes from a Russian asset for making pro Russian speeches.

These are not growing pains.

There is not much point getting into how utterly unfit Reform Politicians are to hold office - the Lib Dems and the Greens habitually bully GC Women, plus the LDs have a roll call of abusive MPs over the years. The Tories have a couple and the Labour Party have lost Petey Manders and Angie and Tulip from the frontline - the possibilities range from ‘public office attracts the very people who should not be in it’ to ‘which of our lives would bear the level of scrutiny public figures are subject to’. Take your pick.

poetryandwine · 21/11/2025 18:31

Leavesfalling · 21/11/2025 16:47

We'd better hope they sort themselves out ASAP then.

Too bad they show no sign of this yet.

The sentencing is the lead story on the BBC News at 6

To elaborate: Nathan Gill is the former head of Reform, Wales. Today he was sentenced at the Old Bailey to a jail term of 10.5 years for accepting bribes from Oleg Voloshyn to give pro-Russian speeches. Mr Voloshyn is considered by the FBI to be connected to the Russian intelligence services and has been sanctioned by the British and American governments.

One would think Reform would want to get to the bottom of this. Ha! While party leaders across the political spectrum are condemning Mr Gill, so far Reform have resisted calls from all other party leaders to investigate how this could have happened.

Sir Ed Davey today reminded Parliament that Mr Farage is on record saying that the politician he most admires is Vladimir Putin.

The security services are also increasing their warnings about foreign interference in the democratic processes of the UK.

Leavesfalling · 21/11/2025 16:47

poetryandwine · 21/11/2025 13:19

It is a matter of public record that Reform has already lost over 5% of the councillors elected to local government just 6 months ago.

The former leader of Reform in Wales has just now been sentenced to 10.5 years in jail for accepting bribes from a Russian asset for making pro Russian speeches.

These are not growing pains.

We'd better hope they sort themselves out ASAP then.

suburburban · 21/11/2025 14:42

Yes absolutely

they don’t need to be here

HellsBalls · 21/11/2025 13:33

suburburban · 21/11/2025 07:48

I think some of the other people from Eastern Europe (I’m not going to name group) who don’t work and live in social housing and don’t seem to abide by the rules should also be asked to go. Why are we paying for them.

Romanians, or more precisely, the Roma.
Normal Romanians are generally decent people like everyone else.

poetryandwine · 21/11/2025 13:19

Leavesfalling · 21/11/2025 07:27

Reform are a new party and learning. Labour don't have that excuse.

We need an alternative to the two main parties as they have both failed. So hopefully Reform will have learned from Kent by 2029. They have time.

It is a matter of public record that Reform has already lost over 5% of the councillors elected to local government just 6 months ago.

The former leader of Reform in Wales has just now been sentenced to 10.5 years in jail for accepting bribes from a Russian asset for making pro Russian speeches.

These are not growing pains.

Leavesfalling · 21/11/2025 08:00

Southernecho · 21/11/2025 07:43

Its not just Kent and what damage will they do whilst they are "learning" ?

As we've seen, in some aspects, with Labour, learning on the job isn't an option and just 16months in doesn't equal "failing", which as a "fair person" i'm sure you'll agree on.

After all, we gave the Tories 14 years.

Still several 100 Albanian families living here which Mahmood wants to send back, why was it never done earlier?

Edited

I think the Albanian issue was fixed under the Conservatives. Presumably they are the stragglers.

You're assuming Kent was in great shape before Reform took over. As everyone said when Labour got in, just give them a chance. As I said, we need a viable alternative to the two main parties. Im hoping it is a centre right one and so Reform is looking like the main option. Fingers crossed for the good of the country that they are in good shape in 2029.

suburburban · 21/11/2025 07:48

Southernecho · 21/11/2025 07:43

Its not just Kent and what damage will they do whilst they are "learning" ?

As we've seen, in some aspects, with Labour, learning on the job isn't an option and just 16months in doesn't equal "failing", which as a "fair person" i'm sure you'll agree on.

After all, we gave the Tories 14 years.

Still several 100 Albanian families living here which Mahmood wants to send back, why was it never done earlier?

Edited

I think some of the other people from Eastern Europe (I’m not going to name group) who don’t work and live in social housing and don’t seem to abide by the rules should also be asked to go. Why are we paying for them.

Southernecho · 21/11/2025 07:43

Leavesfalling · 21/11/2025 07:27

Reform are a new party and learning. Labour don't have that excuse.

We need an alternative to the two main parties as they have both failed. So hopefully Reform will have learned from Kent by 2029. They have time.

Its not just Kent and what damage will they do whilst they are "learning" ?

As we've seen, in some aspects, with Labour, learning on the job isn't an option and just 16months in doesn't equal "failing", which as a "fair person" i'm sure you'll agree on.

After all, we gave the Tories 14 years.

Still several 100 Albanian families living here which Mahmood wants to send back, why was it never done earlier?

EasternStandard · 21/11/2025 07:42

poetryandwine · 20/11/2025 23:20

The Albanian pipeline quite rightly dried up.
We were able to send the Albanians back

That’s pretty much what stops selling to people for Channel crossing.

The only thing really.

suburburban · 21/11/2025 07:40

poetryandwine · 20/11/2025 23:20

The Albanian pipeline quite rightly dried up.
We were able to send the Albanians back

Now we need to send some of the other nations back too.