Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of MN are ableist?

539 replies

Sweetlifeofyours · 16/11/2025 14:15

So I wasn’t going to post but as a mum with a disabled child myself I feel like I have to get things off my chest. I have read a couple of threads over the past week or so regarding mothers who are looking for advice and support for their disabled child/children (2 that stick out to me)

I was very sad to see that there were only a few posters who actually gave support and advice to the OP’s. The rest were in my opinion, downright rude and nasty and clearly just wanted to upset the OP’s even more for whatever reason.

As a mum with a SEN child, it is incredibly difficult and I myself don’t always get the correct help and support I need so to come on here and see that other women/parents show their (somewhat) true opinions of disabled children upset me.

I am completely 100% on board that autism shouldn’t be an excuse for everything, but surely some compassion wouldn’t go amiss to a struggling parent.

One of the worst things I read was a poster saying to the OP that they should make sure their child doesn’t turn into a sex offender because he enjoys hugs. Says more to me about the poster rather than the OP and their child.

I guess my AIBU is, do you think people (maybe especially on here) should have more compassion for the disabled community or have you read threads where you agree with the majority of comments (especially where we are talking about young children)?

OP posts:
Everlore · 19/11/2025 09:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I am loathed to engage with you again and potentially further derail an important discussion about ableism on MN but I just could not let this go unanswered. If I were you I would have taken my suggestion that you were involved in an elaborate satire and used it as your 'get out of jail free' card. Admitting you were playing a grotesque comic character would have saved you the intense embarrassment of admitting that your ridiculous, ignorant and offensive posts are actually for real.
Laying aside your claims to have enjoyed a career in the financial sector while simultaneously seeming to have no idea how our economy works and profering the kind of poorly thought out 'solution' a drunk down the pub would have been ashamed to slur out to their mates after a dozen pints, your views on disabled children are absolutely chilling.
Who are you to declare that disabled children's lives are not worth living? What gives you the right to state that they are less valuable than your life?
I was born severely physically disabled, with the kind of disabilities that heartless and ignorant people like you, lacking any imagination, would probably have thought would mean I would never do anything worthwhile. Luckily, my wonderful parents didn't hold such horrifying views and fought tooth and nail to give me the best education and childhood possible. As a result I excelled academically at school, received a first class degree from a top university, have a rewarding job I love, own my own home and, most importantly, am very happily married with a perfect baby.
I have a great life which is absolutely worthwhile and I am forever grateful that appalling eugenicists like yourself weren't in power when I was born to decide that I was going to be just too expensive to support and would never amount to anything.
What is frightening is that, given you are posting on here, there is a good chance you are a parent, possibly a grandparent. This causes me to fear for your family in the event any of them were to be born or become disabled, which, please remember, can happen to anyone at any time. I hope that seeing someone close to you experiencing the challenges associated with disability may cause you to develop some belated compassion, as it has done for so many others who showed no empathy for disabled people until disability came knocking on their door. However, maybe your humanity, like your spelling, is another skill you have let slip since you quit working.

FoughtIt · 18/11/2025 16:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Vinvertebrate · 18/11/2025 16:09

Well I don’t know about you lot, but I think Dick Lice’s little tantrum about ear defenders in school was a fine example of the type of ableism we’re confronted with daily on here.

Kids with sensory issues using reasonable adjustments to access education: <shakes fist>

Thousands of SEN kids having no education at all: <crickets>

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 15:48

Sweetlifeofyours · 18/11/2025 15:23

Was anybody else not able to get onto MN? Hopefully it was due to them banning all the ableists. Doubt it though😒

It was Cloudfare which is a network used by several websites, apps etc a lot of things were down including X but it's all sorted now by the looks of it.

Cloudflare down LIVE: X, Spotify, ChatGPT, Mumsnet and Bet365 suffer outage - Mirror Online

X, Spotify, ChatGPT, Mumsnet and Bet365 suffer from global Cloudflare outage

A massive Cloudfare outage led to issues on X, Spotify, ChatGPT, Mumsnet and Bet365 today

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/cloudflare-down-live-x-spotify-36265119

Kreepture · 18/11/2025 15:40

LizzieW1969 · 18/11/2025 15:38

Yes, sorry about getting caught up in the hijack. I won’t answer that poster again. I also want to discuss ableism, after our negative experiences with high school and the criticisms from well-meaning family members.

i could talk to you ALL day about that kind of general crap after dealing with 2 kids with AuDHD who're now both at College.

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 15:40

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 15:20

All I can say is Fuck Cancer.
Xxxx

Absolutely!

LizzieW1969 · 18/11/2025 15:38

Kreepture · 18/11/2025 15:29

Let me know when we're back to discussing ablism, not going on about someone's mad fantasy thread hijack.

Yes, sorry about getting caught up in the hijack. I won’t answer that poster again. I also want to discuss ableism, after our negative experiences with high school and the criticisms from well-meaning family members.

Kreepture · 18/11/2025 15:29

Let me know when we're back to discussing ablism, not going on about someone's mad fantasy thread hijack.

Sweetlifeofyours · 18/11/2025 15:23

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 15:20

All I can say is Fuck Cancer.
Xxxx

Hear hear!

OP posts:
Sweetlifeofyours · 18/11/2025 15:23

Was anybody else not able to get onto MN? Hopefully it was due to them banning all the ableists. Doubt it though😒

OP posts:
TigerRag · 18/11/2025 15:21

I've read a lot of posts by @Kirbert2 about her child. Absolutely heartbreaking

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 15:20

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 15:14

Honestly, you just don't have a choice. You get thrown into this new world of chemotherapy and central lines and neutropenia and signing consent forms which include risks of the chemotherapy causing heart failure and a secondary cancer in the future but if they don't have it? The current cancer will kill them and you want to hide from the world and scream WHY MY CHILD? but that child, your child is scared and asking if they are going to die and they need you and you are there for them and all of a sudden it becomes your new normal.

He's been in remission for just over a year now, he's disabled due to some horrendous complications but he's amazing and wonderful and HERE which is all that matters. He's coping well considering how different his life is now. I'm incredibly proud of him.

All I can say is Fuck Cancer.
Xxxx

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 15:14

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 14:47

Yes, devastating. I dont know how parents like you coped. My friend always said, I'm not coping, I'm just carrying on.

I hope both you and your son are doing well now.

Honestly, you just don't have a choice. You get thrown into this new world of chemotherapy and central lines and neutropenia and signing consent forms which include risks of the chemotherapy causing heart failure and a secondary cancer in the future but if they don't have it? The current cancer will kill them and you want to hide from the world and scream WHY MY CHILD? but that child, your child is scared and asking if they are going to die and they need you and you are there for them and all of a sudden it becomes your new normal.

He's been in remission for just over a year now, he's disabled due to some horrendous complications but he's amazing and wonderful and HERE which is all that matters. He's coping well considering how different his life is now. I'm incredibly proud of him.

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 14:47

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 14:45

That's just devastating.

My son had cancer last year and it was awful enough watching your child suffer and fight so much to live. I couldn't imagine not been able to afford things such as a general, lumbar punctures are so critical. Not just for diagnosing and establishing what stage the cancer is at but also for preventative chemo as part of treatment in the hopes of stopping it from spreading to the central nervous system.

My son had a lumbar puncture under general as part of his treatment 8 times plus 2 other times for diagnosis and staging reasons so 10 lumbar punctures in total.

Yes, devastating. I dont know how parents like you coped. My friend always said, I'm not coping, I'm just carrying on.

I hope both you and your son are doing well now.

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 14:45

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 12:34

If all Healthcare was private then standards for those who can afford it would be higher yes. But at the cost of those who can't. Ive lived in other countries and I can promise you Healthcare for those who cant afford the best is dire. I've seen friends in tears because insurance wont allow a child with cancer to have a lumbar puncture without a general, but they cant afford to fund a general themselves. Ive seen people choosing between insulin and kids shoes. Ive seen wealthy people bankrupted by road accidents.

You dont know what youre advocating for.

That's just devastating.

My son had cancer last year and it was awful enough watching your child suffer and fight so much to live. I couldn't imagine not been able to afford things such as a general, lumbar punctures are so critical. Not just for diagnosing and establishing what stage the cancer is at but also for preventative chemo as part of treatment in the hopes of stopping it from spreading to the central nervous system.

My son had a lumbar puncture under general as part of his treatment 8 times plus 2 other times for diagnosis and staging reasons so 10 lumbar punctures in total.

FoughtIt · 18/11/2025 12:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 12:34

ItsDefinatelyHappeningNow · 18/11/2025 11:46

Yes that is what has happened in the NHS because the NHS still very much has a monopoly on healthcare in this country. So if profits are maximised and service is poor then people will still attempt to use it.

If all healthcare was private and hospitals were competing with each other based on the normal things then I would expect the competition to raise standards.

I live in the UK and have watched the NHS go from working pretty well in the seventies/eighties to just not coping now. I admit I have started using private healthcare myself to bypass the system as it is often poor, slow and better services are available by paying. I'd be happy to continue to use the NHS if it worked but I just find it is not coping anymore.

If all Healthcare was private then standards for those who can afford it would be higher yes. But at the cost of those who can't. Ive lived in other countries and I can promise you Healthcare for those who cant afford the best is dire. I've seen friends in tears because insurance wont allow a child with cancer to have a lumbar puncture without a general, but they cant afford to fund a general themselves. Ive seen people choosing between insulin and kids shoes. Ive seen wealthy people bankrupted by road accidents.

You dont know what youre advocating for.

LizzieW1969 · 18/11/2025 12:34

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 12:22

It's very clear that you are speaking from a financially privileged point of view with very little thought for the many people out there who can't afford private healthcare or private anything..

Many people wouldn't have the money to pay for private policing. Obviously the rape conviction rate is awful but ensuring some rape victims would never get even a chance at justice because they wouldn't be able to afford it is also pretty damn awful.

Many people wouldn't have the money to pay for private policing. Obviously the rape conviction rate is awful but ensuring some rape victims would never get even a chance at justice because they wouldn't be able to afford it is also pretty damn awful.

^This absolutely. And the PP didn’t answer my question about murder victims. Would the police really not investigate if there was no one to pay them? Obviously that wouldn’t be the intention, but who would pay the police for doing it? At the very least, some public money would be needed if there was no one alive to pay for the investigation.

And what about protecting the public from rapists and murderers? Who would pay for the life sentences that the public deserves and expects?

Kirbert2 · 18/11/2025 12:22

ItsDefinatelyHappeningNow · 18/11/2025 11:46

Yes that is what has happened in the NHS because the NHS still very much has a monopoly on healthcare in this country. So if profits are maximised and service is poor then people will still attempt to use it.

If all healthcare was private and hospitals were competing with each other based on the normal things then I would expect the competition to raise standards.

I live in the UK and have watched the NHS go from working pretty well in the seventies/eighties to just not coping now. I admit I have started using private healthcare myself to bypass the system as it is often poor, slow and better services are available by paying. I'd be happy to continue to use the NHS if it worked but I just find it is not coping anymore.

It's very clear that you are speaking from a financially privileged point of view with very little thought for the many people out there who can't afford private healthcare or private anything..

Many people wouldn't have the money to pay for private policing. Obviously the rape conviction rate is awful but ensuring some rape victims would never get even a chance at justice because they wouldn't be able to afford it is also pretty damn awful.

ItsDefinatelyHappeningNow · 18/11/2025 11:53

LizzieW1969 · 18/11/2025 11:39

I'm a victim of crime and call the police - I pay for them to come and deal with.
Supermarket shoplifting - the supermarket pays. Yes I know there are holes and yes so much more thought would have to go into it but given that we are commenting on yet another thread (dozens a day it seems) with people venting their frustrating at getting taxed more to pay for others, sick of disabled people and their cars, all the SEN kids and outrage at what people are getting in money etc

So a rape victim should pay to have her rapist tried and convicted? Or a victim of CSA should have their parents pay? (I’m speaking as a victim here.).

And what about when the victim has been murdered? Should the family pay for justice?

I agree that there’s an argument that criminals should be compelled to pay their own legal fees and imprisonment, but, apart from criminals like Epstein, who could afford realistically to pay legal fees and many years of incarceration? If, as I assume, you want long sentences to protect the public?

And who would pay the judges and barristers, and prison officers?

In practice, no one could afford to pay and we’d end up with vigilante justice, as the families wouldn’t be able to pay for proper justice.

That isn’t just naive, it’s ludicrous. And thankfully it won’t ever happen.

How well does the current system work. Frontline police have been falling for years and investigations take so much longer nowadays due to cyber crime and social media.

People openly shoplifting and the police are not interested. Is this better than paying for a service and having it dealt with.

Rape victims hardly ever get convictions. Most of them won't even try as they know they will be dragged through the mud. The percentage of rapists going to prison v the number of offences is tiny. So would you pay to have a more thorough investigation and your rapist punished. Or would you rather it was 'free' (not really) and fails to get results.

It's fine if you disagree. I am just pointing out that our current system is failing horribly. It did use to work quite well when we had policeman on the beat and the internet was not a thing etc.

ItsDefinatelyHappeningNow · 18/11/2025 11:46

dairydebris · 18/11/2025 11:10

What youre forgetting is as soon as you put a profit making company in charge of Healthcare you get execs trying to cut costs. With Healthcare this means suffering.

You speak like someone who has never been poorly off in a country without universal Healthcare.

Yes that is what has happened in the NHS because the NHS still very much has a monopoly on healthcare in this country. So if profits are maximised and service is poor then people will still attempt to use it.

If all healthcare was private and hospitals were competing with each other based on the normal things then I would expect the competition to raise standards.

I live in the UK and have watched the NHS go from working pretty well in the seventies/eighties to just not coping now. I admit I have started using private healthcare myself to bypass the system as it is often poor, slow and better services are available by paying. I'd be happy to continue to use the NHS if it worked but I just find it is not coping anymore.

LizzieW1969 · 18/11/2025 11:39

ItsDefinatelyHappeningNow · 18/11/2025 10:32

I promise when I made the comment I was not being funny at all.

I actually read on here constantly the resentment of some people paying for others ie all the benefit slagging off threads.

Other threads people saying they have reduced their work to avoid tax cliff edges etc

I admit I didn't put alot of thought into it and yes I'm aware of course that taxation has been around a long time but I just thought how straightforward it would be if we all just paid for ourselves. Nobody would feel resentment and we wouldn't have all these benefit slagging threads because everyone would be self funding.

The other thing that prompted me to make a yes (naive) suggestion was how utterly useless this goverment is being. Why pay for a centralised state when they are making such a cock up of things.

I also believe people would work harder, be more responsible and plan better if they had nothing to fall back on but themselves or family.

Not such a mad plan. Most people would just save their tax and NI and use it wisely.

There is such an air of frustration in the country at the moment and whether we like it or not the current taxation model is failing because the number of people working v not working makes it not viable. Also we have a huge number of people leaving so much so they are introducing an 'exit tax' to try and stop them or at least grab some of their money before they go.

I'm quite sure with some thought all services could be made privately paid for.
So a football match - the clubs have to pay for the police to keep order.

I'm a victim of crime and call the police - I pay for them to come and deal with.
Supermarket shoplifting - the supermarket pays. Yes I know there are holes and yes so much more thought would have to go into it but given that we are commenting on yet another thread (dozens a day it seems) with people venting their frustrating at getting taxed more to pay for others, sick of disabled people and their cars, all the SEN kids and outrage at what people are getting in money etc

At the moment the budget, benefits, tax outrage, not wanting to pay for others is the most common topic on Mumsnet. I mean this one is isn't it.

I just thought with the current system not working, so many people not working v working and our debt growing each month we cannot carry on the way we are.

It seems people just want to slag off the current system and worry but not consider any other possible ideas or hybrid ideas. Fair enough.

I'll just go back to moaning then like everyone else.

I'm a victim of crime and call the police - I pay for them to come and deal with.
Supermarket shoplifting - the supermarket pays. Yes I know there are holes and yes so much more thought would have to go into it but given that we are commenting on yet another thread (dozens a day it seems) with people venting their frustrating at getting taxed more to pay for others, sick of disabled people and their cars, all the SEN kids and outrage at what people are getting in money etc

So a rape victim should pay to have her rapist tried and convicted? Or a victim of CSA should have their parents pay? (I’m speaking as a victim here.).

And what about when the victim has been murdered? Should the family pay for justice?

I agree that there’s an argument that criminals should be compelled to pay their own legal fees and imprisonment, but, apart from criminals like Epstein, who could afford realistically to pay legal fees and many years of incarceration? If, as I assume, you want long sentences to protect the public?

And who would pay the judges and barristers, and prison officers?

In practice, no one could afford to pay and we’d end up with vigilante justice, as the families wouldn’t be able to pay for proper justice.

That isn’t just naive, it’s ludicrous. And thankfully it won’t ever happen.

ItsDefinatelyHappeningNow · 18/11/2025 11:28

Everlore · 18/11/2025 08:18

The poor spelling and grammar, coupled with the extreme stupidity of their suggestions were some of the reasons I have decided this poster is engaged in satire, what clinched it for me was them ending one of their ridiculous posts with something to the effect of their ideas being so sensible that they would need to come up with a new word for sensible. That, to me, seemed a real giveaway that they were playing a comic character, just a parody of the horrible posts that proliferate on here.
I sincerely hope I'm right as, if it turns out their posts are genuine, it is chilling to think that somebody simultaneously so lacking any shred of humanity and with such low intelligence could be walking amongst us.

Sorry very well educated as it goes although it does seem a long time ago now. When i went to uni grants were still being dished out. Economic/financial career which allowed me to retire very early.

I admit my posts came from a financial point of view of our country is a mess so how do we fix it. Plus it had the advantage of stopping all the anger that is seen on here daily about funding benefits for others.

I read on here about people sitting in A&E for 18 hours crying in their own vomit. I was suggesting a system where it was private and paid for but much better. I would argue that the current system is becoming pretty unusable or inhumane if you want to call it that.

I'm afraid that with retiring early I have a great interest in political affairs, economic matters and financial things. I do spend alot of time watching and reading. Yes my suggestion was a bit 'flip' and in response to all the threads here about the state of the country, people sick of taxes to pay for benefits etc

the country has changed greatly since the eighties. Yes there were benefits but it was seen as so much more shameful to be on them. I'm pretty sure lots of the benefits that seem to exist today did not exist back then. Of course many of our problems come from the rising house prices which has made people struggle to afford a home on their wages without benefit top ups. In the seventies the goverment spent x amount building council houses. Now they spent just as much paying for temporary accomodation/housing benefit etc.

Whether we like it or not many of our systems were designed when the population was less, when people did not live as long and when the vast majority of the population was not on benefits or out of work. I can't imagine anyone on here thinks the NHS is coping nowadays or that the country is overcrowded.

FoughtIt · 18/11/2025 11:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FoughtIt · 18/11/2025 11:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.