Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cut benefits before increasing council tax

460 replies

Bonde · 15/11/2025 15:19

https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/reeves-council-tax-hike-5HjdMrJ_2/

As an increase in income tax is now out the window, the government will have to look at other ways to fill the gap by increasing a dozen smaller taxes. One option, I think they will opt for, is to apply a surcharge for homes in bands F,G&H. It would be politically expedient to do so because many people will assume those in such homes are wealthy.

We purchased our band f property earlier this year at £550k. We live in London and didn’t want to uproot our family, and move jobs, so decided to buy our 2.5 bed house.
After mortgage and bills, we have £100 to £200 left over, but some months have nothing. An increase would be so difficult to manage.

Why can’t the government have the courage to cut benefits. You can buy a BMW or Mercedes on the Mobility Scheme! Why?

Reeves set to hit thousands of homes with new levy after massive U-turn on income tax | LBC

The Chancellor is preparing to hit homes in the highest council tax bands with a new surcharge

https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/reeves-council-tax-hike-5HjdMrJ_2/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
EasternStandard · 15/11/2025 15:55

gingerbreadmaid · 15/11/2025 15:52

Exactly and I know where my sympathy lies.

People working with dc in London often stretch to buy a house. It’s expensive.

I don’t blame the op for not wanting to be hit with more taxes.

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2025 15:54

Sesma · 15/11/2025 15:51

The question is, did you vote Labour, if you did you get everything you deserve.

Yep I’m applying your empathy to those in Kent voting Reform too - cuts in lots of areas , council tax up to the maximum

gingerbreadmaid · 15/11/2025 15:52

SD1978 · 15/11/2025 15:39

You chose a house you could barely afford, no one chooses a disability…….

Exactly and I know where my sympathy lies.

amicisimma · 15/11/2025 15:52

SugarandSpiceandAllThingsNaice · 15/11/2025 15:42

Yabu.
London council tax is well below the national average. It’s about time things were evened up. Band F in Westminster is only £1500/yr, whereas Band F in my deprived rural area is £3500/yr.

There are 32 Boroughs in London. Most of them have considerably higher Council Tax than Westminster.

PumpkinTwistyWindToots · 15/11/2025 15:51

Sesma · 15/11/2025 15:45

How do I know what you post is true

If you're asking about the universal credit rates you can google that too - my figures were slightly out of date but not too much

www.gov.uk/universal-credit/what-youll-get

Cut benefits before increasing council tax
Cut benefits before increasing council tax
Sesma · 15/11/2025 15:51

The question is, did you vote Labour, if you did you get everything you deserve.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/11/2025 15:51

Viviennemary · 15/11/2025 15:23

I agree benefits need to be cut and also the flash cars on the mobility schemes. But I think fair enough a levy on more expensive houses.

Cutting the ‘flash cars’ on the mutability scheme would save precisely nothing. The Motability scheme is paid for by individuals using their higher rate PIP, plus sometimes an upfront payment, to lease a car. It doesn’t matter what the car is, the PIP cost to the government is what’s important. So to save money you have to reduce PIP for all claimants, or at least reduce the higher rate PIP as I think that’s what’s required to access the Motability scheme.

WiddlinDiddlin · 15/11/2025 15:50

In case anyone needs it clarifying:

Widdlin' qualifies for the mobility part of PIP. She gets £300 a month for this.

Widdlin' can choose to spend that on taxis, buses, a wheelchair, a scooter, on anything that helps her get around really.

She chooses to spend it on a car lease via the Motability Scheme.

She looks at the scheme and finds the only vehicle her wheelchair will fit in is a WAV, a Citroen Spacehopper (Spacetourer) which is massive and has a 5K advanced fee, plus adaptations cost which she doesn't yet know.

She cannot use taxis, there are none in her small town or slightly larger nearby city that can take her powerchair.
She can use the train, but only to get to Very Large City which she rarely needs to go to. The station in Slightly Larger City is not accessible for her chair. Therefore the Spacehopper is really the sensible option unless Widdlin' intends to never go further than Aldi's down the road.

Over the five year lease, Widdlin's Spacehopper is going to cost her at LEAST 23K, vs not having the Spacehopper (not including the adaptations fee which was several more K because its a lowered floor, winch, ramp, tie down points, different seat belt set up).

After 5 years, Widdlin has to do it all over again.

If Widdlin' chooses not to have the Spacehopper, she will still be in receipt of the mobility part of PIP because she is still a big fat cripple. So the cost to the taxpayer will not reduce if Widdlin' does not have the Spacehopper.

Please explain where that buys Widdlin' a car, or where that car is free to Widdlin'.

(figures not quite accurate i have better things to do than go look up the exact numbers. By 'cost her' Widdlin is aware that some will argue this isn't 'her' money it's the governments and thus the taxpayers but this is money the government currently says Widdlin' is entitled to and at the point of choosing whether to use it via the motability scheme or spaff it on cake, it is Widdlin's money because it's in Widdlin's bank account!)

EasternStandard · 15/11/2025 15:50

There wasn’t meant to be more tax rises after the last budget so I get why people are annoyed.

LadyKenya · 15/11/2025 15:50

Tamfs · 15/11/2025 15:47

Do you honestly think people with disabilities on non-means tested benefits are tearing around jn free Mercedes?

If you want to push the personal responsibility agenda, then you shouldn't have bought a house where a £100 a month increase in bills would tip you over the edge.

Don't be talking sense now.

PumpkinTwistyWindToots · 15/11/2025 15:49

Sesma · 15/11/2025 15:45

How do I know what you post is true

You can google - it's easy
https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/sick-or-disabled-people-and-carers/help-for-disabled-travellers1/motability-scheme/getting-a-motability-car/?gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23139573802&gbraid=0AAAAA-Td8Vvll67MoqOx87yoLNW6PaZpH&gclid=Cj0KCQiA5uDIBhDAARIsAOxj0CHQR2mzDnaqWNWjptzrP2Rhwd89h1uBPHg8dgKv5HNY5yFEJTEc9WUaAhECEALw_wcB

If you receive a benefit because you have a disability or illness that makes it hard for you to get around, you can use it to pay for a vehicle from a charity called Motability.

You’ll only be paying for the lease of the vehicle - it won’t belong to you. If you stop receiving your benefit, you’ll have to return it.

Your benefit will go directly to the Motability Scheme each month to pay for your lease. How much of your benefit will go towards your vehicle will depend on which one you choose.

You’ll probably need to make a payment upfront if you choose a more expensive vehicle.

Getting a Motability car

How to find a motability car, scooter or powered wheelchair if you're disabled or have a condition that makes it hard to get around

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/sick-or-disabled-people-and-carers/help-for-disabled-travellers1/motability-scheme/getting-a-motability-car/

LadyKenya · 15/11/2025 15:48

DeafLeppard · 15/11/2025 15:37

Totally agree. I got posts deleted when I pointed out that a poster banging on about their Motability car being essential for them, had said in a previous post its main use was getting their DH to work, and she hardly used it.

Well it is usually an essential to have a roof over one's head. This Woman's husband going to work is part of that. And the recipient of Motability does not have to be able to drive all the time, or even at all. Read up on it perhaps...

Genevieva · 15/11/2025 15:48

SugarandSpiceandAllThingsNaice · 15/11/2025 15:42

Yabu.
London council tax is well below the national average. It’s about time things were evened up. Band F in Westminster is only £1500/yr, whereas Band F in my deprived rural area is £3500/yr.

And Londoners get good public services.

elviswhorley · 15/11/2025 15:47

I think you could do away with anxiety for PIP and that would cut loads. I'd be okay with this. I've had severe anxiety myself. It's not something that can opt you out of work. It's a normal part of life that we all have to deal with.

I know people who receive PIP often work, but if you can top up your wages with PIP, it's about £400/month, it means people can claim anxiety and get that top up so they then don't work those extra hours and pay that extra tax.

Tamfs · 15/11/2025 15:47

Do you honestly think people with disabilities on non-means tested benefits are tearing around jn free Mercedes?

If you want to push the personal responsibility agenda, then you shouldn't have bought a house where a £100 a month increase in bills would tip you over the edge.

PumpkinTwistyWindToots · 15/11/2025 15:46

DeafLeppard · 15/11/2025 15:37

Totally agree. I got posts deleted when I pointed out that a poster banging on about their Motability car being essential for them, had said in a previous post its main use was getting their DH to work, and she hardly used it.

That poster is a fool then as she is losing the equivalent of those car payments from her PIP which could be used for something that directly benefits her. I'd be concerned about financial abuse actually if she's sacrificing her disability benefits to lease a car for her husband's benefit! But you do realise she's not getting any more by using the motability scheme than she would be if she wasn't?

Genevieva · 15/11/2025 15:46

SpaceRaccoon · 15/11/2025 15:44

That's the thing though. A lot of houses in Band F and even higher aren't expensive mansions. But no-one could foresee their council tax getting randomly doubled - it's a huge hike.

I'm in Band F and my house is worth less than a 1 bed flat in London.

The same as us. I think our house is only bang F because all the listed buildings in our area were given band F back in the 70s.

Katypp · 15/11/2025 15:45

Did you this last month OP?
Or just when the plans look look like affecting you? Would you be OK if the ceiling was set at the band above you?

Sesma · 15/11/2025 15:45

PumpkinTwistyWindToots · 15/11/2025 15:44

Oh well if a poster on Reddit said so it must be true!
There's nowhere for benefits to be cut further. Universal credit is £290 a month per adult for their living costs and about £400 for a child. Rent can be claimed towards as well but unless someone is on a very old council tenancy their benefits will not cover their rent so they have to top it up from that meagre living cost sum.
In relation to disability benefits - it's extremely difficult to scam DLA/PIP. More people don't claim them when they are entitled than claim fraudulently. The vehicles are paid for out of the disability benefit. So what a person receives is docked by the monthly hire cost of the car. Yes they may be expensive cars but often they need to be adapted because - you know - disability?

How do I know what you post is true

YorkshireGoldDrinker · 15/11/2025 15:44

I'm pretty sure the Motability scheme is propping up the new car market at the moment, as well as that of the EV market. The whole thing wreaks of state-level fraud.

"I have narcolepsy and fall asleep on the bus, give me a free car." - True story.
www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2025/07/12/drivers-sleeping-disorders-subsidised-cars-scheme/

GarlicBreadStan · 15/11/2025 15:44

EditorInChief · 15/11/2025 15:41

Reddit? Good grief, instead of spitting out untruths why don't you actually do some research.

Hit the nail on the head.

I don't choose to be autistic and burn out easily. My mum didn't choose to HAVE to be medically retired from work, and my son didn't choose to be autistic either.

I appreciate that some autistic people are able to work, but unfortunately, I am not one of them. I couldn't even deal with uni 2 days a week, and that was recent. I had to drop out after 6 months, and I only lasted that long because I felt like I'd be letting people down if I continued.

I'd LOVE to work. But I just can't.

OP, please don't take Reddit posts as fact. I use Reddit, and I can smell most bullshit posts a mile off. I bet the one you read was complete bullshit

Wompet · 15/11/2025 15:44

Goady McGoadface.

SpaceRaccoon · 15/11/2025 15:44

That's the thing though. A lot of houses in Band F and even higher aren't expensive mansions. But no-one could foresee their council tax getting randomly doubled - it's a huge hike.

I'm in Band F and my house is worth less than a 1 bed flat in London.

PumpkinTwistyWindToots · 15/11/2025 15:44

Bonde · 15/11/2025 15:36

I apologise if I come across as lacking empathy. I had read a post on Reddit where a posted had claimed his relatives were all claiming these benefits even though they didn’t need to.

Oh well if a poster on Reddit said so it must be true!
There's nowhere for benefits to be cut further. Universal credit is £290 a month per adult for their living costs and about £400 for a child. Rent can be claimed towards as well but unless someone is on a very old council tenancy their benefits will not cover their rent so they have to top it up from that meagre living cost sum.
In relation to disability benefits - it's extremely difficult to scam DLA/PIP. More people don't claim them when they are entitled than claim fraudulently. The vehicles are paid for out of the disability benefit. So what a person receives is docked by the monthly hire cost of the car. Yes they may be expensive cars but often they need to be adapted because - you know - disability?

Genevieva · 15/11/2025 15:44

AlastheDaffodils · 15/11/2025 15:28

The problem with council tax is the bands bear little relation to today’s values. OP lives in a fairly normal house and is band F. There are £700k houses that are band G paying £4k a year. Meanwhile most of the houses on our London suburban road in a low tax borough are worth about £2m but are band E, £1200 council tax a year.

So if they double the rates for bands G and H, you’ll get £700k houses paying £8k p.a. tax and £2m houses paying £1200 pa. Grossly unfair.

Where you live enough houses sell for you to have a good idea what they are worth. Where we live we have no idea. There aren’t enough houses and there are years where nothing sells. Our house is really old and pretty, but we have no central heating. When we bought the house it had been in the market for 4 years and come down in asking price by 30%. We knocked another 10% off because it had a crack in the stone wall that was letting damp in and needed fixing. I can well see an estate agent valuing our house at a price no one would buy it at, especially holidaymakers, as they might have to pay quadruple council tax. I like my home and I don’t plan to move, but I think it’s in sellable in the current market.