Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help please! To move back "home" to different country despite being super happy in UK

85 replies

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 09:27

I have lived in the UK for the last 12 years, very happy with good job, nice are, husband and child.

The plan was always to move back to my own country but we are so settled now. I feel terrible for my parents though who live back there (they have a lovely life but miss us loads, plus my sister also lives abroad). It's a high income country with great services so it's not that they struggle, but I feel bad for being far away and I really feel the pressure to move soon if we do it at all as son is 6 years old now and wouldn't want to leave it much longer. At the same time I am really worried to leave our life here behind (that's if DH can even find a job there!) The country I would be moving though is, however, on the face of it, "better" in terms of public services, weather, and safety, so I do wonder if I am making a mistake by staying here (I love the UK and not trying to trash it at all by the way)

Make the leap and go or stay here??? AIBU for leaving, YANBU for going

OP posts:
notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 15:12

@LouiseMadetheBestBroccoliPasta I am very curious as to what the country you moved to is, but understand if you don't want to say!

OP posts:
notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 14:50

LouiseMadetheBestBroccoliPasta · 13/11/2025 14:24

It was really hard. In the previous country, we had a cozy, genuinely happy, settled life with lots of friends and community connections that we had built up, where the kids were building their own connections, where we were both comfortable career-wise and financially, and public services etc were really accessible.

We went from that to a struggle life in a (top 8 GDP) country where the people are much more closed off and many seem miserable and depressed, the school system is old-fashioned, and every aspect of daily life was/is much more complicated (tax, healthcare, buying a house etc). Coming from the relaxed comfy previous country, the kids were not happy, and 15 years later, only the youngest, who was 2 when we came, has any affiliation with the country and community. The other two have fled the country as soon as they could. And we earn 3-4 times the national average wage together and we can't understand how people who earn less manage. We also essentially came to help my H's parents, FIL was ill, but the dysfunctional IL family politics were so awful that we all stopped seeing them 4 years in. Most pertinently, I struggled to find my footing careerwise, and as the person who did all of the family's emotional labour, I often felt like I was drowning in stress, and I was constantly exhausted.

So the move turned out to be a real sacrifice for me personally and professionally and even physically (I was underweight for years and ground my molars to pieces). And while it was easier for my H (being his stamping ground), he felt the consequences of the move on me keenly. He knows now what "happy wife, happy life" means.

So yes, we regret the move: we messed up. It definitely wasn't perfect in the previous country - the people are friendly and relaxed but also shallow and complacent - and there are certainly good, even great, things where we are now. But it was EASY to live in the previous country, and we were able to build an EASY and comfortable life for ourselves and our kids. That ease and comfort shouldn't be taken for granted. We did, and regret it.

Also, if the burden and sacrifice of such a move particularly affect one partner (me in our case), this can create a very deep resentment, especially when the other partner is less affected because for them it's just slotting back into their culture and homeland.

You've already mentioned one very serious problem, which is your H's job. If this move means that he has to sacrifice his career, or the move will diminish his opportunities, that is almost certainly going to become a massive friction point for him - and your marriage - over the long run. No matter how well-intended he feels now, how much he loves you, and how willing he is to embrace the new life, if he is the one who suffers while you thrive, that will create an emotional ulcer in the marriage.

You also mentioned that he gets along well with your family and friends in Austria. I did with my ILs too before we moved to be close to them - because before we moved, we were VISITING them. Once we started living here, it was an entirely different thing. I would never have guessed what was lurking behind that lovely kindly facade of my ILs.

Anyway, this is my perspective. I was also older than you, I think (40s), the move was much bigger (transcontinental), and had 3 kids ranging from 10 to 2, so maybe that made things harder. But still, I tell anyone who is considering such a big life-changing move to not take for granted the easy and comfortable life that they already have, and to weigh that up against the possible - but not guaranteed - advantages of moving to the new country.

Edited

My heart goes out to you- that sounds all very difficult! I hope that the future will be brighter and that maybe you can move away from there again, or is this not an option now?

I'm late thirties but the fact that my DS is an only child is worrying me as well in aspects of moving- I somehow think if he had siblings then they could lean on each other. Saying that he is very outgoing though so hopefully he'd be fine!

That's the thing, we live in a lovely community and have made many good friends with neighbours, etc, my son is so happy and settled and I am terrified I could mess this up for him.

OP posts:
LouiseMadetheBestBroccoliPasta · 13/11/2025 14:24

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 12:00

I'm sorry things didn't work out as planned! May I ask what it was that didn't work out? Did you just not feel at home there, or were children unhappy etc.?

It was really hard. In the previous country, we had a cozy, genuinely happy, settled life with lots of friends and community connections that we had built up, where the kids were building their own connections, where we were both comfortable career-wise and financially, and public services etc were really accessible.

We went from that to a struggle life in a (top 8 GDP) country where the people are much more closed off and many seem miserable and depressed, the school system is old-fashioned, and every aspect of daily life was/is much more complicated (tax, healthcare, buying a house etc). Coming from the relaxed comfy previous country, the kids were not happy, and 15 years later, only the youngest, who was 2 when we came, has any affiliation with the country and community. The other two have fled the country as soon as they could. And we earn 3-4 times the national average wage together and we can't understand how people who earn less manage. We also essentially came to help my H's parents, FIL was ill, but the dysfunctional IL family politics were so awful that we all stopped seeing them 4 years in. Most pertinently, I struggled to find my footing careerwise, and as the person who did all of the family's emotional labour, I often felt like I was drowning in stress, and I was constantly exhausted.

So the move turned out to be a real sacrifice for me personally and professionally and even physically (I was underweight for years and ground my molars to pieces). And while it was easier for my H (being his stamping ground), he felt the consequences of the move on me keenly. He knows now what "happy wife, happy life" means.

So yes, we regret the move: we messed up. It definitely wasn't perfect in the previous country - the people are friendly and relaxed but also shallow and complacent - and there are certainly good, even great, things where we are now. But it was EASY to live in the previous country, and we were able to build an EASY and comfortable life for ourselves and our kids. That ease and comfort shouldn't be taken for granted. We did, and regret it.

Also, if the burden and sacrifice of such a move particularly affect one partner (me in our case), this can create a very deep resentment, especially when the other partner is less affected because for them it's just slotting back into their culture and homeland.

You've already mentioned one very serious problem, which is your H's job. If this move means that he has to sacrifice his career, or the move will diminish his opportunities, that is almost certainly going to become a massive friction point for him - and your marriage - over the long run. No matter how well-intended he feels now, how much he loves you, and how willing he is to embrace the new life, if he is the one who suffers while you thrive, that will create an emotional ulcer in the marriage.

You also mentioned that he gets along well with your family and friends in Austria. I did with my ILs too before we moved to be close to them - because before we moved, we were VISITING them. Once we started living here, it was an entirely different thing. I would never have guessed what was lurking behind that lovely kindly facade of my ILs.

Anyway, this is my perspective. I was also older than you, I think (40s), the move was much bigger (transcontinental), and had 3 kids ranging from 10 to 2, so maybe that made things harder. But still, I tell anyone who is considering such a big life-changing move to not take for granted the easy and comfortable life that they already have, and to weigh that up against the possible - but not guaranteed - advantages of moving to the new country.

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 14:08

Ddakji · 13/11/2025 13:58

Ah, OK. Well, that will change in the future as your DS will want to spend more time with his friends (though probably not for some years yet!).

So do you and your DS spend quite a bit of the holidays not with your DH?

No, it's only 2 weeks in the summer where we don't see him. He's otherwise always with us apart from the odd one or two days

OP posts:
Ddakji · 13/11/2025 13:58

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 13:51

Not quite. So with my job I am in the very fortunate position that I can work from anywhere in the world and I often work in the summer, and my mum looks after DS. Then DH joins and we go on holiday to a different country 🙂

Ah, OK. Well, that will change in the future as your DS will want to spend more time with his friends (though probably not for some years yet!).

So do you and your DS spend quite a bit of the holidays not with your DH?

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 13:51

Ddakji · 13/11/2025 13:33

One thing that jumps out is that currently pretty much all your holidays are tied up with going to Austria.

So, two things.

One - that you all clearly love it otherwise you wouldn’t do that.

Two - that if you lived there you could go on holiday to other places.

Tying up holidays to always go back to the same place (do you stay with your parents the whole time you’re there, or do you visit other places?) seems to be not sustainable to me.

Not quite. So with my job I am in the very fortunate position that I can work from anywhere in the world and I often work in the summer, and my mum looks after DS. Then DH joins and we go on holiday to a different country 🙂

OP posts:
Ddakji · 13/11/2025 13:33

One thing that jumps out is that currently pretty much all your holidays are tied up with going to Austria.

So, two things.

One - that you all clearly love it otherwise you wouldn’t do that.

Two - that if you lived there you could go on holiday to other places.

Tying up holidays to always go back to the same place (do you stay with your parents the whole time you’re there, or do you visit other places?) seems to be not sustainable to me.

Theyreeatingthedogs · 13/11/2025 13:21

Do your DH & DS speak your native language?

RainbowBagels · 13/11/2025 13:09

How old are your parents if you only have a 6 year old? They may not even need care until he is much older. I think it sounds like you go over plenty and it's not even that far away. It takes me longer to drive to London to see my DM!

itsthetea · 13/11/2025 13:09

You have a good life
it is hard when your parents are far away but as a parent whilst yes, would rather DD lived close, I know it’s right she lives her life and I am glad she does

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 13:07

ginasevern · 13/11/2025 12:43

Do you think you DH will really be happy in Austria OP? I don't think it's the easiest place to make friends. What about his parents? Are they in the UK and won't the same situation arise with them at some point. Also, he's going to be pretty stressed if he finds a job over there and is too terrified to lose it.

My DH gets on splendidly well with my parents and my friends over there. He also loves sports and would likely join a club. I totally agree though that Austria is not the easiest country to make friends.

With his parents, they have much more family over here than my parents have over there. His sister also lives near and is very involved in their lives.

OP posts:
notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 13:06

Greenqueen40 · 13/11/2025 13:03

It's Austria, just over 2 hours away on a flight, it takes me longer than that to drive to see my DPs in the UK! You are being massively unreasonable towards your husband and son. Your parents may never even need any help in the future.

Thank you for your viewpoint. Yes, it is a short trip. I am not BU towards them at all I don't think - I am thinking of all the plus points a previous poster has pointed out- great landscapes, sparsely populated, fantastic public services, which, in the long run, benefits all of us. Not to mention university education is free in Austria. Also swimming in the lakes, the quality of water and roads, etc. etc.

OP posts:
Greenqueen40 · 13/11/2025 13:03

It's Austria, just over 2 hours away on a flight, it takes me longer than that to drive to see my DPs in the UK! You are being massively unreasonable towards your husband and son. Your parents may never even need any help in the future.

TodaRythm · 13/11/2025 12:57

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 12:02

It's Austria. It is beautiful there, it truly is, and the quality of life is great, but I have always- even when I was a teenager- found the mentality quite closed off (despite having good friends there, to this day). I have always felt somehow more comfortable in the UK, and I have friends here from all over the world, and I find everyone much more polite.

Thank you.
It is a fantastic nation and self-declared neutral country, which in these crazy times we live in, could be a massive plus.
It is a country who consistently ranks really high in the quality of life indices. A strong economy, high employment rates, sparsely populated, lovely landscapes...in the meantime the UK is going to the dogs thanks to Brexit.
For me it is a yes. Go for it!

ginasevern · 13/11/2025 12:43

Do you think you DH will really be happy in Austria OP? I don't think it's the easiest place to make friends. What about his parents? Are they in the UK and won't the same situation arise with them at some point. Also, he's going to be pretty stressed if he finds a job over there and is too terrified to lose it.

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 12:03

PermanentTemporary · 13/11/2025 11:54

I think from everything you say it’s a good idea to move, and soon, because of your son’s age. If you make the decision to move as soon as the right job becomes available, then that suggests being proactive about finding a job, rather than just keeping an eye out for- talking to recruiters, planning the relocation, looking at houses etc.

Thank you. I am so very torn! It's also hard because it will be difficult to find a job for DH, and if he finds one, he really has to keep it because there likely won't be many others to switch to if you see what I mean.

OP posts:
notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 12:02

TodaRythm · 13/11/2025 11:55

What country is it?
We can't help you if you don't say the country.

It's Austria. It is beautiful there, it truly is, and the quality of life is great, but I have always- even when I was a teenager- found the mentality quite closed off (despite having good friends there, to this day). I have always felt somehow more comfortable in the UK, and I have friends here from all over the world, and I find everyone much more polite.

OP posts:
notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 12:00

LouiseMadetheBestBroccoliPasta · 13/11/2025 11:58

I moved for my H, a transcontinental move. We both think it was a mistake, and are now of the firm view that if things are working really well, don't wreck it.

I'm sorry things didn't work out as planned! May I ask what it was that didn't work out? Did you just not feel at home there, or were children unhappy etc.?

OP posts:
MuddlingMackem · 13/11/2025 11:58

I think one thing to consider is if you make the move could you ever move back to the UK?

As awful as it is to think about, but how would you feel living in your home country once your parents are no longer around. Is that where you want to spend the rest of your life, or would you want to come back to the UK? Because by then your kids will - hopefully - be adults and you may then have grandchildren in that country you won't want to move away from.

LouiseMadetheBestBroccoliPasta · 13/11/2025 11:58

I moved for my H, a transcontinental move. We both think it was a mistake, and are now of the firm view that if things are working really well, don't wreck it.

TodaRythm · 13/11/2025 11:55

What country is it?
We can't help you if you don't say the country.

PermanentTemporary · 13/11/2025 11:54

I think from everything you say it’s a good idea to move, and soon, because of your son’s age. If you make the decision to move as soon as the right job becomes available, then that suggests being proactive about finding a job, rather than just keeping an eye out for- talking to recruiters, planning the relocation, looking at houses etc.

Shitstix · 13/11/2025 11:53

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 11:48

Thank you so much for your reply. So you moved once you found the right job over there? And how did your children find the move?

No jobs. Just moved. I started a contract role a couple of weeks in. Took dh months as his field is niche and although he had experience in London, he didn't have 'local' experience.

DC were fine. We made the move seem like it was just what happens - moving home.

notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 11:52

LadyQuackBeth · 13/11/2025 11:41

It isn't unreasonable for your DH to keep an eye on jobs that suit him, local to your parents. YABU to move without him having a job or any real prospects of finding one.

Could you visit more instead? Then you can feel less guilt without giving up your life? Is your sister having the same dilemma?

Thanks for your reply! Good idea to keep an eye on jobs.

Our current visiting schedule:

  • All summer holiday (5-6 weeks)
  • Every Christmas for 2 weeks
  • Either February half term or Easter, or May holidays

This year we went on average every 2 months.

My sister.... well, she's lovely and we get on well, but she doesn't really thing about the more serious things in life. She visits regularly but then just relaxes all day long when she's at my parents. She also has absolutely no plan of ever moving back. I very much envision that when / if the time comes, I will shoulder the absolute lions share of caring/ making arrangments.

OP posts:
notsurewhattodo11 · 13/11/2025 11:48

Shitstix · 13/11/2025 11:44

I did this. And it was the best thing.

A bit different in that we weren't 'super happy' just content. Life was ticking along nicely in the UK. 2 dc, house, really good jobs. Just couldn't imagine how/why we would make the move.

But the how/why popped up one day. DH and l thought about it, and decided to go for it. Dc were 7 and 3.

Thank you so much for your reply. So you moved once you found the right job over there? And how did your children find the move?

OP posts: