Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want child support?

63 replies

CandyColouredEggshells · 12/11/2025 14:53

I’ve been separated since April 2024, divorce came through April this year, and with the house sale we both bought our own properties with mortgages. It hasn’t been easy (he was emotionally and psychologically abusive, coercive and just generally not a nice guy, my previous threads are probably here somewhere without going into too much detail) but I managed to sort things.

We have 50/50 custody of DD, and it mostly works. The problem I have is I earn about £50k, and XHB earns about £104k. When we separated he didn’t see why he should pay me child support because “that would make it like I was paying you to look after her and we look after her equally” and said she’d never go without and if she needed something he’d get it. Obviously that isn’t working, he is a typical Disney dad and she gets everything she wants granted, and if I specifically ask he will sometimes get it.

For example in the holidays I bought her school uniform, new bag, pencil case, lunchbox, new coats, and asked him to get her some school shoes and trainers for PE. Which he did. I had to find out through DD because he ignores me now, but she did tell me he was taking her and shoes did appear.

He said he was going to send me money for half her coat but didn’t, I’ve been paying for her dance classes every month since we split up without him contributing and now I’ve forked out £60 on the rehearsals and costumes for the Christmas show and asked him for half and he’s ignored me. The frustrating thing is if he doesn’t see her show DD would be heartbroken so I’ll have to offer him a ticket too (last year I told him I wouldn’t be booking him one without payment upfront and he did eventually send it).

Has anyone dealt with something similar? Don’t have money for solicitors, don’t want to speak to him about it, especially if I’m not really entitled to anything as we do have 50/50 custody. I can get by, it’s just infuriating.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Whistleme · 14/11/2025 06:41

CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 21:24

Nah more because he buys her unnecessary crap but not anything she actually needs. Plastic crap galore but I’m having to really budget because I’ve spent £60 on her dance show which I don’t have

But he could argue…. He is buying her things that he wants to and that she loves

And you buying her dance classes… presumably she loves dance?

plus with 50/50 - clothes at his, entertainment at his, food, transport - life!

Whistleme · 14/11/2025 06:39

The CMS calculation will incorporate he lives with another child

plus op and ex are 50/50

so chances of a penny to the op are, low

Coconutter24 · 13/11/2025 21:43

CandyColouredEggshells · 12/11/2025 16:03

He does buy a lot for her… skincare, makeup, clothes, accessories, toys, plushies, fidgets.

Nothing for school or extra-curricular without nagging and/or prompting and most the time then I don’t get it. So frustrating that when she wants something I make a note to put it on her Christmas list. Not only do I have a chance he’ll just buy it for her as “a treat” but I might be able to get her more treats if I wasn’t buying all the sensible stuff all the time.

Not a dig at you, sorry, I’m just fed up.

If he does pay you the £40 you mention will he likely stop buying her all the things he currently does? That would mean you’d either be no better off because you’d have to then buy them or you gain a few pounds each week but your DD misses out on things she usually has.

FourCatMama · 13/11/2025 21:32

In the US even if 50/50 c/s is calculated by a special worksheet using income of each parent. With these numbers, mother would DEFINITELY be entitled to child support

Further each would have to pay their proportionate share of the child's medical, school supplies and extracurricular activities as well as any day care or extraordinary medical expenses

Finally you don't have to have a lawyer to do this. You can file with the state and they will have a hearing and set the amount of support. Then they will withdraw directly from his employer if he doesn't pay.

TwinkleTwinkleLittleBatgirl · 13/11/2025 21:26

CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 21:24

Nah more because he buys her unnecessary crap but not anything she actually needs. Plastic crap galore but I’m having to really budget because I’ve spent £60 on her dance show which I don’t have

How old is dd and who started her on the dance show stuff?

CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 21:24

rwalker · 13/11/2025 21:19

I’m slightly confused he has her 50/50 and by your own admission he buys her a lot off stuff
is it because he earns more you think he should cover a chunk of your share as well

Nah more because he buys her unnecessary crap but not anything she actually needs. Plastic crap galore but I’m having to really budget because I’ve spent £60 on her dance show which I don’t have

OP posts:
MoFadaCromulent · 13/11/2025 21:23

Bloody Disney Dad's looking after their kids half the time

rwalker · 13/11/2025 21:19

I’m slightly confused he has her 50/50 and by your own admission he buys her a lot off stuff
is it because he earns more you think he should cover a chunk of your share as well

CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 21:12

GovernmentFundedSteak · 13/11/2025 19:44

This is interesting. I didn't think CMS got involved in anything that happened before you opened a case with them. So if you've been under or over paid then they won't make either parent balance that. They told me that the payments before I opened a case were a private agreement and therefore the fact they were less that CMS awarded me was irrelevant.

I really don’t know what to think, it all seems so convoluted and confusing!

OP posts:
CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 21:10

PeachyKoala · 13/11/2025 19:48

How grabby!

Bless your heart

OP posts:
PeachyKoala · 13/11/2025 19:48

How grabby!

GovernmentFundedSteak · 13/11/2025 19:44

InterIgnis · 12/11/2025 16:12

According to the CMS intro to the calculator:

You will not have anything to pay through the Child Maintenance Service if you are:

  • sharing care equally with the other parent
  • a full-time student with no income
  • in prison

Another MN poster recently ran afoul of blindly trusting the calculator, and not only lost a significant amount of money, but is now likely going to have to pay back the money she did manage to claim from him.

This is interesting. I didn't think CMS got involved in anything that happened before you opened a case with them. So if you've been under or over paid then they won't make either parent balance that. They told me that the payments before I opened a case were a private agreement and therefore the fact they were less that CMS awarded me was irrelevant.

MrsKeats · 13/11/2025 19:35

GreggWallacesTrousers · 12/11/2025 15:53

Why don’t you use the CMS to calculate what you’re owed?

There’s not usually anything owed when it’s 50/50.

CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 19:19

Thank you everyone for your replies. Will check this thread less frequently as I think I have my answer. It doesn’t feel fair but don’t think luck (or the law) is on my side with this one.

Ah well!

OP posts:
CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 19:18

SkinnyOatFlatWhiteForMePlease · 13/11/2025 14:55

@CandyColouredEggshellshave you tried https://www.gov.uk/calculate-child-maintenance calculator for an average calculation?
I would be inclined to call them and ask - you have nothing to lose.

Thank you but a PP somewhere has pointed out that this isn’t reliable because you’re not entitled of you share custody 50/50, bit daft really as it asks in the calculator how much time they spend with the other parent and there’s an option to say half the time.

OP posts:
CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 19:17

elviswhorley · 13/11/2025 15:42

You're letting him control your emotions via his actions and this is the main thing we are free from when we leave them.

He sorts his own ticket for school.

Use AppClose, it's free.

I see it as you both have care of the child and you both spend what you have. I'm not counting pennies and begging my ex for his money because I don't have the energy. I like a stress-free life. I like spending on my child. I'm proud of what I can provide for her.

You’re right, and I do manage, and I am so proud that I’ve got a mortgage and a house in which I can put the heating on and stock the fridge with no help from anyone.

Sometimes it just feels unfair, and I sit and mutter to myself over a glass of wine 😂

But you’re right and it is wasted energy and emotions that he shouldn’t be able to still provoke.

OP posts:
elviswhorley · 13/11/2025 15:42

You're letting him control your emotions via his actions and this is the main thing we are free from when we leave them.

He sorts his own ticket for school.

Use AppClose, it's free.

I see it as you both have care of the child and you both spend what you have. I'm not counting pennies and begging my ex for his money because I don't have the energy. I like a stress-free life. I like spending on my child. I'm proud of what I can provide for her.

SkinnyOatFlatWhiteForMePlease · 13/11/2025 14:55

@CandyColouredEggshellshave you tried https://www.gov.uk/calculate-child-maintenance calculator for an average calculation?
I would be inclined to call them and ask - you have nothing to lose.

Calculate your child maintenance

Use this calculator to work out an amount of child maintenance for your children.

https://www.gov.uk/calculate-child-maintenance

Multiplebroc · 13/11/2025 14:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Multiplebroc · 13/11/2025 14:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CandyColouredEggshells · 13/11/2025 14:36

Multiplebroc · 13/11/2025 14:12

She’s 10, and we do 2 nights, 2 nights, 3 nights. So we get every other weekend to spend the whole weekend with her.

this sounds so disruptive for this child

When I/we were researching how to co-parent and do the split it was an example that came up and so far it’s worked fine for us, she has a bedroom and her stuff at both houses and we live fairly close to each other.

The way I see it she gets to see both her parents every week. If she ever seemed fed up with it I’d obviously address it then.

I know it’s not really about me but I couldn’t imagine not seeing her for a whole week, and what if Christmas was mid-week, how do you navigate that? Genuinely curious here.

OP posts:
Pranaon · 13/11/2025 14:17

MoFadaCromulent · 12/11/2025 16:21

"If one parent earns £50k and the other earns £100k then would the higher earner not be responsible for more of the cost of the child and so be paying the lower earner?"

You're not a partnership anymore

No, but they were when they agreed to raise a child together. If he contributed more to the care of the child financially when they were together, why should the child be disadvantaged by the dissolution of the relationship?

Multiplebroc · 13/11/2025 14:12

She’s 10, and we do 2 nights, 2 nights, 3 nights. So we get every other weekend to spend the whole weekend with her.

this sounds so disruptive for this child

Multiplebroc · 13/11/2025 14:12

CandyColouredEggshells · 12/11/2025 23:02

Erm, dunno how you’ve got here lol, but yes his GF and her DC live there too.

it is relevant @CandyColouredEggshells because any CMS calculation would incorporate that he lives with another child Op ie be less.

50:50…. I’m afraid no chance op especially he is living with another child

CandyColouredEggshells · 12/11/2025 23:11

ItsOnlyHobnobs · 12/11/2025 17:26

It’s a difficult situation to be in op, I do sympathise.

How old is your daughter?
How does the 50/50 split work practically? One week on, one week off, or a division of the week on a rolling basis?

For things like school uniform, I’ve known friends who. Have bought enough uniform for their care of the child, that stays in their home. When dad is doing school, he can provide uniform.

I think in theory that works in a rational world, problem is I’m not in a rational world 😂

She’s 10, and we do 2 nights, 2 nights, 3 nights. So we get every other weekend to spend the whole weekend with her.

The only buying things for when she’s with me sort of works, unless the mufti days end up falling on days when he drops her off and I pick her up a couple of times and then I don’t have any more school trousers so have to ask for them back.

Feel like I’ve gone off on a tangent now, but still 🤣🤣

OP posts: