Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So sick of AI generated fake videos on social media etc

88 replies

MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/11/2025 15:27

Frankly, I don't think AIBU at all, but feel free to contradict if you think i am.

I only use Facebook to keep up with friends and acquaintances, and sometimes to watch crafting videos.

It's bad enough all the fake animal rescue / animals saving children AI slop videos, and the "art" and "music" generated entirely by algorithms. I cross reference anything that looks dodgy.

But today I came across a video that seems to show people in an official looking US legal setting, showing people, average looking citizens, all down on the floor restrained with purportedly armed ICE agents standing over them. The caption was something to do with filibustering and the shut down.

I've done a quick poke around the Internet and obviously there's no other evidence that this is anything other than fake.

I just don't get it. Well, I'm not that naive, I do. I'm just sick of it, sick of not being able to trust anything much I see because the faking is getting so scarily good.

Sorry, I just needed a rant.

OP posts:
Timelineuk · 11/11/2025 07:27

noblegiraffe · 10/11/2025 23:15

A huge amount of the accounts commenting wishing the fake old lady happy birthday are also bot accounts.

It’s AI commenting on AI. No one involved is real.

That’s another level of black mirror I hadn’t thought of

BelleEpoque27 · 11/11/2025 00:26

I think it will be the end of social media. What's the point in following a creator if they're not real, or you don't know if the content is real.

Even on here I'm increasingly not bothering with posts because I suspect they're AI-generated.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 11/11/2025 00:11

elprup · 10/11/2025 22:52

So you don’t have a problem with a state broadcaster splicing together two sentences that were 50 minutes apart in a speech to misrepresent what the most powerful person in the world was saying? Really?

Exactly. The BBC has allowed dishonest employees to destroy its unique reputation for honesty and impartiality. That's what really disgusts me.

manineed · 11/11/2025 00:08

it’s scary how fast it seems to be moving, will it eventually get to a point where there are no tell-tale signs?

I always used to think how cool it is that future generations will have so much photo and video material of history, but that this rate they probably won’t know what’s real or not 🙄

Lovesabadboy · 10/11/2025 23:40

EmeraldRoulette · 10/11/2025 23:14

@Lovesabadboy but I was meeting with AI developers in 2016. (I don't have any understanding of AI, I was part of a very long chain of generally pointless workers)

I don't think it was that good in 2016 though, but I just had that very sad thought that it might not be real.

😧😧Nooooooooooo!!

I still think that most AI videos are pretty rubbish these days (getting better all the time, but there are still tell-tale signs and a 'smoothness' to them IMO), so I prefer to think that back then they would not have been so good/believable.

I have just found the original video on You Tube dated 9 years ago, so I honestly don't think AI was at a very high standard back then.

That video will never not make me laugh!

MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/11/2025 23:38

elprup · 10/11/2025 22:52

So you don’t have a problem with a state broadcaster splicing together two sentences that were 50 minutes apart in a speech to misrepresent what the most powerful person in the world was saying? Really?

Fair enough, I didn't express myself very well on this subject, however I do say in that quote that such editing "no AI needed" is part of the problem. I'm beyond frustrated with every aspect of what is being churned out as "content" no matter the source, and the way it makes it nigh on impossible to get a grasp on reality.

It irks me that Trump is in a position to sue for a billion, when news organisations are supposed to go through everything with a fine tooth legal comb to make sure that doesn't happen. Then again, "churnalism" has been guilty of misrepresenting things for time immemorial, and it seems to be contingent on having power and money to achieve real redress, normally it's a tiny apology buried amongst the newsagent.

But isn't this just an absolute example of the "Idiocracy" endemic in our time?

I spend alot of my time going "eh?" When I dip into current affairs, to the point where I'm seriously concerned that I might be going down the cognitive impairment route, because nothing, but nothing, makes sense to me any more, and while I'm in my late 50s I'm hardly in the "rose tinted glasses nostalgia" cohort due to some personal experiences that gave me a rude awakening about how the world can work.

I'm with the PP who mentioned going the Amish route. Very appealing if we can keep "God" out of it.

OP posts:
powershowerforanhour · 10/11/2025 23:34

"What I don't get is that generative ai scrapes websites for the data it uses to generate. But now people use generative ai instead of looking at a website.
So presumably ai will just eat itself"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0r0erqk18jo

This describes it quite well. The human centipede- shitting out the scrapings, eating them and shitting them out again over and over.

I hate it too. I hate the obvious fakes that are just an insult to the intelligence, but I hate that I've probably been taken in by more realistic looking things plenty of times. Nobody likes being taken for a fool. I hate feeling that I should be on high alert for fakery when I just want to be able to relax and trust the world sometimes- after all, most people are reasonably honest most of the time, most real people have some sort of moral code, but AI does not. Like a lot of you have said, I hate that this is making me suspicious too. My friend sent me a video of a Polish guy skiing off Everest without oxygen. It looks real, and as far as I can tell from cross checking it is real, one of those Red Bull things. But like a PP said, I just want to be simply awed by things, not think "oh wow, that's amazing...hang on, is this just more bullshittery?...." every time

Robin and Zelda Williams pictured at a red carpet for Happy Feet 2 in 2011 in Los Angeles

Robin Williams' daughter pleads for people to stop sending AI videos of her dad

The filmmaker said it is not what her dad, who died in 2014, would have wanted.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0r0erqk18jo

Fizbosshoes · 10/11/2025 23:31

noblegiraffe · 10/11/2025 23:15

A huge amount of the accounts commenting wishing the fake old lady happy birthday are also bot accounts.

It’s AI commenting on AI. No one involved is real.

And an old couple apparently standing in the same place 50+ years later or something bs like that
FB is nearly all ads, fake stuff and AI videos you have to scroll for ages to see any actual real people that you know

I also dislike that if I google something the first answers that come up are AI, and its not always true

Ratafia · 10/11/2025 23:22

Most fakes that I have seen have been embarrassingly bad. There was what purported to be film of a bridge collapsing, which showed a number of cars apparently still driving happily through thin air. And another where a massive wave appeared to break over a quayside with several people on it, none of whom made the slightest attempt to get away and were still standing, clearly bone dry, when the wave receded. They can get quite funny when they're as bad as that.

noblegiraffe · 10/11/2025 23:15

Timelineuk · 10/11/2025 18:50

At the beginning of this year Starmer said AI would be injected in other mainline of the UK same time as Trump announced 500 billion AI industry with Larry Ellison and Theil. Musk then announced AI would do 80% of jobs and the challenge for humans would be find a purpose. Whatever he means I don’t know exactly but he didn’t seem optimistic for humans but he’s optimistic for AI

i can’t believe how many people can’t see a fake happy birthday picture of an old woman saying no one wishing me happy birthday and everybody commenting. It’s Pathetic if one can’t tell what’s real or not but I’m starting to see its getting harder

Edited

A huge amount of the accounts commenting wishing the fake old lady happy birthday are also bot accounts.

It’s AI commenting on AI. No one involved is real.

EmeraldRoulette · 10/11/2025 23:14

@Lovesabadboy but I was meeting with AI developers in 2016. (I don't have any understanding of AI, I was part of a very long chain of generally pointless workers)

I don't think it was that good in 2016 though, but I just had that very sad thought that it might not be real.

Lovesabadboy · 10/11/2025 23:07

EmeraldRoulette · 10/11/2025 21:50

Someone, please tell me that the panda who was really shocked when her baby panda sneezed is real?

I know exactly which video you mean and it has been around for many years (pre-AI), so I think it is definitely real!

Freedomishereandnow · 10/11/2025 23:01

I agree with you OP. I watched a video on youtube about tips to spot AI videos:

  1. Videos are less than 10 seconds
  2. Mistakes in the background
  3. AI is better at hands now so check teeth
  4. People having a conversation but their face/body isn't aligned to the person they are talking to like people would naturally
  5. Fast cuts to scenes that don't follow on from one another
  6. Illegible writing on things
elprup · 10/11/2025 22:54

Kind of ironic that you’ve started a thread about how you’re sick of AI generated fake videos but are perfectly happy for humans to do the same 🤣

elprup · 10/11/2025 22:52

MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/11/2025 16:29

I've been trying to figure out this whole Trump / BBC editing fiasco that's kicked off. Given the utter shite that the Tangerine scream comes out with on the daily, it's utterly bizarre all round. From what I gather Panorama edited out 40 odd minutes of ramble that didn't seem to change much of the thrust of the speech in question, however, I can see that even this, no AI needed is part of the problem. And I'm no big fan of any of the major broadcasters by any stretch.

A few years back it was revealed that a correspondent allegedly in a war zone being shown behind him, was actually in front of a green screen.

The film "Wag the Dog" is on a long list of fiction that has foreshadowed reality to an alarming degree.

So you don’t have a problem with a state broadcaster splicing together two sentences that were 50 minutes apart in a speech to misrepresent what the most powerful person in the world was saying? Really?

Classiccar1 · 10/11/2025 22:47

My wife's friends are constantly sending her AI videos of cute animals and babies. They think they are lovely - I hate them!

bananapies · 10/11/2025 22:41

It going to break up a few people.

JillMW · 10/11/2025 22:26

I don’t watch any videos unless from a reliable source except craft ones. I may soon have to stop the craft ones, they have been so useful for me learning skills but lately the ai has meant they are completely unreliable.

EmeraldRoulette · 10/11/2025 21:50

Someone, please tell me that the panda who was really shocked when her baby panda sneezed is real?

Theresabatinmykitchen · 10/11/2025 21:49

GentleSheep · 10/11/2025 19:13

Musk then announced AI would do 80% of jobs and the challenge for humans would be find a purpose

Such a huge red flag right there! Anything that removes humanity's purpose can't be a good thing.

Sadly it’s happening at rapid pace, this is very sobering.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/UclrVWafRAI?si=pVnoZxZ9h4_sblUB

IBorAlevels · 10/11/2025 19:27

But it is at the point we don't really know if it is real people commenting or just bots stirring up hatred/fear. Every year we get the same Poppy crap about intolerance and I see the same idiotic comments swallowing it but surely by now everyone knows that no one objects to anyone wearing a poppy?

GentleSheep · 10/11/2025 19:13

Musk then announced AI would do 80% of jobs and the challenge for humans would be find a purpose

Such a huge red flag right there! Anything that removes humanity's purpose can't be a good thing.

Tiebiter · 10/11/2025 19:00

What I don't get is that generative ai scrapes websites for the data it uses to generate. But now people use generative ai instead of looking at a website.

So presumably ai will just eat itself

Timelineuk · 10/11/2025 18:50

At the beginning of this year Starmer said AI would be injected in other mainline of the UK same time as Trump announced 500 billion AI industry with Larry Ellison and Theil. Musk then announced AI would do 80% of jobs and the challenge for humans would be find a purpose. Whatever he means I don’t know exactly but he didn’t seem optimistic for humans but he’s optimistic for AI

i can’t believe how many people can’t see a fake happy birthday picture of an old woman saying no one wishing me happy birthday and everybody commenting. It’s Pathetic if one can’t tell what’s real or not but I’m starting to see its getting harder

TidyCyan · 10/11/2025 18:32

I hate it. All of it. I hate that people are asking ChatGPT to design them a bedroom, what messages from their partner mean, and how to do their jobs. I hate that people Google stuff and just trust the AI summary when it's usually based off one web result and incorrect.

It's going to be so easy to win elections in the future with a few carefully-placed fake videos for the hard of thinking.