Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Father was convicted of sexual assault on 17 year old, should I let him see my kids + MORE

310 replies

Lordvampire3 · 09/11/2025 21:37

Hi Everyone,

This is extremely hard to post and I am looking for other insight of whether I am being unreasonable.

My Father was convicted and due to be let out of prison for sexual assault of a 17 year old (in the UK this is over consent age so wasnt charged as child offense)

My DP and I made the decision that he would not see our 4 kids when he leaves prison due to what he has done. I was talking to my brother today and they exploded saying I was being out of order to not let him see his grandkids because of what he did

Am I being unreasonable? For context 3 of my children are girls, 11 9 and 4 and out little boy is 3.

I have been talking to him once a week and havent found the courage to say he wont see them as I worried about the fallout, plus selfishly I didnt want to be the cause if he didnt something stupid inside (like off himself etc)

Any help would be appericated

OP posts:
Springtimehere · 10/11/2025 07:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Dancingsquirrels · 10/11/2025 07:45

Remember, if he / family kick off, who started all this? Your father, not you. This situation is all of his own making

Cycleaway · 10/11/2025 07:44

Well firstly, your brother is free to make his own decisions, but has no business making yours.

whatever you decide is the right thing, but if you want to feel more confident/justified when discussing this with your brother, I would suggest that if you do some reading around reoffending profiles for sexual offenders - The profile is very different to other crimes - you will feel entirely justified in your decision

Bellyblueboy · 10/11/2025 07:43

Andromed0 · 09/11/2025 22:00

It must be very hard to know your dad assaulted a young woman, or any woman. There is no reason to think he is sexually attracted to children; his victim was not a child; but he has been abusive to at least one woman and do you want your young children growing to trust and love someone who would do that? I'd be inclined to wait until they are old enough to hear what your father has done, and let them decide for themselves.

Oh my heavens. This is a man who would sexually assault a 17 year old. And you think that makes him safe with children?

that is not a risk I would ever, ever take. He shouldn’t be alone with any females - he is a dangerous man.

When someone tells you who they are believe them.

Mischance · 10/11/2025 07:40

His offence was serious enough to warrant a prison sentence so I think you are right to keep him away from your children.

Andromed0 · 10/11/2025 06:53

PinkPonyClubDancer · 09/11/2025 23:35

You don’t know that for certain at all. It’s not a risk that I would take, sounds like you would though.

The age of consent in the UK is 16. Its an anomaly that 16 and 17 year olds are called children legally and the terminology confuses this kind of issue. The man's crime was sexual assault, not sex with a child. I guess anyone can have paedophilic tendencies, but there is no evidence in this case.
Assuming that the two things are connected is a little bit like the bad old days when being a gay man was conflated with sexually abusing young boys. That idea seems to have gone or at least decreased. Much more unfair of course, because being gay is not wrong and sexual assault is.
I am with OP in being reluctant to let her dad spend time with her children until they are older. I wouldn't allow it.

Didkyle · 10/11/2025 06:38

For the person that ask as well, I had no issues in my childhood and honestly cant fault him as a fathe

I don’t remotely trust your benchmark for what you perceive as a “fault” in a father

Neemie · 10/11/2025 06:36

You made a very reasonable decision with your DP (whose views are also very important here). Your father created this situation so you don’t have to feel guilty. He is responsible for his behaviour and the consequences of it.

thepariscrimefiles · 10/11/2025 06:32

Lordvampire3 · 09/11/2025 21:58

Thank you for all the people commenting so far! Its nice to feel I am not being unreasonable.

For context in why im still speaking once a week, I feel if I had stop talking to him completely and he decided to take his own life (which im sure many would say it would be no great loss considering what he did) that I would love with the guilt that my action caused his death.

Just wanted that added as I know some will be wondering why I am even in contact myself at all.

As a manipuulative sex offender, I doubt that he would take his own life. He will threaten to do so to manipulate you and to get his own way. Many people have gone no contact with a parent for much less than what your father has done.

I don't understand your brother's position on this at all. Isn't he also disgusted and ashamed of what his dad has done or is he minimising and excusing the sexual assault? If it is the latter, I would be giving him a wide berth as well.

rainbowsparkle28 · 10/11/2025 06:25

Absolutely not. Honestly I would be concerned about someone’s ability to protect their child/children if they did. A firm no. And don’t let other family members make you feel bad, you are safeguarding your children which is your job and as for the feelings of the person that did it, I’m sorry but they gave away the right to contact when they made the decision to do that.

BelatrixLestrange · 10/11/2025 06:21

stichguru · 09/11/2025 22:44

I think there are 2 questions here -

Would you be unreasonable to stop your children seeing your dad?
NO you would be 100% reasonable to do this if that is what you want to do.
Would you be unreasonably putting your children at risk if you did let your children see your dad?
NO If you put in appropriate safeguards such as you or another trusted adult always being in the room or space alongside your dad and your children.

Would you be unreasonably putting your children at risk if you did let your children see your dad?

What do you mean no? By seeing their grandfather they would be learning that he is a safe adult. He is NOT a safe adult.

ElizaMulvil · 10/11/2025 05:54

And don't ever leave your children with your brother. He may well take the opportunity to introduce their grandfather to them to remedy your 'mistakes'. Ditto any other family member who is showing signs of sympathy for your father.

WearyAuldWumman · 10/11/2025 02:33

ThatBlackCat · 10/11/2025 02:17

The fact that your brother thinks it's no big deal and your father should still have access to your girls is very worrying and shows he has no care or compassion for victims of assault. I hope he doesn't have daughters. I'd cut contact with your brother too, what a horrible person he is too.

He might be in denial.

That was the case for the relative I mentioned in a previous post. By the time the offender was imprisoned for a second time, my relative had died.

I had previously reported the offender's contact with other children to the authorities. Nothing came of that until after his second imprisonment. I suspect that there were many other victims.

I'll add here that the offender kept trying to get back in contact with my relative's family and I fear for his motives. He was rebuffed but kept trying, even to the extent of watching a family funeral from a distance.

The point I'm making is that that this type of offender is determined and the OP will need to keep careful watch on her children, particularly since it seems that her brother might try to enable him to make contact.

ThatBlackCat · 10/11/2025 02:17

The fact that your brother thinks it's no big deal and your father should still have access to your girls is very worrying and shows he has no care or compassion for victims of assault. I hope he doesn't have daughters. I'd cut contact with your brother too, what a horrible person he is too.

DrowningInIt · 10/11/2025 02:09

Lordvampire3 · 09/11/2025 22:42

Thank you for all the post and I am sorry I am unable to reply to all of them!

This has helped reinforce my decision and make me feel like I should never of doubted it on the first place.

Thank you also to those who had made me realise that having the contact regardless of what happens has been a way of me not having control. I will be cutting contact, and if parts of my family cant expect that then I guess it might be time to cut them to, my children and my DP are my world and I will always want to keep them safe.

For the person that ask as well, I had no issues in my childhood and honestly cant fault him as a father (his now crime has completely tainted all of that though)

Sometimes It helps to have the outaide perspective and to point out things that I might overlook as it is a "norm" to myself

Thank you everyone

Is the name of the man’s first name Beginning J ending in S
second name beginning with F ?

allthingsinmoderation · 10/11/2025 02:05

You sound a bit naive ,make a Claires law application and find out exactly what your father is convicted of and its relevance to the safety and wellbeing of your children.

HoppingPavlova · 10/11/2025 01:20

No idea how you could ask this. Of course, a sex offender shouldn’t be in contact with your children. An internet shouldn’t have to tell you this. If your brother has children, they should be removed frankly, due to beyond poor judgement. I couldn’t have any contact with the person, irrespective of what they may do to themselves.

WaryHiker · 10/11/2025 01:15

If you were posting on here about any other man, asking whether you were reasonable to allow your children to be around a sex offender because you were frightened of offending your brother if you didn't, you would be rightly handed your arse and told to get a grip and parent properly.

Why is it any different because you happen to be related to the sex offender?

PinkyFlamingo · 10/11/2025 01:04

I think you need some help sorting out your feelings, if he killed himself as you suggest then that's entirely on him, not you

tapaw · 10/11/2025 00:40

If he will look at a 17yo in that way, then he will look at your 11yo like that.

Also the fact that she was 17 and over the age of consent is not relevant. For a start, nobody consents to sexual assault and for another thing, she was a child. Plus if he did it to her, there will be plenty of others who he has done this to

WearyAuldWumman · 10/11/2025 00:39

MySilentLions · 10/11/2025 00:38

Got it, easy done. But on such a sensitive topic, could be hurtful to OP.

My apologies once again.

MySilentLions · 10/11/2025 00:38

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/11/2025 00:31

So sorry. Skim reading. Idiot.

Got it, easy done. But on such a sensitive topic, could be hurtful to OP.

WearyAuldWumman · 10/11/2025 00:35

MySilentLions · 10/11/2025 00:35

Again, Im not seeing anything in OP’s posts about her husband/partner saying this??? I don’t think I’ve missed an update. It’s her brother who exploded.

Yes, I've apologised above.

MySilentLions · 10/11/2025 00:35

WearyAuldWumman · 10/11/2025 00:12

That could be it.

I'll add here that the offender I mentioned above attacked females - both adults and children, but one of his victims was a male child.

The OP's husband is crazy if he thinks that a sex offender can be trusted around anyone.

Again, Im not seeing anything in OP’s posts about her husband/partner saying this??? I don’t think I’ve missed an update. It’s her brother who exploded.

JFDIYOLO · 10/11/2025 00:33

How to make a Sarah's Law enquiry:

https://www.police.uk/request-sarahs-law

Swipe left for the next trending thread