Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why do you wear a poppy?

411 replies

oiolehnvn · 06/11/2025 11:45

Lots of red poppies around us at the moment. Disclaimer I am not British but come from a country that is currently waging a war, in fact technically two countries that have been in the news for waging wars and have always been uncomfortable with people supporting or celebrating our army. I am therefore puzzled as to why the Brits wear poppies ever year. If you choose to wear one, what's your rationale? Equally, if you do not - what's yours?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TimeForATerf · 09/11/2025 17:03

Yes, and like probably most multi generational Brits, I has ancestors (my grandmothers siblings) who went to war as teenagers and never returned and the one that did never recovered from his shell shock and ended his days as a tramp.

i will continue to wear one.

ThatCyanCat · 09/11/2025 16:58

"Rather hoped I’d get through the whole show. Go back to work at Pratt & Sons; keep wicket for the Croydon gentlemen; marry Doris. Made a note in my diary on the way here. Simply says: ‘Bugger'."

ThatCyanCat · 09/11/2025 16:36

cardibach · 09/11/2025 16:23

I think those who have had to fight or may have to in the future, or who have been affected by war, are generally in favour of maintaining peace.

I would certainly think so.

cardibach · 09/11/2025 16:23

ThatCyanCat · 09/11/2025 14:00

I was at my local remembrance service this morning and there was plenty of attention given to the importance and value of peace (it's always been rather the point for me). The local army battalion/regiment (sorry, I'm not good with the correct terms) and RBL representatives were there, so I assume they had no objection to this.

I think those who have had to fight or may have to in the future, or who have been affected by war, are generally in favour of maintaining peace.

ThatCyanCat · 09/11/2025 14:00

I was at my local remembrance service this morning and there was plenty of attention given to the importance and value of peace (it's always been rather the point for me). The local army battalion/regiment (sorry, I'm not good with the correct terms) and RBL representatives were there, so I assume they had no objection to this.

BringBackCatsEyes · 09/11/2025 13:30

cardibach · 09/11/2025 12:06

Odd. I wore mine to play in a concert. I’m a flautist somid have been repeatedly knocking it. Never budged. It was difficult to remove, and it stuck firmly to something else after - maybe you had a faulty one. I’ve lost umpteen pinned on ones though.

I suspect it might have been the fabric it was stuck to. It's a Uniqlo jacket and I just looked up what's it made of - 100% Elastomultiester whatever the heck that is

celticnations · 09/11/2025 13:25

Hardly anyone wearing one here in the Highlands & Grampian. There are clusters eg in Forres near RAF Lossiemouth & Kinloss Barracks.

cardibach · 09/11/2025 12:06

BringBackCatsEyes · 09/11/2025 12:05

I got one of the new poppies yesterday - thin card/paper, no plastic and a sticker rather than a pin.
I stuck it on my coat and walked to the village war memorial and noticed the sticker poppy didn't make it!

Odd. I wore mine to play in a concert. I’m a flautist somid have been repeatedly knocking it. Never budged. It was difficult to remove, and it stuck firmly to something else after - maybe you had a faulty one. I’ve lost umpteen pinned on ones though.

BringBackCatsEyes · 09/11/2025 12:05

I got one of the new poppies yesterday - thin card/paper, no plastic and a sticker rather than a pin.
I stuck it on my coat and walked to the village war memorial and noticed the sticker poppy didn't make it!

BinaryDot · 08/11/2025 14:03

Because in my family, and most other British families, young working-class men who had barely ever left their home towns volunteered or were sent to go to hellish battlefields in Europe, Asia and Africa in two world wars.

Many of them didn't come back to their families, many who returned were physically and psychologically disabled. Meanwhile their families were uprooted, suffered privations, lived in constant fear of bomb strikes and invasion. When I remember my family, I have to remember all the other families who have been through wars and conflicts in defence of my country.

That soldiers from my country were previously sent to fight colonial and civil wars initiated by powerful leaders does not diminish anything that ordinary soldiers and civilians have had to sacrifice in service.

In WWII, a truly huge contribution was made by the many soldiers and civilians in what were then British territories in South and Southeast Asia, the Middle East, Africa and the Caribbean who went into the war on the Allied side, not forgetting the brave Irish soldiers who also went.

In later years, British soldiers were sent to fight all over the world, risking death and disability and struggling to adjust to civilian life afterwards.

I have led such a comfortable and secure life in this country compared to them and the very, very least I can do is wear a bloody poppy to remember all of those peoples' sacrifices and contribute some cash to veterans' charities.

Wearing a poppy isn't an endorsement of governments or war leaders or ideologies, It's a specific act of acknowledgement and remembrance. I'm pleased to see the purple poppies this year to also mark the loss of many service animals who died in the wars.

I despise the kinds of people who, for their own gormless political aims, attempt to disparage poppy day and remembrance.

Snowflakecentral · 08/11/2025 11:29

Layer · 08/11/2025 10:31

That's shocking that people have commented directly to you, knowing what you have been through. I think we all need to respect each other's trauma not diminish it as less important - something it forget and get over. Britain has done some bloody awful things - they rightly should own it, if other countries don't that doesn't make them right.

Thank you, I wear it for my deceased h, for the fallen, for veterans and their families.

Layer · 08/11/2025 10:31

Snowflakecentral · 08/11/2025 10:19

Thank you for asking, yes, it has been commented on by several who knew my h had been killed.
Also it is online on many areas, 'why are red poppies so negative' brings up a lot of reasons.
I actually said in a pp that Britain apologises for a lot of things, history related, that other countries couldn't give a shit about and wouldn't do so, poppies got pulled in with my thoughts.
But I do think some peeps are being obtuse on here regardless.

That's shocking that people have commented directly to you, knowing what you have been through. I think we all need to respect each other's trauma not diminish it as less important - something it forget and get over. Britain has done some bloody awful things - they rightly should own it, if other countries don't that doesn't make them right.

Snowflakecentral · 08/11/2025 10:19

Thank you for asking, yes, it has been commented on by several who knew my h had been killed.
Also it is online on many areas, 'why are red poppies so negative' brings up a lot of reasons.
I actually said in a pp that Britain apologises for a lot of things, history related, that other countries couldn't give a shit about and wouldn't do so, poppies got pulled in with my thoughts.
But I do think some peeps are being obtuse on here regardless.

Layer · 08/11/2025 10:06

Snowflakecentral · 08/11/2025 09:52

No, it's not Bull Shit you can say it.
Nobody needs to apologise for wearing a poppy nor should they.
I was refering to the side of society that doesn't agree with red poppies and promotes it in a negative way.
You won't need to go too far to educate yourselves on the matter.
Some people believe it to be racist in favour of white people totally incorrect view but theit opinion.
Others think it's outdated, which it never will be and others say they won't wear it due to past links of the empire oppression among other examples.
My first h was killed in the Falklands so I have full respect for the military veterans.

Have people directly criticised your wearing of the poppy or is this something you’ve been aware of online? I

Boomer55 · 08/11/2025 09:55

oiolehnvn · 06/11/2025 11:45

Lots of red poppies around us at the moment. Disclaimer I am not British but come from a country that is currently waging a war, in fact technically two countries that have been in the news for waging wars and have always been uncomfortable with people supporting or celebrating our army. I am therefore puzzled as to why the Brits wear poppies ever year. If you choose to wear one, what's your rationale? Equally, if you do not - what's yours?

It’s thanks for those who lost their lives so that we kept our freedom.

The money raised goes to a good cause. 👍

HappyGolmore2 · 08/11/2025 09:54

‘red poppies and promotes it in a negative way.’

promoting it how, by not wearing a poppy???? I don’t care if you wear one or not, I choose not to and Inhave very good reasons.

Snowflakecentral · 08/11/2025 09:52

HappyGolmore2 · 08/11/2025 08:58

I’ve yet to meet anyone wearing a poppy who felt the need to apologise for wearing it, that’s total BS.

No, it's not Bull Shit you can say it.
Nobody needs to apologise for wearing a poppy nor should they.
I was refering to the side of society that doesn't agree with red poppies and promotes it in a negative way.
You won't need to go too far to educate yourselves on the matter.
Some people believe it to be racist in favour of white people totally incorrect view but theit opinion.
Others think it's outdated, which it never will be and others say they won't wear it due to past links of the empire oppression among other examples.
My first h was killed in the Falklands so I have full respect for the military veterans.

HappyGolmore2 · 08/11/2025 08:58

I’ve yet to meet anyone wearing a poppy who felt the need to apologise for wearing it, that’s total BS.

Sterlingrose · 08/11/2025 08:57

Snowflakecentral · 06/11/2025 12:45

I wear a red and a purple poppy, men and animals both made horrific sacrifices though no choice of their own. Plus it is also about supprting our veterans and currently serving men and women.
We seem to have to apologise for wearing poppies where as America celebrates its veterans and those serving and quite rightly so.
But then Britain offers apologies for a lot of things where other countries don't give a shit about. that's another thread though so not derailing.
As you were peeps.
Poppies are not celebrating any thing, never have and never will, but the fallen, injured and seriving must be remembered always.

When have you ever had to apologise to anyone for wearing a poppy? Such an absurd thing to say.

Washingbasquait · 08/11/2025 08:46

HeyThereDelila · 06/11/2025 12:09

As you say, you’re not British so presumably have no appreciation of the destruction, sacrifice and magnitude of World War I and World War II.

I wear a poppy with pride to honour the sacrifices and hardships of men and women in those generations. A toll and hardships our generation wouldn’t have a clue about.

It’s not glorifying war - it’s honouring those who gave everything for our freedom.

Do only British people have an appreciation of the impact of WWI and WW2?

HappyGolmore2 · 08/11/2025 08:43

If only there was a symbol that only represented the fallen of the World Wars while excluding ‘soldier’ who abused and murdered civilians in NI.
But there isn’t.

Duckie2025 · 08/11/2025 04:58

In respect and memory of the men and boys who were slaughtered to keep their homeland and loved ones safe.

Layer · 08/11/2025 03:52

Phoenix1Arisen · 07/11/2025 22:54

You're quite right. I am lucky.

My family, massive Irish inheritance, CHOSE to move on.

I say again, as I stand beneath the Menin Gate, among representatives of dozens of nations, forgiveness is the only way forward.

Has anybody in the whole history of humankind ever come up with something better?

Your are funny - “my grandparents were Irish” that’s a bit of a joke in Ireland it’s something we usually hear from Americans who know nothing either. If you knew anything you’d say nothing, but you don’t - I forgive you.

MermenHunters · 07/11/2025 23:31

Phoenix1Arisen · 07/11/2025 22:54

You're quite right. I am lucky.

My family, massive Irish inheritance, CHOSE to move on.

I say again, as I stand beneath the Menin Gate, among representatives of dozens of nations, forgiveness is the only way forward.

Has anybody in the whole history of humankind ever come up with something better?

Please do not claim that your ‘massive Irish inheritance’ entities you to any particular insight. Any more than the racists who have imaginary black best friends.