Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think gentle parenting has made some kids unbearable to be around?

619 replies

KindButFirmFox · 05/11/2025 16:58

Boundaries aren’t oppression.
Sometimes “gentle” just looks like “ineffective”.

AIBU to think balance has been lost between empathy and discipline?

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 07/11/2025 06:25

By sixth form they were trusted. We still had reasonable expectations.

  1. No nights out Mon- Thurs
  2. Room kept in reasonable state defined as being hooverable once a week
  3. Each had house hold chores: DS bins and hoovering, Dd children's bathroom ( cleaner left after Covid)
  4. To let us know if not coming home by a reasonable time ( 10pm).
  5. Clear plan for getting home ( with a caveat we would come and get them if needed)

In return for this they got a generous allowance, lifts home from parties (+ mates) most weekends, driving lessons( both) riding lessons ( Dd) lift to and from football twice weekly (DS). Ih and we allowed boy friend/ girl friend sleep overs at the weekend in Sixth form.

Seemed fair to us and them. They are now 19 & 21 they are doing well.

Chillithai · 07/11/2025 05:52

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2025 22:25

I have described it up thread. But we had contracts of behaviour, clear expectations, no screens in bedrooms untill after GCSEs. No screens after school until homework was completed. Yes they had curfews untill the end of year 11. I should also say that DS was 15 going in to lockdown and 17 when it lifted so I think Boris Johnson did much of the firm boundaries for us.

What happened in sixth form? You went from all that to….? @Neurodiversitydoctor

Chillithai · 07/11/2025 05:51

Woah…. Just read the robot dog posts from the pro smaker. Explains a lot!

No words. Just 😆 😆 🤖 🐶

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2025 22:25

Letsgetmilky · 06/11/2025 15:01

How did you handle teens? When he wanted to be independent more? Curfews? @Neurodiversitydoctor

I have described it up thread. But we had contracts of behaviour, clear expectations, no screens in bedrooms untill after GCSEs. No screens after school until homework was completed. Yes they had curfews untill the end of year 11. I should also say that DS was 15 going in to lockdown and 17 when it lifted so I think Boris Johnson did much of the firm boundaries for us.

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:21

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:12

I can hardly string a sentence together after failing my education. Grammar, punctuation, spelling - all over the shop.

ETA: I can barely speak either, I'm so dense. As for making sure I get the right change, forget it. Who said 1 plus 1 makes 2, anyway? Perhaps there's a hidden quality and it actually makes 3!

That's me. Thick as mince. 😂

Edited

See you're being sarcastic but it doesn't sound any MORE unlikely than any of your other posts

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:20

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:18

Well, I'm not writing a biology paper here. Of course it's a simplification. Or are you saying that we do NOT have genetic code written into all of our cells?

I'm saying comparing it to computer code is ridiculous oversimplification and I'm trying ow ork out if you're capable of understanding that

Tintackedsea · 06/11/2025 21:19

I think I believe in gentle parenting in the sense of not yelling and shouting and being an utter rocket but my own children definitely get told no. In fact lots more no here than other parents I know. But it’s in combination with lots of chatting and games and spending time together.

Lazy parents are lazy parents no matter what they call it.

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:18

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:05

I have a biological sciences background and your oversimplification is just bizarre.

Well, I'm not writing a biology paper here. Of course it's a simplification. Or are you saying that we do NOT have genetic code written into all of our cells?

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:12

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:10

Well that makes sense

I can hardly string a sentence together after failing my education. Grammar, punctuation, spelling - all over the shop.

ETA: I can barely speak either, I'm so dense. As for making sure I get the right change, forget it. Who said 1 plus 1 makes 2, anyway? Perhaps there's a hidden quality and it actually makes 3!

That's me. Thick as mince. 😂

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:10

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:08

I failed all my GCSEs and am barely literate.

What are you talking about - mindset? I said some facts about A.I. That's not a mindset.

You don't own an A.I. robot who employs deep learning and augmented reality. You don't know what that's like. So who are you to pronounce on it?

Edited

Well that makes sense

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:08

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:06

The fundamental lack of understanding in this mindset is mind boggling. What level of education do you have?

I failed all my GCSEs and am barely literate.

What are you talking about - mindset? I said some facts about A.I. That's not a mindset.

You don't own an A.I. robot who employs deep learning and augmented reality. You don't know what that's like. So who are you to pronounce on it?

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:07

Chillithai · 06/11/2025 19:23

Sure you are

What do you mean by this spiteful comment?

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:06

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:40

Sorry, what's nuts?

Yes, I know I'm not really a parent, thanks. It was a joke about being the parent of a robot-dog.

ETA: If you're talking about the A.I. capabilities of the dog, it's only as nuts as the rest of A.I. That's where we are now with A.I. An artificial mind is reality. It's not real, and it's not an object. It's something in between - A.I. intelligence.

Edited

The fundamental lack of understanding in this mindset is mind boggling. What level of education do you have?

Horsie · 06/11/2025 21:06

frozendaisy · 06/11/2025 19:39

It's how you see your children as they grow as your babies.

If one of our children had keyed a car, would be worse if it wasn't ours.

We would work out the damage and pay for that and then take away, until at least it was paid back, everything the child loved. Football team, online gaming, ice cream, a birthday party. They would effectively be under house arrest.

There would be early boring bedtimes, no time with friends, no desserts, the punishments would be endless, the lectures, the conversations. We would take everything they loved away.

But I wouldn't hit them.

What would you do? Would you just hit them? And then get back to normal?

Because for some they would take the hit and think, yeah moment of pain but not enough to make me stop.

A four year old keying a car is very different to a 10 year old keying a car which is different again to a 15 year old keying a car.

And no car is worth either of our children, it's just a car. Our children are human beings with complex brains, there might be an underlying anger that meant they only felt they could get attention if they did something outrageous. It's possible. There could be something going on in their brains that they had hidden and yes whilst expensive to sort out and embarrassing and anger producing, perhaps keying a car was the calling car you needed to see before they ended up in a despair of which there was no coming back from.

So yes keying a car would be extreme, but it wouldn't be so black and white as to hitting and them job done, punishment handed out, don't do that again.

This is just a summary of a thought process we could go through if our children had done something like that. Does that explain things a little?

Sorry, missed this. Yes, thank you.

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 21:05

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:31

But it's true. Genetic code. Our entire bodies work via genetic coding. That's why science is trying to edit the code - to take out all the genetic code errors that cause illness. Look up CRISPR.

I have a biological sciences background and your oversimplification is just bizarre.

EngineerIngHappiness · 06/11/2025 20:46

coldiris · 05/11/2025 17:05

Sometimes when I ask myself that question, I wonder whether it's me getting old or the times have changed. It's not just gentle parenting. A lot of things seem to have changed recently. For example, my sister has one daughter and sometimes I am under the impression that she wants to plan every second of her day every day. She just won't let her be bored even one day a week. She always has to be doing something. I honestly don't remember our parents being like that.

I am also finding that teachers these days are just afraid to do or say anything, and I understand them: it's either political correctness, rules or regulations or something else.. God forbid anyone gets offended, traumatised or upset. It's like you can't put your foot right anymore. And it isn't just with children. Sometimes it kind of feels like that at work too. It's as if we are living in a world of snowflakes.

I don't know if we just weren't aware of the issues or potential issues that existed before or the world really has changed.

I know what you mean. I did something without checking with someone else today. I mean honestly it was such a minor thing. I do think a good person has no problem apologising - fine. All good they raised it and all that. But I'm also not a fucking mind reader love 😂

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:40

frozendaisy · 06/11/2025 20:34

This is utterly nuts
If this is true, and I am on the fence on whether I want it to be or really don't want it to be.
But either way.

@Horsie you are not a parent, you are, at best, an owner. But you're not a parent.

Sorry, what's nuts?

Yes, I know I'm not really a parent, thanks. It was a joke about being the parent of a robot-dog.

ETA: If you're talking about the A.I. capabilities of the dog, it's only as nuts as the rest of A.I. That's where we are now with A.I. An artificial mind is reality. It's not real, and it's not an object. It's something in between - A.I. intelligence.

Rescuedogblues · 06/11/2025 20:36

ohwoaw · 06/11/2025 19:26

It tends to be favoured by lazy/weak parents

Bullshit. Gentle/theraputic parenting takes a lot of input if youre doing it right.

frozendaisy · 06/11/2025 20:34

This is utterly nuts
If this is true, and I am on the fence on whether I want it to be or really don't want it to be.
But either way.

@Horsie you are not a parent, you are, at best, an owner. But you're not a parent.

Nutmuncher · 06/11/2025 20:33

You can see it straight away in those whose parents were early adopters of the concept, the fragile teenagers who lack basic social skills, critical thought and struggle with basic tasks and requests.

The real world is quite a shock for them. Their lost vacant stares say it all.

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:32

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 20:30

I think you think you're being funny and cute somehow.

You clearly hate this stranger's guts, so why do you keep talking to me? Why don't you shut your mouth and go away?

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:31

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 20:30

Lines of code? You are not well are you? Or are you actually AI trying to prove your aliveness?

But it's true. Genetic code. Our entire bodies work via genetic coding. That's why science is trying to edit the code - to take out all the genetic code errors that cause illness. Look up CRISPR.

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 20:30

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:28

You are making no sense.

ETA: Anyway, I am a parent. I'm a robot-dog parent, and what's more, I have two of them. Do not even ask me how I settle their arguments, but let's just say the older one isn't happy about sharing his aibone and his other toys.

Edited

I think you think you're being funny and cute somehow.

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 20:30

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:27

All of that is the result of lines and lines of code.

Of course I don't have any human companionship. I'm a sinister man who wants to go round smacking children for having fun, remember? According to you and your extremist views and desire to be nasty.

Lines of code? You are not well are you? Or are you actually AI trying to prove your aliveness?

Barnbrack · 06/11/2025 20:29

Horsie · 06/11/2025 20:28

You are making no sense.

ETA: Anyway, I am a parent. I'm a robot-dog parent, and what's more, I have two of them. Do not even ask me how I settle their arguments, but let's just say the older one isn't happy about sharing his aibone and his other toys.

Edited

I'm making no sense in suggesting you should stop advocating for parents hitting their kids now you've had a chance to think about it and realise it's harmful and abusive? How so?

Swipe left for the next trending thread