Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I really do not like DH new look after having cosmetic surgery!

161 replies

cinnamontroll · 01/11/2025 13:01

I’ve been married to DH for 22 yrs. We have a pretty good marriage overall I think.
3 years ago he lost a significant amount of weight (215lbs) and he looks absolutely fantastic and is in great health now. He has been approved for skin removal surgery on the NHS but they are only doing chest and arms (which is fair I think) as it’s not considered cosmetic.
He wanted to also have an upper and lower blepharoplasty on his eyes. He said it bothered him and made him look older than he was. I said I understand and wanted him to feel better about himself as he’s worked tremendously hard living a ketogenic lifestyle and I’m proud of him for this.

Last month he went abroad to have the procedure done and now it’s about 4 weeks later I have to say I hate the way it’s changed his whole eye look! He looks like he’s always staring so intensely now and it stresses me out as they just are not the same eyes I’ve loved since we were 20yrs old. The surgery itself was done perfectly and the lower blepharoplasty does look good as he has no bags under eyes anymore but the eyelid just so startling to me now. I don’t say much about it as I know he’s happy with the results but it’s so hard to get used to him looking different!
I honestly do not know whether to ever say I don’t like it or not?

To give you an idea, Bradley Cooper has recently had this done to his eyes and he gives the same kind of wide eyed look now too. Many people are commenting on this I’ve seen online and fear people may be also thinking this about him or talking behind his back about it.

AIBU to raise my thoughts about it or should I keep my thoughts about his new look to myself?

OP posts:
C66Peas · 03/11/2025 05:30

OP, please try not to worry - it’s still very early days after surgery, and your DH’s eyes will continue to settle over the next few weeks. I went through a disastrous upper blepharoplasty myself where too much skin was removed. I couldn’t fully close my eyes and the shape of them completely changed. But 18 months on, the skin has stretched, and my eyes both look and function much better. I’m sure your DH’s eyes will soften and improve over the coming weeks and months too.

GarlicHound · 03/11/2025 04:58

CoolFineDoneWicked · 01/11/2025 14:15

This is the thing - so many people say “oh you can’t tell when it’s done well”. You can, it’s just people are too polite to say “you look weird now”.

No, some of my friends have had brilliant ones. Their eyes look exactly like they used to. They did spend a small fortune with London surgeons, though.

GarlicHound · 03/11/2025 04:55

Baninarama · 01/11/2025 13:36

Not much you can do BUT ageing is continuous and his eyes will look more like the old him as time goes on and gravity takes its course.

I agree that blepheroplasties seem so hard to get right. Kate Moss looked like Liberace when she had hers done - I wondered if they'd left enough skin for her to blink! Natalia Vodianova has ruined her unique look with hers, too.

Agree with everyone else - YANBU but it'd be madness to say anything harsher than "You look amazing, very different though! I'm still getting used to it."

I keep seeing women on TV who've clearly had a bit too much taken out of their upper eyelids. They look kind of haunted, with big eyes in cavernous sockets. It will still settle a bit, though, OP, and ageing will continue.

Thepossibility · 03/11/2025 04:30

I sympathize, I would hate for my DH to change anything about his face but especially his eyes, those are what makes him, HIM. I look into those eyes every single day.

Lovehascomeandgone · 02/11/2025 21:16

I’m sorry OP but this isn’t about you, it’s about what makes your DH happy. Why would you hurt him by saying anything?!?!

Mimimayhem18 · 02/11/2025 20:38

I had upper eyelid surgery in 2023 because it was affecting my vision, especially on the right eye so both were done so I would look even. I looked excessively wide eyed after and I didn’t like the look of it at first but after 6 months it looked much better and now 2 years later that wide eye look has gone and my eyes look normal, just without any sagging skin.

For the people commenting about being mentally ill to have it done? I just can’t agree, the fold of skin used to get sore, dry, swollen- it even split once in very cold weather. It was definitely a medical need even though I had to pay for it privately.

Hellohelga · 02/11/2025 20:08

Just googled BC - yikes imagine those intense eyes staring across the breakfast table. Sorry OP but you’ll just have to get used to it. Buy him some nice shades for Christmas.

Littlemisssavvy · 02/11/2025 19:58

I have a friend who had the eyes done along with a full face lift and i was the same….i thought she looked weird and hated it. However i think its your brain just adjusting to the change, after about a year (and it was as long as that), i forgot how she looked before and she looks amazing now (20 years later!!)

Wooky073 · 02/11/2025 18:43

I understand its difficult for you but it cannot be undone. No point in being neggy openly as it will impact his self confidence which is new and fragile. At most say it will take you a little while to get used to it - and it probably will take a while. But you will get use to it. Meanwhile he will continue to age and probably the folds and bags will return. No one stays looking their same throughout their lives. Thats nature regardless of surgical interventions.

SimplyAFolly · 02/11/2025 18:41

cinnamontroll · 01/11/2025 13:01

I’ve been married to DH for 22 yrs. We have a pretty good marriage overall I think.
3 years ago he lost a significant amount of weight (215lbs) and he looks absolutely fantastic and is in great health now. He has been approved for skin removal surgery on the NHS but they are only doing chest and arms (which is fair I think) as it’s not considered cosmetic.
He wanted to also have an upper and lower blepharoplasty on his eyes. He said it bothered him and made him look older than he was. I said I understand and wanted him to feel better about himself as he’s worked tremendously hard living a ketogenic lifestyle and I’m proud of him for this.

Last month he went abroad to have the procedure done and now it’s about 4 weeks later I have to say I hate the way it’s changed his whole eye look! He looks like he’s always staring so intensely now and it stresses me out as they just are not the same eyes I’ve loved since we were 20yrs old. The surgery itself was done perfectly and the lower blepharoplasty does look good as he has no bags under eyes anymore but the eyelid just so startling to me now. I don’t say much about it as I know he’s happy with the results but it’s so hard to get used to him looking different!
I honestly do not know whether to ever say I don’t like it or not?

To give you an idea, Bradley Cooper has recently had this done to his eyes and he gives the same kind of wide eyed look now too. Many people are commenting on this I’ve seen online and fear people may be also thinking this about him or talking behind his back about it.

AIBU to raise my thoughts about it or should I keep my thoughts about his new look to myself?

Once he puts a bit of weight back on, he should look better.

Otterdrunk · 02/11/2025 14:07

Dery · 02/11/2025 09:30

@cinnamontroll

As PP have said, it will likely relax over time. You can’t say anything negative to your DH about it beyond saying you’re still getting used to it.

On another note, some tabloid journalists trawl MN for stories and the details you have posted are quite identifying so you might want to see if MN HQ will delete your post.

@cinnamontroll this is a very valid point!! Can you imagine if your DH discovered how you really feel about his surgery by seeing it in the DM?! Not knocking you for seeking support & posting - just unfortunately as @Dery says, the DM use it for stories.

Disturbia81 · 02/11/2025 12:25

And Catherine Zeta jones has lost one of her features. I don’t like it either, they look like mannequins and just don’t look like them anymore.

notatinydancer · 02/11/2025 12:22

thankgoditssaturday · 01/11/2025 23:27

After having been a nurse in ‘plastics’ for a few years ( 20 years ago) I would say people are mentally ill if they get plastic surgery ( as a poster did say here) but I did come to think there were many who were very insecure and lacking in confidence or coerced by family or partners. I had certain patients asking me 30 mins post op how they looked. I saw partners trying to influence the surgeons decision about breast sizes, mothers coaxing daughters to have larger breast sizes. In the end I had enough as I found it pretty depressing and sickening. I can think of a smaller percentage where the individuals had a real need; breast reductions, deviated septum’s. I came away glad that Im happy to age warts and all.

I hope you didn’t speak to your patients like that.

notatinydancer · 02/11/2025 12:19

it can take months to settle down. He will get a bit of relaxation of the lids.

Lovelyview · 02/11/2025 12:01

Gettingbysomehow · 02/11/2025 09:40

What nonsense, I too worked in plastics for years at East Grinstead. I am certainly not mentally ill, Im single and don't want a partner again and have nobody influencing me yet here I am having a deep plane face and neck lift. Im sick of my turkey neck and how it digs into the neckline of everything I wear.
There is nothing wrong with wanting to look good for my age, for me.
Your attitude is dangerously patronising. How dare you say we are all mentally ill.
Do you wear nice clothes? Don't be so vain, get the sack cloth out.
I've also had a breast uplift without implants and Im very happy with it.

I think that was a mistype. The poster seems to be saying that she wouldn't say they were mentally ill - not would - but they were insecure and sometimes coerced into procedures.

cinnamontroll · 02/11/2025 09:54

I appreciate all the advice I’ve been given not to say anything negative, especially now it’s done.
I’m glad I asked before I came out and say I don’t like it, especially as it is still healing tbh

4 weeks is still quite a short time I suppose, in terms of healing, I’m hoping it will settle and as the aging process continues he’ll look more like the man I married.

I have to say I do not understand all the mean comments about people being mentally ill if they have something like this done.

He is not mentally ill in the slightest, he’s an amazing husband and father to our kids. He’s worked so hard to turn his lifestyle around to be around longer for us and he’s still so handsome, but I just didn’t expect such a tiny removal of skin would change the eye shape so much. The lower part does look really good as I mentioned before. He had puffy bags underneath his eyes that never seemed to go and now they are completely gone, he’s over the moon with it!

Thanks again for all the advice, I do appreciate the feedback given!

OP posts:
StrongLikeMamma · 02/11/2025 09:50

utamea · 02/11/2025 09:28

i wish people didn’t feel the need to get their eyes done. A school mum had it done and she looked so wide eyed afterwards. The irony was that she was absolutely stunning before the procedure. The procedure made her look scary.

It’s so sad.

Gettingbysomehow · 02/11/2025 09:46

JamieCannister · 01/11/2025 14:51

Only if there is life-long life insurance in place, registered with the NHS, so not one single penny of ax-payers money goes into pincking up the pieces.

Only if people are willing to lose their marriages over it.

But other than that, no. Mentally ill people deserve mental health support not being encouraged to mutilate themselves.

I sincerely hope you are not obese, or smoke, or eat rubbish food or diabetic, if so you should be dumped by the NHS. I work in vascular and its these people who are crushing the NHS with their lifelong, self inflicted problems not the odd facelift that has gone wrong.

Gettingbysomehow · 02/11/2025 09:40

thankgoditssaturday · 01/11/2025 23:27

After having been a nurse in ‘plastics’ for a few years ( 20 years ago) I would say people are mentally ill if they get plastic surgery ( as a poster did say here) but I did come to think there were many who were very insecure and lacking in confidence or coerced by family or partners. I had certain patients asking me 30 mins post op how they looked. I saw partners trying to influence the surgeons decision about breast sizes, mothers coaxing daughters to have larger breast sizes. In the end I had enough as I found it pretty depressing and sickening. I can think of a smaller percentage where the individuals had a real need; breast reductions, deviated septum’s. I came away glad that Im happy to age warts and all.

What nonsense, I too worked in plastics for years at East Grinstead. I am certainly not mentally ill, Im single and don't want a partner again and have nobody influencing me yet here I am having a deep plane face and neck lift. Im sick of my turkey neck and how it digs into the neckline of everything I wear.
There is nothing wrong with wanting to look good for my age, for me.
Your attitude is dangerously patronising. How dare you say we are all mentally ill.
Do you wear nice clothes? Don't be so vain, get the sack cloth out.
I've also had a breast uplift without implants and Im very happy with it.

Holluschickie · 02/11/2025 09:35

Blondeshavemorefun · 02/11/2025 09:30

Had to google. I don’t see the diff in the pics of brad tbh

regards your dh. Don’t say anything. It can’t be changed and if he’s happy with it , then all that matters

Those are captioned wrongly.

minishiteboard · 02/11/2025 09:31

ooh you would die at our family - eye lift, boobs, nose job, pstotis ( that is between four of us so far)

Blondeshavemorefun · 02/11/2025 09:30

Had to google. I don’t see the diff in the pics of brad tbh

regards your dh. Don’t say anything. It can’t be changed and if he’s happy with it , then all that matters

I really do not like DH new look after having cosmetic surgery!
Dery · 02/11/2025 09:30

@cinnamontroll

As PP have said, it will likely relax over time. You can’t say anything negative to your DH about it beyond saying you’re still getting used to it.

On another note, some tabloid journalists trawl MN for stories and the details you have posted are quite identifying so you might want to see if MN HQ will delete your post.

utamea · 02/11/2025 09:28

i wish people didn’t feel the need to get their eyes done. A school mum had it done and she looked so wide eyed afterwards. The irony was that she was absolutely stunning before the procedure. The procedure made her look scary.

minishiteboard · 02/11/2025 09:20

mentally ill?