Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree to pretend to my company that I don’t know what a man or woman is?

142 replies

Grain25 · 31/10/2025 16:08

My company has held a big team meeting this afternoon to bollock us because we haven’t been following their guidance that in our notes we refer to everyone as ‘they’ and ‘them’ unless we’ve explicitly asked if they identify as a man or woman and what their pronouns are.

It is grammatically and logically ridiculous.

They want me to pretend I don’t know if a male voice with the name Michael is a man and a female voice named Susan is a woman. They want no he/she in the notes unless we confirm with the aforementioned Michael and Susan that they are indeed a man and woman, which would make me look quite mad.

They have tried to conflate it with not assuming a married Michael is married to a woman, and that Susan is married to a man. This is completely right and proper and I hope I wouldn’t assume this.

AIBU to simply not change my notes?

OP posts:
BundleBoogie · 01/11/2025 22:02

Grain25 · 01/11/2025 18:34

Humans do not need to ask a person what their sex is to confirm it.

I’m not going to follow it.

Good! It’s a ridiculous and unnecessarily dictatorial policy. I hope you get to tell them to get stuffed and then get a job with a much better company.

Tontostitis · 01/11/2025 20:12

Grain25 · 01/11/2025 10:33

Because it’s batshit and the people I talk to would think I’d lost the plot.

Can't you just say I have checked

Chinsupmeloves · 01/11/2025 19:48

My word, yes totally ridiculous! The majority of people are just simply he/she and those who wish to be addressed by a different pronoun usually state this. Having to change the whole grammatical construction of a language to appear to show accommodation for a minority isn't what they want anyway. To be aware and accept preferred pronouns is, from my observation, what is being asked for, not to address everyone by them. Batshit!

BundleBoogie · 01/11/2025 19:38

Agix · 31/10/2025 17:05

Oh gosh this reminds me of something!!

When my postie came this morning, they couldn't get the envelope through my letterbox and so left it on the porch! It got super wet, I was pretty pissed off at them tbh.

On top of that, I saw my doctor yesterday and they said they think I'm making good progress with my mental health, which was lovely to hear. Unfortunately their computer wasn't working so I had to pick up my prescription from thr counter.

There. I just used "they/their/them" as singular pronouns - twice - and I guarantee absolutely no one had a problem with it. At most, you thought I was in the wrong thread.

They, their and them have been used as singular since the 13th century, only recently have people decided they have an issue with it.

Just use they/their. You likely use it as a singular pronoun every goddamn day, you can do it a bit more for a job you get paid for. I bet you use loads of jargon at work perfectly fine.

No, you just sound utterly ridiculous because the important grammatical aspect you left out is that it is only relevant to use singular ‘they’ if you don’t know a persons sex. So if you were sat in front of your doctor or even glimpsed postie through the window, you just sound weird if you claim you can’t tell what sex they (plural) are.

If you are really stuck, ask your dog (or your neighbours dog) - as it will be able to tell even if a person if trying to disguise their sex.

jkjkazcfdspor · 01/11/2025 19:04

Sorry wrong thread 😂

jkjkazcfdspor · 01/11/2025 19:03

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 19:01

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:55

And yet, as someone with chronic sinusitis I’ve been pretty frequently misgendered / named but people who failed to distinguish between raspy and male. So while you may have superior powers of perception, those powers aren’t universal. Hence why the guidance exists.

I'm stocky and have short hair, kiss think I'm a bloke all the time. Couldn't care less.

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:55

Grain25 · 01/11/2025 18:34

Humans do not need to ask a person what their sex is to confirm it.

I’m not going to follow it.

And yet, as someone with chronic sinusitis I’ve been pretty frequently misgendered / named but people who failed to distinguish between raspy and male. So while you may have superior powers of perception, those powers aren’t universal. Hence why the guidance exists.

Grain25 · 01/11/2025 18:34

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:01

You are being unreasonable.

There is a company policy approach to record keeping. You need to follow it.

That includes (quite reasonably) not using any information which has not been confirmed.

Humans do not need to ask a person what their sex is to confirm it.

I’m not going to follow it.

OP posts:
RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 18:28

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:10

Hence why it’s generally easiest to go non specific.

It’s really standard in many documents and records now.

Equally, records generally are expected to be contemporaneous- so if person said he for that interaction records can reflect that even if say she next time. Although makes for a confusing read whereas they stays consistent.

Yes but... I don't identify as "they" so you're misgendering me by using it...

Dasherthereindeer · 01/11/2025 18:19

Would it be useful or acceptable to read one sentence of your notes back to the client so they can agree with your summary of the situation and have the opportunity to voice any errors about pronouns at the same time? Eg: ‘So Michael, I’ve written here in my notes that ‘Michael has explained his internet is not working and has requested we send the maintenance team to fix it as soon as possible.´Hopefully that does the trick and it’ll all be sorted for you shortly. Is there anything else you wanted to ask about today?’
This would not be the right approach for a group with lots of people who identify as non binary or trans but for a client base where this almost never comes up it might do the job of unobtrusively confirming pronouns and so negate the need for singular ´they’ constantly.

Tiebiter · 01/11/2025 18:17

Now they/them is often seen as an identity under the umbrella of gender then using they/them IS misgendering if you prefer she/her or anything else for that matter. They are bigots!

YodasHairyButt · 01/11/2025 18:13

Grain25 · 31/10/2025 16:31

This is my thinking too. They surely cannot discipline people for referring to a man as a man and a woman as a woman.

I would invite them to try and see how far they get.

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:10

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 18:03

But the problem is, you would actually have to ask every time you made a note.

How are you confirming their choice?

A d going back and changing them is crazy, because what if the person finds out you are calling them he, when they wanted to be she in July.

Hence why it’s generally easiest to go non specific.

It’s really standard in many documents and records now.

Equally, records generally are expected to be contemporaneous- so if person said he for that interaction records can reflect that even if say she next time. Although makes for a confusing read whereas they stays consistent.

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 18:03

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:01

You are being unreasonable.

There is a company policy approach to record keeping. You need to follow it.

That includes (quite reasonably) not using any information which has not been confirmed.

But the problem is, you would actually have to ask every time you made a note.

How are you confirming their choice?

A d going back and changing them is crazy, because what if the person finds out you are calling them he, when they wanted to be she in July.

ScaryM0nster · 01/11/2025 18:01

You are being unreasonable.

There is a company policy approach to record keeping. You need to follow it.

That includes (quite reasonably) not using any information which has not been confirmed.

Breadcat24 · 01/11/2025 18:01

Organised a conference recently. Pushed by marketing to have a load of He / She button badges for people to take. Approx 300 no idea the cost . No body did

ThankYouNigel · 01/11/2025 17:57

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 17:14

The grammar thing. I think they and their is fine if you don't know the sex.

For example
P1) I saw Sam the other day in hospital
P2) oh, are they okay?
P1) yes, he was just visiting his aunt
What would you use?

It’s over-thinking it. Most people either know a ‘Sam’ or ‘Tony/i’ or whoever well enough to know their sex. If speaking face to face it’s obvious 99% of the time. If really unsure in conversation or over email I would double check by asking: can I just double check if that’s Samantha of Samuel? As people have managed to navigate using common sense easily for years before all this nonsense started. I actually have a gender neutral abbreviated first name myself, but my Mrs is part of my email, so it’s obvious.

MagpiePi · 01/11/2025 17:25

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 17:14

The grammar thing. I think they and their is fine if you don't know the sex.

For example
P1) I saw Sam the other day in hospital
P2) oh, are they okay?
P1) yes, he was just visiting his aunt
What would you use?

Thats fine, but then in the normal world you wouldn’t carry on referring to Sam as they.

But why would someone be saying they had seen Sam in hospital if the other person didn’t already know who Sam was?

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 17:14

ThankYouNigel · 01/11/2025 11:45

Totally agree. I’m sick of all of it. Them/they grammatically to me means more than one person for a start off. I’m a woman, a female, a mother, I breastfed, the list goes on. I would never in a million use tolerate being referred to as a ‘chest feeding person’ either. 🤦🏻‍♀️

The grammar thing. I think they and their is fine if you don't know the sex.

For example
P1) I saw Sam the other day in hospital
P2) oh, are they okay?
P1) yes, he was just visiting his aunt
What would you use?

RessicaJabbit · 01/11/2025 17:10

Dontlletmedownbruce · 01/11/2025 13:53

Has anyone ever come up with rubbish pronouns and been allowed? or is it only they/them that is permitted (which of course goes against the whole point of choosing pronouns). I'd like to challenge them and ask to referred to as it/its or our/ours just to see if it sticks and to annoy HR. Or better still, say I don't agree with pronouns as a concept and would like to be referred to as my chosen nickname only - 'spiderman' , 'toilet roll' etc

Edited

Best thing to do is change them every day and make HR go through the nonsense and be hugely offended when they try to suggest you're taking the piss...and quite their policies at them.

Gettingbysomehow · 01/11/2025 13:56

I work in the NHS and have absolutely refused to collude with any of this bullshit. They can't sack me for this so they can get stuffed.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 01/11/2025 13:53

Has anyone ever come up with rubbish pronouns and been allowed? or is it only they/them that is permitted (which of course goes against the whole point of choosing pronouns). I'd like to challenge them and ask to referred to as it/its or our/ours just to see if it sticks and to annoy HR. Or better still, say I don't agree with pronouns as a concept and would like to be referred to as my chosen nickname only - 'spiderman' , 'toilet roll' etc

Dontlletmedownbruce · 01/11/2025 13:48

I think the wfh dynamic is giving more licence to this nonsense. If this was introduced at a large meeting or conference people would probably start laughing and raise hands to present these different scenarios, highlighting the madness of it all.

NCTDN · 01/11/2025 13:41

ThankYouNigel · 01/11/2025 11:45

Totally agree. I’m sick of all of it. Them/they grammatically to me means more than one person for a start off. I’m a woman, a female, a mother, I breastfed, the list goes on. I would never in a million use tolerate being referred to as a ‘chest feeding person’ either. 🤦🏻‍♀️

I hate bad grammar. Then/ they/ their as singular pronouns do not make sense. It’s as simple as that!

Swipe left for the next trending thread