Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you expect a thank you

88 replies

knowingmekniwingyou · 30/10/2025 18:27

Emergency at nursery so we had to collect children. I messaged my friend asking if she needed help to collect her kid as I could take them home on the bus.

Didn't bother to respond to the message for an hour. And it wasn't "oh thanks for offering" it was just stating she was busy getting work sorted.

Aibu In thinking she could have acknowledged me offering to help her. She goes on about the village and this is the second time I've offered. Other time when she was trying to get someone to look after little one after she had IVF. She didn't even ackoledge me.

Ok you may think she doesn't want me to, which is fair enough, but just say "oh thanks I'll bare that in mind".

I'm very hormonal today

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dailyconniptions · 01/11/2025 03:38

Yes it was rather rude. Please know it's bear in mind though. Bare always means naked and I'm sure you didn't mean that!

Sadworld23 · 31/10/2025 21:32

Justcallmedaffodil · 30/10/2025 19:53

So you made an unsolicited offer to collect her DC because you were already collecting yours? And she didn’t need you to. I’m not sure why she’d be thanking you for offering help she didn’t ask for or need.

I guess politeness is old fashioned.
I'm going to the shops can I get yiu anything, no thanks I'm fine

Do you want/need a lift home, thanks for offering but I'm happy walking/getting the bus.

Etc etc

I'm a dinosaur.

MasterOfOne · 31/10/2025 13:08

lazyarse123 · 31/10/2025 09:00

Usually. I suppose your attitude is why manners are becoming less of a thing and people will become less willing to help.

Lol yup I am the downfall of society.

It's was just a question I was posing. I am almost embarrassingly polite at times - i just don't believe we should get all twisted up when someone is rude. Call it out or don't, but its just life, right.

Thelicaandlemontrees · 31/10/2025 10:10

MasterOfOne · 31/10/2025 00:02

Should we always be polite to every unsolicited offer?

Unless its someone knocking on your door and offering you 50p for your house, or offering you a sausage roll in exchange for a sex act, then YES! Any unsolicited offer would always be met with a thank you. My lovely (much older) colleague recently took me aside and offered me my pick of her wardrobe clear out. I know her style is very much not me at all, to say the least, but I said 'that's so kind of you but I've so man6 clothes I need to do a clear out myself! Thank you for thinking of me though!' I do not want her clothes but still said thank you.

lazyarse123 · 31/10/2025 09:00

MasterOfOne · 31/10/2025 00:02

Should we always be polite to every unsolicited offer?

Usually. I suppose your attitude is why manners are becoming less of a thing and people will become less willing to help.

CosySeason · 31/10/2025 08:36

Stop offering or helping. It’s her own responsibility.

blackwhitepink · 31/10/2025 08:34

She’s been messaging me non urgent stuff all evening so it’s not like its affected her evening

perhaps you need to work on your emotional response to others because it certainly affected your evening.

JustMe2026 · 31/10/2025 05:18

Sorry but autism covers so many spectrum you can't say it's rude if she doesn't say and btw some of the best maskers are autistic people and you wouldn't have a clue face to face...anyway my sister would never think to say please thankyou etc she will say what she has to straight to the point and everyone that knows her knows that's fine and she will also only answer texts if it either interests her or she can actually think of a reply...my autism totally different in that I can't do forms, computers, keep a schedule etc so I do remember please and thankyou but majority of the time i wont engage in a conversation and bad days will be blunt and straight to the point if a reply is actually necessary

MannersAreAll · 31/10/2025 05:09

If someone offers to help in an emergency/unexpected situation then it's basic manners to thank them, even if you don't need their help.

Basic manners have totally gone downhill in many ways over the last years so it's not surprising when people like your friend don't bother. It was rude of her.

feathermucker · 31/10/2025 05:06

I thought you meant you’d actually collected for her and she hadn’t said thank you! To not thank you for your offer is, at worst, mildly irritating. You’re placing too much emphasis on this.

Terrytheweasel · 31/10/2025 05:05

Justcallmedaffodil · 30/10/2025 19:53

So you made an unsolicited offer to collect her DC because you were already collecting yours? And she didn’t need you to. I’m not sure why she’d be thanking you for offering help she didn’t ask for or need.

I have to agree with this

PollyBell · 31/10/2025 05:03

MasterOfOne · 31/10/2025 00:02

Should we always be polite to every unsolicited offer?

Exactly!

Theextraordinaryisintheordinary · 31/10/2025 05:01

I’ve stopped putting myself out as much with one particular person as it’s one sided and always all take. I invited her to mine for a coffee rather than me going up to her house as always. She was obviously put out and replied “don’t worry about it”. It felt tudey. There was no ‘thank you’. It annoyed me. Anyway, it’s all ok. Just stop helping out so much. We need to put less energy in to others and ask ourselves why we feel the need to keep pleasing.

MasterOfOne · 31/10/2025 00:02

lazyarse123 · 30/10/2025 23:59

Maybe because it's the polite thing to do.

Should we always be polite to every unsolicited offer?

lazyarse123 · 30/10/2025 23:59

Justcallmedaffodil · 30/10/2025 19:53

So you made an unsolicited offer to collect her DC because you were already collecting yours? And she didn’t need you to. I’m not sure why she’d be thanking you for offering help she didn’t ask for or need.

Maybe because it's the polite thing to do.

MasterOfOne · 30/10/2025 23:55

And can i go back to my earlier question about your relationship? Are you best friends? Neighbours??

It's hard to understand without knowing how close you two are?

Do you feel comfortable challenging her oj her rudeness?

MasterOfOne · 30/10/2025 23:52

knowingmekniwingyou · 30/10/2025 23:49

She moans about having no village and she gets an offer of help and doesn't even say "thanks but no thanks".

She's been ranting about stuff all evening so much that I've muted her

Edited

OP - it's a big deal for you.

You said earlier she complained about no village. I am a single parent too, literally no family around me, I am lucky to have good friends who have supported me. But I still feel very vulnerable witg no immediate family around me no "village"

That's clearly my perspective...

Could that be hers too?

knowingmekniwingyou · 30/10/2025 23:50

Splendidbouquet · 30/10/2025 23:08

I'm quite staggered by some of the replies.

There are routinely threads on MN about people finding a total lack of civility and manners in their every day life. And quite a few of the replies on this thread highlight how many people actually don't set any value on consideration and manners.

Yes exactly.

This is a long list of things with her ATM

OP posts:
knowingmekniwingyou · 30/10/2025 23:49

MasterOfOne · 30/10/2025 23:48

I think pp nailed it.... it's about is the ops reponse proportional to the situation detailed.... in reality no.

All those posters "staggered by the reponses" whats so interesting to me is how we (and I'll make the assumption thst we are majority women) have to be so unfailingly polite and apologetic in every interaction.

The op literally stated she offered something, and is upset by lack of acknowledgment.

Really... in the grand scheme of things, this truly isn't a big deal and not society going downhill.

She moans about having no village and she gets an offer of help and doesn't even say "thanks but no thanks".

She's been ranting about stuff all evening so much that I've muted her

OP posts:
knowingmekniwingyou · 30/10/2025 23:48

RandomMess · 30/10/2025 23:27

Someone nailed it about that her reply was factual. The stress of the situation would highly likely impact her ability to remember to use the required thank you etc. As in she would like find us proportionally more stressful than the op because of her ASC as it’s unpredictable and out of routine. Probably very much on the zone of sorting work out to leave and not able to deal with anything else.

It is very challenging for many people with ASC to “remember their manners” because it’s something not seen as necessary.

It’s like those work emails with all the shit in them instead of bullet points of what needs to be done. Then you waste time trying to work out what they are asking, do the tasks which are part of responsibility and get another email saying thank you. Wasting more time and energy even if it’s just to hit the delete button.

I wouldn’t be offended or think it’s rude if someone didn’t say thank you.

Shes done it before, in a not stressful situation.

She was talking about childcare and how she had a preplanned hospital appointment and wasn't aure if she wasn't going to be back in time. I volunteered to help, which was ignored. This was for her IVF.

So perhaps she didn't want me to look after him, but all she needed to do was say "thanks but it's ok I'm on my way".

She's been messaging me non urgent stuff all evening so it's not like it's affected her evening

OP posts:
MasterOfOne · 30/10/2025 23:48

Edited as double posted

MasterOfOne · 30/10/2025 23:48

I think pp nailed it.... it's about is the ops reponse proportional to the situation detailed.... in reality no.

All those posters "staggered by the reponses" whats so interesting to me is how we (and I'll make the assumption thst we are majority women) have to be so unfailingly polite and apologetic in every interaction.

The op literally stated she offered something, and is upset by lack of acknowledgment.

Really... in the grand scheme of things, this truly isn't a big deal and not society going downhill.

RandomMess · 30/10/2025 23:27

Someone nailed it about that her reply was factual. The stress of the situation would highly likely impact her ability to remember to use the required thank you etc. As in she would like find us proportionally more stressful than the op because of her ASC as it’s unpredictable and out of routine. Probably very much on the zone of sorting work out to leave and not able to deal with anything else.

It is very challenging for many people with ASC to “remember their manners” because it’s something not seen as necessary.

It’s like those work emails with all the shit in them instead of bullet points of what needs to be done. Then you waste time trying to work out what they are asking, do the tasks which are part of responsibility and get another email saying thank you. Wasting more time and energy even if it’s just to hit the delete button.

I wouldn’t be offended or think it’s rude if someone didn’t say thank you.

Splendidbouquet · 30/10/2025 23:08

NinaGeiger · 30/10/2025 20:17

Staggered by the voting results. I don't think you're being unreasonable at all.
I'd be beyond grateful if someone offered to collect my children

I'm quite staggered by some of the replies.

There are routinely threads on MN about people finding a total lack of civility and manners in their every day life. And quite a few of the replies on this thread highlight how many people actually don't set any value on consideration and manners.

knowingmekniwingyou · 30/10/2025 22:24

Thelicaandlemontrees · 30/10/2025 21:40

Ahhh mumsnet. Where having basic societal expectations is seen as being precious and needy.

Op, I had a friend who often did this. She would be in a pickle and needed money or childcare or a lift or some kind of help. I would tell her I could lend her money or take her kids etc. She always found a way to tell me she didn't need my help which involved not saying thank-you. Sometimes she would just say she didn't need it and sometimes would just ignore it. I remember once offering to lend her hundreds of pounds and she didn't even acknowledge it. When she DID take me up on my offer, she didn't say thank you. I did babysit for her three times and each time she didn't say thank-you. On her birthday or Chrostmas I would hand her the gift and she would smile and say 'oh lovely'...but never a thank you. She would get out of the car if you gave her a lift and say 'bye, see you next week'. She never ever said thank-you. The joke is that she often talks about her impeccable manners, and to my amusement told us, incredulously, that someone accused her of being rude. She literally said 'ME!!!! You all know what a stickler I am for good manners!'

We have been friends since school and she has got better as time has gone on, but I definitely have suspected that she is on the spectrum for a very long time. In her mind she IS a veryammerly person. I don't go out of my way to offer her help and I prepare myself that she won't say thank you when I do. I stopped agreeing to babysit for her when her child was young but didn't have the communication skills to tell her why at the time. It's a shame as I loved kids and was happy to do it until I felt like I was being used.

Saying thank you is an act designed to please the other person. I say thank you for allammer of things that I'm not even grateful for, such as when the girl in the shop hands me my receipt or when someone gives me 5p change that I'm entitled to anyway. It's a thing we do for other people so they feel valued and respected. Saying thank you should be a reflex every time someone gives you something, offers something or does something for you. To me it's so weird to not thank someone for offering to help but OP I would try not to take it too personally. It's not normal to ignore an offer of help like that and so she probably does that to everyone. Don't take it to heart.

Thank you

OP posts: