Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU are presents from DIL

69 replies

DILDilemmas · 26/10/2025 14:46

My son has a very nice wife - we love her and (I think!) she loves us, so there is no animosity underpinning this query. I'm just curious as to how others would approach it.

Son and DIL have very busy, full on lives - both have jobs with long hours, three young children, large chaotic renovation project house. My husband and I provide them with a lot of help and support - regular childcare commitment for the younger two children (and the eldest in the school holidays), and a couple of weekends a month they invite us for lunch and we usually help them with something like a DIY project. I also often do their ironing. My husband and I don't resent this at all. We love the children and appreciate the time we get with them, and we are both retired so have lots of spare time which we don't mind spending helping them out. It's generally a happy, friendly family arrangement which we all enjoy.

DIL has recently started giving us random presents as thank yous for this help - not big things, but candles, vouchers, flowers etc. It's not every time we help but it's about once a month. I've told her it's very kind but not necessary to her face and have also told my son she doesn't need to feel obliged to do this - we really are happy to help. He said it makes her feel better and like she's not taking advantage, but to me it almost feels transactional, like she's paying for the help. I'd rather she just accepted it as something families do out of love rather than being done in the expectation of a reward.

Would you raise it with her again and say it really is unnecessary, or would you just accept it's her way and accept the gifts with thanks?

(Aware this is not a juicy problem by mumsnet standards)

OP posts:
hmmnotreallysure · 26/10/2025 16:17

That's lovely of her. I wouldn't see it as transactional but that she doesn't want you to feel taken for granted. I'd just say thank you and take it for what it is.

MrsPositivity1 · 26/10/2025 16:16

I think your DIL sounds lovely. Please accept her gifts kindly

Autumn38 · 26/10/2025 16:14

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 26/10/2025 14:51

Giving gifts of gratitude is her love language… considering the many horrible relationships between MILs and DILs you read about here to read a happy helpful one with both people who a grateful is wonderful to read. So take the presents and cherish them as she is showing she cared

This. Also I’d take note that her love language is gift giving so she might well occasionally enjoy the same from you. A thoughtful gift if she feels poorly for example x

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 26/10/2025 16:10

JurassicPark4Eva · 26/10/2025 14:47

Accept them graciously. She's just trying to do something small and nice for people who do lots of nice things for her.

This in spades.

Act delighted, thank her for being thoughtful and appreciating you,* then pop it in the cupboard with the rest of the things.

*this is what she is communicating to you.her gratitude and appreciation - its a mistake to "reject it".

Ps you sound like an amazing in law....
Id pay good money to swap you with my own!

BoldBlueZebra · 26/10/2025 16:10

Accept them - they are her way of showing how much she appreciates and understands how much you do for them - I do this with my mum - I would never want her to feel unappreciated for everything she does for me or that I take her for granted. These things you do mean so much to her

Smugbadger · 26/10/2025 16:09

She’s not trying to pay you. She’s acknowledging, in her own language, that you are a huge help to you and that she’s grateful. Accept them graciously, and carry on with your otherwise beautiful sounding arrangements!

Irenesortof · 26/10/2025 16:09

DILDilemmas · 26/10/2025 14:54

Thank you all - I needed the head wobble! I suppose I wish she didn't need to 'feel better', I.e. she shouldn't feel bad that we're helping because we enjoy it and like that we're useful, but going forward I will just accept them as affection / appreciation.

Good plan. For some people a gift is a way to say thank you, and the words on their own don't mean as much.

blackgiraffe · 26/10/2025 16:07

Sounds like gift giving is her love language, and to her it’s not transactional

Namechangefordaughterevasion · 26/10/2025 16:05

My mum used to do this. Every time I did some little thing for her I'd get a thank you card and a small gift. I hated it. It made doing little things for her transactional, as if she couldn't stand to be indebted to me but always had to be one step ahead. And as she got older and more dependent on me it spiralled out of control The gifts and cards just kept coming and became entirely random and meaningless.

menopausalfart · 26/10/2025 15:35

She sounds perfect.

martinisforeveryone · 26/10/2025 15:35

DILDilemmas · 26/10/2025 14:54

Thank you all - I needed the head wobble! I suppose I wish she didn't need to 'feel better', I.e. she shouldn't feel bad that we're helping because we enjoy it and like that we're useful, but going forward I will just accept them as affection / appreciation.

I think perhaps your son didn't have the language to express your DIL's actual feelings. It's more nuanced. I suspect she buys little things to let you know she/they appreciate everything you do for them and that they don't take it, or you, for granted.

She's not trying to reward or compensate you, just expressing thanks, which is something we all do when we want people to know how kind and helpful they're being.

Sound more like it? Besides, far better to fret the way you are than feel you are taken for granted and not appreciated, no?

MoominMai · 26/10/2025 15:33

cramptramp · 26/10/2025 15:14

My daughter does this to me. She says it makes her feel better about all the help I give her. I never thought it was transactional in any way. I accept them in the spirit they are given and carry on offering support and helping out. I suggest you do the same.

It’s slightly different for OP though as this isn’t her immediate daughter. It’s different with your own child obviously as nothing would ever feel transactional with them.

@DILDilemmas I get it why you feel as you do but agree with PP saying to not ask her again not to give them. Accept them in the spirit they’re meant and enjoy! 🙂

godmum56 · 26/10/2025 15:30

The way I see it is your help makes her smile; she wants to make you smile.

Ricciarelli · 26/10/2025 15:25

There’s an easy solution to this OP.
Go NC. You won’t have to consider transactions again.
Not keen?
Of course not.
You and your DH childmind, do DIY and iron because you love your DGC, your son and your DiL. This is your love language.
Your DiL’s language is thinking of you, deciding how to show you mean a lot to her and enjoying you receiving these gifts. She speaking volumes but you’re hearing the wrong word, one which hasn’t even entered her head. Don’t preclude this conversation.

Merryoldgoat · 26/10/2025 15:25

I have a similar relationship with MIL and I give her things because it’s how I show I care and think about her. It’s not transactional - it’s not ‘payment’ - it’s appreciation.

pottylolly · 26/10/2025 15:18

I think it sounds lovely but if you want to even things out a bit why not get them a nice weekend away (while you take care of the kids) or pay for a joint holiday together?

Loub1987 · 26/10/2025 15:15

Given the cost of childcare in my case is 1350 a month for for toddler, not including after school clubs and holiday clubs for my school age child. Any support you are giving is not transactionally set off by the odd candle.

You are doing a nice thing, supporting them, saving them a lot of money and also having a great relationship with your grandkids. She is grateful and wants to show it.

You sound lovely, they are lucky to have you.

cramptramp · 26/10/2025 15:14

My daughter does this to me. She says it makes her feel better about all the help I give her. I never thought it was transactional in any way. I accept them in the spirit they are given and carry on offering support and helping out. I suggest you do the same.

Crinkle77 · 26/10/2025 15:11

Its nice to hear about in laws getting on for a change. Just smile and say thank you.

Catsknowbest · 26/10/2025 15:11

Arlanymor · 26/10/2025 14:49

"He says it makes her feel better"

I would accept, because it makes her feel better. There's no mental gymnastics to be done here, it makes her feel good - so accept with good grace?

I totally agree with this- she isn't trying to pay for what you're doing she is just showing a little extra appreciation 😊

dinglethedragon · 26/10/2025 15:09

I have an elderly friend that I do things for - mainly sorting out things like IT and taking her to appointments. I'm very happy to do this as she has been very supportive of me and my DC over the years. I too get endless little "thank you" gifts - bottles of wine (I no longer drink, which she knows as we go out and I have fizzy water) and bags of sweets (things like Wurthers originals which I once said - about 30 yrs ago - that I always associate with my grandma, so she assumes I like them 🤷🏼‍♀️). I don't eat sweets - haven't for about 30yrs.

I've tried the "please don't, no need....." etc route - but as pp have said, it's her love language. I now just smile, take them and put in the cupboard for regifting.

MummaMummaMumma · 26/10/2025 15:09

Sounds like a lovely relationship that would envy many!

RedNine · 26/10/2025 15:05

DILDilemmas · 26/10/2025 14:54

Thank you all - I needed the head wobble! I suppose I wish she didn't need to 'feel better', I.e. she shouldn't feel bad that we're helping because we enjoy it and like that we're useful, but going forward I will just accept them as affection / appreciation.

Awww OP this is so nice, you've been able to take on board that you have been a bit UR with such good grace. Well done.

😍

Hankunamatata · 26/10/2025 15:04

Its her way of showing her love and appreciation.

NattyRedFinch · 26/10/2025 15:03

You sound like a lovely mil and your dil also sounds lovely. It’s a set up I so desperately wished for my family, but sadly it wasn’t to be. Don’t mess it up! Xxxx