Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say tradesman are a bit useless?

58 replies

onesign · 23/10/2025 12:11

Ok, that’s probably harsh but AIBU?

I’ve recently had an extractor fan fitted, and it seems to be doing its job well, so no complaints there. But this is the first time it’s been windy since the fan went in, and all I’ve heard this morning is constant banging. I thought there might be a bird or something stuck in the loft, but when I checked outside, I realised it’s the vent cover flapping in the wind! It’s so bloody annoying!! It’s not even that windy here, so I can only imagine how loud it’ll get when we have some really bad weather.

I’ll talk to the electrician and see if it can be replaced, probably at my own expense (which is frustrating having to pay for something twice). AIBU to be annoyed that he didn’t mention this? He installs these all the time, so he must know they can be a bit flimsy. I’d be surprised if none of his other customers mentioned it. I would have happily paid for a sturdier one. First world problem I know, but it really bugs me having to get things done / pay twice!

OP posts:
Greggsit · 23/10/2025 12:45

Just stick a bit of felt or something similar to where it bangs. No need to buy a new one, just a tiny bit of something soft added

40YearOldDad · 23/10/2025 12:44

Struggling to see how this is a trade's fault for a poorly designed fan?

Most customers want the cheapest price possible, and if a trade started pricing up the best hardware, he'd soon find himself out of work. Not saying you fall into this category, but I've seen it hundreds of times.

Three or four quotes, all with different prices, as expected, some are widely cheap and I couldn't even supply for the same price, never mind supply and fit. You then start to find out why, when they had a £40 contract tap fitted on a 3k granit worktop when you're called back 6 months later to fit an actual decent tap.

BetterOffNow · 23/10/2025 12:37

Bit of a sweeping statement there OP!

surreygirly · 23/10/2025 12:31

I have had a few good ones
Many useless ones

Tollington · 23/10/2025 12:30

We had this issue with the external vent on our bathroom extractor fan. It had three slats and one had fallen off so it would flap in the wind. My husband replaced it with a different design, louvres instead of slats and they are fixed so the wind doesn’t blow them open/close

TeachMeSomething · 23/10/2025 12:29

I think the electricians who did my kitchen (before I bought the flat) must have got the apprentice to do the work. On his first day at work. Unsupervised.

AgDulAmach · 23/10/2025 12:25

Some are definitely although I've had some fabulous ones down through the years, including a decorator who sanded and varnished my stair railing for free because it would look nicer and a plumber who did absolutely painstaking work, to the extent it got a bit annoying and I wanted him to speed up! His work is still good ten years on. It's best to get recommendations, but that's not always possible. It's the lack of attention to detail that annoys me - doing the bare minimum and not taking any pride in the work.

CloudSky · 23/10/2025 12:21

Sadly, yes, a lot of them are. Since living with a tradie I’m acutely more away of the shoddy jobs, cut corners and lack of care from many tradespeople, as DP points it out to me - from things in my own house to jobs other folk are doing/have done. And you’ve no way of knowing which type of person you’ve got until it’s too late a lot of the time. The other issue is that as a layperson you don’t know the art of the possible, so they can easily fob you off saying something “can’t be done” when it can, they’re just lazy or lack skills.

Swipe left for the next trending thread