Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men suggesting home dates early on

420 replies

Sunshine386 · 18/10/2025 09:44

I met a guy online, been on a couple of dates in pubs, seem to get on well and have kissed at the end of both dates. He seems to be looking for something longer term.

Thing is, he is really pushing for home dates. He even suggested it as an option for the second date, saying he could come to mine to cook or I could go to his, but he also suggested pub dates which we did. There is some distance between where we live so I don't know if that's partly why he suggested coming to mine to make things easier for me. However I was taken aback by the suggestion this early on.

I am all for this intimacy if I'm seeing someone for a bit, but it's been two meetings, and I am in the phase where I want to get to know someone over a few dates and see if they are the right fit. He's suggested home dates again for a third meeting but also given a meal out as an option, saying home dates are a good way of getting to know each other. He looked slightly put out when I wanted to go out somewhere. He also said he's away dog sitting for a couple of days at another house and even suggested casually that I could go there with him.

Would anyone else find this a little pushy this early on and off putting, and like he is trying to rush things? Surely if you've suggested home dates once and the person is not going for it you should just wait for them to give the green light. For me I would want to be inviting someone from online for a home date maybe 5th or 6th date minimum

OP posts:
Jade3450 · 21/10/2025 17:03

ERthree · 20/10/2025 19:39

Why on earth would you invite a stranger into your home or go to theirs ?

When do they stop being a stranger?

Every person I’ve ever dated has been a stranger at some point.

BauhausOfEliott · 21/10/2025 13:41

ERthree · 20/10/2025 19:39

Why on earth would you invite a stranger into your home or go to theirs ?

Because there isn’t a specific number of dates at which you can definitively tell whether someone is a murderer or a rapist.

Yes, you could invite him in after one date and only then discover he’s a violent maniac the moment he steps through your door. You could also invite him in after the 10th date and only then discover he’s a violent maniac the moment he steps through the door. Most sexual and physical violence suffered by women is from long-established partners who are violent for the first time only after the relationship is very well-established.

I would invite a man into my home when I felt good and ready. That might be after loads of dates or it might be after one or two. Frankly, in my case it would more likely be one or two - if I fancied someone I’d like to have sex with him. If I didn’t fancy him enough to have sex with him early on, I wouldn’t want to go on a second or third date anyway and it would be a moot point.

Essentially, women can and should do what they feel comfortable with, based on what they personally feel is proportionate to any risk.

Footloosefiona · 21/10/2025 12:32

SomeHorse · 21/10/2025 11:12

Indeed. A woman who has met you precisely once once previously doesn’t want to risk discovering that the Real You’s idea of a nice, ‘real’ second date involves doggy style over the back of your mangy sofa before she’s even taken her coat off, as the smell of stale fags and burning spag bol fills her nostrils…

😆😆

JHound · 21/10/2025 12:30

SomeHorse · 21/10/2025 11:12

Indeed. A woman who has met you precisely once once previously doesn’t want to risk discovering that the Real You’s idea of a nice, ‘real’ second date involves doggy style over the back of your mangy sofa before she’s even taken her coat off, as the smell of stale fags and burning spag bol fills her nostrils…

This was so specific and so hilarious at the same time! 😂

Footloosefiona · 21/10/2025 12:27

Cosyblankets · 21/10/2025 11:17

It's something you both need to agree on.
He wants it
You don't
I would move on.
And as a dog owner I would not be happy if my dog sitter brought what is essentially a stranger to stay over in my home

"And as a dog owner I would not be happy if my dog sitter brought what is essentially a stranger to stay over in my home"

Exactly this. ^

He's disrespecting the home of someone who has allowed him there on trust and is planning to leave his sex-slop in someone else's bed.
😒
Big yuch from me.

Cosyblankets · 21/10/2025 11:17

Sunshine386 · 18/10/2025 14:25

I've done a fair bit of dating and haven't previously had this issue where I am being pushed for home dates very early on like this, usually things just happens naturally and the other person seems to be able to read the room. Agree with posters, perhaps I need to be more direct, however people can generally pick up on signals like this regarding people's comfort levels so I'm wondering why he is not. Maybe he's used to having first or second date sex with all past partners and expects this?!

It's something you both need to agree on.
He wants it
You don't
I would move on.
And as a dog owner I would not be happy if my dog sitter brought what is essentially a stranger to stay over in my home

TwistedWonder · 21/10/2025 11:14

ThatCyanCat · 21/10/2025 11:05

I feel there's an element of performance about dates in public and that you can often be more real in private.

Mm hmm.

Yep - ‘more real’ = easier to get those knickers off on the sofa rather than attempting a fumble in the pub car park

SomeHorse · 21/10/2025 11:12

ThatCyanCat · 21/10/2025 11:05

I feel there's an element of performance about dates in public and that you can often be more real in private.

Mm hmm.

Indeed. A woman who has met you precisely once once previously doesn’t want to risk discovering that the Real You’s idea of a nice, ‘real’ second date involves doggy style over the back of your mangy sofa before she’s even taken her coat off, as the smell of stale fags and burning spag bol fills her nostrils…

ThatCyanCat · 21/10/2025 11:05

I feel there's an element of performance about dates in public and that you can often be more real in private.

Mm hmm.

AverageBloke · 21/10/2025 10:34

Sunshine386 · 18/10/2025 14:25

I've done a fair bit of dating and haven't previously had this issue where I am being pushed for home dates very early on like this, usually things just happens naturally and the other person seems to be able to read the room. Agree with posters, perhaps I need to be more direct, however people can generally pick up on signals like this regarding people's comfort levels so I'm wondering why he is not. Maybe he's used to having first or second date sex with all past partners and expects this?!

My question would be is he "pushing" or simply giving the home date as an option amongst others?

Men can be oblivious about safety concerns and while I'm not now, I certainly have been in the past and might well have suggested a home date fairly early on. I feel there's an element of performance about dates in public and that you can often be more real in private.

SomeHorse · 21/10/2025 10:13

AverageBloke · 21/10/2025 10:03

Only people with money should date? Seems a bit on the mercenary side...

Nothing at all mercenary about not wanting to date someone who defaults to ‘It’s either a soft drink in a pub or you have to come over to mine for my bargain macaroni cheese, or alternatively come on a free dogsitting weekend’ from the second date.

ThatCyanCat · 21/10/2025 10:09

AverageBloke · 21/10/2025 10:03

Only people with money should date? Seems a bit on the mercenary side...

I don't think anyone is suggesting you need to be Jeff Bezos but if you can't afford a meal or drinks or a coffee out every so often, then it's probably not the right time for you.

You'll probably find that women consider it a red flag that you think it's "mercenary" to want to date a man who can afford to pay for at least his own pizza and Coke.

AverageBloke · 21/10/2025 10:03

SomeHorse · 20/10/2025 08:20

Then, bluntly, he shouldn’t be dating.

Only people with money should date? Seems a bit on the mercenary side...

Imbusytodaysorry · 21/10/2025 09:49

@Sunshine386 he doesn’t want to do dates . He has invited himself to your house and you think he would Exocet to stay over . He has invited you to a dog sitting job he is doing.

Has he invited you to his house at all ?

T1Dmama · 21/10/2025 09:14

It would be a red flag for me!…
either he’s pushing for sex or he’s a serial killer!

Just be up front and actually say to him that you want to get to know someone before having them round your house or going to theirs. If he asks how many dates before ‘home dates’ are applicable just say ‘I can’t put a time on it, it’s just when I feel comfortable and ready!!’
Dont say 6 dates minimum to him…. Or he’ll be thinking on date 6 he can up the pressure again…

Men say what they need to say to get their leg over…. So don’t be too trusting that it’s a long term thing he actually wants !

JHound · 20/10/2025 22:06

OldLondonDad · 20/10/2025 17:31

Where did I say I think it's possible to "get it right" with all women or that women are a monolith?

I'm merely saying it's difficult to get right for a man. We usually are expected to figure it out, often with very little spoken or unspoken cues, and with the woman evaluating our every move - or lack of moves. Hence I suggested actually speaking about it rather than have him just guessing and/or being surprised when he does the wrong (or not enough of the right...) thing.

You have just said it again “it’s difficult to get it right”.

How can you “get it right” with 51% of the population. It’s a really weird mindset.

No need to guess. Just be yourself. It won’t work with the wrong person and will work with the right person.

ERthree · 20/10/2025 19:39

Jade3450 · 19/10/2025 21:11

Quite. I think it’s a pretty normal next stage if you’ve already kissed twice? You’re not 14.

He’s obviously attracted to you and wants to progress things.

If you don’t fancy him then don’t go on any more dates with him. If you do, why not have sex with him?

There isn’t a magic number of dates after which sex is acceptable/he won’t dump you afterwards.

It’s supposed to be fun, not some sort of test.

Why on earth would you invite a stranger into your home or go to theirs ?

dh280125 · 20/10/2025 18:07

I'd never usually consider, or offer, a home date until we were established. It sounds pushy as heck to me.

JohnTheRevelator · 20/10/2025 17:37

This is one of many reasons that I have given up on men. Every time we'd had one date,they were pushing to come back to my place next time. I even had one who was trying to get me to agree to come to mine for the evening on a first date. I got so fed up with it,as basically it's just a way of trying to get you to have sex with them. Once you agree to them coming to your house,that's all they ever want to do. I ended up finishing with one bloke because of this. Never wanted to go anywhere. I started to feel like he was ashamed to be seen outside with me!

OldLondonDad · 20/10/2025 17:31

JHound · 20/10/2025 17:25

Why would you think it’s possible to “get it right” with all women. Women are not a monolith.

Where did I say I think it's possible to "get it right" with all women or that women are a monolith?

I'm merely saying it's difficult to get right for a man. We usually are expected to figure it out, often with very little spoken or unspoken cues, and with the woman evaluating our every move - or lack of moves. Hence I suggested actually speaking about it rather than have him just guessing and/or being surprised when he does the wrong (or not enough of the right...) thing.

Noodles1234 · 20/10/2025 17:29

namechangetheworld · 20/10/2025 09:29

How embarrassingly shallow. I can count on one hand the number of restaurants DH and I went to when dating. We were both young and skint, him especially so. He now earns about five times more than me.

Edited

I agree, I met my DH online, we were both skint so had a lot of walks in the park or out in the countryside dates / he made me lunches / meets at pubs type of dates. Both of us paying for solicitors with divorces costs a lot.
Now he earns more than me, shallow to expect only rich men to want to date. It’s the effort that counts.

JHound · 20/10/2025 17:25

OldLondonDad · 20/10/2025 17:23

Don't know your age, but yeah, 3 dates is basically the standard.

Not that it's a must, but it's the norm as I understand it. Especially under say 30.

You basically can't win as guy. You're either too fast, too slow, too push, too nice, whatever. I'm fairly sure things went nowhere with numerous women when I was dating a few years ago for not moving things fast enough. Many of them told me quite clearly that was the reason. It's virtually impossible to get right, so we just default to a short-hand of the 3 date norm...

I get why you find it too pushy, but maybe you should just have an open conversation with him.

Why would you think it’s possible to “get it right” with all women. Women are not a monolith.

OldLondonDad · 20/10/2025 17:23

Don't know your age, but yeah, 3 dates is basically the standard.

Not that it's a must, but it's the norm as I understand it. Especially under say 30.

You basically can't win as guy. You're either too fast, too slow, too push, too nice, whatever. I'm fairly sure things went nowhere with numerous women when I was dating a few years ago for not moving things fast enough. Many of them told me quite clearly that was the reason. It's virtually impossible to get right, so we just default to a short-hand of the 3 date norm...

I get why you find it too pushy, but maybe you should just have an open conversation with him.

OliveSeal · 20/10/2025 17:05

could be that he is also trying to see how low he can set the bar of his effort, to see how much you give in return? If he cooks and it doesn’t work out, would you find excuses for him and not make him feel bad etc. Or what your current lifestyle is. Basically focusing on the transactional aspect straight away.

TwistedWonder · 20/10/2025 14:17

eastegg · 20/10/2025 14:05

Had you met him online though? I think that makes a difference. If you knew who he was, friend of a friend etc, before your first date then third date isn’t quite so early iyswim.

So many scumbags online now who could be anybody!

That’s the difference. My ex H was part of a group who i knew from out and about locally and I knew some of his circle really well. So I had no qualms about him staying at mine after a few dates.

Nowadays as most dating is online, you really have no idea who these men are and really need to do a bit of due diligence before being alone with them

Swipe left for the next trending thread