Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New neighbours don’t want to know

366 replies

NeighbourDespair · 17/10/2025 17:08

We’ve lived in a lovely village for the past 15 years. It was my absolute dream to live here, and it hasn’t disappointed me. It’s not only beautiful, but has a real sense of community – everyone is so friendly, pops in and out whenever, and we all pull together, especially in times of need or a crisis. One of my neighbours hadn’t had a holiday in years because she was struggling with care for her elderly mother; we put together a rota to look after her so my neighbour could finally have a few days’ break. It’s just that kind of place.

Houses here are very sought-after and hardly ever come up for sale, because nobody ever wants to leave. However, one set of our neighbours sold up earlier this year because they wanted to downsize and move closer to their grandchildren. We were very sad to see them go, but at the same time, were looking forward to making the new people welcome, and seeing a family enjoying a wonderful home.

Things could not have worked out more differently. The new people just do not want to know, at all. It’s like they’re almost offended by our attempts to interact and bring them into the community; or at least a bit bewildered by it all. Nothing we do seems to do any good. They don’t seem to understand that they’re part of a community, and one that other people would love to be part of.

I went over to chat as soon as I saw them moving in. They were polite enough, but certainly not forthcoming. You could tell they were itching to get inside. I put it down to them being busy and stressed with the moving and thought I’d try again another time, or that maybe they’d pop over themselves the next day.

I knocked again a couple of days later. The wife answered and was perfectly polite again, but she seemed to be a bit bemused as to why I was there. I said I just wanted to welcome them properly now they were in; she said “Oh, thank you; that’s very kind”, but it became obvious I wasn’t going to be invited in. I felt awkward, so said I had to get on, but that if she’d give me her number I’d add her to the village WhatsApp. She seemed a bit taken aback; she thanked me, but said they didn’t really “go in for” big chat groups. I told her how useful it was and that that’s where we share all the important local information, and she actually said “Oh well, I’m sure we’ll hear about it if it’s important”. I was really shocked; it just felt so brusque when I was trying to make her feel welcome.

I’ve tried a couple of times with her husband, and he’s the same - polite enough, but not at all forthcoming. He’ll respond if you say hello, but makes zero effort. I thought our kids might get to know each other, as they’re similar ages, but we hardly see them, and she drives them off to private school every morning (even though the school is one of the big draws here).

I wondered if it was just me they didn’t like, but my friends and neighbours have all said the same thing - never actively rude, but zero effort or engagement. The owner of the village shop said she’s been in a couple of times, but an Ocado van arrived the day after they moved in, and they’ve never even been seen in the village pub or our local cafe - so it seems they’re not even going to support local businesses.

I know people can buy houses wherever they want to, but I’m just completely confused as to why they’d move to a lovely village with a real reputation for community when they seem to want nothing to do with it. They could have bought a new build in any anonymous town or city if they wanted to stay in their own little world, never talking to anyone, never being part of our community. So why, why did they have to pick here? It’s so rare for a house to come up here; it could have gone to a lovely family who actually wanted to part of things. They must have paid tens or even hundreds of thousands more to live here than some bland new build estate. Why?!

I honestly feel a bit gutted. I know it sounds a bit much, but I’ve loved every minute of being in a street and a community where everyone knows and cares about everyone. I don’t want neighbours who barely nod at me. I think of the wonderful street parties we had for the jubilee and the coronation - now if we have anything like that, it will be painfully obvious that one house is studiously ignoring it all. They might even object to it.

Is there anything we can do to engage these people? Have we done something awful by just trying to be welcoming and involving them in the community? Or do I have to just sit it out hoping they’ll decide they don’t want to be here and will sell up?

OP posts:
thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 15:47

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 15:02

Nice how you tell her to ignore the “mean people” but then tell her to do something actually mean.

Treat people as you’d like to be treated, that’s what I say. If this miseries next door want to be left alone, OP should do it - even when it doesn’t suit them.

OP is reacting really badly to the criticism on this thread to the extent that Mumsnet has deleted at least one of her posts where she is being rude to other posters.

The neighbours aren't being mean at all. They obviously have much busier lives than OP and their social life and their children's education isn't centred in the village. I'm sure they would take in a parcel for OP if the courier knocked on their door. OP does sound petty enough to take your advice though.

BMW6 · 18/10/2025 15:39

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 15:02

Nice how you tell her to ignore the “mean people” but then tell her to do something actually mean.

Treat people as you’d like to be treated, that’s what I say. If this miseries next door want to be left alone, OP should do it - even when it doesn’t suit them.

Not wanting to be on a village WhatsApp and wanting to keep your distance - at least to begin with - is NOT being "a misery" FFS!

Are you another like the OP who thinks your way of being is the only way? Think you're sooo great everyone should be just like you?

Tediously arrogant.

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 15:02

Nice how you tell her to ignore the “mean people” but then tell her to do something actually mean.

Treat people as you’d like to be treated, that’s what I say. If this miseries next door want to be left alone, OP should do it - even when it doesn’t suit them.

PrivateMusic · 18/10/2025 14:57

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 14:32

Ignore the people being mean, OP. I think where you live sounds lovely - and what you did for your neighbour and her mother was so nice!

In my experience, neighbours like your new ones are suddenly a lot keener to get friendly if they need you to take in a parcel or want to borrow something. I think I’d be busy when they came knocking, see how they like it when the boot’s on the other foot!

Me and my neighbours happily take parcels for each other, jump cars that won’t start, move bins left in stupid places by the council etc etc we don’t expect to be invited inside the home of someone we don’t even know.

Nice how you tell her to ignore the “mean people” but then tell her to do something actually mean.

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 14:32

Ignore the people being mean, OP. I think where you live sounds lovely - and what you did for your neighbour and her mother was so nice!

In my experience, neighbours like your new ones are suddenly a lot keener to get friendly if they need you to take in a parcel or want to borrow something. I think I’d be busy when they came knocking, see how they like it when the boot’s on the other foot!

ilovesooty · 18/10/2025 13:32

I described my relationship with my neighbours, which to me seems normal. @NeighbourDespair responded with "Welcome to 2025". I'm still waiting for her to tell me what she meant.

freakyfriday23 · 18/10/2025 13:11

Sorry op but you sound a little unhinged 🤣. Leave the poor bastards alone. It's a good enough reason to move to a village and purchase a lovely old house. It would never enter my head I'd have to adopt the locals too. Sorry op but I'm with the new neighbours. I'd be the same, polite but not take the friendship. I hate that boring suffocating neighbour thing. You'll sadly have to suck it up and accept that the cliquey days when everyone is in and out of each others homes is over. Be happy you still have most on board. Oddly enough I have a new neighbour who moved in yesterday (old Victorian terrace, we share one side). I was about to go to m and s to buy some flowers. Having read this post I'm now having second thoughts as I don't want her to think I'm unhinged too 🤣

cherieamore · 18/10/2025 12:51

OP thank you for this post, I really hope it is real as it has cheered me up so much. The idea of living in a village like this would terrify me, I would find it so suffocating but I get that it might be wonderful for others. But what I love are your replies, totally unapologetic! I hope you come back with more.

Cherrytree86 · 18/10/2025 12:38

@NeighbourDespair

i think maybe they just don’t like you, Op. you do sound very annoying tbf. Maybe back off and if they wanna come to you then they will. Be prepared they might though as based on first impressions you might have come across to them as a weirdo.
you live and you learn.
hth.

Lifesd · 18/10/2025 12:22

Jesus Christ leave them be.

Didimum · 18/10/2025 12:18

OP, you’re coming across as though you think you own the village and exactly how you think it should be conducted.

You don’t.

You also seem to believe that your ideas of kindness and decency are the only way. They aren’t. What you’re certainly missing is tolerance for a diversity of opinions and conduct.

If you’re neighbours had been outright rude to you, then I’d be on your side, but you come off as very controlling and narrow-minded.

Why does is matter why they wanted to move to this village? You don’t control the reasons for its appeal and you don’t get to have an opinion on where people live and why.

Take a step back and try to be more tolerant of individual attitudes to social involvement.

This is from someone who also lives in a community-centred village, gets involved and is in the village WhatsApp.

zingally · 18/10/2025 12:01

You need to chill your boots. Not everything is for everyone. And while it's lovely that the village has a nice community feel, people are allowed to join in (or not) as much as they like.
Two young kids (your op implied primary school age) and probably 2 full time jobs as well, trying to settle into a new house, and here's Jill from down the road bending my ear about the village whatsapp group. Give it a break. Because I can guarantee, you're not helping.

Istilldontlikeolives · 18/10/2025 11:52

I don't know if this is real and I don't actually care. I just want to say thank you.

BuckChuckets · 18/10/2025 11:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Grammarnut · 18/10/2025 11:36

NeighbourDespair · 17/10/2025 20:07

Thank you for all the comments. For all the people who thought I wasn’t coming back, it wasn’t deliberate - I was out and had no idea the thread had taken off so quickly.

I understand what people are saying, but I feel I’ve been misinterpreted. I do completely understand why this kind of community isn’t for everyone. Of course it isn’t. But what I’m struggling with is why if, it isn’t your thing, you’d pay a premium to live somewhere that’s so well known as a close knit community. Why not live somewhere more anonymous for £100,000 less?

I see pictures of luxury city centre apartments, and they look beautiful. But I’d never buy one, because I don’t want to pay a fortune for flash restaurants and bars where you have to look a certain way and you could be anyone of a hundred people. I like my village pub where they know why name and have already poured my drink before I reach the bar. If I can recognise that I’d hate city centre living and pick somewhere that suits me, why is it so wrong to expect people who pay a fortune to live in a village to want village life?

I doubt they knew it was 'a close knit community', they don't put that on the house specs. They bought a house they liked, which they could afford, convenient for work/schools etc in a pretty village. They didn't realise they had joined a group of 'local' people on the set of League of Gentlemen and they don't want to join.

BriefEncountersOfTheThirdKind · 18/10/2025 10:57

Go and drop round the list of expected events they should be at, every voluntary role they are expected to take up and that'll show them!

TwistedWonder · 18/10/2025 09:11

This is so obviously made up nonsense - no one could possibly go through life being so intrusive and oblivious to their batshit behaviour

If my any tiny chance it is real I’d say OP leave these poor people the fuck alone before you end up with restraining order slapped on you.

thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 09:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Not only do you have absolutely no boundaries, you have no sense of humour either. You really don't recognise a piss-take when you see one.

thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 08:57

NeighbourDespair · 17/10/2025 22:20

I’m sorry someone made you so sad and angry.

Ooh, that's pretty judgemental and passive-aggressive. That poster isn't sad or angry. She's just telling you that people may have other reasons to move to a village and that it isn't compulsory to become 'part of the community'.

You sound as though you have too much time on your hands.

BMW6 · 18/10/2025 08:53

Your attitude appears to be that YOUR way is the only right way to be OP.

Incredibly arrogant of you.

thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 08:31

Tamfs · 17/10/2025 17:22

I'm sorry this made me laugh, I can just picture the OP bustling off back down the path to their house, after her 25th visit to involve them in the community, shouting back at them 'If you need a favour, I shall be thinking thrice. THRICE!' before shutting the gate quietly and carefully so as not to disturb the community.

Absolutely love 'bustling'! It's so evocative and apt. I can just picture OP bustling off in high dudgeon at their unbelievable rejection of involvement in the community.

NewPapaGuinea · 18/10/2025 08:28

Is it pronounced “Bucket” or “Bouquet”?

thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 08:26

Wowwee1234 · 17/10/2025 17:19

I've lived in a similar village and suspect they might just see involvement as beneath themselves or not part of "their circle". They bought for the kudos not the community. You won't win them round. Give up.

Oh and when they do need a favour, I'd think thrice

Ooh, what a dreadful punishment that would be! OP thinking thrice if they need a favour. I've lived in my home for 38 years and I have never asked my neighbours for a favour, so I'm pretty sure OP's neighbours will be OK without being the recipient of OP's overbearing largesse.

Cherrysoup · 18/10/2025 08:22

Took me about 20 years to have my attached neighbour’s number and that was purely because some ‘yoofs’ were being painful in the street. If I moved and someone came over demanding my number for the village Whatsapp, I’d run a mile, hence I’m planning a fairly remote move soon. Leave them alone, fgs.

ThePoliteLion · 18/10/2025 08:18

I too live in a lovely village. There is a sense of community. But the OP is not respectful of her neighbours’ boundaries or autonomy. People are free to live wherever they like and if they don’t want to actively engage with others in the village, that’s their right.

(also still wondering if the post is real).