Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New neighbours don’t want to know

366 replies

NeighbourDespair · 17/10/2025 17:08

We’ve lived in a lovely village for the past 15 years. It was my absolute dream to live here, and it hasn’t disappointed me. It’s not only beautiful, but has a real sense of community – everyone is so friendly, pops in and out whenever, and we all pull together, especially in times of need or a crisis. One of my neighbours hadn’t had a holiday in years because she was struggling with care for her elderly mother; we put together a rota to look after her so my neighbour could finally have a few days’ break. It’s just that kind of place.

Houses here are very sought-after and hardly ever come up for sale, because nobody ever wants to leave. However, one set of our neighbours sold up earlier this year because they wanted to downsize and move closer to their grandchildren. We were very sad to see them go, but at the same time, were looking forward to making the new people welcome, and seeing a family enjoying a wonderful home.

Things could not have worked out more differently. The new people just do not want to know, at all. It’s like they’re almost offended by our attempts to interact and bring them into the community; or at least a bit bewildered by it all. Nothing we do seems to do any good. They don’t seem to understand that they’re part of a community, and one that other people would love to be part of.

I went over to chat as soon as I saw them moving in. They were polite enough, but certainly not forthcoming. You could tell they were itching to get inside. I put it down to them being busy and stressed with the moving and thought I’d try again another time, or that maybe they’d pop over themselves the next day.

I knocked again a couple of days later. The wife answered and was perfectly polite again, but she seemed to be a bit bemused as to why I was there. I said I just wanted to welcome them properly now they were in; she said “Oh, thank you; that’s very kind”, but it became obvious I wasn’t going to be invited in. I felt awkward, so said I had to get on, but that if she’d give me her number I’d add her to the village WhatsApp. She seemed a bit taken aback; she thanked me, but said they didn’t really “go in for” big chat groups. I told her how useful it was and that that’s where we share all the important local information, and she actually said “Oh well, I’m sure we’ll hear about it if it’s important”. I was really shocked; it just felt so brusque when I was trying to make her feel welcome.

I’ve tried a couple of times with her husband, and he’s the same - polite enough, but not at all forthcoming. He’ll respond if you say hello, but makes zero effort. I thought our kids might get to know each other, as they’re similar ages, but we hardly see them, and she drives them off to private school every morning (even though the school is one of the big draws here).

I wondered if it was just me they didn’t like, but my friends and neighbours have all said the same thing - never actively rude, but zero effort or engagement. The owner of the village shop said she’s been in a couple of times, but an Ocado van arrived the day after they moved in, and they’ve never even been seen in the village pub or our local cafe - so it seems they’re not even going to support local businesses.

I know people can buy houses wherever they want to, but I’m just completely confused as to why they’d move to a lovely village with a real reputation for community when they seem to want nothing to do with it. They could have bought a new build in any anonymous town or city if they wanted to stay in their own little world, never talking to anyone, never being part of our community. So why, why did they have to pick here? It’s so rare for a house to come up here; it could have gone to a lovely family who actually wanted to part of things. They must have paid tens or even hundreds of thousands more to live here than some bland new build estate. Why?!

I honestly feel a bit gutted. I know it sounds a bit much, but I’ve loved every minute of being in a street and a community where everyone knows and cares about everyone. I don’t want neighbours who barely nod at me. I think of the wonderful street parties we had for the jubilee and the coronation - now if we have anything like that, it will be painfully obvious that one house is studiously ignoring it all. They might even object to it.

Is there anything we can do to engage these people? Have we done something awful by just trying to be welcoming and involving them in the community? Or do I have to just sit it out hoping they’ll decide they don’t want to be here and will sell up?

OP posts:
Needanadultgapyear · 19/10/2025 08:20

What is village life? For me ( I have lived in a village most of my life) it is living somewhere fairly rural, I don’t have to get in my car to walk my dogs, it is peaceful, but there will be rural smells. I love it.
But I have real social anxiety, I had ‘organised fun’ and I view my home as my castle and I shut my gate to keep the world out.
I am a good neighbour taking in parcels, bring the bins in from the bottom of the lane and I go to occasional village events spend money and stay a minimum amount of time.

BlueandPinkSwan · 19/10/2025 08:18

SleepingisanArt · 17/10/2025 17:12

Leave the poor people alone! It sounds like an awful place to live with everybody feeling they have a right to know everyone else's business!

That would drive me insane to have neighbours that virtaully lived in my home with me! It sounds a complete nightmare of a place. I'm friendly yes on my terms but I don't go out of my way to meet people personally because I'm not that way inclined. I certainly don't want everyone knowing my business and being in my face in the guise of being 'helpful'.
Leave them alone OP and the fellow busy bodies, live in your overbearing weird little utopia.
When truth be known there are probably others who don't like it but don't say anything because they are MNers and don't like to offend anyone so just smile and moan about it on here.😀

MrsMillyFluff · 19/10/2025 08:08

I find your posts and replies condescending and patronising with a touch of arrogance. You're banging on about the neighbours not being very nice, while gossiping about the poor people, that's a dangerous game to play. I'd hate to live near you.

Barney16 · 19/10/2025 08:06

This sounds like a Charlie Brooker plot where someone quite innocently moves to a village and everyone else turns out to be very very strange. An Ocado van? How very dare they.

Telephon · 19/10/2025 08:01

I started to type a response but then I realised the OP post cannot possibly be real, so I haven’t bothered.

On the off chance this is real, you’re being unreasonable.

PinkElephants356 · 19/10/2025 07:59

anytipswelcome · 19/10/2025 07:48

Except OP said repeatedly that this couple have been perfectly polite to everyone in every interaction, never ever rude.

So a completely different situation.

Yes that’s true, there is a difference between being friendly and polite (but wanting to be a little reserved) and being rude and unfriendly.

PinkElephants356 · 19/10/2025 07:57

SuffolkSun · 19/10/2025 05:38

I see pictures of luxury city centre apartments, and they look beautiful. But I’d never buy one, because I don’t want to pay a fortune for flash restaurants and bars where you have to look a certain way and you could be anyone of a hundred people

Newsflash: when you buy a city flat you're buying somewhere to live, not a lifestyle. It's not obligatory to eat out or dress a certain way. What a bizarre (dare I say parochial) take.

There's nothing wrong with your new neighbours' polite responses to you; you may or may not get to know them better over time. If they find you've been starting ill-informed gossip about them though, that's unlikely to happen.

What mostly comes over in your OP is the overegged insistence on how wonderful your village is - and overegged insistence is often a sign that really things aren't that great at all.

I think what they are trying to say is there’s a price tag associated with living near swanky restaurants and bars and if you don’t want that why pay a higher price to live somewhere that has them close by? Why not let someone whose desperate for that lifestyle buy the place instead especially if they are in short supply?

anytipswelcome · 19/10/2025 07:48

PinkElephants356 · 19/10/2025 07:34

To be honest based on where we have moved to, I kind of know what you mean.

The street we have moved to is not at all as friendly and community oriented as yours, but it’s much friendlier than where we used to live. People are not overly friendly but are generally on first name terms, chat in the street, always say hello, are very considerate of each other and therefore it’s a lovely quiet place.

But there’s one house that doesn’t engage with anybody. My neighbour who lives next to them said when she first went round to introduce herself she was given a very cold response and has never spoken to them since. They are also not as considerate with how fast they drive up the cul de sac which they do many times a day ferrying their kids all over the place. It’s very odd, I wonder why they would want to live on a street like that if they want to be unfriendly and not enjoy a quiet and considerate street, because obviously there’s a higher price for a nicer street as well. Maybe they want to enjoy a quiet street but aren’t willing to contribute to it themselves, I really don’t know.

Except OP said repeatedly that this couple have been perfectly polite to everyone in every interaction, never ever rude.

So a completely different situation.

PinkElephants356 · 19/10/2025 07:34

To be honest based on where we have moved to, I kind of know what you mean.

The street we have moved to is not at all as friendly and community oriented as yours, but it’s much friendlier than where we used to live. People are not overly friendly but are generally on first name terms, chat in the street, always say hello, are very considerate of each other and therefore it’s a lovely quiet place.

But there’s one house that doesn’t engage with anybody. My neighbour who lives next to them said when she first went round to introduce herself she was given a very cold response and has never spoken to them since. They are also not as considerate with how fast they drive up the cul de sac which they do many times a day ferrying their kids all over the place. It’s very odd, I wonder why they would want to live on a street like that if they want to be unfriendly and not enjoy a quiet and considerate street, because obviously there’s a higher price for a nicer street as well. Maybe they want to enjoy a quiet street but aren’t willing to contribute to it themselves, I really don’t know.

The13thFairy · 19/10/2025 07:04

You are an absolute nightmare neighbour.

Kirova · 19/10/2025 06:26

I've recently moved with my family to a village so that we can be nearer to DH's parents, who are in their 70s and not in the best of health. One of my children has ADHD and he can get very overwhelmed being surrounded by people, so we thought moving somewhere smaller and quieter would also be good for him. When this house came up, we jumped at it because the location was ideal - closer to DH's parents but also easy for us to commute to work and for DC to stay at the same school.

Everything has worked out really well, but there is one issue. The lady next door is quite... How can I say, overwhelming? Intrusive? Exhausting? Firstly, she turned up and starting asking us half a dozen questions on the doorstep when we were moving in - we hadn't even got inside yet and we were pretty tired out from the move. A few days later, she turned up on the doorstep and demanded that I give her my number so that she could add me to the village WhatsApp. I don't just randomly give out my number for everyone in the village, who I don't actually know yet, to access. Is that so odd?

My kids are loving it here, but days are longer with their commute to school and they tend to be a bit tired out - so they've not spent a lot of time out making friends, but I'm sure they will do once they've adjusted to the new routine. I really like it here, but I'm quite a reserved sort of person and it takes me a while to come out of my shell with people. To be honest, I have started to avoid going to the village shops because every time I go in, somebody pounces on me. The other day, someone started telling me I should support the local businesses more and another person was chiding me for the fact my kids don't go to the village school. I'm sure it's a fantastic school (it looks lovely) but my DS has very specific learning needs and he is well settled at his current school and has great support in place.

I like it here, but I just want to adjust to the new place, finish working on our house and unpacking (!) and get to know people in my own time. AIBU?

SuffolkSun · 19/10/2025 05:38

I see pictures of luxury city centre apartments, and they look beautiful. But I’d never buy one, because I don’t want to pay a fortune for flash restaurants and bars where you have to look a certain way and you could be anyone of a hundred people

Newsflash: when you buy a city flat you're buying somewhere to live, not a lifestyle. It's not obligatory to eat out or dress a certain way. What a bizarre (dare I say parochial) take.

There's nothing wrong with your new neighbours' polite responses to you; you may or may not get to know them better over time. If they find you've been starting ill-informed gossip about them though, that's unlikely to happen.

What mostly comes over in your OP is the overegged insistence on how wonderful your village is - and overegged insistence is often a sign that really things aren't that great at all.

Hernameisdeborah · 19/10/2025 05:31

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 23:43

I find it interesting that, if people buy a house and strip out period features or put patios or decking in mature gardens, Mumsnet is horrified. Yet buy a house in a tight knit community and act like you don’t want anyone near you, and that’s fine.

The neighbours in the OP aren’t acting like they don’t want anyone near them though, they’re just trying to live their lives and be polite. They clearly have some boundaries but nothing about their behaviour described in the OP sounds rude or unusual.

Hernameisdeborah · 19/10/2025 05:21

Apart from everything else on this frankly bizarre post, a total stranger demanding the new neighbour’s phone number and giving the whole “community” access to contact her night and day when she’s barely had a chance to settle in? Nope.

Surely not every single person in this village is this invested in community?

Can you not just accept people have the right to their own lives and get on with your own?

And gossiping to other people about them not behaving the way you want them to? That’s just mean and nasty of you.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 19/10/2025 05:06

I've never had a post deleted before 😥 and I can't even remember what I said - apologies if it offended anyone, I'm mostly just taking the p 🫶.

TeaAndTattoos · 19/10/2025 01:40

Good god woman leave them alone they have made it clear they aren’t interested how many ways do they have to tell you before you get the message and stop pestering them.

TardisGirl81 · 19/10/2025 01:28

Just reread OP to enjoy the batshittery again. You have children at school? I assumed you were some lonely old bat who had too much spare time! Seriously please get a life!

TardisGirl81 · 19/10/2025 00:43

Ii live in a small village, friendly enough, facebook group etc. the facebook group is always about dog poo, suspicious ‘foreign looking’ men and bin day to give you an idea of how riveting village life is! If my neighbours wanted to ‘pop in and out’ of my house without prior invite I’d be horrified. I don’t even like my own family turning up uninvited!
did you really think after knocking on their door for the second time days after they’d moved in you would be invited in?? I mean this kindly but you sound like an overbearing busybody. Leave your poor neighbours alone, they’ve made it clear they’ll be pleasant but are not interested in joining your cult! Maybe get a hobby and keep yourself busy with that.

BriefEncountersOfTheThirdKind · 19/10/2025 00:34

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 23:43

I find it interesting that, if people buy a house and strip out period features or put patios or decking in mature gardens, Mumsnet is horrified. Yet buy a house in a tight knit community and act like you don’t want anyone near you, and that’s fine.

Because those two situations aren't the same...

OriginalUsername2 · 19/10/2025 00:28

thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 08:26

Ooh, what a dreadful punishment that would be! OP thinking thrice if they need a favour. I've lived in my home for 38 years and I have never asked my neighbours for a favour, so I'm pretty sure OP's neighbours will be OK without being the recipient of OP's overbearing largesse.

Phil Collins is singing “Oh..think thrice” in my head now

Nearly50omg · 19/10/2025 00:15

Leave the poor buggers the fuck alone!!! You are HARASSING them!!! Seriously!!!

ToeJob · 18/10/2025 23:43

I find it interesting that, if people buy a house and strip out period features or put patios or decking in mature gardens, Mumsnet is horrified. Yet buy a house in a tight knit community and act like you don’t want anyone near you, and that’s fine.

FOJN · 18/10/2025 19:37

BMW6 · 18/10/2025 15:39

Not wanting to be on a village WhatsApp and wanting to keep your distance - at least to begin with - is NOT being "a misery" FFS!

Are you another like the OP who thinks your way of being is the only way? Think you're sooo great everyone should be just like you?

Tediously arrogant.

Well quite. If they won't be friends on my terms "fuck em". What a worryingly immature way for adults to behave.

neverbeenskiing · 18/10/2025 16:14

If I can recognise that I’d hate city centre living and pick somewhere that suits me, why is it so wrong to expect people who pay a fortune to live in a village to want village life?

Because, funnily enough, you don't get to decide for other people what "village life" means. There is no law that states "village life" requires the level of active participation you personally expect. It's your expectations that are entirely the problem here, not the behaviour of your new neighbours which has been perfectly normal and polite.

Who are you to say these people you don't even know haven't picked a home that suits them?? Maybe the layout of the house suits them. Maybe the size of the garden suits them. Maybe being within driving distance to local amenities without the noise, pollution and crowds associated with city living suits them. Maybe they don't like new-build houses. You seem to think that the only reason anyone would possibly want to live in a village is because they relish the prospect of living in the pockets of their neighbours. But believe it or not, plenty of people manage to live very happily in villages without being in a village whatsapp groups, spending all their free time volunteering to arrange flowers at the church or bake cakes for the fete, and without being in and out of their neighbours houses all the time. Your new neighbours categorically did not sign up for any of that when they bought their house!

It's really, really odd that you don't seem to be able to comprehend that you are not entitled to impose your chosen way of life on other people simply because they've purchased a house in the same postcode as you. I note that you even seem personally offended that they've chosen not to send their child to the village school, as if that's any of your business!! These people don't owe you anything other than common courtesy, they are not beholden to you in any way. You don't get a say in their lives and you have no right to judge them for having different priorities to you.

godmum56 · 18/10/2025 16:11

thepariscrimefiles · 18/10/2025 15:47

OP is reacting really badly to the criticism on this thread to the extent that Mumsnet has deleted at least one of her posts where she is being rude to other posters.

The neighbours aren't being mean at all. They obviously have much busier lives than OP and their social life and their children's education isn't centred in the village. I'm sure they would take in a parcel for OP if the courier knocked on their door. OP does sound petty enough to take your advice though.

yeah its the usual kind of thing

OP Aibu
Mumsnet yes
OP no I am not