Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - GREEN party - Zack Polanski

164 replies

hollyblueivy · 17/10/2025 06:59

AIBU to consider voting Green even though I’m gender critical?

I stumbled across a couple of reels where he was interviewed by Carole (surname unknown shouty presenter) and he really kept his cool and spoke very well.

I’ve just gone down a rabbit hole on his instagram page and can see the Greens are surging and I agree with so much of what he says. It’s refreshing and positive and nothing like the doom and gloom and hatred that comes from Reform.

I am tempted to join them. To feel like I’m doing something to try to change and shape a better future in politics.

my concern is that I am gender critical and they are quite the opposite to me in views. Should I put this aside for the greater good?

AIBU to consider voting green despite this difference in gender critical view?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Swamphag · 22/10/2025 10:32

Ex GP member here.
Not a chance in hell I'll vote for them again. It makes me sad because there's a very real need for a left wing party who are focussed on the environment.

There's clearly a big push to make Hypno Tits popular. My 17 yo asked me what I thought about him the other day. The Greens must be flooding all sorts of social media at the minute and targeting as many different demographics as possible.

If you can lie about men being women, then you'll lie about anything.

PlaceIntheClouds · 22/10/2025 08:01

I used to vote green as my protest vote because I felt obligated to put a tick somewhere. Now they have started getting more support I will probably stop.

Some of their views are bonkers.

SaveMeFromHumanity · 22/10/2025 08:01

Chiseltip · 22/10/2025 07:31

You think gender is the most important manifesto issue!

It's clearly important to the Green Party because they have said they don't want GC women voting for them.

There have also been a number of high profile issues within the party as a result of their position on this.

Zimniy · 22/10/2025 07:55

I voted Green back in the day when they were sensible and cared about the environment. I will never vote for them again as they are zealots in thrall to multiple ideologies. They have treated many of their members appallingly and I wouldn’t trust them to organise a piss up in a brewery.

Sausagenbacon · 22/10/2025 07:47

Look up how they fcked up Brighton. You’ll find your answer.
And now Bristol.
Why would I vote for the Greens to run the country when they can't even run a city?

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/10/2025 07:45

Chiseltip · 22/10/2025 07:31

You think gender is the most important manifesto issue!

oddly a lot of women go think the "gender" issue ie redefining 51% of the population women so that women no longer means 'adult human female' but 'adult human female and men with special non definable lady feelings' is pretty bloody important

it means the greens would be unable to have any definite policy on women's issues because it would include men, it means they cannot monitor the impact of anything they go on women because their definition includes men

but also it means that the Greens think womanhood is a costume men can pop on, that 51% of the population (women) are a set of gendered stereotypes men can perform

if that they're batshit and insulting about something as fundamental as biological sex I wouldnt trust them to run a bath.

SpaceRaccoon · 22/10/2025 07:44

theyve done fuck all to stop Israel murdering Palestinians

Oddly enough, you need to be a Nato member to enjoy the benefit of its protection.

You guys are being fooled by Polanski, he's a slick conman. But it'll split the Labour vote at least.

BobbyBrewstersMagicTorch · 22/10/2025 07:36

I've voted Green ever since Starmer took over. I don't agree with some of their policies, particularly trans issues (where they conflict with women's issues). But they have many good policies that I can get behind so they're definitely better than any of the current parties.

Chiseltip · 22/10/2025 07:31

norestforthewickedwitch · 17/10/2025 07:06

I feel the same.

I always vote green in the locals as they do such a good job in my area but held back in the last few general elections because of their stance on gender.

I just don’t know if I can make the step. Their gender views enrage me. Yet ZP is impressive and importantly to me, is a vegan.

You think gender is the most important manifesto issue!

DdraigGoch · 22/10/2025 07:20

hollyblueivy · 21/10/2025 13:11

The news this week has gone nuts for this party and there seems to be a real momentum behind them.

Where does that leave us mumsnetters that stick two fingers up to Reform, but cannot bring ourselves to vote Green?

There are several serious parties. Pick one.

moderate · 21/10/2025 20:27

hollyblueivy · 17/10/2025 06:59

AIBU to consider voting Green even though I’m gender critical?

I stumbled across a couple of reels where he was interviewed by Carole (surname unknown shouty presenter) and he really kept his cool and spoke very well.

I’ve just gone down a rabbit hole on his instagram page and can see the Greens are surging and I agree with so much of what he says. It’s refreshing and positive and nothing like the doom and gloom and hatred that comes from Reform.

I am tempted to join them. To feel like I’m doing something to try to change and shape a better future in politics.

my concern is that I am gender critical and they are quite the opposite to me in views. Should I put this aside for the greater good?

AIBU to consider voting green despite this difference in gender critical view?

Nice try, Zack. Not fooled though.

Anthempart2 · 21/10/2025 13:30

There’s ’perfect people’ then there’s publicising that you think you can hypnotise peoples tits

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · 21/10/2025 13:29

Are people really still dragging up that Sun article?!

Anyone who knows anything about trash redtop media knows he was most likely asked to take part in that feature and told what to do / say. Yes it's distasteful but he has apologised for it some time ago and has taken responsibility for his mistake which I personally respect.

I don't think politicians have to be perfect people.

I also think it's unrealistic to find a political party with which you'll agree with unequivocally.

He's obviously doing a very good job of getting dissatisfied voters to sit up and listen talking about real issues that affect the majority in a way that resonates.

Frankly, people's stance on trans doesn't impact the vast majority of people on a daily basis. (The worst affected are probably trans people themselves)

Cost of living, housing, taxation, healthcare, education, transport do.

Malariahilaria · 21/10/2025 13:14

Bingowingsincoming · 17/10/2025 07:58

I can't trust what anyone says if I know they are a liar. And anyone who says a woman can have a penis is either lying or deranged. Neither of these are appealing in a political leader.

This exactly. I like what he says and how he deals with the reform people, but he'd throw women and girls under a bus in an instant. I'm glad he's providing a counter weight to reform but I can't actually vote for him.

hollyblueivy · 21/10/2025 13:11

The news this week has gone nuts for this party and there seems to be a real momentum behind them.

Where does that leave us mumsnetters that stick two fingers up to Reform, but cannot bring ourselves to vote Green?

OP posts:
ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 19/10/2025 21:20

Shame really as I would love to find a left of centre, environmentally concerned, gender realist, party.

Isn't this the dream @Alquilarque

Paul2023 · 19/10/2025 20:20

The Green Party are ok to vote for when it comes to local elections, like when the council want to turn a cricket pitch into housing. The Greens are good to object to those such things.

However, into Government the Greens would be would be lunacy. They’d bankrupt the country within six months , that someone else would have to take over.

Have you heard Zach Polanski speak? He wants open borers his solution on the economy is just to tax rich people.. Labour tried that any many rich people are leaving.

Have you heard about when Zach Polanski said he could hypnotise women to make their breasts grow? Don’t believe me , he even admitted it recently on Question Time.

AgapanthusPink · 17/10/2025 17:05

PerriFuckingSickOfIt · 17/10/2025 07:11

Voting for someone based on their diet is bonkers.

Oh I do wish we still had the laugh emoji?! I thought exactly the same!

PrincessFluffyPants · 17/10/2025 15:44

I'm so glad this thread popped up, I had only just been talking about the Green Party with my window cleaner who had told me he had just joined them (for £4?). My window cleaner had zero knowledge of the women's rights/GC issues, (even though he has daughters) but he said he had voted for them for the huge taxation they were planning "on the rich" and for their ecological credentials and also he thought ZP would make a great leader for the UK. I was skeptical but came from the door step to check the Green Party website but struggled to get the info I wanted to see and I certainly couldn't see that their stance on women's rights had changed. I was planning to put a post on here but got distracted. My post was to ask, are the Green Party worth joining/voting for now? And it seems it's still a big fat NO.

Namelessnelly · 17/10/2025 15:21

JeminaTheGiantBear · 17/10/2025 14:09

I loathe his views on single sex spaces & women’s rights.

I may well vote for him, however, because I believe that in the UK our rights, prosperity, health, freedom, democracy, job security, social cohesion & natural environment are being annihilated- deliberately destroyed by ‘politicians’ who aren’t really politicians at all, just corrupt paid lackeys of huge corporations & financial interests, asset stripping what’s left of our national infrastructure before they gleefully escape to their tax havens, leaving ordinary people impoverished, unhealthy, & desperate in a shattered society.

I disagree with ZP abour many things- but I think he’s a genuine politician, with a conscience, who wants to improve the lot of ordinary people. That means he can be reasoned with- whereas other ‘politicians’ are unprincipled lowlife, who can only be bought. All they listen to is money: I don’t think that’s true of him.

I also think the huge media campaign to ridicule & demonise him reflects this. Those who rule us really, really don’t want us realising where our real interests lie. We all need to be terrified of ‘Putin’ and ‘bad immigrants’ and ‘Farage’ while the ruling class cashes in & our children’s future is destroyed. Trans ideology is really useful in this respect; it’s a great way of dividing ordinary people, which is exactly why it has been pushed by so many huge financial institutions & corporations. It’s a weapon.

Don’t let them win.

But he is either
a - batshit crazy and believes humans can change sex
b - misogynist who believes women don’t deserve tights
c - lying about believing humans can change sex.

these are all very good reasons no one should believe a single word he says.

Abra1t · 17/10/2025 15:11

Pollqueen · 17/10/2025 08:07

Are you confusing NATO with the UN? What pray, has NATO to do with Israel and Palestine??

I was wondering this!

midgetastic · 17/10/2025 15:10

The environment challenge we face is unbelievably complicated and multi dimensional requiring innovative and sometimes hard solutions

if they get distracted by gender issues and can’t tell sex from gender why on earth would I join them ? No credibility at all

hellowhaaat3632 · 17/10/2025 15:05

I used to vote Green but now it's where all the nutters aggregate, so i would avoid if i were you

I mean, if you look on Reddit, it's where the craziest ones say they'll be heading

Anthempart2 · 17/10/2025 15:00

Wellnowlookhere · 17/10/2025 14:57

Do you not think there is a huge risk the greens can actually do fuck all about prosperity, health, freedom and social cohesion if in power, but will then additionally trample all over women and their remaining rights on top of that quagmire of crap? That is far too big a risk for me, to vote for a party where this guy thinks breasts can be convinced to grow under hypnosis is in charge. Leave him with the economy and my right to single sex spaces?
No thanks. Turkeys voting for Christmas.

Absolutely this!

What I’ve noticed with the Greens and Your Party is they’re a bit like the Respect lot years ago - they’re a Trojan horse for very sinister identity or foreign policies, made to appeal to the less intelligent of the masses by quickly adding at the end ‘and we’ll tax the rich so you can have everything for free’.

anamo · 17/10/2025 14:58

The Greens were green once and I supported their eco vigilance.

They have gone down a rabbit hole of madness and causes that are a bit crazy, and have thus lost their founding principles.

That's a no from me now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread