Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Genuine question for anti-vaxxers

584 replies

Raisinmeup · 12/10/2025 12:25

I see a lot online about anti-vaxxers and I’m trying to understand where they’re coming from, so this is a genuine question, not rage bait.

My understanding is that some parents choose not to vaccinate their children because they believe vaccines cause harmful side effects, or they just don’t trust the government and big pharma in general.

But what’s the alternative? If everyone stopped vaccinating, wouldn’t we start seeing diseases like polio coming back? That would mean more infant deaths and lifelong disabilities. It just doesn’t seem like a rational trade off?

From what I’ve seen, there seems to be a belief that immune systems can deal with these illnesses naturally, but I wonder if part of that belief comes from the fact that parents of today haven’t actually seen what a world without vaccines looks like. We’ve grown up in a time where infant death from preventable diseases is almost unheard of, so maybe it’s easy to forget how serious these infections really are.

And lastly, if you haven’t vaccinated your child and they then catch one of these illnesses, do you not end up turning to the same big pharma for the medicine or treatment anyway?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
user098786533 · 14/10/2025 09:45

FlyMeSomewhere · 13/10/2025 22:36

I went to a surgeons museum in Edinburgh, great place for seeing medical equipment from throughout the ages and lots of things in jars but there were some things that never left me such as images and paintings of people wild eyed with pain and terror during a tetanus spasm that's contorting their entire bodies!
These are illnesses that you would have to be a total bastard to put your kids through whilst you sit back with your luxury protection because your parents didn't join tin foil cults! Nobody had an issue with jabs until the cult instructed them to!

I used to work near a graveyard once that I used to walk around sometimes on my lunch hour, it was a very old graveyard and had a lot of children buried in it, many graves had multiple siblings in it because the diseases swept through entire families, many adults were lucky if they lived through their 30"s! That's the dark legacy that gets left, the anti vaxxers kids that don't die in childhood could become like the people that died early in adulthood, they carry on the legacy from Granny & Grandad Anti vax and generations are born where the premature death rate is high! How do you sleep at night knowing you are volunteering your kids to vicious illnesses that you are protected from!

Even some of the milder complications are things like infertility! That's going to be a good conversation when these kids grow up passionately wanting a family & having to deal with the fact that their parents were responsible for voluntarily removing their infertility! Do these anti vaxxers think of the hate and disownment they've got coming if they voluntarily give their kids long term health issues that dog them for the rest of their life!

It's a valid question and I think if we did see cases of this we would change our minds.

But I know lots of families who don't use vaccines and there is a yearly outbreak of measles locally and these vaccinated children remain unscathed.

Tetanus is a bad example surely? People worked on farms in dirt and the lack of sanitation back then. A deep puncture wound filled with horse manure is hardly likely in the UK. If they want to be farmers when older they can get a tetanus jab first.

user098786533 · 14/10/2025 09:38

thecatfromneptune · 14/10/2025 09:37

To be honest, I think that anyone who cites “toxic stress” as equivalent to the brain injuries that can be caused by measles encephalitis is not educated or informed about medicine, or posting in good faith.

I agree. I didn't do that though. I mentioned it as something which contributes to worse outcomes.

thecatfromneptune · 14/10/2025 09:37

To be honest, I think that anyone who cites “toxic stress” as equivalent to the brain injuries that can be caused by measles encephalitis is not educated or informed about medicine, or posting in good faith.

user098786533 · 14/10/2025 09:36

thecatfromneptune · 14/10/2025 09:33

And yet there were still women who had disabled babies or stillbirths because of rubella, and some children who had brain damage from varicella encephalitis, deafness, vision loss or cognitive impairments from measles, young men who had fertility problems from mumps, and so on. For some people it was actually very serious; as a small child you would have been unaware of these cases and so naturally you just recall it all being fine.

I was once on a live MN thread about ten years ago where a mum couldn’t wake her fifteen month old, and posters came on to say get him to A&E now, including another poster’s DH who was a GP. It turned out that the baby had encephalitis from undiagnosed chickenpox (with only a few spots on his foot). The mum came back on a while later to say he had survived, but had a long road to recovery. I often think about her and her child and hope they are okay. Childhood illnesses are not always all simple and minor, and most Western countries now vaccinate for chickenpox because even though it’s generally mild, in rare cases it can be disastrous.

But it's the same with vaccines. Generally safe but an adverse event can be disastrous.

The only thing that vaccines have in their favour with that particular point is a statistically lower risk of an adverse event from a vaccine than from a disease, but then there are other factors at play as I said above. Every individual child's risk profile is different,.

user098786533 · 14/10/2025 09:34

Wrenjay · 13/10/2025 22:33

Your treatment was "off label". Does that mean it was not a tried and tested drug for your symptoms? If so, why was it given to you?

you can be prescribed a medicine off-label by a professional if there is evidence that it can work for that condition. There is a medicine used for anxiety and intrusive thoughts that was developed as a medicine to stop excessive scratching in dogs. Ketamine is used in human medicine but is primarily a horse tranquiliser.

thecatfromneptune · 14/10/2025 09:33

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 09:25

It was more a chicken pox party thing in the 80's but ultimately people need to understand what we were exposed to as kids wasn't a potentially very serious illness without being jabbed.

And yet there were still women who had disabled babies or stillbirths because of rubella, and some children who had brain damage from varicella encephalitis, deafness, vision loss or cognitive impairments from measles, young men who had fertility problems from mumps, and so on. For some people it was actually very serious; as a small child you would have been unaware of these cases and so naturally you just recall it all being fine.

I was once on a live MN thread about ten years ago where a mum couldn’t wake her fifteen month old, and posters came on to say get him to A&E now, including another poster’s DH who was a GP. It turned out that the baby had encephalitis from undiagnosed chickenpox (with only a few spots on his foot). The mum came back on a while later to say he had survived, but had a long road to recovery. I often think about her and her child and hope they are okay. Childhood illnesses are not always all simple and minor, and most Western countries now vaccinate for chickenpox because even though it’s generally mild, in rare cases it can be disastrous.

user098786533 · 14/10/2025 09:32

Beachtastic · 14/10/2025 09:27

^ was?

Chicken pox is a mild, routine, self-limiting infection and I wouldn't even consider a vaccine. There's just no indication my children would have a more than baseline risk of complications.

Vaccines are a perfectly reasonable public health policy. It's not practical to administer them on a case by case basis; say kids who are never breastfed, exposed to toxic stress, malnourished, immune compromised... so we use them for all, but we are still free to hedge our bets of resilience in other ways and forego prophylactic therapy.

I'm not denying that unvaccinated children are statistically more at risk of VPDs, but I don't believe that being unvaccinated makes you intrinsically more likely to die.

user098786533 · 14/10/2025 09:27

Angels1111 · 13/10/2025 15:12

My cousin had a very severe reaction to a vaccine and ended up profoundly disabled for the rest of her life. She died in her 40s, mentally never progressing beyond 2, the age when she was vaccinated. My aunt and uncle broke their backs caring for her.
But, I still chose to vaccinate my DC - as I didn't want to feel responsible for him getting one of the diseases had I chosen not to....and I figured I was only even considering not vaccinating because, as you say, I hadn't seen such severe illnesses in my lifetime. But I do have sympathy with the fears around side effects.

I realise statistically my children are less at risk of what you describe than of a VPD, and it also scares me.

Someone above also said that some children are susceptible to vaccine damage genetically, but I don't think this is confirmed by the medical establishment?

If there were a test to confirm or deny this I would use it as I would like to give my children vaccines but I am just too afraid of the adverse events from the vaccines.

And even though it suggests that there are conspiracies involved within medicine, I don't believe that, if it were the case vaccines caused more harm than is widely accepted, it would be publicised. So I remain sceptical and I remain worried about VPDs to an extent.

Beachtastic · 14/10/2025 09:27

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 09:25

It was more a chicken pox party thing in the 80's but ultimately people need to understand what we were exposed to as kids wasn't a potentially very serious illness without being jabbed.

^ was?

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 09:25

Beachtastic · 14/10/2025 09:20

It was true of my childhood! Our local GP encouraged kids to play together if anyone had German measles (as long as no mothers were pregnant!), so that we would all catch it young, and get it over and done with. He used to ring us up if he knew of a case. He was particularly keen for girls to catch it, so that they needn't worry about infection later in life when pregnant. I think it was fairly common in the 1960s, because there was no way to prevent rubella except through natural immunity. It was like an unexploded grenade, we tried our best to control how it affected our lives rather than just letting it circulate unpredictably and reach vulnerable pregnant women. It's wonderful that vaccination now offers protection.

It was more a chicken pox party thing in the 80's but ultimately people need to understand what we were exposed to as kids wasn't a potentially very serious illness without being jabbed.

YorkshireGoldDrinker · 14/10/2025 09:20

ThisTipsyGreyCrab · 13/10/2025 20:47

Isn’t Covid recommended during pregnancy too? I got pregnant a year ago (with the wonderful baby that’s now in my arms :) ) and went and had the flu and Covid jabs a few weeks after finding out. I also had the others vacs recommended to me by midwifes. I just assumed Covid was also a risk if I caught it whilst pregnant and flu/cold season was approaching..

The covid jab isn't offered anymore where I am. If I was lucky enough to be pregnant anywhere between 2020 and 2021 and I was offered it, I wouldn't have taken it then, either. They said it was safe, but it was rushed through and I don't trust it. On the other hand, the flu jab has been around for donkey's moons and I trust that.

Beachtastic · 14/10/2025 09:20

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 07:23

It annoys me when people claim that our parents had measles parties which just isn't true, I can remember mums being twitchy in my 80's childhood when GM was about and keeping kids away from other kids when they had it.

It was true of my childhood! Our local GP encouraged kids to play together if anyone had German measles (as long as no mothers were pregnant!), so that we would all catch it young, and get it over and done with. He used to ring us up if he knew of a case. He was particularly keen for girls to catch it, so that they needn't worry about infection later in life when pregnant. I think it was fairly common in the 1960s, because there was no way to prevent rubella except through natural immunity. It was like an unexploded grenade, we tried our best to control how it affected our lives rather than just letting it circulate unpredictably and reach vulnerable pregnant women. It's wonderful that vaccination now offers protection.

messybutfun · 14/10/2025 08:44

ThejoyofNC · 12/10/2025 13:24

I am unvaccinated as are my children.

I come from a culture where probably 75% of people are unvaccinated. I did an awful lot of research and put a lot of consideration into my decision as I didn't want to blindly follow my culture when it came to medical choices. I looked into each individual vaccine and the ingredients it contained.

Ultimately I came to the decision not to vaccinate and my husband supported this (he was vaccinated as a child with everything except MMR).

I am very satisfied with my choice. And I'm not some moron who believes social media conspiracies which I know people will jump to, in fact I'm not even on social media at all.

And yet, here you are

thecatfromneptune · 14/10/2025 08:40

CharlieRight · 14/10/2025 07:36

I wouldn't call my self anti-vaccine. But the wide introduction of vaccines coincided with various other public health improvements (public sanitation, personal hygiene, NHS, nutrition,....) so it may be that they get more credit than they are truly deserve (but I am not saying that they don't deserve any).

To say this is to not understand vaccination — no amount of improved sanitation can completely eradicate a virus (if anything, viruses are much more transmissible in the modern world). Only vaccination can do that, by creating herd immunity and this removing the viral reservoir (the places where the virus circulates).

Improved sanitation and living standards haven’t eradicated viruses for which we don’t have vaccines, have they?

CharlieRight · 14/10/2025 07:36

I wouldn't call my self anti-vaccine. But the wide introduction of vaccines coincided with various other public health improvements (public sanitation, personal hygiene, NHS, nutrition,....) so it may be that they get more credit than they are truly deserve (but I am not saying that they don't deserve any).

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 07:26

A few years back, I had tetanus, diphtheria, polio, typhoid and yellow fever jabs all in one afternoon and had no ill effect! There's no justification for risking lives over jabs that have been safe for many generations!

Wimin123 · 14/10/2025 07:25

ThejoyofNC · 12/10/2025 13:24

I am unvaccinated as are my children.

I come from a culture where probably 75% of people are unvaccinated. I did an awful lot of research and put a lot of consideration into my decision as I didn't want to blindly follow my culture when it came to medical choices. I looked into each individual vaccine and the ingredients it contained.

Ultimately I came to the decision not to vaccinate and my husband supported this (he was vaccinated as a child with everything except MMR).

I am very satisfied with my choice. And I'm not some moron who believes social media conspiracies which I know people will jump to, in fact I'm not even on social media at all.

You are influenced by social media though - that’s where all the nonsense comes from. It can’t be from evidence based scientific research or you would have come to the opposite conclusion.

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 07:23

sashh · 14/10/2025 07:14

Measles and German measles are totally different diseases. As a PP said GM is rubella.

And although rubella is normally a mild childhood disease it can be devastating for an unborn child.

My mother was pregnant with me, had been visiting a relative with a young child the the next day developed rubella.

Fortunately as it was a family member my mum knew she had been exposed, her only option was injections of gamma globulin.

There was no ultrasound then so she had to wait until I was born to find out if I would be born disabled.

It annoys me when people claim that our parents had measles parties which just isn't true, I can remember mums being twitchy in my 80's childhood when GM was about and keeping kids away from other kids when they had it.

dcthatsme · 14/10/2025 07:15

Measles (the first M in the MMR) vaccine is a horrible illness. The daughter of a friend of my mother's was born in the early 1960s. A bright healthy girl from an affluent family (ie she had everything to eat she needed and a warm home etc etc). She contracted measles aged 3 and sadly developed encephalitis, a not uncommon associated condition. She was left with brain damage and has had to be cared for her entire life. Children regularly died of this illness in the past. Many people today don't know this because we are so fortunate here in the UK to have been shielded from it thanks to vaccinations introduced in late 1960s. This useful website run by the University of Oxford gives all the facts and figures about different vaccinations in clear and simple language. Please read if you are in any doubt.
vaccineknowledge.ox.ac.uk/mmr-vaccine#Key-vaccine-facts

sashh · 14/10/2025 07:14

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 06:19

Because there's two types of measles, when I was a kid yes, German measles used to circulated is a much milder disease than the variant we were vaccinated for - plus would it have been as mild if we hadn't been vaccinated! The myth that these disease are mild needs to stop, we weren't exposed to worst version of measles because we were jabbed!

Measles and German measles are totally different diseases. As a PP said GM is rubella.

And although rubella is normally a mild childhood disease it can be devastating for an unborn child.

My mother was pregnant with me, had been visiting a relative with a young child the the next day developed rubella.

Fortunately as it was a family member my mum knew she had been exposed, her only option was injections of gamma globulin.

There was no ultrasound then so she had to wait until I was born to find out if I would be born disabled.

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 06:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BertieBotts · 14/10/2025 06:28

German measles is Rubella, the R in MMR.

FlyMeSomewhere · 14/10/2025 06:19

Morningsleepin · 14/10/2025 00:17

You are generations away from those days but I grew up in those days and children did not routinely die from measles. All children got measles when I was young and I never even heard of anyone being harmed, though there must have been some rare cases

Because there's two types of measles, when I was a kid yes, German measles used to circulated is a much milder disease than the variant we were vaccinated for - plus would it have been as mild if we hadn't been vaccinated! The myth that these disease are mild needs to stop, we weren't exposed to worst version of measles because we were jabbed!

lollylo · 14/10/2025 05:08

Crwysmam · 13/10/2025 14:30

The problem with the HPV vaccine is that it’s only given to girls. As soon as your DD becomes sexually active she will be exposed to the virus. Not only does it cause cervical cancer but it can lead to oral cancer.
I hope you encourage her to attend cervical screening as soon as she is sexually active so any infection can be picked up early.

It’s been on the U.K. vaccine schedule for boys since 2019. Obviously, in having the vaccine if you are exposed then you are protected.

Morningsleepin · 14/10/2025 03:46

Bones101 · 14/10/2025 00:44

For anyone unvaccinated let me tell you about a child I saw last week in my hospital.

She was born full term. No time in NICU. Parents a bit odd and didn't get her vaccinated.

At age 3 she contacted an infection. A bad strain. She ended up in ICU as she couldn't breathe. She was then paralysed from the neck down.

She is now 12 and is still paralysed from the neck down and still has a Trachestomy in place.

I don't care what you do with your body but your child doesn't have a say and should be fully vaccinated. This child's life was destroyed by her selfish and ignorant parents.

What infection did she contract?

Swipe left for the next trending thread