Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH to wash his hands?

141 replies

SENSummer · 09/10/2025 19:12

Ok, so I’m totally willing to be told IABU maybe I am, looking for some perspective.

I’m an emetophobe and one of my two small kids is disabled so I’m even more aware of cleanliness and germs. We get ill a lot. More than you would expect in my opinion.

DH is a hospital doctor. He works in the hospital all day. I’m often upstairs with the kids doing bedtime when he comes in so don’t observe his routine but tonight I was downstairs and noticed he didn’t wash his hands when he got home. Just wanted through the door and started shoving his hands into the bread bag to make toast and touching loads of fruit in the fruit bowl…etc

I asked if he’d washed his hands. He said yes, earlier in the day before he left work. I was a bit taken a back. I asked if he would mind washing his hands when he comes into the house on a night due to him being in the hospital all day. Both me and the kids wash our hands as soon as we come in from school or activities. It’s not an excessive amount but just seems a reasonable precaution to me.

DH hit the roof and made it clear I was being completely and utterly unreasonable and reminded me firmly that he knows better in these matters than I do.

So I put it to you oh wise MN’s… was I being unreasonable to ask DH to wash his hands?

OP posts:
Elfie111 · 10/10/2025 20:01

I am totally with you. I would also be asking him to ditch whatever clothes he had on into a (toxic waste) laundry bin and shower and change.

I am like this anyway and we don’t even have anyone who is immunosuppressed.

Backing you all the way on this one. Even if it just makes you feel better to have him wash his hands that’s surely the point - but also we know how germs spread and he knows very well too - he’s a doctor.

♥️

ClareBlue · 10/10/2025 19:58

Whatever you opinion is on hand washing on entering the house the bit about 'hitting the roof' and lecturing you that he knows more than you about it, would piss me off. If it makes you happy then the 25 seconds to do it is no big deal, whatever he thinks about the merits of doing it, why not just do it. Why do people have to be so confrontational with their partners. This isn't about him being controlled or OP being a controlling partner, it's something that concerns her that he can resolve with minimal effort and time input. Then everything is good for the evening. Why come home from a stressful work situation and cause more stress at home and with the person you love because 'you know more about it'.

Labelak · 10/10/2025 19:56

You wash hands before preparing food. He stuck his hands straight into food prep. So he is very unreasonable.

That said, if he'd washed his hands when leaving work, and then driven home, then it was probably OK not to wash them immediately. However, if used bus/tube etc, then hands definitely need washing upon arrival.

Opal888 · 10/10/2025 19:53

I'm in healthcare and wash my hands immediately I get in, and insist that DW and kids do too. I know for a fact they ignore me when they think I'm not in. But IANBU and neither are you

Shessweetbutapsycho · 10/10/2025 19:53

I’m not an especially OTT person when it comes to handwashing, but I generally wash hands when coming home after being out at work all day. I think for me it’s a bit of a hangover from covid, and working in quite a high risk workplace. I would say that a hospital is even higher risk in terms of catching illnesses etc (my DS and DBIL are both hospital workers and I’d say the frequency of sickness of various types in their household is well above what I see for other families. With that in mind I’d say it was basic common sense for someone coming in from a hospital would change and wash hands when they come home, certainly before helping themselves to communal food items. In the case of the OP, this simple act could help her manage her anxiety about germs and sickness too, so I don’t see what the issue is with her husband just washing his hands when he gets in?

FMc208 · 10/10/2025 19:51

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:10

Genuine question. Do you ask visitors to wash their hands?

I did when it seemed acceptable when Covid was at the forefront of everyones mind, but now I'd feel very uncomfortable asking.

My family and friends all do it anyway so don’t need to be asked.

BellissimoGecko · 10/10/2025 19:37

He works in a hospital. Yes, he should wash his hands when he gets home, and especially before touching food!

Fabulously · 10/10/2025 19:36

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:28

It goook a while, but obviously someone managed to turn a thread about hand washing onto illness being being a fat issue

FFS HAVE A DAY OFF

And it took no time at all for an overweight person to take offence at the fact that excess weight can impact your health.

plus that wasn’t the point of my post, seems you’re looking to be offended. It was just an illustration.

JLou08 · 10/10/2025 19:35

I think YABU. I don't wash my hands when I get in. I'm rarely ill and when I am it's colds which are airborne. I haven't had a stomach bug for over 10 years.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 10/10/2025 19:30

What do you do about house guests who come into your house having been on the tube or wherever and don't go "to freshen up" straight away? I was cringing recently when my son and his girlfriend came in from the airport recently after a holiday. I think my son washed his hands as the habit was drummed into him from school age, but his girlfriend didn't. They were touching cupboards, the bread, taps, all sorts. The first thing I do when arriving at a destination after travelling is wash my hands. It does make a difference. If I'm out all day on a city break it's not always possible to wash your hands before eating etc and those are the times I end up sick.

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:28

Fabulously · 10/10/2025 18:58

this is a poor argument. Firstly, patients might “acquire” illnesses that hospitals can’t avoid such as airborne viral illnesses spreading given the higher amount of ill people in close proximity including visitors, & healthcare being free/mandatory to access. People who are visiting an unwell relative in hospital aren’t going to stay home if they have a cold for example. But that has nothing to do with whether people wash their hands or not.

conversely, a doctor at a hospital is more likely to see “valid” illnesses caused by underlying conditions, injury, relevant medical history etc as opposed to conditions caused by not washing hands in particular. They likely aren’t going to see many people whose illness can be attributed to that, so I understand OP’s husband’s general point.

Plus there’s a range of factors that make someone more susceptible to getting illnesses, an unwell obese person is going to be more likely to be unwell due to their excess weight than not washing hands for example.

It goook a while, but obviously someone managed to turn a thread about hand washing onto illness being being a fat issue

FFS HAVE A DAY OFF

Octoberaddsagale · 10/10/2025 19:26

I don’t think I used routinely to wash my hands before preparing food until I did my level 2 Food and Hygiene certification. Now I always do. I also wash my hands before I eat, but in most schools it’s just not practical and that’s where children may learn hygiene practices they don’t follow at home.

Several years ago, pre-Covid, I was helping backstage with an amateur production when one of the cast came into the dressing room and started washing his hands. I don’t think he’d just been to the loo, as there are sinks in there, but he may just have touched something grubby offstage. I wasn’t particularly paying attention to him until I realised how long he was taking and noticed how thoroughly he was washing every surface of his hands. When I asked him what his job was he said he was a doctor. It must have been second nature and trained into him, so that he did it even when not at work.

Perhaps it’s a generational thing. He was probably late 20s.

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:25

taxguru · 10/10/2025 18:49

So he teleported himself from the washbasin in the hospital to his home kitchen then if he touched nothing on the way!!

Exactly her point hence saying YANBU,

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:23

Allseeingallknowing · 10/10/2025 18:07

How do people with long nails maintain toilet and food hygiene ? Certainly wouldn’t want them preparing my food! Often wonder how those working in care homes with ridiculously long nails avoid scratching residents when bathing them, pressure area care etc. They must have a special knack!

I've had natural ling nails for years

i wash my hands. That includes my nails. Everyone has the part if a nail most likely to be dirty/trap dirt, the bit near your finger skin.

i have never once scratched or otherwise hurt a baby/child/cared for person with my nails.

I imagine it's much more likely with false nails as people might not be so used to them.

You're incredibly unlikely to ever have good prepared by me, but don't be so judgemental. I'd rather have my food prepared by someone with long nails that washes their hands than half this thread of soap dodgers.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 10/10/2025 19:22

taxguru · 10/10/2025 15:41

The difference is all the germs you could pick up from door handles, hand rails, etc., even moreso if using public transport. Presumably he's touching your front door handle to open it and touchpoints/doors for leaving the hospital? If using public transport, it's really grim not to wash hands when you get home as you'll have been touching all kinds of surfaces that literally hundreds of other people have touched that day.

And yes, I do wash my hands when I come in from work, school run, shopping, etc., I think the point is that hospitals are full of unwell people with all kinds of infections, so obviously an even higher risk than shopping etc., even if he has washed his hands before coming home - he'll still be touching door handles, lift buttons etc in the hospital on his way out!

I totally agree with you. I only realised what a difference it made once my kids started school. I was sick of us all getting sick so often. So insisted on us all washing hands when we got in from the school run, and also anywhere else we'd been. Made such a difference.

DH has always been half-hearted about it. Pain in the arse. His argument that he washes his hands before he leaves work and he's in his own car and not on public transport. But he's touching all sorts of door handles and lift buttons after that. I think a lot of men are just naturally grubby creatures.

I work in a school and always try to wash my hands before I eat my lunch. If I don't I am much more likely to catch the latest thing going round.

Sagaciously · 10/10/2025 19:14

It wouldn’t occur to me to wash my hands when I arrive home.

The issue is yours, OP. You should be addressing it.

clinellwipe · 10/10/2025 19:11

Oh wow I had to check the username as I wondered if I had posted this in a sleep deprived state…

I’m an emetophobe and husband is a hospital doctor (I was a hospital doctor too but now at home with our autistic son!).

My husband was not the type to wash his hands coming home from work. He is the type to walk into a staff room and scoff whatever food is in there without thinking of washing his hands, he would chew on his pen whilst writing in notes etc (yes yes this is unhygienic I agree). Anyway, I’ve successfully hassled him enough over our marriage to wash his hands WHENEVER he comes home - whether he’s been at work or Aldi or whatever. I just think that’s common sense. It’s now a habit for him. I can hear that he’s doing it when he comes home late at night even when he thinks I’m asleep.

basically YANBU. It’s common sense, he’s at bigger risk of bringing home germs, if your family gets unwell it’s more inconvenient due to your emetophobia and your disabled child, and it’s also inconvenient to his workplace if he gets unwell - leaving his colleagues and patients in the lurch.

Catquest · 10/10/2025 19:11

NoSoupForU · 09/10/2025 19:17

I think its hugely unfair of you to project your issues onto other people. It isn't really normal to have to wash your hands whenever you come home. You can't eradicate germs from your world, but you just know this.

However, I think he should wash his hands before handling food that other people will also be having.

What?
It's basic hygiene

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:10

FMc208 · 10/10/2025 16:25

I am absolutely gobsmacked at the people that don’t wash their hands when coming in! It’s basic hygiene. It’s a non negotiable in our house and no one has ever thought it weird or over the top.

I couldn’t imagine coming in from work/the shops/public transport and not washing my hands. Imagine all the grub/germs/bugs you touch when in these places, bringing them into the house? No thanks.

Maybe it’s coincidence or maybe it’s not but all of us are very rarely ill.

Genuine question. Do you ask visitors to wash their hands?

I did when it seemed acceptable when Covid was at the forefront of everyones mind, but now I'd feel very uncomfortable asking.

Bedtelly · 10/10/2025 19:08

The amount of emetophobics on MN is crazy. That being said he should just wash his hands when he comes home, it's not exactly a massive inconvenience.

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 19:05

SummerFeverVenice · 09/10/2025 19:26

What is the difference between washing your hands right before you leave the hospital vs when you get home?

You don’t wash your hands right before you come home from the school run, shopping, your work? So not really fair to compare.

Well, unless he floats home touching nothing, whatever he's touched on the journey home....

plus, so what, 2-3 minutes washing & drying his hands properly isn't exactly a hardship.

if he lived here, he'd be going straight into the shower & putting home clothes on & the work clothes in the washing machine.

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 10/10/2025 18:59

onlyoneoftheregimentinstep · 09/10/2025 19:19

It has honestly never crossed my mind to wash my hands when getting home. Completely over the top.

Did you sleep right the way through ALL of the Covid advice?? FFS even Boris got it!

@SENSummer

I don't think its unreasonable to ask him to wash his hands when he gets home & especially before touching food.

However, if he's washing his hands (as you said he was) before he leaves work (& he washes them thoroughly) where he works is really completely irrelevant.

I have to admit that I became somewhat complacent while the Covid rate was low, but due to it shooting up recently I've become more diligent again. (& yes. I'm aware other bugs/virus are available )

Fabulously · 10/10/2025 18:58

taxguru · 10/10/2025 18:47

Tell that to the enormous number of people who get "hospital aquired infections" in hospitals etc!

this is a poor argument. Firstly, patients might “acquire” illnesses that hospitals can’t avoid such as airborne viral illnesses spreading given the higher amount of ill people in close proximity including visitors, & healthcare being free/mandatory to access. People who are visiting an unwell relative in hospital aren’t going to stay home if they have a cold for example. But that has nothing to do with whether people wash their hands or not.

conversely, a doctor at a hospital is more likely to see “valid” illnesses caused by underlying conditions, injury, relevant medical history etc as opposed to conditions caused by not washing hands in particular. They likely aren’t going to see many people whose illness can be attributed to that, so I understand OP’s husband’s general point.

Plus there’s a range of factors that make someone more susceptible to getting illnesses, an unwell obese person is going to be more likely to be unwell due to their excess weight than not washing hands for example.

taxguru · 10/10/2025 18:57

Pezdeoro41 · 10/10/2025 18:50

Is he not saying though that he washes them before he leaves work? If he's doing that right at the end of the day (and in a hospital sense ie using anti bac soap) then surely he is already washing all of that off? Depends if he then drives or take public transport but surely the hospital aspect isn't relevant if he is washing before leaving?

Except he will be touching things as he leaves the hospital, i.e. door handles, lift buttons, etc., so he'll still be picking up the germs of all the ill and unhealthy people in the hospital!

springissprung2025 · 10/10/2025 18:54

I'm 60, wash my hands after using the loo, before prepping food and obviously in the shower. Other than that wouldn't think of it. I'm perfectly healthy, take no medication, have never had any D&V bugs. I've also brought up a disabled child into adulthood. Maybe your lifestyle is impacting on the illnesses in your household?