Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Discuss How Not To Be A Bullying Victim

109 replies

ClockedIt · 09/10/2025 08:45

There was another thread on a similar but not same subject this week that that mentions that this would be a good subject to explore but, to use a well worn phrase ‘would be the subject of a different thread’.

That thread had some really interesting posts about group dynamics.

I had a discussion a while ago about this with someone who had been badly bullied - didn’t fit in in school, college or work. We became friendly and had a lot of deep personal chats. I said to him “who is most likely to become a victim of bullying - is it someone with no friends?”

He said “no - not exactly someone with no friends - it’s someone who is unsure”

Even though he was bullied, he had a good perception of people and people’s motivations.

Someone else I spoke to said that people pick on differences between people but if a person with differences has a strong personality that deters bullies.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
user1471453601 · 13/10/2025 23:18

@ClockedIt Started to reply, but it was swallowed in the ether,no matter.

I think they wanted to wield their power in front of the rest of the management team,and I was an obvious target, being female.

they were, of course,very stupid, because they didn't have anything in their gift that I wanted.

I didn't want promotion, or need others to like me. I was quite happy with what I had.

I had something they'd never have, and that was enough. Enough money, enough influence. Just, enough.

They seemed to hate me for that.

ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 22:55

Kibble19 · 13/10/2025 22:40

I have no time for this “the bully might have autism/adhd/a bad home life/separated parents” talk. Not one part of that is any of my concern.

My son will be brought up to know that he can hit back and absolutely should. Every single time.

All that “be kind” rubbish breeds victims. I’m not raising a victim.

I know the pacifist mob like to suggest that teaching a child to hit back will mean they’ll be in jail as an adult for violence, but there’s a world of difference between showing some little bastard that you’re capable of looking after yourself and going around assaulting people as an adult.

Yes totally agree sounds like you’ve got the balance right !

OP posts:
Kibble19 · 13/10/2025 22:40

I have no time for this “the bully might have autism/adhd/a bad home life/separated parents” talk. Not one part of that is any of my concern.

My son will be brought up to know that he can hit back and absolutely should. Every single time.

All that “be kind” rubbish breeds victims. I’m not raising a victim.

I know the pacifist mob like to suggest that teaching a child to hit back will mean they’ll be in jail as an adult for violence, but there’s a world of difference between showing some little bastard that you’re capable of looking after yourself and going around assaulting people as an adult.

ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 22:27

user1471453601 · 13/10/2025 22:10

I was the target of two male bullies later in life. Both were too thick to realise that, although they were senior to me, they had nothing in their gift (popularity, preferment,, more seniority) nothing that I wanted.'. They gave up pretty quickly when they,eventually realised that.

Sad, sad people.

in my experience, not of course in yours, my bully wanted something. The mistake they made was in assuming I wanted the same thing was them.

What did your bully want if they were senior you ?

OP posts:
TheWildZebra · 13/10/2025 22:20

NellieElephantine · 10/10/2025 21:38

Agree, dd1 sadly has been captured by the 'be kind' shite.

Apologies if I’m misreading your posts, but This feels like a really sad way for your kids to learn how to deal with conflict? Your DD1 is sensitive and gentle (the qualities you probably want in a person) and she is victim blamed, and DD2 responds with aggression to provocation and that’s somehow a good thing? It doesn’t sound like DD2 is actually learning much resilience that will work in the real world where you can’t just deal with confrontation using your fists.

user1471453601 · 13/10/2025 22:10

I was the target of two male bullies later in life. Both were too thick to realise that, although they were senior to me, they had nothing in their gift (popularity, preferment,, more seniority) nothing that I wanted.'. They gave up pretty quickly when they,eventually realised that.

Sad, sad people.

in my experience, not of course in yours, my bully wanted something. The mistake they made was in assuming I wanted the same thing was them.

ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 22:07

bakebeans · 13/10/2025 21:54

I have a strong personality.

I’m chatty and yet I’ve been bullied 3 times in my life and fought back each time.
schooL was usually a full class ganging up on me. Think of not being picked for the group.
When in work, tasks were being left for me knowing I didn’t have the taught skills ( I was new to the role) to complete the tasks or put in a situation I was forced to deal with without knowing all the information.

Each time it was systemic bullying, not direct but I was made to feel inadequate, a failure, I would make mistakes and be made to feel ashamed but crucial information had been deliberately left out or I had not been taught the correct procedure

Yes I sympathise I’ve had something similar to this in work.

2 of my colleagues forced me to deal with a difficult customer then ‘hid’

when they saw me dealing with the actual customer confidently and effectively they looked really sheepish but then stepped in to refer him to his housing officer

OP posts:
Echobelly · 13/10/2025 22:03

I was the sort of kid who was bullied, but then in my early teens I realised that it was quite easy to tell what reaction a bully wanted and to do the opposite.

Some bullies wanted to provoke a reaction - so don't react to those ones. For example there was an older boy who used to try to wind me up on the walk home and when I realised he just wanted a reaction, I ignored him. 'Grey rock' basically. Once he snatched my hair band and went dancing down the road expecting me to chase him and get upset, so I kept walking and he just looked like an idiot and had to drop the band on the floor and pretend it hadn't happened.

Other bullies want to make you feel embarrassed and awkward, for example by asking personal questions, so you slink off red-faced to avoid them. The trick is to actually answer them back and give them more detail than they want. Once some boys tried to embarrass me by asking me if I was on my period - I told them that I was and invented some graphic details so they were the ones who ran away.

Same with adults - do the opposite of what they want.

bakebeans · 13/10/2025 21:54

I have a strong personality.

I’m chatty and yet I’ve been bullied 3 times in my life and fought back each time.
schooL was usually a full class ganging up on me. Think of not being picked for the group.
When in work, tasks were being left for me knowing I didn’t have the taught skills ( I was new to the role) to complete the tasks or put in a situation I was forced to deal with without knowing all the information.

Each time it was systemic bullying, not direct but I was made to feel inadequate, a failure, I would make mistakes and be made to feel ashamed but crucial information had been deliberately left out or I had not been taught the correct procedure

ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 21:53

ShodAndShadySenators · 11/10/2025 09:07

It is probably all about confidence and self esteem - the kids with both were never bothered. It makes sense to try to ensure your child is confident and sure in themselves but it's not like an app you can install, you can do your best as a parent but find that because of other factors, your child can still be the target to those who sense someone weaker.

I think crushes on people can improve self esteem - I think there’s a biological reason for them but of course they can be destructive if they go OTT and develop into obsessions

OP posts:
ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 21:47

dizzydizzydizzy · 13/10/2025 21:44

Not being neurodivergent helps you to not be a victim of bullying.

I'm autistic. I was diagnosed in my mid 50s. The psychologists who diagnosed me said they thought I was very vulnerable to bullying because of not understanding body language, facial expressions, inferences and all sorts of other ways that people communicate. Also low self-esteem, people pleasing tendencies etc.

The worst bully I ever had was exDP. He was very good it because he is very intelligent (has a PhD). He managed to convince me that his bullying was largely my fault. So obviously that was domestic abuse.

I had low self esteem and people pleasing tendencies .. definitely!

OP posts:
dizzydizzydizzy · 13/10/2025 21:44

Not being neurodivergent helps you to not be a victim of bullying.

I'm autistic. I was diagnosed in my mid 50s. The psychologists who diagnosed me said they thought I was very vulnerable to bullying because of not understanding body language, facial expressions, inferences and all sorts of other ways that people communicate. Also low self-esteem, people pleasing tendencies etc.

The worst bully I ever had was exDP. He was very good it because he is very intelligent (has a PhD). He managed to convince me that his bullying was largely my fault. So obviously that was domestic abuse.

ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 20:46

ncnow · 13/10/2025 20:38

Bullying is an absolutely wicked thing to do. My DS was bullied at school. It's horrendous and ultimately can result in suicide.

I found that the parents of bullies either deny or condone it. Schools have absolutely no idea how to tackle it. DS was made to sit down with his bully, explain what he was doing was upsetting him and why. I mean, it should be obvious that taking someone's stuff and wrecking/binning it is upsetting them? Or calling them a fucking retard and tripping them up? Sticking pens into their body in lessons? It's obvious stuff. Yet DS was made to explain.

All it did was make the bully do it more. As it was clearly having the desired impact.

Only one thing, after several years and a growth spurt, got through to this bully and that was unfortunately my DS bashing him. My DS has never hurt anyone before or since, and this was 10 years ago now. He didn't want to do it, but was left with no options after systematic bullying. The bully moved on to other victims, continuing this shitty behaviour and destroying people's lives. When older, these new teen victims (not my DS), cornered this bully together and really beat the shit out of him - not just the one big bash like my DS did. I have to say, I was pleased and happy to hear that these kids had done this.

Society doesn't tackle bullying. It destroys people's lives. Almost all school shooters have been victims of severe bullying. When this stuff happens, people wonder why. Bullying is why, plain and simple.

Ooh yes it’s so true that almost all school shooters have been victims of bullying - often severe bullying.

Although after reading a book on the Colombine shootings in America in 1999 - actually it seemed to be that the perpetrators there weren’t as bullied as much as me or as humiliated as much as me in school just ignored and not really included more than anything. It seemed that people in school were slightly fearful of them before the shootings. So they were just left alone it seems to me more than actively bullied but I apologise if I’ve got this wrong

OP posts:
ncnow · 13/10/2025 20:38

Bullying is an absolutely wicked thing to do. My DS was bullied at school. It's horrendous and ultimately can result in suicide.

I found that the parents of bullies either deny or condone it. Schools have absolutely no idea how to tackle it. DS was made to sit down with his bully, explain what he was doing was upsetting him and why. I mean, it should be obvious that taking someone's stuff and wrecking/binning it is upsetting them? Or calling them a fucking retard and tripping them up? Sticking pens into their body in lessons? It's obvious stuff. Yet DS was made to explain.

All it did was make the bully do it more. As it was clearly having the desired impact.

Only one thing, after several years and a growth spurt, got through to this bully and that was unfortunately my DS bashing him. My DS has never hurt anyone before or since, and this was 10 years ago now. He didn't want to do it, but was left with no options after systematic bullying. The bully moved on to other victims, continuing this shitty behaviour and destroying people's lives. When older, these new teen victims (not my DS), cornered this bully together and really beat the shit out of him - not just the one big bash like my DS did. I have to say, I was pleased and happy to hear that these kids had done this.

Society doesn't tackle bullying. It destroys people's lives. Almost all school shooters have been victims of severe bullying. When this stuff happens, people wonder why. Bullying is why, plain and simple.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/10/2025 20:34

I don't agree with using violence back. I did that once and got bullied much worse for it. For years, I blamed that bully, but now I realise I could have been arrested myself for what I did.
Also, if you hit someone the same size as you, next one might be their big brother.

Being the victim of violence is better than being the victim of verbal abuse though because you can prove it. Verbal/subtle bullying can be impossible to prove. I had a workplace bully who just didn't talk to me or gave me dirty looks. i couldn't make any kind of complaint against her.

TheGrownup · 13/10/2025 20:27

Ablondiebutagoody · 09/10/2025 09:01

Bullies pick victims who they can scare, who will be too timid to fight back. They want to issue the "we'll get you after school" threat and have the kid bricking it all day long. Makes them feel good.

From a young age we have to teach DC to fight fire with fire. Don't accept that crap and be willing to use violence if they have to. The bullies just knowing that's the case changes things.

I hate all the "kind hands, tell the teacher" stuff. Doesn't work.

This is the kind of message which I would have disagreed with a few years ago but unfortunately I completely agree now. So many parents don't care that their children are bullies as long as they are not being bullied and schools hands are so tied that these kids get away with far far to much. I've told my child not to throw the first punch and always be kind as a rule but they are not required to be kind to bullies. Sometimes a smack in the chops is all that will register for them.

ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 19:37

beaniebabby · 11/10/2025 08:55

Bullies sense weakness

This, so do abusive men, muggers etc. It's how you carry yourself etc.

Fighting back isn't always the answer, more important how to learn who to stand up or to or back down & how to avoid standing out.

This is so true - it’s knowing when and who to stand up to

Aged 13 I punched someone in the face who said she’d been the ‘hardest’ girl in primary school. She started crying and I could see by her face she was scared of me. I’m ashamed of this now, not least because she wasn’t actually bullying me at the time - just interfering so I think I went overboard tbh. At this time though - I was only in my 2nd year and overall had a reasonably ‘neutral’ reputation in school - I wasn’t popular but neither was I a social pariah

However 3 years later when I was 16 I said “fuck off’ to a hard, popular girl in school cos I was putting on some daft make up and I thought she made a derogatory comment. She didn’t take this lying down and cornered me in the yard basically handing my ass to me on a plate. She said a couple of things to shame me - basically repeating some humiliating gossip that had been said about me - said I was fat and humiliated me - a boy in her gang then spat at me. I was scared. Thing is by the age of 16 my social life at school had collapsed like a load of jenga blocks and I now hung round with the social pariahs and was a real social pariah myself. I was in the last year of school - as it was the January I only had about 3 months realistically left to go cos in the last year ‘real’ school is over by Easter. So looking back in this situation I’d have been better off keeping my powder dry and ‘backing down’ - if she made a derogatory comment I should’ve just laughed along rather than saying fuck off - cos the same girl had about a year before made a point of singling me out and saying “you don’t say much do you?” to which I just smiled and laughed along then she just left it. To be fair I shouldn’t have said fuck off because this girl hadn’t bullied me - it was a one off comment cos of the make up not repeated, sustained behaviour

So I think from these examples it is
good to know when to fight and when to back down. As it happened, I wasn’t bullied in either of these situations. A LOT has to do with the alliances you’ve made and the social support you have as to how easy it is to be bullied

OP posts:
ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 17:15

Rocknrollstar · 11/10/2025 08:25

When DS was at school I asked if he was bullied and with the wisdom of a 14 year old he said ‘I’m not the sort that gets bullied’. He had a solid group of friends, wasn’t quite top of the class, played sports and was in a band. If only we could teach it or bottle it!

Am pleased for your son 😊 and I wish to be honest this couldn’t been me.

i wasn’t at school with my DP but like your son I don’t think he was the ‘type’ to be bullied.

It was a rough, working class school with atrocious results - so not an academic school at all and one where bullying and violence were rife.

However my DP had the advantage of being very physically attractive, the youngest in a large family with several ‘sensible’ older siblings, and a decent, upbeat straightforward lad who might stick up for the bullying victims if he could.

OP posts:
ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 14:37

ilovesooty · 11/10/2025 08:39

The psychology of workplace bullying is often poorly understood.

https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/Bully_in_Sight.html?id=9T9mn72jffkC&redir_esc=y

Thanks for this link 🙌

OP posts:
ClockedIt · 13/10/2025 13:40

gannett · 09/10/2025 10:09

He said “no - not exactly someone with no friends - it’s someone who is unsure”

Oh this is so perceptive. He's right, it's not about being different - it's about being insecure about your differences. That's what psychological bullies pick on - the feeling that you're the weird one and there's something wrong with you.

I didn't fit in at school - mixed-race in a rural environment, nerdy and speccy and not very socially adept. I wasn't ever bullied. I think some of the kids did try to pick on me but I didn't really pay them much attention, nor did I want them to like me, because from the age of 12 all I was thinking about was my life after school. It was easy to brush off because I was always confident that I was only weird in a good way, and it'd pay off down the line. (I was right!)

That's just psychological bullying though. Physical bullying is unfortunately more straightforward and there's not much you can do when someone who's bigger and stronger decides they're going to use that against you.

This is great actually- knowing that you’re different/ ‘weird’ but in a ‘good’ way

I was the only only child amongst my peer group, my mum was a very aspirational full time career woman which, even in middle class circles, was slightly unusual for the time. I was a loner who liked my own company as, rightly or wrongly, industries the demographic of the particular school I was in. At 13 I was happy with myself and felt confident and independent- but because my mum said I was being selfish, this ruined everything

OP posts:
blankittyblank · 12/10/2025 18:42

ClockedIt · 12/10/2025 12:32

Thanks again so much for this.

ive started watching from the beginning

i think his description about bullying being a game is correct

l I had a friend on Facebook who was very patronising. She’d also be very nosey. She was a prime example of dish it out but not take it iyswim! I think adults bully more by patronising and being deliberately intrusive than the traditional schoolyard bullying.

Anyway she’d ask where I was living and I would deliberately say a lie. If they put up photos of parks etc where I was actually living for all including her to see. She soon saw I was living in a completely different area and I wasn’t even bothering to cover my tracks! She was unhappy and put I hate liars on her Facebook page as a status but didn’t confront me directly about it.

I know the mature thing is just not playing games by lying just cut her off my Facebook !

Anyway she backed off after that and didn’t want to know me anymore. I think bullies don’t like being made a fool of. I should’ve done the mature thing and not lied but unfriended her but at least it taught me about the psychology of this type of person

Edited

It's great isn't it! Glad you liked it. It's such a clever way to deal with bullies. But ultimately, very hard to implement if your immediate and natural reaction is to be upset or defensive. Or if you're terrified of your bully. But, if we can teach our kids to approach it in a similar way, or at least talk about the theory, it might help.

HuskyNew · 12/10/2025 18:04

It’s interesting to consider what exactly is bullying? The same behaviours will be labelled it by one person but not another.

example - A girl in y7 constantly accuses the other girls of bullying. She regularly doesn’t want to go to school and cries in the playground etc.

I have witnessed first hand many incidents and I honestly do not think she is being bullied. She’s over sensitive and desperate to fit in, but goes about it in the wrong way. For example if the girls are playing football she will cry about not getting the ball. Or stand in front of the goal and then cry that the ball has hit her. Or refuse to play but then stand on the sidelines crying that she’s being “left out”. The other girls are exasperated by her behaviour, and even more so when the parents regularly complain she’s being bullied. They try their best to include her but she’s really a bit of a wet lettuce and manipulative so whatever they do risks getting twisted into a drama. I myself have assigned groups for projects and then had complains that the other groups are “leaving her out”. When of course they are not - she has a group to work with!

In my view she needs support and possibly some play therapy to learn how to make friends and join in. And some resilience that it can’t always go her way. But when that is suggested to the parents they accuse the school of cover up and being unsupportive.

HuskyNew · 12/10/2025 17:54

beaniebabby · 11/10/2025 08:55

Bullies sense weakness

This, so do abusive men, muggers etc. It's how you carry yourself etc.

Fighting back isn't always the answer, more important how to learn who to stand up or to or back down & how to avoid standing out.

This. It’s about self assurance and inner steel.

People tried to bully me. I genuinely didn’t give a shit about their opinion. Takes away their power.

My children are taught to stand up for themselves and have a healthy disregard for others views. Be true to yourself. I also talk to them a lot about the world and how adults behave (not always well) and share news and social stories about how people deal with situations in good ways and bad ways. I try and offer both sides of the stories and let them think about what they think is right and what’s best to do. I’m very open about family dynamics and how decisions in the wider family are made. Avoids them being gullible / not worldly wise which also makes an easy target.

ilovesooty · 12/10/2025 14:53

You're very welcome. I hope the book helps you as much as it's helped me. 💕

Perly · 12/10/2025 14:43

Thank you to the poster who linked to that book on workplace bullying. I was bullied by my manager to such an extent that I had significant mental health struggles and ended up resigning the job I loved (before she took charge). I do not think I was weak or insecure: on the contrary, I was well-liked by my colleagues, was good at my job, reliable and conscientious. This manager hated me for it and did everything she could to undermine me and make me feel insecure in my job when I was at my most vulnerable (eg when had health problems which temporarily impacted my job, after the death of my mother etc). I have since left that job and feel a million times better for it. I certainly did not invite her to bully me through any weakness or uncertainty in my personality. She just hated what I stood for. She was also the union rep so there was no point going down that route. Often the bullies are the weak ones in these scenarios. She must have known somewhere deep down that she was a horrible, unloveable person, but didn’t have the insight to recognise it or change it in herself.