Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carveries are the work of the devil

181 replies

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2025 21:20

DH and I decided to go to a Carvery after looking after the grandchildren,Daren earlier this evening. It’s on the way home and meant we wouldn’t get stuck in commuter traffic. I’ve not been to one for years!
The one we chose, a Toby carvery, is just next to the motorway slip road. There were about 4 cars on the car park and a couple of tables were occupied; mainly it was empty. We stood waiting for 5 minutes until someone came to see to us, asked us if we had a booking and said that as we hadn’t they couldn’t serve us as they only had enough food for the reservations they already had. It was 5.15 on a Tuesday evening!
When we walked out and sat in the car laughing, we realised we reeked of cooking fat and boiled cabbage 😳. Looking at the building we saw it was basically falling down - I think we had a lucky escape.
there was another Carvery a few 100 yards further on so we went there. No problem getting a table, no horrible smells, all looked nice and well kept. Clean toilets (very important!!). DH ordered a bean burger and chips - he’s veggie and wont touch a carvery - and I went to get my food. It wasn’t great, but wasn’t inedible - soggy veg, mushy roasts and gloopy mash, but tasty meat and gravy.
DHs on the other hand was very much inedible. A stale bun that shattered as he cut through it, a bean burger that seemed to have been stored unwrapped in the freezer for weeks so was rock hard, uncut table and certainly inedible. It was the colour of uncooked pastry! (maybe they had used butter beans). Chips were very undercooked and soggy.
I took the plate back and the staff were very apologetic, refunding the meal instantly. He ended up having cheese on toast for tea. I’m gutted - I was so looking forward to a tasty mid week meal!

OP posts:
cordeliabuffy · 07/10/2025 21:44

I go to a Stonehouse one and it’s lovely. It’s not the best meal I’ve ever had but for £6, I can’t fault it
plus I get to eat as many Yorkshires as I want!
loads of different veg too

BlueberryLatte · 07/10/2025 21:40

I have never been to one in my life. They sound pretty gross, but are you honestly surprised? Aren't they like an all you can eat roast dinner type thing? It's probably made a bit like bad cafeteria food

PurpleSky300 · 07/10/2025 21:37

I absolutely love a good carvery! Especially one with Northern gravy i.e so thick the spoon practically stands up.

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/10/2025 21:36

I’d look around for a well-reviewed gastropub which does carvery and decent veggie options. Toby Carvery markets itself as food being cheap and plentiful, rather than high quality and in lovely surroundings. There’s one I drive past occasionally which advertises carvery at £7.49 weeknights, and ultimately if you’re paying not much more than the cost of a Tesco meal deal for unlimited hot food, the place is probably going to be a bit run down and they’ll be minimising waste wherever they can by catering for as many bookings as they have. The second place probably much the same, the food will suffer if they’re trying to make it plentiful in carvery style but cheap. Price, variety, quality: pick two

CandyRuby · 07/10/2025 21:36

Erm I think you will find Toby carvery is doing £6 carvery this week so it would be fully booked, you can’t get a table at my local this week for that reason.

Brightbluesomething · 07/10/2025 21:35

Post reviews on Tripadvisor?

Swipe left for the next trending thread