Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sarah & Dean MAFS UK **No Spoilers**

64 replies

CandleMug · 05/10/2025 20:46

Just catching up when they’re at the first commitment ceremony and I feel sorry for Sarah with the way the ‘experts’ went on at her for being disrespectful etc…

I felt sorry for her during this episode as they made her feel so small for saying Dean gives her the ick with all the singing and performing but she was telling her fellow contestants. They said she was disrespectful but I think she’s just being honest as she doesn’t fancy him.

Anyone that’s seen it feel they weren’t fair on Sarah?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DrowningInSyrup · 12/10/2025 21:23

Monstermissy36 · 06/10/2025 10:45

What really annoys me is she knows her type is someone with ‘loads of tattoos and looks like they may of just got out of prison’ and it’s not gone well for her. She asked specifically to be match with someone not like that. She’s literally got what she asked for! I wish someone would remind her she said she wanted someone different to her normal type.

i hate all the face pulling etc but that is probs in the edit and he is annoying! I would hate all the rapping!! I imagine he’s awesome to have as a mate and see in small doses but living together would grate!

I have to forgive the face pulling, because I do it. It's not on purpose at all, it's just completely reactive and I can't control it.

DrowningInSyrup · 12/10/2025 21:22

soverymuchdone · 06/10/2025 01:47

I'm finding it very uncomfortable this series watching Sarah, Grace, and Leigh being pressured into intimacy with people they clearly aren't attracted to, and getting unsympathetic edits due to their reluctance to consummate the 'marriage'. It's not fair on them and it's not fair on their partners.

Yes, it's bloody weird. They do it every year. It's a step too far, way too far. Nobody should be foisted onto another, especially if it is for entertainment. It's pretty abusive pressure really and they should be called up on it.

chaosmaker · 09/10/2025 20:00

You can almost see some of the edits. Sarah didn't say anything malicious about the bloke she's stuck with. Just honest. He has been 'poor meeing' since he got there. As he said himself, when he lost weight he was horrible. Being fat will just make him horrible with added fat.
Gaslighty horror of a man and his friend was no better. Sarah's friend should have been telling her to write leave in huge block letters.
Dean should have left when she allegedly 'dissed' him the second time. Firmly team Sarah here.
JR, Leigh, Ashley and obvs the football guy are far worse.

CandleMug · 07/10/2025 06:47

Platespin · 06/10/2025 21:38

I see where you're coming from. I bet she'd been keeping everything in for a week and it all came out, albeit inappropriately at times. I do agree that we need to hold up gender comparisons but let's also not forget the rapport and false sense of security that the producers and cameramen/women build up so that when a question's asked, someone is honest rather than diplomatic. After all these people are making TV, create these traps then vilify people when they fall into them! It's very uncomfortable to watch. She's obviously been tactless and disrespectful at times but now she obviously can't express how she really feels and being is guilted into going beyond what she's comfortable with to please the experts. Being pressured into that to be seen as more accepting is plain wrong as well.

Absolutely this!

OP posts:
Platespin · 06/10/2025 21:38

I see where you're coming from. I bet she'd been keeping everything in for a week and it all came out, albeit inappropriately at times. I do agree that we need to hold up gender comparisons but let's also not forget the rapport and false sense of security that the producers and cameramen/women build up so that when a question's asked, someone is honest rather than diplomatic. After all these people are making TV, create these traps then vilify people when they fall into them! It's very uncomfortable to watch. She's obviously been tactless and disrespectful at times but now she obviously can't express how she really feels and being is guilted into going beyond what she's comfortable with to please the experts. Being pressured into that to be seen as more accepting is plain wrong as well.

CandleMug · 06/10/2025 14:44

TrixieFatell · 06/10/2025 14:38

It's how she said it. I think you're being a bit obtuse tbh.

Eh! I’m clearly not the only one that thinks she’s been received and treated harshly. It’s called having a different opinion and ours clearly differ. I could say the same about your views about being obtuse, in that you can’t at all see why the be kind shight is problematic. Poor woman is probably terrified to say anything.

Another poster felt strong enough to complain to ofcom so I’m not the only one that feels sorry for her

OP posts:
TrixieFatell · 06/10/2025 14:38

It's how she said it. I think you're being a bit obtuse tbh.

CandleMug · 06/10/2025 13:00

TrixieFatell · 06/10/2025 10:49

Honesty is "I'm just not attracted to him. I find his rapping and singing too much. Physically he isn't ticking my boxes". Sarah's approach was "he's fat, gives me the ick, he's like a care bear" to a small group that he is part of. It wasn't cool, and strayed into the territory that you say you find wrong with other couples.

If Sarah doesn't want to be in a relationship with Dean, she shouldn't feel obligated to. She should just write leave and go (don't get me started on having to stay a week after writing leave).

Thats my main point though, she didn’t say anything worse than the others (He’s too small etc…) or the way the others acted with disgust etc…it’s as if she’s been made an example of and singled out and that’s what I find off

OP posts:
Coffeetime25 · 06/10/2025 10:59

Frankblackwife · 06/10/2025 10:28

Was that the guy where she reminded him of his sister? Or was that the year before

yeah him

Nearly50omg · 06/10/2025 10:54

Why is Sarah still there if she doesn’t want to be with Dean?! 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ whole point of the show! Or is it as someone who has known her since she was in school has come out and said and she’s desperate to be an “influencer” and famous?

TrixieFatell · 06/10/2025 10:49

Honesty is "I'm just not attracted to him. I find his rapping and singing too much. Physically he isn't ticking my boxes". Sarah's approach was "he's fat, gives me the ick, he's like a care bear" to a small group that he is part of. It wasn't cool, and strayed into the territory that you say you find wrong with other couples.

If Sarah doesn't want to be in a relationship with Dean, she shouldn't feel obligated to. She should just write leave and go (don't get me started on having to stay a week after writing leave).

CandleMug · 06/10/2025 10:46

Monstermissy36 · 06/10/2025 10:45

What really annoys me is she knows her type is someone with ‘loads of tattoos and looks like they may of just got out of prison’ and it’s not gone well for her. She asked specifically to be match with someone not like that. She’s literally got what she asked for! I wish someone would remind her she said she wanted someone different to her normal type.

i hate all the face pulling etc but that is probs in the edit and he is annoying! I would hate all the rapping!! I imagine he’s awesome to have as a mate and see in small doses but living together would grate!

I agree with you especially the last bit! Fab as a mate but not a DH

OP posts:
CinnamonBuns67 · 06/10/2025 10:45

There's a difference between being honest about lack of attraction and being nasty about it she was the latter. She didn't need to make jokes and jibes about what she doesn't find attractive about him all she had to say is "He's a very nice man but personally I don't find him attractive" and left it at that. I'm glad she was held accountable for what she said.

Monstermissy36 · 06/10/2025 10:45

What really annoys me is she knows her type is someone with ‘loads of tattoos and looks like they may of just got out of prison’ and it’s not gone well for her. She asked specifically to be match with someone not like that. She’s literally got what she asked for! I wish someone would remind her she said she wanted someone different to her normal type.

i hate all the face pulling etc but that is probs in the edit and he is annoying! I would hate all the rapping!! I imagine he’s awesome to have as a mate and see in small doses but living together would grate!

CandleMug · 06/10/2025 10:43

TrixieFatell · 06/10/2025 10:31

I don't think anyone is saying she should be forced into finding someone attractive. I'm uncomfortable at the pressure people have put on them to be intimate with someone they are not physically attracted to. The intimacy task was horrible to watch. Dean isn't unattractive but he isn't her type (though why people come on this show to be matched with a new type then get annoyed when it's not the usual type they have issues with in the past is beyond me)

However to say that is the same as her slagging him off and being very unkind about his appearance is completely wrong as many have said in this thread which you have ignored. She could have easily said she wasn't attracted to him and found him too much rather than get very personal about his looks and look like a bit of a bitch. I think her frustration at not having who she wanted spilled over and didn't make her look like a nice person.

Edited

It’s not a case of ignoring it, it’s just I don’t perceive it to be as you and others have described. It’s the same every year when all the women get together and discuss the ins and outs and some are over the moon with their partners and others not so and they discuss the whys and hows. I can empathise with her for being disappointed because they want to meet their person.

I guess I was surprised, because I view it as her being honest, whereas others must view it as her being cheeky etc…

When I think of the other couples, some of the women were really unkind to the men. The woman who’s a midwife was quite directly horrible to her DH and I felt sorry fro him. The woman that went on about whether her DH was an alpha male. I found the actions of the way they acted more offensive than what Sarah said.

OP posts:
Coconutter24 · 06/10/2025 10:37

CandleMug · 06/10/2025 07:39

As other posters have pointed out, she shouldn’t feel forced to be in situations she’s not comfortable in just to keep the peace.

She shouldn’t be forced in to a situation she’s not comfortable with and she could easily say no as plenty of people on the show have had their boundaries and stuck to them. She did it because she had been called out for her awful behaviour and she wanted to show she’s not a horrible person and trying

DarkRootsBlue · 06/10/2025 10:37

She has been a bit rude about him, and she is immature with her spiel about wanting someone with tattoos. She in no way deserves all the abuse she is getting through. She is trying now to be direct but polite and try and keep some boundaries but is being hounded by the experts. And I don’t buy that Dean is a ‘nice guy’ at all, at best he is an attention seeker without a clue about women.

TrixieFatell · 06/10/2025 10:31

I don't think anyone is saying she should be forced into finding someone attractive. I'm uncomfortable at the pressure people have put on them to be intimate with someone they are not physically attracted to. The intimacy task was horrible to watch. Dean isn't unattractive but he isn't her type (though why people come on this show to be matched with a new type then get annoyed when it's not the usual type they have issues with in the past is beyond me)

However to say that is the same as her slagging him off and being very unkind about his appearance is completely wrong as many have said in this thread which you have ignored. She could have easily said she wasn't attracted to him and found him too much rather than get very personal about his looks and look like a bit of a bitch. I think her frustration at not having who she wanted spilled over and didn't make her look like a nice person.

Frankblackwife · 06/10/2025 10:28

Coffeetime25 · 06/10/2025 10:00

what was the guys name last year that got hung drawn and quartered for calling his partner fat
yet it perfectly fine for a women to fat shame as man
dont buy the double standards

Was that the guy where she reminded him of his sister? Or was that the year before

teddydaniels · 06/10/2025 10:27

Calling someone a care bear is hardly crime of the century

teddydaniels · 06/10/2025 10:27

She's being bullied on tv and these replies are awful.

I've complained to Ofcom:

The misogynistic double standards from the charlatan 'experts' in relation to Sarah is despicable. When Leah flirts with Rebecca (somebody in the competition who she sees regularly and who lives in the same apartment block) this is a-okay with the experts, yet when Sarah flirts with a gay producer (who has zero interest in women) that she saw for two seconds, she's a terrible person who is disrespecting her husband. And what's the difference in this scenario? It's that Leah has a wife and Sarah has a husband. The misogynistic double standards is despicable, not just in terms of Sarah, but in terms of how Leigh's feelings are entirely disregarded in favour of excessive himpathy for the man baby. I feel for Sarah, as Dean gives classic 'nice guy' vibes. He's also exceptionally entitled. He's forever guilt-tripping and saying, "when is my wife going to tell me she finds me attractive", as if he's entitled to attraction from her just because these charlatans thrust them together in the competition, knowing full well he's not her type. One of these days, there's going to be a really serious incident on this show, and it will be these dangerous quacks' fault for gaslighting women into staying with abusive men for the sake of some ratings.

Sarah & Dean MAFS UK **No Spoilers**
CandleMug · 06/10/2025 10:25

HugelyExpensiveCrystalDuck · 06/10/2025 10:20

Maybe Sarah thinks it’s less controversial to say that there is no spark and she likes tattoos rather than he’s an absolute dick and I can’t stand anything about him. Especially when other people are saying how lovely he is.

I’m up to the commitment ceremony now.

I bet you’re right, because everyone seems to love him and it’s fine in small doses but her experience will be different to the rest of the group as she has to spend 24/7 with him rapping and singing 🎶

OP posts:
HugelyExpensiveCrystalDuck · 06/10/2025 10:20

Maybe Sarah thinks it’s less controversial to say that there is no spark and she likes tattoos rather than he’s an absolute dick and I can’t stand anything about him. Especially when other people are saying how lovely he is.

I’m up to the commitment ceremony now.

CandleMug · 06/10/2025 10:15

Coffeetime25 · 06/10/2025 10:00

what was the guys name last year that got hung drawn and quartered for calling his partner fat
yet it perfectly fine for a women to fat shame as man
dont buy the double standards

When someone asks her why she’s not attracted to him she was honest. He asked her outright and said have you ever been with anyone bigger and she said no.

It seems to me the whole ‘be kind’ rhetoric being spouted out is toxic at times because be kind in this is basically suggesting she should pretend to fancy him because if she’s honest she’ll hurt his feelings… that’s not right.

OP posts:
Ooogle · 06/10/2025 10:07

Dean directly asked her about his weight and she answered. She definitely could have been more careful with her wording when telling her friends she isn’t physically attracted to him at the first dinner party.

however, dean is very clever with his I’m such a sweet guy act. He knows he’s going to get Sarah into trouble and immediately goes into oh it’s ok it’s not your fault so everyone thinks he’s amazing, kind and forgiving. He likes the ‘woe is me, she’s mean to me but I am so so sweet I will always have her back’ approach. I do think that last week the experts told her off as she had said too much but this week went really hard on her for telling a gay producer he looks hot. Obviously she didn’t fancy the producer who also didn’t fancy her.

I was surprised they didn’t pull dean up on his:
‘This is my wife, I can touch her whenever I want’

errr what??’