Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

11 million immigrants since 2000. When I

789 replies

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 08:40

Sorry, it’s another immigration one.

I always see immigration discussed in terms of race, religion, who may or may not be a good fit for the UK, whether it’s by small boats - to be honest, this is not the biggest worry for me.

The biggest worry is the sheer increase in our population and how many people this country can reasonably accommodate. We are now 8th in Europe for population density - only behind Belgium and the Netherlands, and a handful of places like Vatican City and the Channel Islands. At present we have net migration of around 500,000 a year.

I’m worried that the key issues of overpopulation are being overlooked to make this conversation all about race. What about our pollution levels, wildlife habitats, flood risk, food security, infrastructure? Will this eventually be a polluted city state country? It seems to be heading that way.

Posters always say we need immigration, but we have already welcome 11 million since 2000. If that still isn’t enough; what is? Or do we just keep going?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:12

CatchingtheCat · 04/10/2025 09:10

Now look at population density for England. The Scottish highlands distort the figures.

It’s such a worry isn’t it.

People seem to think a garden and local park is enough, they have no clue about our farming needs and the impact of this on our wildlife

OP posts:
NotMeNoNo · 04/10/2025 09:11

If you look at the population pyramid, it's actually older age groups who are increasing the numbers. Immigrants are almost all working age and necessarily filling the gap. The vast majority are either students or people who are working in your local hospital or hotel or construction site and doing valuable jobs.

11 million immigrants since 2000. When I
BallerinaRadio · 04/10/2025 09:11

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:09

Please say why? And produce your own figure, to prove me wrong.

I don't know the figure. But I'm not the one claiming my "easily worked out" figure is a fact. Just because I don't know (a brief Google suggests you're wrong from multiple sources) it doesn't make your figure true FFS 😂

Livelovebehappy · 04/10/2025 09:11

EasternStandard · 04/10/2025 09:07

AI will change things. It’s a bit of a Ponzi scheme otherwise, how do you get out of the we need to increase as they age issue? It’s very difficult but AI removing jobs might be the new issue.

Absolutely. It’s happening in plain sight, and I think it’s going to be the ‘new’ problem the government are going to have to address. My industry is being hugely compromised by AI. From advertising many roles several years ago, we’re now adverting nothing. Voluntary redundancies are no more. Now it’s compulsory ones.

MaturingCheeseball · 04/10/2025 09:11

YellowTigerTail · 04/10/2025 08:51

My view is that we have an aging population, and over the coming decades, immigration is the only way we will be able to get enough young people into the country to do all the jobs required to support the economy and keep the pensions going for the huge numbers of OAPs.

Also in terms of population density, the vast vast majority of this country is countryside and not built up. It's hard to believe when you are in a big city. I believe there a a few new towns being built here and there and I imagine that will continue

Edited

O you honestly believe that all these “extra” people are going to be working? What jobs? NHS? Women from certain communities do not work, neither do their daughters. And the men certainly won’t be wiping bums in care homes. Also everyone grows old. The problem of pensions/care doesn’t end when the current horrid old waste-of-space boomers have popped their clogs (others’ opinion of them)

As for the countryside… er, farming? Food? Much of it moorland, mountainous, hard rock, marshy… And if you build over, say, Wiltshire, where are people going to work? Are they all just going to sit in new-builds claiming benefits?

thedramaQueen · 04/10/2025 09:11

NototerrorismIntheUK · 04/10/2025 09:04

I agree partly. The previous 14 years of Tory government didn't help with services. However, bringing more people in wont help either until housing, services, health etc can cope.

Even if immigration was stopped tomorrow people are still going to be angry until this is sorted, only at the moment they have a perceived acceptable source to blame. And in fact they might get more annoyed when they find there is no one to do the jobs in the NHS and caring services.

It really does annoy me how all our problems are blamed on immigrants rather than successive governments failures..

ilovesooty · 04/10/2025 09:10

The world is changing and population is shifting. Where would you like potential immigrants to the UK to go instead?

CatchingtheCat · 04/10/2025 09:10

fizzyroselemonade · 04/10/2025 08:42

ranked 8th for population density in Europe does not automatically translate to overpopulation

Now look at population density for England. The Scottish highlands distort the figures.

Harriet9955 · 04/10/2025 09:09

Canle1905 · 04/10/2025 08:50

Do you have any option on the home countries of these immigrants. Recently I am hearing of more people coming here from SA, USA and Australia. In all cases they are coming here for health care reasons. They often are one UK citizen who moved abroad more than 30 years ago but now have an ailing spouse and want access to NHS. In some cases adult children who have UK passports but have never contributed to this country are coming with their parent. I honestly have no idea what these people can access once here and would like to know. However in all situations their biggest financial concern is how to avoid paying tax on assets or pensions.

I see this a lot with older people in my line of work ( benefits). They've been in living in Spain for years then start getting health problems so come home. Invariably house prices have risen hugely in the years they've been away and they can't buy so looking for housing, housing benefits etc. I guess they've often paid taxes here for many years though so not like they haven't contributed.
The situation ( that I also see a lot) that makes me most annoyed though is elderly unwell men in their sixties and seventies bringing over young wives ( often in their 20's) form India and Pakistan to be their carers. These young women can't work, and whilst they can't get benefits until they get indefinite leave to remain, the husband can still start claiming benefits for the kids. They always seem able to father a couple of kids with this new wife whilst being disabled enough to need a carer. The women are stuck with not much english and unable to work. If the husband dies they have very limited language and job opportunities.

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:09

BallerinaRadio · 04/10/2025 09:08

As suspected, absolute horseshit

Please say why? And produce your own figure, to prove me wrong.

OP posts:
BallerinaRadio · 04/10/2025 09:08

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:07

https://fullfact.org/immigration/net-migration-to-the-uk/

If you look at the chart, immigration has been a minimum of net 100,000 since the early 90s, and peaked in the late 2010s with net going up to 800,000 or 900,000. In that time our population has grown by 11 million people, but British citizens haven’t been having children at a rate to sustain the population in years. No one source will give you the figure but you can easily work it out. If you produce a different number I would be interested to see it?

As suspected, absolute horseshit

orangessquashed · 04/10/2025 09:08

My bigger concern is that with the amount of men coming here, men will seriously outnumber women for an entire generation and what impact will that have?

EasternStandard · 04/10/2025 09:07

Livelovebehappy · 04/10/2025 09:03

It needs to slow down hugely, if only to anticipate the effect AI is going to have on employmen5 within the coming years. We’re already seeing many industries affected by AI, and it makes sense that a lot of people here are going to need to retrain. Possibly taking the roles in social care which people say need filling. If we’re not careful, unemployment is going to be a major issue where we have too many people chasing too few jobs. It’s already happening. I’m seeing more and more people struggling to get work in their chosen profession because of AI and offshored work. The government need to be anticipating this very real situation, and plan ahead accordingly.

AI will change things. It’s a bit of a Ponzi scheme otherwise, how do you get out of the we need to increase as they age issue? It’s very difficult but AI removing jobs might be the new issue.

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:07

And yes I checked FullFact and ONS as I know websites like Migrationwatch can be misleading and use disinformation.

OP posts:
Livelovebehappy · 04/10/2025 09:07

LadyKenya · 04/10/2025 09:04

They cannot back up their wilful lies, that is why. Honestly there are some really hateful people out there.

People on here are trying to debate rationally. If you can’t do that, and don’t like the post, just scroll on by. You do know it’s not compulsory to comment on posts if you have nothing to contribute?

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:07

https://fullfact.org/immigration/net-migration-to-the-uk/

If you look at the chart, immigration has been a minimum of net 100,000 since the early 90s, and peaked in the late 2010s with net going up to 800,000 or 900,000. In that time our population has grown by 11 million people, but British citizens haven’t been having children at a rate to sustain the population in years. No one source will give you the figure but you can easily work it out. If you produce a different number I would be interested to see it?

How many migrants come to the UK? – Full Fact

A guide to understanding migration trends and the statistics behind one of the most debated topics in UK politics.

https://fullfact.org/immigration/net-migration-to-the-uk/

OP posts:
BallerinaRadio · 04/10/2025 09:07

NototerrorismIntheUK · 04/10/2025 09:02

Surely its a concern expressed by many. Don't you watch the news?

Free speech not allowed? Say why you think @Uggbootsforever is incorrect rather than shut down conversation.

Free speech is allowed. But if you say bullshit then expect to be called bullshit on it.

Fwiw I disagree because that is a fake number probably designed to get people frothing and that is why I'm reporting unless I get a source. Nothing to do with 'free speech'

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:04

LadyKenya · 04/10/2025 09:04

They cannot back up their wilful lies, that is why. Honestly there are some really hateful people out there.

Can you quote what I have said that is ‘hateful’? Or is anything less than open borders and a gag on anyone saying the I-word ‘hateful’?

OP posts:
NototerrorismIntheUK · 04/10/2025 09:04

thedramaQueen · 04/10/2025 09:01

The thing is I don't actually care about the numbers, to me it's irrelevant. What matters is the infrastructure - having doctors, schools, housing and jobs available for everyone. The fact is governments over and over have failed to make sure this happens for everyone - so people blame a what they see as a acceptable source, immigrants, rather than the governments who have screwed this up time and time again. I'm fed up of people and governments not seeing this.

I agree partly. The previous 14 years of Tory government didn't help with services. However, bringing more people in wont help either until housing, services, health etc can cope.

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:04

Livelovebehappy · 04/10/2025 09:03

It needs to slow down hugely, if only to anticipate the effect AI is going to have on employmen5 within the coming years. We’re already seeing many industries affected by AI, and it makes sense that a lot of people here are going to need to retrain. Possibly taking the roles in social care which people say need filling. If we’re not careful, unemployment is going to be a major issue where we have too many people chasing too few jobs. It’s already happening. I’m seeing more and more people struggling to get work in their chosen profession because of AI and offshored work. The government need to be anticipating this very real situation, and plan ahead accordingly.

AI is another good point. It seems to have suddenly taken off in a way it didn’t pre Covid.

OP posts:
LadyKenya · 04/10/2025 09:04

FreeTheOakTree · 04/10/2025 09:02

You seem to be awfully consumed by this subject OP.

Starting yet another thread without a credible link though?

It isn't on us to go searching to back up your claims.

They cannot back up their wilful lies, that is why. Honestly there are some really hateful people out there.

BallerinaRadio · 04/10/2025 09:04

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:02

Why is it rage bait? There’s a lot of race immigration posts, this one isn’t one of them. It’s about the practical implications of immigration, not the immigrants themselves. If that’s ’rage bait’ and you feel we shouldn’t be able to discuss it, that says more about you.

Hi again 👋🏻

Source for the 11 million immigrants?

Notonthestairs · 04/10/2025 09:03

thedramaQueen · 04/10/2025 09:01

The thing is I don't actually care about the numbers, to me it's irrelevant. What matters is the infrastructure - having doctors, schools, housing and jobs available for everyone. The fact is governments over and over have failed to make sure this happens for everyone - so people blame a what they see as a acceptable source, immigrants, rather than the governments who have screwed this up time and time again. I'm fed up of people and governments not seeing this.

Absolutely - it’s the government’s role to ensure that the necessary infrastructure is in place. They haven’t.

(IMO they spent too much in wars (Blair) and internal nonsense (Brexit))

Yamamm · 04/10/2025 09:03

Inward migration has accounted for 98% of the population increase since 2000.
Agree that the demographic for inward migration needs to be factored in to policy and planning. We need young working people and children and definitely don’t need more pensioners to support.
Anyway. When you consider that there really isn’t infrastructure planning to absorb the population increase then virtually everyone can agree it’s a problem.
Housing! My town is building 5500 new homes. Mostly small flats. It’s a massive project and changing the town. Also represents a tiny tiny fraction of the population increase. We can’t keep up. We need a break to absorb all these people. It’s virtually impossible to remove them once they’re here so pause immigration as much as possible. Invest in those already here and building what we need for them.
Wont happen. It will carry on increasing until the UK and similar countries offer nothing more than where people are migrating from. Which is bad for our countries.

Uggbootsforever · 04/10/2025 09:03

FreeTheOakTree · 04/10/2025 09:02

You seem to be awfully consumed by this subject OP.

Starting yet another thread without a credible link though?

It isn't on us to go searching to back up your claims.

I have never started a thread about immigration before? I have posted on CITME.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread