Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hybrid is now 4 days no flexibility

221 replies

Abby23 · 01/10/2025 06:40

The US multinational I work for has mandated all UK employees back to the office for at least 4 days a week. It was 3 days before. I’m gutted. I took this job 3 years ago having moved from my previous role that was 2 days hybrid. I’d been there for over 10 years.
My commute is 2 hours into Canary Wharf (ie 4 hours round trip minimum). The cost is another matter but that’s ok. I’m a single parent with a young teenager I have to leave at home at 6am when I leave for work, I’m not back till at least 7 pm. She makes her way to/from school but I feel so guilty. I get home and I’m exhausted. BTW, my teenager is going through an AdHd/autism assessment and does not particularly like school. Her behaviour can best be described as challenging.
Has anyone had to deal with this transition?. If so, did you embrace it?. I have asked my boss if I can apply for an exemption so I continue doing 3 days in the office due to my commute plus family commitments. Still awaiting a response,
I don’t want to sound precious because most people did 5 days in the office before Covid. But, I do feel so deflated and stressed about it as I really love my job. Unfortunately, I’m seriously thinking of looking elsewhere.
I do wonder if some companies do this to reduce staff numbers. We have just concluded a huge restructure..
would be grateful to hear people’ s comments.
thank you

AIBU to feel deflated?

OP posts:
Shineonyoucrazydiamond1 · 01/10/2025 11:48

Don't be deflated- just do what you can about it- ie put in a formal flexible working request, and then do something about the things you can control- contact your previous employer to see if they have any opportunities, look for a job closer to home or with more flexibility that will enable you to be there for your daughter. Yes it's gutting having only moved jobs a few years ago, but life's not a straight road- things change and don't always pan out the way we expect and we need to change with them...

PaellaPan · 01/10/2025 11:39

What does your contract say?

I work for a US company who have also mandates return to office policies round most of the world where they can, following the number of people who quietly moved further away or stayed WFH post COVID.

My contract is home based full time, following a flexible working request a decade ago. I am still home based. No one has made any attempt to get me back to the office. They would have to change my contract to make it happen, and prove my job has changed. Oddly, I am in a position where the office has moved, and is now much closer to home, so I could go back in, but my role is global so makes no odds where I am physically sitting.

TwistedWonder · 01/10/2025 11:33

JustMyView13 · 01/10/2025 11:29

I’ll refrain from guessing the age and gender of the CEO 🫠

American male late 40’s lives in Caribbean - was you close?

Sunshineandoranges · 01/10/2025 11:32

nomas · 01/10/2025 06:45

The problem is that some employees ruin a good thing for everyone else by either

  • refusing to coming in to the office at all
  • refusing to come in to the office the mandated 3 days per week
  • lowering their productivity significantly on their days at home

Ideally employers would just sack the above and keep it at 3 days for everyone else.

And yes, they do use the 4 days mandate as a tactic to weed out the non-attenders.

So true.

JustMyView13 · 01/10/2025 11:29

TwistedWonder · 01/10/2025 10:44

Our head of HR raised with the board what the impact would be but she was brushed off. And she was 100% correct.

We've had several roles advertised for months now and absolutely no one wants to apply once they find out it’s 5 days in office. One senior role has been offered to 3 candidates and they’ve all pulled out when they realise there’s no flexibility but the board won’t budge.
The CEO isn’t in the UK and just refuses to take any constructive feedback onboard

I’ll refrain from guessing the age and gender of the CEO 🫠

AmIHumanOrAmIAYeti · 01/10/2025 11:26

I have an AuDHD teen daughter, OP. I get the challenges.

Starlin · 01/10/2025 11:25

I've seen this a lot lately (similar industry but as consultant). It's gone from 1-2days onsite to 3-4 with no discussion or conversation. Just orders.

AmIHumanOrAmIAYeti · 01/10/2025 11:24

It’s worth putting a flexible work request in and including that you have some protection as the parent of a disabled child under the Equality Act 2010……..

workingfamilies.org.uk/articles/flexible-working-for-parents-and-carers-of-disabled-children/

Wexone · 01/10/2025 11:20

TwistedWonder · 01/10/2025 10:44

Our head of HR raised with the board what the impact would be but she was brushed off. And she was 100% correct.

We've had several roles advertised for months now and absolutely no one wants to apply once they find out it’s 5 days in office. One senior role has been offered to 3 candidates and they’ve all pulled out when they realise there’s no flexibility but the board won’t budge.
The CEO isn’t in the UK and just refuses to take any constructive feedback onboard

This has exactly happened in my friends company, the are so stuck for staff now they are using agency staff, but the agency staff are allowed to WHF more than the staff employed directly. Its the only way they can get staff. Agency staff are being offered contracts direct with the company then but they are rejecting it due to the Hybrid/WFH policy. Management are not listening
@allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld my commute is now a 4 hour round trip commute, but it wasn't when i started 6 years ago, you could do it in an hour each way. The traffic has doubled now on the roads i use, the parts where i knew traffic was going to start building up has now moved further down, the short cuts i used now have lots of housing estates built along them, the industrial estate i work in has also expanded so more people going into it . They have also put in cycle routes, added more bus lanes therefore reducing the width of the roads for cars and some places we had two lanes is now one lane. Plus there is no good time anymore to travel, it takes 2 hours regardless if you leave at 6am or 8am . There no quiet time

TomorrowisThursday · 01/10/2025 11:19

Relocate

AncoraAmarena · 01/10/2025 11:19

Sassylovesbooks · 01/10/2025 11:00

My husband went for a job interview a few years ago. He was told he'd be able to work fully remotely from home, and attend his base site office in Wiltshire once a month (for context we live in Dorset). He was unsure about the job, and as it happened he didn't get the role. It was about a year or so later, the company mandated all employees had to work 5 days per week in the office! He was very glad, he didn't get the role, as the journey would have been horrendous. My point is, all companies can turn around and increase the number of days in the office. It's the danger of taking a role, where your base site is a long distance from where you live. You've put in a request to stay going into the office 3 days per week, rather than the required 4. All you can do is see what they say. I'd highly recommend finding a new job. The reasons behind the new mandate are irrelevant really, it's been asked, and that's it.

An employer can't just turn around and mandate/make changes if the working pattern or location is contractual. They would have to go through a consultation process first.

@Abby23 have you put in a formal flexible working request? If not then do so as it can only be turned down for one of the eight formal reasons. If you've done that already then good luck with the outcome.

Antimimisti · 01/10/2025 11:18

You need to stress that you are a carer for a disabled child in your application for flexible working.

Newbutoldfather · 01/10/2025 11:18

I think you are being very self indulgent here.

You have to realise that you have a lot of choices that others don’t and a lot to be grateful for.

You can suck it up.

You can move house closer to work. You may need to downsize a bit and your child change schools, but lots of people do it all the time.

You can look for another job with more flexibility, but maybe less pay and fewer benefits.

What you want is the best of all worlds and you have to accept that won’t happen. I do understand that we all get used to the status quo and anything that makes it worse is annoying or depressing. But, as a highly successful and well remunerated person, you also need resilience and flexibility.

PeachySmile2 · 01/10/2025 11:17

My workplace allows 2 days in the office. I could handle 3 but if they upped it to 4, there is no way I’d stay. Plenty of other businesses still offer the original 1/2 days in the office policy.

BuildbyNumbere · 01/10/2025 11:13

Put in a request for flexible working and if that’s denied look elsewhere. Two hours each way is far too much, I said no to that commute doing 3 days with my current company.

Tryingatleast · 01/10/2025 11:05

I suppose this comes down to if you look at the cost of commuting does your job still pay enough for you and your daughter to maintain whatever lifestyle you have/ want? Are jobs tough to find in your sector or alternatively could you move?

Littlemisscapable · 01/10/2025 11:01

Could you reduce hours to 4 days. Or even fewer days and job share? At least you would have the security and benefits and some of salary. I would be reluctant to give that up but it's so difficult balancing both.. and that is a serious commute and you are far from your dc. It's hard.

Sassylovesbooks · 01/10/2025 11:00

My husband went for a job interview a few years ago. He was told he'd be able to work fully remotely from home, and attend his base site office in Wiltshire once a month (for context we live in Dorset). He was unsure about the job, and as it happened he didn't get the role. It was about a year or so later, the company mandated all employees had to work 5 days per week in the office! He was very glad, he didn't get the role, as the journey would have been horrendous. My point is, all companies can turn around and increase the number of days in the office. It's the danger of taking a role, where your base site is a long distance from where you live. You've put in a request to stay going into the office 3 days per week, rather than the required 4. All you can do is see what they say. I'd highly recommend finding a new job. The reasons behind the new mandate are irrelevant really, it's been asked, and that's it.

Abby23 · 01/10/2025 10:56

@SummerInSun yes I work in finance. Reasonably senior professional and well paid with excellent benefits which I will struggle to find else where.

if I was not a mom, I would get on with it without mention. But I do feel I’m being a horrible parent considering my child’s potential issues.

money is not everything I know but I have bills to pay and a lifestyle to maintain.

i am truly fed up. I feel like I’m slowly drifting into depression. I need help!

OP posts:
PurpleThistle7 · 01/10/2025 10:54

I'm sorry this is happening but I don't think you'll get any sort of flex because of your commute - people choose where to live and where to work and this is up to you. You can move one or the other if it doesn't work. If your teenager isn't happy in school and you don't have any local help then could you move?

My only query is about them 'promising' you something in interview. Is it part of your contract? We don't promise anything about hybrid working in interview and it's non contractual. But if you have something in writing you might have a case.

user1492757084 · 01/10/2025 10:52

If you love your job, move house.
Your daughter will appreciate more of your time.

Iamnotalemming · 01/10/2025 10:50

It's sadly becoming normal. I read an interesting post from a recruiter on LinkedIn recently about how they had put together a shortlist of 10 men for a senior role. It involved 5 days a week in the office plus regular international travel. They were criticised by the employer for not having any women on the list, but they explained that they had in the first sift had roughly equal numbers of male and female candidates, and in the shortlist process, ALL of the women had pulled out themselves due to the lack of flexibility in the role. It really resonated with me. I worry that the experience of Covid and then then hard swing back we have seen since is going to impact women in the workplace significantly.

Lovemycat2023 · 01/10/2025 10:48

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 01/10/2025 10:22

@Abby23 sorry but why would anyone even consider taking a job which involved a 4 hour round trip in the first place?? I personally do not think anyone should still be working from home! I know I will get shot down for this!

It’s not unusual when commuting into London because most people have a drive to the station, and then train, and then tube / bus / walk the other end. It’s not about the distance, more than the transport isn’t joined up. If I was driving the same distance it would have been half the time. I was lucky that my commute in could be shorter than that if the buses and tubes all aligned. I wouldn’t chose to do it now, but then I don’t work in a London-centric industry.

Lovemycat2023 · 01/10/2025 10:45

I don’t think this is a wfh v office debate, it’s about expectations and the fact they said 3 days at interview really means they should stick to that. I would remind them of that OP.

marshmallowmix · 01/10/2025 10:45

I've noticed it is even moving towards 5, which doesn't work for me.

Yesterday I'd 2 calls about jobs and both wanted 5 days in the office.

Swipe left for the next trending thread