End to the genocide in Palestine?

Does anyone honestly think this peace deal will work? Letting Trump head up the group running Gaza? Expecting Hamas to hand over all weapons and hostages before Israel does anything, even allows aid in?

I don't think it's realistic, of intended to work. I think they will use it's failure to justify their genocide.

I think people often forget what happened to the Jews, and not that long ago either.

Hitler and his murderous regime killed a THIRD of ALL JEWS in the most barbaric and inhumane ways possible. Six million people, gassed, shot, starved, brutalised. Tiny children wrenched from their parents’ arms, never to see them again. Families separated, to be sent to work to death or just murdered immediately. Can you even imagine this being the end of your beautiful child’s life? The last thing you see of them, crying and being dragged away with no idea what would happen to them after that? Knowing they would likely be gassed to death surrounded by strangers.

They have, understandably, been left with a fuck ton of intergenerational trauma and mental scars which most of us are lucky enough to never experience.

I’m not excusing the genocide in Gaza (and yes, that’s what it is), but Jewish people have been under constant attack for a century. People think they don’t deserve 1 small piece of land to call their own, finally a home they can defend and not be dispersed across the world, at mercy of whatever regime they end up in.

I won’t apologise for feeling very protective of Jewish people, who in the UK show impeccable British values and law abiding morals, and for taking a very dim view of people who think they deserve further instability and that ‘Zionism’ is a dirty word.

He is, heck Hamas were in Qatar discussing one of his proposals when Israel attacked them and derailed the discussions.

Qatar and some other regional countries have been playing intermediary in negotiations.

There's no proof at all Israel attacked the flotilla. I'm sure Greta and her pals would have loved it if Israel was vehinf it but it wasn't a military grade drone, just a bog standard one available to anyone

https://www.france24.com/en/middle-east/20250909-gaza-flotilla-drone-attack-expert-analysis-greta-thunberg

Easy to say whilst you’re safe in the UK and your family aren’t being used as human shields by Hamas.

'Pro'-Palestinians are never that pro Palestinian. The poor Palestinians are just cannon fodder for them so they are free to criticise Israel. One of Hamas' leaders said on tv they're a nation of martyrs, I guess their supporters in the West see them in the same way.

Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib (a Gazan) on X and Facebook has been very vocal about how western supporters do more harm than good to the Palestinian cause

You’re laughing at how shit Trump is yet no one else is doing anything to try to end the situation. It’s interesting how people like you can’t put your hatred for Trump aside over common sense.

Irrespective of if you like or hate him we should all be rooting this to work for the sake of peace but your need to make snarky comments is priority. The ball is now in Hamas’s court and I do hope they can reach a deal not because I like or hate Trump but because peace in the region is a good thing for the world.

What about Israel attacking the flotilla with drones IN INTERNATIONAL WATERS? is that just okay with you all too? You make me sick.

I really hope this is in good faith.

Also stopping aid into Gaza for the citizens that are dying in the thousands, is that not a war crime? No?

You want more Palestinians to die so you can have the luxury of seeing Israel ‘held accountable’ (aka more war with no result)?

Can you explain who exactly has expressed support for terrorists on this thread?

nobody agrees with 7th october, but to actively starve out & bomb the citizens of Gaza full well knowing that HAMAS was not in those buildings isnt terroism no?

Unfortunately, and unsurprisingly, they pop up in every thread on Israel or Gaza. The worst of their comments usually get deleted by MN HQ, some of the things I've seen said on here have been jaw dropping. I think people belong to vile little bubbles and don't realise when they speak outside of those dark little corners that normal people are repulsed by them

OP have you been drinking?

Israel has already agreed to the plan, including opposition ministers. I think it looks very promising

Both sides have form for intransigence mainly.

I feel the same. Really shocked to see support for terrorists in here.

Corbyn had the brass neck to say ‘the events of October 7th have lead to more public support for Palestinians’

‘Events’ 🙄

How the hell are you extrapolating this view from this discussion?

Do you think there's a chance this deal won't achieve that? If not, why?

Well yes, which is why it's an important topic to discuss. Everyone wants peace for the sake of ordinary people on both sides, whether the politicians involved can achieve that via this deal is surely up for debate?

I'm firmly in the "I'll believe it when I see it" camp.

I'm so shocked to see so many terrorist supporters here. Have you blanked out what they did on 7th October?

And if Hamas can't/won't comply then the war will continue and that will be on them

Why would they have an issue with any of this?

20 key points from the Trump-Netanyahu meeting

1. Gaza to be a deradicalised terror-free zone
2. Gaza to be redeveloped for the benefit of the people of Gaza
3. Immediate end to war, if both sides agree
4. Within 72 hours of Israel publicly accepting agreement, all Hamas-held hostages to be returned
5. Once all hostages released, Israel to return 250 life sentence prisoners plus 1,700 detained Gazans
6. Hamas members who commit to peaceful co-existence and decommissioning weapons to be given amnesty. Members of Hamas who wish to leave Gaza provided with safe passage
7. If deal agreed, full aid to be be immediately sent into the Gaza Strip
8. Entry of distribution and aid in Gaza to proceed without interference from the two parties
9. Gaza to be governed under temporary governance committee. The committee will be made up of qualified Palestinians and international experts, chaired by President Trump alongside others including Sir Tony Blair