Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that estrangement doesn’t automatically mean I’m broken or doomed in life?

57 replies

EstrangedNotBroken · 29/09/2025 11:19

I’m 31 and estranged from my family. It wasn’t a decision I made lightly, it came after years of hurt and it’s something I’ve processed deeply, including with professional help.

A friend recently said this to me: “You are never going to live a fulfilling life when you hate a parent. You’re just not unfortunately. I wish it was different because there are some parents that are unloveable. But the reality is we can’t be whole without the two people that birthed us… try and create some connection if you can, even if it’s at arm’s length. Do it for you. Because all that anxiety, depression, coping mechanisms - they come from not feeling loved by the people who birthed you.”

She also added that women in my situation usually end up with narcissistic exes or have “broken” love lives and said she hopes I’m able to set the same boundaries with men in my life as I do with my father. 😬

It rubbed me the wrong way. I get that some people believe reconnection is healing but isn’t it incredibly reductive to assume that every estranged person is emotionally damaged or incapable of healthy relationships?

AIBU to think you can live a fulfilling, emotionally rich, peaceful life, even if you’re estranged from family?

OP posts:
Mistyglade · 29/09/2025 11:32

If I had continued to try pursuing a relationship with the people who birthed me I’d have committed suicide years ago. Your friend is an ignorant dick and I’ve held my tongue there.

MauriceTheMussel · 29/09/2025 11:29

Your friend is a mega twat.

She might have a point about how carrying hate isn’t helpful, and I would agree that cool indifference towards your estranged parents is better for you. BUT that doesn’t mean you have to have any relationship with them whatsoever, just that active hatred just harms oneself rather than the other party.

Supporterofwomensrights · 29/09/2025 11:26

I suspect the estrangement will always hurt a little, even if you're just mourning the people they are not.

But I also predict that you'll live an unfulfilling life with friends like that!

km21 · 29/09/2025 11:25

Absolutely you can. Someone close to me suffered huge mental health issues due to toxic parents. They cut ties some years ago and are now living their best life having realised they are not the worthless loser they were constantly told they were.

LeavesTrees · 29/09/2025 11:24

Your friend sounds like she should be cut off too. She sounds a cow. Nothing she said was helpful or constructive or supportive, she just cut you down and made you feel doomed for life.

I think you carry wounds that are hard to heal (I’m NC), but I think it is possible to rebuild a life and make connections, you just end up more selective, which is probably a good thing!

GarlicBreadStan · 29/09/2025 11:23

Of course you can live a fulfilled, happy life while being estranged from family. In some circumstances, that's the ONLY way to have a fulfilled, happy life. YANBU

TheShadowOfTheWizard · 29/09/2025 11:22

Your friend is a bit of a dick, should keep opinions to themselves really.