Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so upset and betrayed

65 replies

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 08:43

My husband was diagnosed with cancer at the end of July. We told some trusted friends (friends we’ve known since he was 16 and I was 18 and we’re almost 40 now) with strict wishes not to tell anyone else as we were in shock and so much to process. He had the affected organ removed in the second week of September. We have two young children who know daddy had a poorly organ and needed an operation to remove it. We didn’t mention cancer as our 8 year old understands what it is and there’s a slim chance my husband may not need further treatment. We wanted to hold off having that difficult conversation if it may not be needed. We won’t find out pathology for 6-8 weeks and until the tumour is finally graded and the suspected lymph nodes biopsied.

The issue - the friends we told, who have been great with childcare, emotional support and bringing food etc chose to tell their sister (and dad, so the family has discussed it and they are a close family who hang out all the time). The sister’s kid is best friends with our 8 year old - they hang out every day in school and sit on the same table. We are worried kids may overhear things and then pass things to ours when we are not ready to tell them.

I guess I am hurt and pissed off they told their sister when we specifically told them not to. They asked a couple of times if they wanted us to tell people (close mutual friends) and we repeatedly said no. They said they wouldn’t.

My husband was not ready to tell a lot of people - it’s been such a rollercoaster since finding out to trying to understand staging and grading and different opinions from surgeons and oncology. We’ve gone from it’s not curable, only treatable, to it may be curative to remove the organ, let’s have the surgery and see. We’ve been navigating summer holidays and managing our emotions without it affecting our children, who are our biggest concern. We desperately don’t want to cast a dark shadow over them and their childhood when 6 weeks since diagnosis, there’s a small chance this surgery may be curative. We will have the conversation with them and I think that’s what’s so upsetting, feeling forced to have that chat with our children before we wanted to. Terrified they’ll hear something from someone at school and we will then lose trust between us and create other issues.

Our deepest darkest moments feel like gossip they’ve shared. The friend and her sister’s mum also had cancer of the same organ so it’s a trauma that will bring up bad memories for our friend but we very clearly stated we didn’t want anyone else knowing. The friend could have talked to her partner about it, it wasn’t as she didn’t have anyone to talk to.

We feel upset and disrespected and almost now forced into telling and worrying our kids to protect them from hearing anything on the playground they weren’t prepared to hear.

I know they’re capable of keeping medical things private - they kept a close mutual friend’s fertility issues to themselves for years. I have no issue that this mutual friend didn’t want to share with me - I’m old enough to respect people’s wishes and understand that I’ll know if I’m supposed to. (I know now because this mutual friend has now told me btw and yay, she now has a beautiful baby). So I feel even more upset they’ve been so loosey goosey with us.

What do I do? Confront them?

Sorry this post is so long and rambling, I’ve been quite upset by it and slept on it, and still feel so angry. Why do we have this on top of everything else, feel like I can’t trust people we love and relied on.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 22:05

Dweetfidilove · 20/09/2025 19:10

It's an unfortunate way to find out they can't be trusted with a secret, but that seems to be the way now. Everyone needs to be centred and supported to deal with news, which means your business becomes public consumption.

It’s the feeling of being open to dissection that also hurts.

OP posts:
SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 22:04

FrondsofFriday · 20/09/2025 16:46

Hello OP.

My husband also has cancer, so your post struck a chord with me.

There is so much that is out of our control on this path. So so much. It’s easy to hyper fixate on controlling the elements we think we can, and get angry and upset when even those don’t stay under our control. And there will be many, MANY times when individuals or institutions feel like they’ve in some way failed you along this journey- believe me.

These people love you, and they are proving themselves to be good friends to you. I think long term you and your husband are far better served by accepting that they’ve messed up, that they didn’t mean to hurt you, that this is not a betrayal or anything to do with what you are both worth- it’s just fallible humans navigating a complex situation.

Wishing your husband well x

I’m sorry you’re going through it as well. I’m sorry for anyone affected by this kind of situation and pain. Thinking of you x

OP posts:
Dweetfidilove · 20/09/2025 19:10

It's an unfortunate way to find out they can't be trusted with a secret, but that seems to be the way now. Everyone needs to be centred and supported to deal with news, which means your business becomes public consumption.

Nanny0gg · 20/09/2025 19:04

If someone comes to you with some devastating (for them) information and ask you to keep it to yourself, please tell them that you're not going to be able to keep quiet.

Let them be aware that you're not the friend they thought you were

And no, all the help in the world doesn't excuse it

Nanny0gg · 20/09/2025 19:01

CeciliaMars · 20/09/2025 09:07

You felt the need to share the news so you could access some support - maybe she felt the same way?

I'm not sure her need for support is on quite the same level...

TallulahLikesHoola · 20/09/2025 18:58

Espressosummer · 20/09/2025 16:34

This feels very dramatic. The friends made a mistake, they have not been "unspeakably awful". They have done a lot for the OP and her husband.

Edited

Agree, I am assuming @SVDW1136 that you are no longer accepting any of the help and support given your level of distrust in them?

Hankunamatata · 20/09/2025 18:10

Also the children dont know, you aren't forced to tell them. Your making some assumptions
I wouldnt do messages or anything like that as I dont think friendship would recover.
You can have a face to face chat and say you are concerned that their family know and your extremely worried now the kids will find out and its added a later of stress to a stressful situation. See what your friend says

Hankunamatata · 20/09/2025 18:04

I think the situation is massively complicated by the fact your friends mother had cancer of the same organ.

She may not have been coping and needed her sisters and or fathers support with all the issues it brought up feom her own mother cancer. By asking you to tell other people I think they were indicating this.

RockyRogue1001 · 20/09/2025 17:23

This reply has been deleted

Duplicate post removed.

RockyRogue1001 · 20/09/2025 17:18

I really hope for the best outcome for your DH.

From your posts, it really seems you do have to say something to them for your own benefit.
My suggestion is that you write out a message which you and your DH agree on, and then sit on it for 24-48 hrs.
Then decide whether to send it or not

Seelybee · 20/09/2025 17:17

MN is quite possibly the worst place to go with such sensitive and emotional issues when the last thing you need is judgement and criticism. My take is that your friends were wrong and tactless to do this, but you and your DH can't afford to waste any energy on what can't be undone. Make sure your children know what's needed to preempt any comments from their peers for now. I wouldn't make a specifc point of saying anything specific to your friends but when an opportunity arises you could let them know you had to tell the children much sooner than ideal because they shared the information and you couldn't risk them finding out other than from you. Hope very much that you get positive news.

Ooodelally · 20/09/2025 17:12

Espressosummer · 20/09/2025 16:34

This feels very dramatic. The friends made a mistake, they have not been "unspeakably awful". They have done a lot for the OP and her husband.

Edited

They have broken their trust and in a way that could very likely affect their children terribly. For me that’s unforgivable. But it’s just my opinion you may well find it dramatic but, to answer the OP’s question, I would feel compelled to tell them they’d betrayed my trust and I’d want nothing more to do with them. The OP is under no obligation to do as I would.

FrondsofFriday · 20/09/2025 16:46

Hello OP.

My husband also has cancer, so your post struck a chord with me.

There is so much that is out of our control on this path. So so much. It’s easy to hyper fixate on controlling the elements we think we can, and get angry and upset when even those don’t stay under our control. And there will be many, MANY times when individuals or institutions feel like they’ve in some way failed you along this journey- believe me.

These people love you, and they are proving themselves to be good friends to you. I think long term you and your husband are far better served by accepting that they’ve messed up, that they didn’t mean to hurt you, that this is not a betrayal or anything to do with what you are both worth- it’s just fallible humans navigating a complex situation.

Wishing your husband well x

YourFairCyanReader · 20/09/2025 16:36

Sorry you are going through this. How do you know the friends told sister and father? Ie are you 100% sure? Do you know how much they know?

Espressosummer · 20/09/2025 16:34

Ooodelally · 20/09/2025 16:22

I’m sorry you are going through this. Your “friends” have been unspeakably awful, considering the clear possibility of playground gossip. I am very confrontation averse but I would be pulling right back and telling them why in no uncertain terms. I actually couldn’t forgive this. I’m sorry people you trusted have made a horrible time even worse for you. X

This feels very dramatic. The friends made a mistake, they have not been "unspeakably awful". They have done a lot for the OP and her husband.

123Needtodof00dshop · 20/09/2025 16:30

Nobody can control what other people say or do

Suggest, put your energy, time & thoughts into your own immediate family

B0D · 20/09/2025 16:25

Difficult. Do you know if the sister has actually told her child? If that is how you are worried your child might find out, I would ascertain that fact and then speak to your friend and her sister about how you feel from there. Sorry that your husband is so ill

Ooodelally · 20/09/2025 16:22

I’m sorry you are going through this. Your “friends” have been unspeakably awful, considering the clear possibility of playground gossip. I am very confrontation averse but I would be pulling right back and telling them why in no uncertain terms. I actually couldn’t forgive this. I’m sorry people you trusted have made a horrible time even worse for you. X

Wadadli · 20/09/2025 16:19

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 08:43

My husband was diagnosed with cancer at the end of July. We told some trusted friends (friends we’ve known since he was 16 and I was 18 and we’re almost 40 now) with strict wishes not to tell anyone else as we were in shock and so much to process. He had the affected organ removed in the second week of September. We have two young children who know daddy had a poorly organ and needed an operation to remove it. We didn’t mention cancer as our 8 year old understands what it is and there’s a slim chance my husband may not need further treatment. We wanted to hold off having that difficult conversation if it may not be needed. We won’t find out pathology for 6-8 weeks and until the tumour is finally graded and the suspected lymph nodes biopsied.

The issue - the friends we told, who have been great with childcare, emotional support and bringing food etc chose to tell their sister (and dad, so the family has discussed it and they are a close family who hang out all the time). The sister’s kid is best friends with our 8 year old - they hang out every day in school and sit on the same table. We are worried kids may overhear things and then pass things to ours when we are not ready to tell them.

I guess I am hurt and pissed off they told their sister when we specifically told them not to. They asked a couple of times if they wanted us to tell people (close mutual friends) and we repeatedly said no. They said they wouldn’t.

My husband was not ready to tell a lot of people - it’s been such a rollercoaster since finding out to trying to understand staging and grading and different opinions from surgeons and oncology. We’ve gone from it’s not curable, only treatable, to it may be curative to remove the organ, let’s have the surgery and see. We’ve been navigating summer holidays and managing our emotions without it affecting our children, who are our biggest concern. We desperately don’t want to cast a dark shadow over them and their childhood when 6 weeks since diagnosis, there’s a small chance this surgery may be curative. We will have the conversation with them and I think that’s what’s so upsetting, feeling forced to have that chat with our children before we wanted to. Terrified they’ll hear something from someone at school and we will then lose trust between us and create other issues.

Our deepest darkest moments feel like gossip they’ve shared. The friend and her sister’s mum also had cancer of the same organ so it’s a trauma that will bring up bad memories for our friend but we very clearly stated we didn’t want anyone else knowing. The friend could have talked to her partner about it, it wasn’t as she didn’t have anyone to talk to.

We feel upset and disrespected and almost now forced into telling and worrying our kids to protect them from hearing anything on the playground they weren’t prepared to hear.

I know they’re capable of keeping medical things private - they kept a close mutual friend’s fertility issues to themselves for years. I have no issue that this mutual friend didn’t want to share with me - I’m old enough to respect people’s wishes and understand that I’ll know if I’m supposed to. (I know now because this mutual friend has now told me btw and yay, she now has a beautiful baby). So I feel even more upset they’ve been so loosey goosey with us.

What do I do? Confront them?

Sorry this post is so long and rambling, I’ve been quite upset by it and slept on it, and still feel so angry. Why do we have this on top of everything else, feel like I can’t trust people we love and relied on.

My SIL has breast cancer. We’ve been friends since the age of 11 and are married to brothers. We have many close mutual school friends and I have told NONE OF THEM that she’s unwell. My BIL and husband share a mutual friend from their schooldays. We saw mutual friend recently, and having recently had chemotherapy himself, mentioned SILs diagnosis to us and we admitted we knew age was unwell. We haven’t even discussed it with the two other brothers because we were specifically asked not to other than between ourselves

So no, @SVDW1136, you have every right to be upset as is was not your friends’ place to discuss what you asked to be kept confidential with ANYONE

Heres wishing your husband a speedy and uneventful recovery 💐

tripleginandtonic · 20/09/2025 16:11

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/09/2025 08:59

Ita a tricky one. Yes you told them in confidence. Yes they shouldn't have passed this on.

However I imagine if I had a very close friend who I'd known most of my life who had a life threatening illness, who I was providing some practical support to, and it was the same type of cancer which was triggering difficult memories for me...I'd want to tell someone close to talk it through as I'd also be very upset.

There are lots of threads on here from people who have been dropped by friends as soon as they're ill, and it sounds like they've been supportive. So I wouldn't fall out with them but I would tell them that you're worried your chd would find out and please could they make sure that their daughter is not told anything

This.

Whataretalkingabout · 20/09/2025 16:07

I will say this a bit bluntly, OP but I do understand your concerns. Your kids probably are more worried than you imagine because of all the covering up and trying to hide the obvious.

Take control now and tell them gently; get it out in the open. This will dedramatize the whole situation and you won't lose any friends and will relieve some unnecessary stress at an already difficult time.

If you are so big on keeping things hushed you should set the example.

IThoughtIdHeardItAll · 20/09/2025 16:06

I’m 100% in agreement with you OP. I speak from personal experience. I’m upset for you with comments like ‘you are reacting in a hyper sensitive way’. These people clearly have zero experience of being hit by just the worst news like you have. It’s gut wrenching, terrifying and really really scary. And that’s before you even begin to think of your young children and how to manage the whole thing with them. You are still reeling from the shock for heavens sake! I’m really annoyed by many of the replies you’ve had. I hope you are able to ignore them. And I’m so very sorry your dear friends have let you down; they had absolutely no right to ‘share’ (gossip) your very personal news to anybody. If you want to preserve the friendship, you should tell them how upset and let down you feel before trying to move on. I wish your husband a full recovery and hope everything goes well for you and your family.

Praying4Peace · 20/09/2025 15:46

Hi OP, I can totally understand your hurt and feelings of betrayal.
I think you need to let them know how you feel.
I truly hope that your husband has a positive outcome.
Please try not to let this take over too much headspace, you need your energy and resources to deal with your current situation

Toesy · 20/09/2025 15:34

Very difficult situation OP.
I can so understand you wanting to protect your children.
There is something so distasteful about someone who just can't keep something to themselves.
This is your worry and upset.
The couple could have spoken among themselves but they chose to break your confidence.

I wish you luck in navigating this.
For me a trust broken, is that, broken.
I do not forget this type of betrayal unfortunately.

I hope you can move on but for me I would never feel the same about them again unfortunately.

I take discretion very seriously though.

I wish your husband and your whole family the best.

Hellovation · 20/09/2025 15:23

Op you’re going through hell, and I’m sorry for that-and understandably responding with heightened emotion, but be really really careful that you don’t end up letting all the hidden emotion of hiding this from your children and trying to cope alone and process everything come tumbling out due to this.

You also acknowledge that they had close experiences with this before, and that will have been triggering for them. Your friends love you and will also be crushed by this knowledge. Was it right for them to share? No of course not. But I can see how and why and I think it was a lot for them to hold. Not comparative to you and your family no, but I think its important you don’t end up losing friendships when you need them most. It’s ok to be hurt, but I think it’s ok to accept that we’re all human and they just needed someone too.