Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Looking after grandchild

362 replies

icravestardamage · 16/09/2025 11:51

My son and his girlfriend are due to have their first baby soon.
When she goes back to work she has asked if I will have baby one day a week, on my day off which I am thrilled to do.
I live 30 minutes from them and have just been told by her that I am to go through to where they live and look after baby there as she does not want baby more than 10 minutes away from her work.
Also reading between the lines she doesn’t trust me to drive with baby because I once had an accident with my son in the car when he was little, he was not hurt I just ran into the back of someone.
I was hoping that I could meet her at her work, which is just over half way for me and take baby back to my house.
I understand she is being protective of her first baby - we've all been there but AIBU to think that on my only day off I should not be spending the whole day where they live and I should be able to take my grandchild back mine or for trips out.

OP posts:
99victoria · 16/09/2025 19:37

Xsxjxmx · 16/09/2025 18:41

As a mum of a toddler that really isn't all they need. And her home will only be safe of all breakables ect are moved and cupboard locks etc are used where needed, and baby gates. All stuff that will already be at the baby's home. Toddlers are naturally curious and put these measures in place are a lot easier than always saying no and having to move them away. They can learn boundaries without being told to stop endlessly because the house isn't suitable for a baby, before that reason is used. Food the baby likes, toddler friendly cutlery, crockery and cups, toys, a suitable place to nap, their pram. All things that are genuinely needed, because we don't want to give a toddler a glass, China plate and fill sized cutlery, we don't want toddlers napping on the floor uncomfortable or the sofa where they may fall off.

Good grief 🙄I'm amazed any of the parents on here ever feel comfortable leaving their children with grandparents. I mean - what if we put them to sleep on the sofa then walk out of the room and just forget about them and they fall off. Or what if they get into the cupboard under the sink and drink the bleach and we've been so busy being elderly that we haven't noticed 😱

ChampagneLassie · 16/09/2025 19:04

Thechaseison71 · 16/09/2025 12:59

How do u manage for nursery, school , clubs friends houses etc. Surely they not all a few mins walk

We mostly cycle, child seats on bikes & just got a trailer. Or walk with baby carrier (she also hates the pram!) or trike. We do put her in car at least once a week but generally only for a few mins drive and I’m hoping she gets happier with it so we can do longer trips. Lots of people without cars have kids I don’t think cars are fundamental but I do agree it makes long distance trips easier

Elsvieta · 16/09/2025 19:02

I don't want to be away from home all day on my day off, but I'm happy to pick dgc up. Or you can drop the baby at my house if you prefer. Or we can meet half way - what works best?". She's being a major CF; don't pander. If she doesn't want you driving the baby, fair enough, she can do all the driving.

Xsxjxmx · 16/09/2025 19:00

Whateverwillwedonow · 16/09/2025 18:53

Grandparents aren’t stupid. We’ve had children, we’ve been mums to toddlers.

My house is baby safe, we have everything that they need. We aren’t the enemy.

At what point did I say anything about being an enemy or stupid. The woman said was all the baby needed was for it to be safe warm and clean. I was saying that simply isn't true. For one day a week the last would need a lot of things when she can simply spend the day at the child's house

Whateverwillwedonow · 16/09/2025 18:53

Xsxjxmx · 16/09/2025 18:41

As a mum of a toddler that really isn't all they need. And her home will only be safe of all breakables ect are moved and cupboard locks etc are used where needed, and baby gates. All stuff that will already be at the baby's home. Toddlers are naturally curious and put these measures in place are a lot easier than always saying no and having to move them away. They can learn boundaries without being told to stop endlessly because the house isn't suitable for a baby, before that reason is used. Food the baby likes, toddler friendly cutlery, crockery and cups, toys, a suitable place to nap, their pram. All things that are genuinely needed, because we don't want to give a toddler a glass, China plate and fill sized cutlery, we don't want toddlers napping on the floor uncomfortable or the sofa where they may fall off.

Grandparents aren’t stupid. We’ve had children, we’ve been mums to toddlers.

My house is baby safe, we have everything that they need. We aren’t the enemy.

Xsxjxmx · 16/09/2025 18:41

Cherrytree86 · 16/09/2025 18:23

@Xsxjxmx

presumably OP’s house is safe and warm and clean. That’s all a baby needs. As if they care if a different changing mat is being used when they have a nappy change or whatever.

As a mum of a toddler that really isn't all they need. And her home will only be safe of all breakables ect are moved and cupboard locks etc are used where needed, and baby gates. All stuff that will already be at the baby's home. Toddlers are naturally curious and put these measures in place are a lot easier than always saying no and having to move them away. They can learn boundaries without being told to stop endlessly because the house isn't suitable for a baby, before that reason is used. Food the baby likes, toddler friendly cutlery, crockery and cups, toys, a suitable place to nap, their pram. All things that are genuinely needed, because we don't want to give a toddler a glass, China plate and fill sized cutlery, we don't want toddlers napping on the floor uncomfortable or the sofa where they may fall off.

Cherrytree86 · 16/09/2025 18:23

Xsxjxmx · 16/09/2025 18:12

It is so much easier for you to be at their house where it is suited for their child and all their child's things are there. She's being precious because the baby is precious. If you don't agree with her terms then don't help, but personally, you should do what they ask and be part of the village they will need

@Xsxjxmx

presumably OP’s house is safe and warm and clean. That’s all a baby needs. As if they care if a different changing mat is being used when they have a nappy change or whatever.

Cherrytree86 · 16/09/2025 18:22

mindutopia · 16/09/2025 18:16

I’d happily drive to help family. I think it makes sense for you to go to them, because 2 hours in the car is a lot for a baby and cuts into quality time. It’s also fine to say no.

@mindutopia

shes gonna have the baby all day, she will have plenty of time with them.

Allthings · 16/09/2025 18:22

Some of the comments on here are eye opening and I am left quite speechless by some of them.

Thankfully in the real world the majority of parents are only too grateful that GPs are providing free care that they bend over backwards to enable that to happen. The majority will find a way forward that benefits all parties as much as possible.

I have always taken into account my DD’s wishes when looking after our GC and have also striven to make life as easy as possible for her. However, she has never dictated and the most I have been asked to adhere to was not allowing GC to nap beyond a certain time.

Making a home child safe is not really a big deal and it’s a massive assumption that it is easier for GP’s to look after DGC in the DGC home. Interestingly enough, unless you have a nanny, all other childcare is outside the home with nursery’s and childminders managing perfectly well as does the child. GPs get on with it as well, they are also capable of finding out the latest ideas on child rearing if they are not already aware, but their offspring should be more than capable of advising if there is any avoidance of doubt.

It is not clear as to how old the DGC will be when OP is going to look after them, but given that a high proportion of parents will take the maximum maternity/paternity leave, and then perhaps have some annual leave tagged on to the end, its likely that DGC will be at toddler stage and not a tiny baby, which a lot of posters appear to be referring to.

mindutopia · 16/09/2025 18:16

I’d happily drive to help family. I think it makes sense for you to go to them, because 2 hours in the car is a lot for a baby and cuts into quality time. It’s also fine to say no.

Xsxjxmx · 16/09/2025 18:12

It is so much easier for you to be at their house where it is suited for their child and all their child's things are there. She's being precious because the baby is precious. If you don't agree with her terms then don't help, but personally, you should do what they ask and be part of the village they will need

Loubylie · 16/09/2025 18:08

A baby does not need to be in 'their home environment'. A baby can be anywhere safe and warm. The baby will be better off with a Grandma who is relaxed and happy getting on with stuff rather than a bored Grandma stuck in someone else's house, scrolling and watching the clock.

samlett · 16/09/2025 18:02

Bananaandmangosmoothie · 16/09/2025 17:23

Some things have changed in the past generation, though. For example, my parents used to smack us but no way would that be allowed for my own kids. Similarly, car seat rules are much stricter than they used to be. If you care for your grandchildren exactly the way you cared for your own children in the 1980s, you may end up breaking the law.

People who are new grandparents now were actual kids in the 80s! In any case they have brains, everyone knows that smacking isn't acceptable now and that kids have carseats. Geez.

brunettemic · 16/09/2025 18:01

You’re giving her free childcare. You have the child on your terms or not at all. End of discussion.

ElsieMc · 16/09/2025 17:59

I offer childcare for 2 of my gc's over the past five years. I started off in my own home but now move between the two,dependent on weather etc or what we have arranged.

Tbh, its easier at my dd's. More parks nearby, walks, shops etc. Its a personal preference really. I often take my dogs but they are confined to the kitchen /utility where they go to sleep. They walk to heel with the pram. I get that some would not like this at all. My dd has grown more confident with me and DH over time. Its about compromise but remember your wishes count.

IneedtheeohIneedtheeeveryhourIneedthee · 16/09/2025 17:58

TimeForATerf · 16/09/2025 17:17

I have my DGD one day a week, at MY house. I have a car seat, a buggy and lots of toys here, and can look after DGD whilst carrying on with my life, you know in the same way as her mum does. I personally think they’re cheeky expecting you to travel there and back and do a full day child care away from your own home.

lots of young girls are very cheeky. We have an entitled generation on our hands and sadly they are raising the future's kids!

icravestardamage · 16/09/2025 17:50

Bananaandmangosmoothie · 16/09/2025 17:23

Some things have changed in the past generation, though. For example, my parents used to smack us but no way would that be allowed for my own kids. Similarly, car seat rules are much stricter than they used to be. If you care for your grandchildren exactly the way you cared for your own children in the 1980s, you may end up breaking the law.

I didn't bring my children up in the 80"s! They are mid 20's
Like I said before I'm 50!!Grin

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/09/2025 17:50

Bananaandmangosmoothie · 16/09/2025 17:20

It’s up to you ultimately, since you’re the one providing free childcare. My Mum has my kids at her house. Hugely grateful! Of course it would be more convenient for us if she came here but she said she won’t, so fair enough.

My mother in law has my nephew and niece at my brother in law’s house. She would rather have them at hers, but they’ve said no to that and she’s so keen to have them she goes by what they want. They also have loads of cameras in their house and watch her and message her about things when she’s caring for their children. No way my mum would ever stand for that.

So it’s up to you where your boundaries are, really. And it’s up to your daughter in law where hers are as well.

Edited

What?!!! No way would I allow being spied on when I'm doing a favour! That poor MIL.

saraclara · 16/09/2025 17:47

I've always done child care at my house. I'm amazed at the number of GPs on this thread who find it easier to be at the GC's home.

I feel much more relaxed in my own home. I have all the equipment I need, and my son in law (who does the transfers) packs a bag with anything extra that the GC/s might need that day. We do a transfer half way between my house and theirs on his way to work.

At home I can get on with anything I need to do, I know where everything is, and I don't feel like an intruder in someone else's house, always looking for things and having to poke in cupboards etc.

Consequently my DGCs see my house as somewhere they properly belong, and love the routines that we've built up at Grandma's house.

I'm sorry that your relationship with your DIL is a bit too fragile for you to strongly state your preference @icravestardamage , but I totally get why you'd rather do the care at your home.

Notagain75 · 16/09/2025 17:47

99victoria · 16/09/2025 17:35

I don't get all this 'it'll be easier at the parents house because everything will be there' narrative. As previously mentioned I have looked after 3 of my grandchildren over the last 9 years (oldest nearly 10, youngest 1). I have a buggy, a highchair, a car seat, toys, beaker cups, a bottle, plastic cultery and plates, a pile of spare clothes in the airing cupboard, nappies and wipes in the bathroom, a changing mat etc

Most 60 year olds are perfectly capable of sourcing and storing these things and buying/preparing food etc suitable for young children. Honestly, it all reads so patronising. I don't have a stair gate so I keep the door to the hall closed when I'm looking after my one year old dgs. Or, I make sure I'm with him if he goes out into the hallway.

I know some guidance on childcare has changed and I'm happy to take those things on board but seriously, there's no need to be so patronising. We're perfectly capable of taking care of our grandchildren in our own homes 🙄

I was thinking about the.baby.
I have also looked after my three grandchildren at my house and at theirs.But if it was an early start I always went to their house. It's much less disruptive for the child and I think much better than rushing a baby out of the house in the morning

nextholidaypending · 16/09/2025 17:42

My MIL offered to help care for my children one day a week when I returned to work. It took me a long time to trust her (or anyone other than my husband) to drive them around. Not because I didn’t trust them, just my own anxieties. It’s a big thing to leave your children when they are tiny, particularly your first born. Try not to take offence as I’m sure it’s nothing personal and she clearly trusts you to have them in your care!

99victoria · 16/09/2025 17:35

I don't get all this 'it'll be easier at the parents house because everything will be there' narrative. As previously mentioned I have looked after 3 of my grandchildren over the last 9 years (oldest nearly 10, youngest 1). I have a buggy, a highchair, a car seat, toys, beaker cups, a bottle, plastic cultery and plates, a pile of spare clothes in the airing cupboard, nappies and wipes in the bathroom, a changing mat etc

Most 60 year olds are perfectly capable of sourcing and storing these things and buying/preparing food etc suitable for young children. Honestly, it all reads so patronising. I don't have a stair gate so I keep the door to the hall closed when I'm looking after my one year old dgs. Or, I make sure I'm with him if he goes out into the hallway.

I know some guidance on childcare has changed and I'm happy to take those things on board but seriously, there's no need to be so patronising. We're perfectly capable of taking care of our grandchildren in our own homes 🙄

Shinysunday · 16/09/2025 17:34

icravestardamage · 16/09/2025 12:11

Thank you for your responses.
I am fearful of speaking up because we have had a fragile relationship in the past. I feel if I don't agree to her terms I could end up being the bad guy.
As to meeting her at work it would be done in the office car park, or I am happy to collect from their house.
My initial thoughts were 'lets see'
There is no real issue over the cost as she would get 50% discount on childcare.

She wants to keep her baby close by - nothing sinister about that, and no reason to think it's a reflection on your driving. Everything is set up for a baby at her house, and the right food and medicines and so on will be to hand. The time you spend driving that extra half hour each week would likely be spent preparing and tidying your home and doing extra shopping. And it is the parents' choice. You were trilled to be asked, so don't spoil it by arguing over the details. If it doesn't work out for some reason, you can discuss it and agree something different.

Notagain75 · 16/09/2025 17:31

ruethewhirl · 16/09/2025 17:27

Personally as OP's offering free childcare and now being asked to put herself out, I don't see how she's BU. It's free so baby's mum doesn't really get to pick and choose imho.

If the grandmother wants to.look after the baby I think mother does get to pick and choose. She had to think about what is best for the baby and that is obviously staying in their own home

ruethewhirl · 16/09/2025 17:27

Namechangerage · 16/09/2025 13:18

YABU.

My mum travelled 20 mins by bus to mine and looks after baby there. It’s easier because all the stuff is there and baby will likely be more familiar. Plus you’ll have to pick him up anyway? So it’s an hour in the car for baby each day. Course you can do days out etc that’s different.

Personally as OP's offering free childcare and now being asked to put herself out, I don't see how she's BU. It's free so baby's mum doesn't really get to pick and choose imho.