Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is some kind of weird push towards the far right?

795 replies

Checkcheckout · 16/09/2025 01:07

I’m the first to admit that I am not the best informed - I prefer to keep my life stress free and simple as much as possible, and don’t have a TV, don’t read papers, and only listen to the radio when I’m driving (which is quite often). For my own mental health I prefer to live in my own little bubble.

But even with my limited exposure to media, I’ve noticed on Radio 2, both on the news and Jeremy Vine’s show, Reform are being given so much air time considering their paltry amount of MPs, the polls are being discussed regularly even though we’re years from an election. More than once listening to the radio I’ve thought the way they’re talking makes it sound like Reform winning the next election is a done deal, and thought to myself that this is how self fulfilling prophecies happen.

My algorithms on FB are seriously messed up. Despite having never been remotely interested in anything in the least bit right wing, all of a sudden I’m getting endless posts from knuckle dragging ‘patriot’ groups that I don’t even follow, with really horrendous and openly racist comments, thousands of them, which somehow FB are allowing to remain even though any kind of hate speech has always been censored on there. Why are these posts suddenly being allowed and pushed in my face?

Alongside this there seems to be a new story pretty much every day about the latest scandal involving Labour (again reported by the BBC), ok these things aren’t great although compared to the Tories’ rap list from their last spell in government, are fairly small fry really. It seems like there’s an active push for people to rebel away from the left just as the far right are gaining momentum.

Has anyone else noticed this or am I talking shite?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Shakeoffyourchains · 16/09/2025 13:55

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/09/2025 13:16

If that's what you're seeing, you're clearly following the wrong people. If you are left leaning politically, your social media algorithm with flag up negative 'right' rhetoric. That's how it works.

Attendance estimates for Saturday's 'far right' rally are now coming out at around 3 million. How many arrests? 25!
That's in stark contrast to a family event like this year's Notting Hill Carnival. How many arrests? 423!

Don't know about you but I know which event I'd be more 'afraid' to attend.

Look, at the end of the day, the left can keep going with this 'facist', 'racist' rhetoric... then they can all scratch their heads when we have a Reform govt wondering: 'How on earth did that happen!?'
Might want to start listening.

We've listen ad nauseam. You're unhappy that standards of living, public services and public infrastructure has declined while the cost of living has increased.

You blame migration, the EU and 'the left' for this, not austerity and increasing wealth inequality (the actual causes).

You opposed any and all attempts at addressing the root causes and want to remove everyone's human rights so you can punish your scapegoat(s).

Out of interest, once Reform get in and, just like their MAGA counterparts, fail to make life better for the average person, who will you blame?

Ps no credible outlet has put out an estimate of more than 150,000 at the march.

Mlddleoftheroad · 16/09/2025 13:43

KhakiTiger · 16/09/2025 13:19

The far left never learn. And more worryingly, they are making things worse for minorities by labelling people far right when they are just ordinary people.

Like this one.

To think there is some kind of weird push towards the far right?
BloominNora · 16/09/2025 13:43

tramtracks · 16/09/2025 13:00

I would totally support this IF it could work. The problem is that I can envisage a lot of uber wealthy would simply mibr their domicile status to somewhere with lower tax regimes. Then we’d effectively lose the revenue we get from them atm.
Unless we can get global agreement on tax rates - I just don’t think it works - and would worsen the lives of the poorest who can’t move.

Except that's an arguement the uber wealthy use as a scare tactic.

If they want to go, then fine - Labour have removed the non-dom perks already - which despite dire warnings have not led to a mass exodus.

You need to look at where the wealth comes from - which is largely UK property and business. Combine the higher rate tax with the removal of honors (an awful lot seem to be Lords and Sirs), limits on property ownership for non-Uk tax payers, limits on access to UK government contracts and introduce a system like the US where even if you are resident and paying tax elsewhere, you have to pay tax to maintain your residency, you will find that far fewer actually leave than threaten it.

Access to UK for business purposes is far too lucrative.

Shakeoffyourchains · 16/09/2025 13:40

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 12:24

Ah, there's more on that same thread, including a link to this article in 2022 which is very interesting.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/01/troll-factory-spreading-russian-pro-war-lies-online-says-uk
‘Troll factory’ spreading Russian pro-war lies online, says UK
St Petersburg outfit hijacks discussions on Twitter, TikTok, world leaders’ social accounts and media websites, as well as manipulating opinion polls

The research said TikTok influencers were being paid to amplify pro-Kremlin narratives. Operatives also amplified genuine messages by legitimate social media users that happen to be consistent with the Kremlin’s viewpoint – seemingly to evade social media platforms’ measures to combat disinformation.

The analysis suggests one main activity is “brigading”, to steer attention of discussion on social media and in comments sections of newspapers towards favoured opinions.

[...] Social media accounts of bands and musicians including Daft Punk, David Guetta, Tiesto and Rammstein appear to have been targeted by the disinformation operation.
Researchers say the group seems to have learned from the tactics used by QAnon conspiracy theorists and from the Islamic State terror group.

Interesting, especially the part about interference with polls.

I'm donning my conspiracy hat for a moment but, I wonder if there's any connection between Russian bot farms, Reform leading in the polls and Reform refusing to call a by-election for Kruger's deflection.

I mean, I know they don't have to call one, but you'd think if they were confident the public polls reflect reality they'd jump at the chance of having their new MP re-elected with a thumping majority.

StandFirm · 16/09/2025 13:36

StandFirm · 16/09/2025 13:35

Yes. It's all being engineered by US interests.

And when I say 'US' I mean MAGA...

StandFirm · 16/09/2025 13:35

Checkcheckout · 16/09/2025 01:07

I’m the first to admit that I am not the best informed - I prefer to keep my life stress free and simple as much as possible, and don’t have a TV, don’t read papers, and only listen to the radio when I’m driving (which is quite often). For my own mental health I prefer to live in my own little bubble.

But even with my limited exposure to media, I’ve noticed on Radio 2, both on the news and Jeremy Vine’s show, Reform are being given so much air time considering their paltry amount of MPs, the polls are being discussed regularly even though we’re years from an election. More than once listening to the radio I’ve thought the way they’re talking makes it sound like Reform winning the next election is a done deal, and thought to myself that this is how self fulfilling prophecies happen.

My algorithms on FB are seriously messed up. Despite having never been remotely interested in anything in the least bit right wing, all of a sudden I’m getting endless posts from knuckle dragging ‘patriot’ groups that I don’t even follow, with really horrendous and openly racist comments, thousands of them, which somehow FB are allowing to remain even though any kind of hate speech has always been censored on there. Why are these posts suddenly being allowed and pushed in my face?

Alongside this there seems to be a new story pretty much every day about the latest scandal involving Labour (again reported by the BBC), ok these things aren’t great although compared to the Tories’ rap list from their last spell in government, are fairly small fry really. It seems like there’s an active push for people to rebel away from the left just as the far right are gaining momentum.

Has anyone else noticed this or am I talking shite?

Yes. It's all being engineered by US interests.

squidsin · 16/09/2025 13:24

smallpinecone · 16/09/2025 13:22

The right haven’t haven’t been in politics for a long time.

The Tories weren't even centre right. Trying to pass mild welfare reforms and making a bit of noise about reducing illegal immigration while doing nothing to address it do not make a government centre right.

The fact you think this just shows how far the Overton Window has been dragged to the right.

EmpressoftheMundane · 16/09/2025 13:23

OP, I think you are seeing the Overton Window shift to the right. Social attitudes swing like a pendulum. With corrections and over corrections. It’s not a one-way ratchet.

smallpinecone · 16/09/2025 13:22

squidsin · 16/09/2025 12:41

The 'left' (Labour are centre right) have been in power for ONE YEAR. They haven't had time to do much, either right or wrong. The cost of living crisis, the crashed economy - this is all the legacy of the Tories that's basically almost impossible to fix.

The right have been in power for about 99% of history. What we're seeing now is toys being spctacularly chucked out of the pram because the right have slightly loss their stranglehold on British politics.

The right haven’t haven’t been in politics for a long time.

The Tories weren't even centre right. Trying to pass mild welfare reforms and making a bit of noise about reducing illegal immigration while doing nothing to address it do not make a government centre right.

squidsin · 16/09/2025 13:22

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/09/2025 13:16

If that's what you're seeing, you're clearly following the wrong people. If you are left leaning politically, your social media algorithm with flag up negative 'right' rhetoric. That's how it works.

Attendance estimates for Saturday's 'far right' rally are now coming out at around 3 million. How many arrests? 25!
That's in stark contrast to a family event like this year's Notting Hill Carnival. How many arrests? 423!

Don't know about you but I know which event I'd be more 'afraid' to attend.

Look, at the end of the day, the left can keep going with this 'facist', 'racist' rhetoric... then they can all scratch their heads when we have a Reform govt wondering: 'How on earth did that happen!?'
Might want to start listening.

There were not 3 million people at that rally. That's a false claim made up by old Tommy himself. The official estimate from the Met police put max attendance at 150,000.

London's infrastructure would have collapsed if that many people descended on it all at once. And it didn't.

If you have to lie to back up what you're saying, you're saying the wrong things.

Goldenbear · 16/09/2025 13:21

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 13:06

I see today Maria Caulfield has defected to Reform today.

She was a Tory MP during the period of these cuts to health services – indeed Minister of State for Health at one point.

The people who spent more than a decade causing the service declines everyone is rightfully complaining about, are now busily populating Reform.

The audacity!

KhakiTiger · 16/09/2025 13:19

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/09/2025 13:16

If that's what you're seeing, you're clearly following the wrong people. If you are left leaning politically, your social media algorithm with flag up negative 'right' rhetoric. That's how it works.

Attendance estimates for Saturday's 'far right' rally are now coming out at around 3 million. How many arrests? 25!
That's in stark contrast to a family event like this year's Notting Hill Carnival. How many arrests? 423!

Don't know about you but I know which event I'd be more 'afraid' to attend.

Look, at the end of the day, the left can keep going with this 'facist', 'racist' rhetoric... then they can all scratch their heads when we have a Reform govt wondering: 'How on earth did that happen!?'
Might want to start listening.

The far left never learn. And more worryingly, they are making things worse for minorities by labelling people far right when they are just ordinary people.

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/09/2025 13:16

If that's what you're seeing, you're clearly following the wrong people. If you are left leaning politically, your social media algorithm with flag up negative 'right' rhetoric. That's how it works.

Attendance estimates for Saturday's 'far right' rally are now coming out at around 3 million. How many arrests? 25!
That's in stark contrast to a family event like this year's Notting Hill Carnival. How many arrests? 423!

Don't know about you but I know which event I'd be more 'afraid' to attend.

Look, at the end of the day, the left can keep going with this 'facist', 'racist' rhetoric... then they can all scratch their heads when we have a Reform govt wondering: 'How on earth did that happen!?'
Might want to start listening.

Underthinker · 16/09/2025 13:13

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 12:46

That might answer @Underthinker 's question a little: Yes, Russia does put the welly in to influence, well, everyone, and it doesn't have to be done directly.

"Brigading" creates the appearance of high level of support for particular positions, and I expect eventually picks up real life support as well. So it creates noisy "constituencies" which become attractive for politicians to please or dangerous for them to ignore.

Plus the bots push fake support in both directions for a good old stir. I don't think Russia always has to invent issues: it can pick up existing ones, which genuinely concern lots of real people, and heat them up and work to drive the discourse to extreme poles.

It's all about nudging real people with real lives and real concerns.

Obviously these tricks aren't just used by the Russians. Any group can and does play.

Explain it to me like I'm [more] stupid.

Lots of people genuinely adopted the belief that trans women are women, including celebrities, journalists, politicians, activists and lobbyists. As a result, laws & policies were changed across many organisations to give the rights to some males to be in womens sports, prisons, changing rooms etc etc etc. This is all real right? So far this can have little to do with Russian interference can it?

When women began to object, several were fired or discriminated against at work. (Maya Forstater, Jo Phoenix etc etc). Women were also kicked out of British political parties (the lib dems and the greens IIRC). Again, its not plausible to me that foreign interference could have had much impact on these factual events.

These events were unjust so triggered a backlash, and you could claim that here Russian bots amplified the news of such cases and highlighted for example Maya Forstater's case to build her support. But if they did, and as far as I know, there is no evidence that they did - So what? She was right.

I suppose my overall question is, if we believed Russians manipulated the gender debate, what worse situation are we in now than if they hadn't?

squidsin · 16/09/2025 13:10

ainsleysanob · 16/09/2025 13:05

But exactly that - many people don’t want the Conservatives and they don’t want Labour either because that would be more of the same. The greens, libdems and the new poncy party that Corbyn will be trying to thrust upon us doesn’t appeal either.

What do you think would be different about Reform?

squidsin · 16/09/2025 13:09

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 13:06

I see today Maria Caulfield has defected to Reform today.

She was a Tory MP during the period of these cuts to health services – indeed Minister of State for Health at one point.

The people who spent more than a decade causing the service declines everyone is rightfully complaining about, are now busily populating Reform.

Wasn't she Minister for Women at one point? She'll be right at home in the party where one of their four (now five) MPs has a conviction for beating up his girlfriend, then!

squidsin · 16/09/2025 13:08

tramtracks · 16/09/2025 13:00

I would totally support this IF it could work. The problem is that I can envisage a lot of uber wealthy would simply mibr their domicile status to somewhere with lower tax regimes. Then we’d effectively lose the revenue we get from them atm.
Unless we can get global agreement on tax rates - I just don’t think it works - and would worsen the lives of the poorest who can’t move.

It is a problem though. As a percentage of his income, Rishi Sunak - a millionaire, and just as an example - pays less than the average person, as the majority of his taxes are capital gains, which means he's paying a lower rate of tax than a high rate income tax. If you're rich enough to afford a good accountant, you end up dumping the tax burden onto people who are a lot less capable than you of shouldering it. The argument is always 'otherwise they'd just leave' but that's just a way of shrugging shoulders at massive and unfair tax inequality.

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 13:06

I see today Maria Caulfield has defected to Reform today.

She was a Tory MP during the period of these cuts to health services – indeed Minister of State for Health at one point.

The people who spent more than a decade causing the service declines everyone is rightfully complaining about, are now busily populating Reform.

DoneKebab · 16/09/2025 13:06

OnlyMabelInTheBuilding · 16/09/2025 05:32

Honestly the left never learn. There’s no ‘push’. It’s how many people, actually feel. Why can people on the left never imagine any other viewpoint but their own. Always has to be some sort of ‘interference’

We’re trying to make some type of excuse for you, but perhaps you’re right, and there is none.

By the way, listening works both ways.

ainsleysanob · 16/09/2025 13:05

Checkcheckout · 16/09/2025 01:18

I’m no fan of Keir, but I can’t see that what he’s done in one year of being prime minister is any worse than the previous 14 years of the conservatives. He’s basically a Tory in a red tie, so it’s pretty much more of the same from what I can tell.

But exactly that - many people don’t want the Conservatives and they don’t want Labour either because that would be more of the same. The greens, libdems and the new poncy party that Corbyn will be trying to thrust upon us doesn’t appeal either.

inamarina · 16/09/2025 13:03

OnlyMabelInTheBuilding · 16/09/2025 05:32

Honestly the left never learn. There’s no ‘push’. It’s how many people, actually feel. Why can people on the left never imagine any other viewpoint but their own. Always has to be some sort of ‘interference’

Agree with this.
Posters assuming there must be lots of paid bots on MN, do they genuinely find it inconceivable that others might have different opinions and experiences to them?
Fwiw, I’m an EU immigrant living in the UK and I wasn’t in favour of Brexit at the time, but I wouldn’t call everyone who voted or expressed their support for it a bigot or a bot.

tramtracks · 16/09/2025 13:00

BloominNora · 16/09/2025 12:53

In terms of wealth beyond measure there could easily be a consensus reached - there are an increasing number of billionaires who will never in their lifetimes be able to spend what they hoard.

The money is seen as a measure of success which is why it is so important to them - lets start handing out medals and stickers instead!

Our top rate of income tax is the lowest it has ever been - post war it was 90%, even under Thatcher it was 60%.

The Thatcher government preferred 'indirect taxation' and raised VAT from 8% to 15% to enable cuts to income tax. This meant poorer people paid more tax while higher earners paid less tax.

The current tax thresholds are too low with cliff edge drop - but I would love to see VAT reduced and income tax increased for higher earners, with increases on capital gains tax and tax on investment dividends. Bring back 90% income tax on anything earned over £1million!

By everyone working together, I mean putting an end to the current polarisation. We don't all agree, but with compromise there has to be common ground that will make things better for everyone.

Other than the uber wealthy and the zealots, can anyone say they are truly happy in a world where it has become more important to 'own' the opposition than to actually make a difference?

I would totally support this IF it could work. The problem is that I can envisage a lot of uber wealthy would simply mibr their domicile status to somewhere with lower tax regimes. Then we’d effectively lose the revenue we get from them atm.
Unless we can get global agreement on tax rates - I just don’t think it works - and would worsen the lives of the poorest who can’t move.

squidsin · 16/09/2025 12:57

ColdSalads · 16/09/2025 12:49

Oh, I totally agree it will be more of the same.

Low key civil war may be an issue in the not too distant future.

I think your sentence about bashing brown and black people is obnoxious, especially as white working class kids in this country are some of the most deprived and under privileged and that the UK is one of the most, if not the most, tolerant, unracist countries in the world.

Regardless of whether you think it's 'obnoxious', that's very much reality. There is nothing working class about the Reform party itself - look at who they've got as MPs/potential MPs, still loads of Oxbridge people who've never known what it feels like to be skint, most of them are ex-Tories and Farage himself is an ultra-privileged ex-public schoolboy. Reform's policies are designed to funnel wealth upwards, not downwards to ordinary people.

I appreciate the white working class feel left behind (although I would dispute that they're any more left behind than any other element of the working class) but thinking Reform is going to save them is, unfortunately, them being massively played. Tommy Robinson may be wheeled out as a sort of useful idiot (an ex football hooligan who founded the EDL - he's as racist as they come so it's disingenous to pretend race isn't a key element of Reform's efforts at whipping up support) to try and pretend Reform is the part of the working classes, but he won't be allowed anywhere near hard power. It'll be more of the same, but worse. They function by encouraging the white working class to punch down instead of looking up, so literally all they'll realistically be offering them is the chance to do just that, while they raid the economy for their own personal gain.

LegoNinjago · 16/09/2025 12:56

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 12:46

That might answer @Underthinker 's question a little: Yes, Russia does put the welly in to influence, well, everyone, and it doesn't have to be done directly.

"Brigading" creates the appearance of high level of support for particular positions, and I expect eventually picks up real life support as well. So it creates noisy "constituencies" which become attractive for politicians to please or dangerous for them to ignore.

Plus the bots push fake support in both directions for a good old stir. I don't think Russia always has to invent issues: it can pick up existing ones, which genuinely concern lots of real people, and heat them up and work to drive the discourse to extreme poles.

It's all about nudging real people with real lives and real concerns.

Obviously these tricks aren't just used by the Russians. Any group can and does play.

Plus the bots push fake support in both directions for a good old stir

Exactly.
This the exact tactic that has been used in Eastern Ukraine since 2014 by Putin: he didn’t have to prove to them that he’s telling the truth, he only needed to prove that NOONE is telling the truth.

it is the main building block of russian propaganda

NigelFaragesFakeRoarofLaughter · 16/09/2025 12:56

The conservatives used to be a party that believed in lowering taxes, especially those on businesses. But the last 14 years of Tory gov couldn’t or didn’t do anything in this regard.

The Conservatives did cut taxes. Eg here's a summary of their 2015 manifesto.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2015-32302062

(IIRC they did so again 2017, though I CBA to dig up a ref so will stand corrected on that if I'm wrong.)

Unfortunately this meant they cut the spending on health and support for the disabled and low income families with children.

It degraded the NHS significantly, while hiding behind the rhetoric that the sum going to the NHS wasn't being cut... but not increased in line with the aging population, and meanwhile the health and social care budget which keeps people out of hospital was slashed.

https://www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/news-item/what-was-austeritys-toll-on-the-nhs-before-the-pandemic

David Cameron

Election 2015: Conservative manifesto at-a-glance

The Conservative Party launches its manifesto ahead of the general election. Here are some of the key points.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2015-32302062