Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Keir Starmer is looking more ridiculous by the day

281 replies

Viviennemary · 15/09/2025 17:37

I've just seen an interview with Keir Starmer talking in riddles. If he knew then what he knew now then this mess wouldn't have happened. Three hour debate about it tomorrow in Parliament. Surely his time is up. But if a lefty takes over it might be worse.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
EasternStandard · 16/09/2025 19:32

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:13

And here is the up to date chart based on bi-elections won since GE

That’s a big chunk of red to turquoise isn’t it?

Labour to Reform

FrogOfFroggHall · 16/09/2025 19:30

EmpressoftheMundane · 16/09/2025 10:57

Farage wanted Brexit. We Brexited.

Farage started a new political party. It is now 15 points ahead of any other party in the polls.

He seems to be the most consequential politician of a generation.

Whether one agrees with his politics, is another question.

Exactly. He has led the agenda in British politics for years now. The two (formerly) main parties are just dancing to his tune.

I’m a leftie so I despise what he stands for. But he’s obviously very talented.

Manxexile · 16/09/2025 19:24

randomchap · 15/09/2025 21:13

The Tory party had a massive majority at the time. They could have forced through any deal they could have agreed with the EU. Johnson just didn't want the scrutiny. He was cowardly

Johnson's deal was and is awful for this country. Trade barriers with our biggest export market, more paperwork, border delays, regulatory divergence.

Exports have struggled, investment fallen, labour shortages in key areas such as food production

Sorry but can you remind me what "massive majority" the Tories had when Johnson attempted to prorogue Parliament in August/September 2019?

I don't think they had an outright majority at all between the 2017 election and the run up to the one in December 2019.

Again Johnson tried to prorogue Parliament because he didn't have an outright majority and he wanted to avoid what May had gone through with the Labour, Tory, Lib DEm and Scot Nats remainers all denying the democratic will of the electorate by not endorsing May's efforts at reaching a deal with Brussels That (ie Labour sticking its head in the sand over the referendum result hoping it would go away) is what caused harm to the country and led to Johnson hurrying through a muddled deal.

The electorate then had it's say about the remainers in the Decmber 2019 election in which the Tories made a net gain of 53 seats against Labour. That was for ignoring the refernedum result and blocking a deal.

PandoraSocks · 16/09/2025 19:04

I didn't say it excuses Labour. Just saying that it is a well worn tradition. 🤷‍♀️

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:56

PandoraSocks · 16/09/2025 18:47

Neither.
Just pointing out that all Governments blame their predecessors. It's not unique to the current government.

And I'm sure you pointed that out to Tory voters when they were in government.
So just because previous governments do something means it excuses Labour? I thought they were the "grown ups" and "transparent" etc. Oh no sorry that's just what they tried to convince the electorate that they were. Thankfully they've dropped that pretence now.

PandoraSocks · 16/09/2025 18:47

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:22

Whataboutery? Deflection?

Neither.
Just pointing out that all Governments blame their predecessors. It's not unique to the current government.

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:24

TheNuthatch · 15/09/2025 21:03

So you think that Reform are not a threat to Labour? What about the red wall?

Red Wall is now a turquoise wall, even Grauniad is reporting this

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:22

PandoraSocks · 16/09/2025 18:19

"It takes a long time to fix the mess that I was left."

"We are half way through a building job,"

Who said that and when?

Whataboutery? Deflection?

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:21

CurlewKate · 15/09/2025 21:31

They didn’t introduce an education tax. They closed a tax loophole for private schools. A very different thing.

You really want to do this?

It wasn't a loophole it was a legitimate zero rating on education based on the principle of it being a merit good. Labour were told by judges not to use language of "tax breaks" because that was an opinion not fact. You know this yet you continue to spread misinformation that it was a "loophole" when that's blatantly false.

The tax on children's education is exactly that, a taxation on the supply of education for children in certain settings. UK is now only country in the WORLD to tax education of children. We are now ideologically behind Nigeria.

PandoraSocks · 16/09/2025 18:19

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:11

At what stage do you stop blaming Tories and make Labour accountable for shit policies? Seemingly not after 14 months so is ot after 18 months? 2 years? Never?

Always someone else's fault ie Tories/Reform/right wing press/rascists isn't it?

"It takes a long time to fix the mess that I was left."

"We are half way through a building job,"

Who said that and when?

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:14

bombastix · 15/09/2025 21:07

Good question. Are they the don’t knows in the chart? There seems very small stream between Labour and Reform. Ideologically that makes sense to me.

You are using an old chart. I've provided the most up to date one ie from this week

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:13

bombastix · 15/09/2025 20:57

The reason Reform win is not because the Labour Party are talentless. When you look at where the Reform vote is growing it is from
the Conservative Party. These people are not Labour people yet.

However the voting patterns in the UK are changing in intent. Here is an excellent way of representing these changes.

And here is the up to date chart based on bi-elections won since GE

To think Keir Starmer is looking more ridiculous by the day
twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:11

BallerinaRadio · 16/09/2025 08:27

And they didn't for the past 14 years?

At what stage do you stop blaming Tories and make Labour accountable for shit policies? Seemingly not after 14 months so is ot after 18 months? 2 years? Never?

Always someone else's fault ie Tories/Reform/right wing press/rascists isn't it?

twistyizzy · 16/09/2025 18:09

TheNuthatch · 15/09/2025 22:12

No, the failings of the Conservatives led to the Labour landslide win. If Labour continue as they are, and the tories don't improve, Reform will win the next election.
The tories have already been punished, Labour are on course for the same.

Spot on 👏

RuttleTuttle · 16/09/2025 18:03

Hellohelga · 15/09/2025 19:50

It’s very relevant - the behaviour of his predecessors is a yard stick by which to measure him. He’s clean Asa a whistle compared to BJ.

Which is why he's doing so well in the polls, and his own party are so actively supporting him! 🤔

EmpressoftheMundane · 16/09/2025 10:57

Farage wanted Brexit. We Brexited.

Farage started a new political party. It is now 15 points ahead of any other party in the polls.

He seems to be the most consequential politician of a generation.

Whether one agrees with his politics, is another question.

AngelicInnocent · 16/09/2025 09:58

CurlewKate · 16/09/2025 08:44

Is he? He is an excellent self publicist. He is obviously crap leader of a party and a crap chooser of people.

It always amazes me how people can't deviate from their own script.

Reform would be a nightmare for me if they got in. I will never vote reform.

That being said, it is ridiculous to deny that Farage is excellent at reading the general feeling of the public and appealing to it. Therefore he is successful as a politician.

CurlewKate · 16/09/2025 08:44

FrogOfFroggHall · 15/09/2025 22:06

He is an excellent politician in that he is excellent at achieving his political aims. Impossible really to think of anyone more effective operating today.

You’re quite right that he’s anything but an excellent public servant though!

Is he? He is an excellent self publicist. He is obviously crap leader of a party and a crap chooser of people.

BallerinaRadio · 16/09/2025 08:27

baroqueandblue · 15/09/2025 23:15

Is that the royal "we?" Because a lot of ordinary people are enduring austerity (by any other name) after 1 year under Starmer's Labour.

And they didn't for the past 14 years?

AlasPoor · 16/09/2025 08:06

randomchap · 16/09/2025 07:47

Gilt yields are linked to the BoE interest rates, these have risen to fight inflation. However inflation has stayed higher, these have pushed up the gilt rate. There has also been gilt rate rises in other countries. The UK is not alone in having rises unlike during Truss's fuck up

What the Tories did post Truss, and Labour have continued, is try to set a more predictable fiscal policy so that the markets aren't spooked.

Truss's mini-budget caused the cost of borrowing to skyrocket. Mortgage offers with withdrawn. Rates went from 2% to 6% in a few weeks.

So on a typical 300k house, your repayment would have gone from £1100 to about £1700 depending on how much deposit you had. That's £600 a month taken from a household budget.

You’re just confusing swap rates, inflation, BOE interest rates and 2 and 5 year Gilt yields with 30 year. Inflation was higher under Truss for example.

The spike for Truss was because of loss of short term confidence in the economy mainly affecting 2 and 5 year Gilts which are often used on swaps for mortgage rates. What’s happened with Labour is loss of long term confidence in the U.K.

Saying that Labour’s economic management is only a bit worse than Truss is hardly a vote winner.

randomchap · 16/09/2025 07:47

EmpressoftheMundane · 15/09/2025 22:53

What other factors are raising gilt yields now?

Edited

Gilt yields are linked to the BoE interest rates, these have risen to fight inflation. However inflation has stayed higher, these have pushed up the gilt rate. There has also been gilt rate rises in other countries. The UK is not alone in having rises unlike during Truss's fuck up

What the Tories did post Truss, and Labour have continued, is try to set a more predictable fiscal policy so that the markets aren't spooked.

Truss's mini-budget caused the cost of borrowing to skyrocket. Mortgage offers with withdrawn. Rates went from 2% to 6% in a few weeks.

So on a typical 300k house, your repayment would have gone from £1100 to about £1700 depending on how much deposit you had. That's £600 a month taken from a household budget.

baroqueandblue · 15/09/2025 23:15

BallerinaRadio · 15/09/2025 18:28

I think after the the last 14 years we've endured he can have a bit more time

Is that the royal "we?" Because a lot of ordinary people are enduring austerity (by any other name) after 1 year under Starmer's Labour.

tipsyraven · 15/09/2025 23:07

Ihateboris · 15/09/2025 19:09

You are actually spot on there. He's just a puppet...and it shows

He doesn’t have any political acumen so is relying on his advisors who are making bad decisions. Everything that Labour has messed up could have been avoided by someone who was politically astute. The other problem they have is they don’t talk about the positive things they have done, the legislation they have passed for the better, so all the negative gets amplified. The press have a large part to play in this as much of it is anti-Labour and always has been so they aren’t going to highlight the positive.Trying to out-Reform Reform is never going to work either as it makes them look weak.

tipsyraven · 15/09/2025 22:58

Sodukuchess · 15/09/2025 18:30

You lost me at 'a lefty'.

Do we have 'a righty' alternative?

Same here.

TheNuthatch · 15/09/2025 22:55

x2boys · 15/09/2025 22:42

Well quite we all know the Tories ballsed up massively but they have gone
Labour are now in power and doing very badly at the moment, there's no point in saying yeah but Tories, that's over if things don't improve then neither the Conservative, s or Labour are going to be a viable choice and where does that leave us?

Yes agreed.
I've heard the rise of Reform described as breaking the emergency glass. I think that's an accurate description of where many people are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread