Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just split the house 50/50, even though I will walk away with debt & him with savings?

58 replies

miserableaboutmoney · 15/09/2025 11:45

In the process of separating from DH. We have DS19 and DD16, both in full-time education.

DH and I earn the same when working FT, but I went PT for 10years to be with the kids, save on childcare and also assist his elderly parents.

We own a house together. When we first met, I had about £25k of personal debt. I was later made redundant and had a payout, which I was planning to use to clear that debt. Instead, we used £15k of it for a house deposit and the rest for living expenses while I wasn’t working for 6months. During that time we lived with his parents rent-free and he was adding to the deposit pot from his earnings. By the time we bought the house, there was nearly £30k altogether.

Since then, we’ve split general household costs 50/50. I paid the debt repayments from my PT salary and often had nothing spare, sometimes resorting to credit cards just to get through the month. He, on the other hand, has been able to save. For big costs (holidays, house maintenance etc.) he’s generally covered them for the whole family.

I also homeschooled DD for 3 years (due to a mental health crisis), costing around £10k. I put that on a credit card (with DH’s agreement). The plan was to repay it from her higher education ISA in a few years (with her knowledge and consent), but in the meantime the debt is in my name and I’m paying the interest.

Money has been a big factor in our marriage and now we’re separating. For ease (and to keep things amicable), I’m leaning towards just splitting the house 50/50. I’d use my share to clear the debts and then we’d both go our separate ways.

But am I doing myself an injustice by not pushing for something like a 60/40 split, given that I’ll be leaving with debt while he has savings?

Worth saying: my debt is a mix of home-related stuff and, admittedly, my long-standing poor attitude to debt (it’s been part of my life since student days). I am really trying to get a grip on it now, but it feels unfair that I walk away with nothing while he walks away with savings.

Has anyone been in a similar position? What’s fair here?

OP posts:
Loveduppenguin · 15/09/2025 11:52

But it’s not just about you and him…it’s about the dc and the two of you being able to provide adequate housing for them by yourselves. EVERYTHING is taken into account and is considered in the decision making! Do you have solicitor? If no..get one! A good solicitor won’t let you come out with nothing and him with something!

miserableaboutmoney · 15/09/2025 11:51

Thanks guys. A couple of extra points (drip feed) but they seem less relevant now I’ve read these replies already.

  1. He ‘lent’ me £1k last year as I was struggling and he wants that back.
  2. We sold my car and he bought me a newer one that is ULEZ compliant that we can both use. He wants to be paid back for that.
  3. Both children would live with me when we separate.
OP posts:
Tessasanderson · 15/09/2025 11:51

Family assets and family debt split 50/50. Anything less is an insult

Hollietree · 15/09/2025 11:51

In a long marriage everything is shared.

The starting point is 50/50 on everything - The savings should be split 50/50. Pensions should be split 50/50. Debts should be spilt 50/50. Equity in the house is split 50/50.

However if one person has lower earning capacity, still has children at home, then they may be awarded more than 50%.

It is imperative that you see a solicitor and you don’t agree to anything with your Husband without doing that.

shoofly · 15/09/2025 11:51

I think you need proper legal advice on a financial settlement. It looks like you have taken all the financial hits during your marriage. There's an impact to your pension, from going part-time, to look after children and his parents.

50/50 is extremely unfair to you

AirborneElephant · 15/09/2025 11:48

Yes, you would be doing yourself a huge injustice and you will come to regret it. Insist on a proper 50:50 of all assets, including his pension, his savings, your debt, and the house equity. There’s absolutely no point giving him tens of thousands of pounds in the hope it will keep him amicable, it won’t.

Neodymium · 15/09/2025 11:48

And the savings

Neodymium · 15/09/2025 11:48

50/50 of everything including the debt.