Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's impossible to eat a UPF free diet as an ordinary person?

338 replies

MyHealthyMission · 13/09/2025 14:14

I mean ordinary as in, works full time, earns a decent but not huge wage, has free time but not entire days at a time to dedicate to cooking etc.

I'm on a bit of a health kick, and have turned my attention to eating whole foods and ensuring I'm eating as healthy as possible as we come into winter.

I've had a sourdough starter on the go for a while and decided I'd knock up some bread rolls and soup to have for lunch in the coming week because it's turned cold. Figured it would be a great, low UPF meal. Until I googled the beef stock, which is apparently a really bad UPF! Even the super expensive all natural concentrates are UPF. So unless you can afford to buy and boil a load of beef bones, it seems you're out of luck.

Obviously you can do the normal things like avoiding crisps, protein shakes etc. as they're all full of UPF, but when even things like stock cubes are stuffed full of them, it just seems impossible! AIBU to think it's just become impossible to eat a UPF free diet?

OP posts:
FancyBiscuitsLevel · 13/09/2025 15:50

Thank you to the suggestions on thread for frozen bone broth, will give that a whirl.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 13/09/2025 15:50

OP - you don’t need to eat bread. The idea that homemade sourdough is a health food yet homemade standard loaf is unhealthy is nonsense. The additives and stabilisers are the issue.

we bought a bread maker, it takes less then 5 mins to set it going at night, I have a fresh load the next morning, do that every other day for a standard “sandwich” loaf. Once a week we buy a sourdough loaf from a local baker, but as it’s not mass produced, we pay nearly £7 for that, it’s therefore a weekend treat.

I wouldn’t make my own jam, just buy good quality preserves. Look at the ingredients, it’s mainly sugar and fruit then go for it. The main ingredient in jam is sugar so if you are trying to have a healthier diet, replacing shop bought with home made ain’t going to do much. Try an organic nut butter instead. (If you need to stir it to get the oils back in before spreading, you know it’s a good one).

Toomanywaterbottles · 13/09/2025 15:50

But why on earth would you buy stock cubes? Of course they’re UPF. I make soup a lot and would never use a stock cube. If you haven’t got any leftover chicken bones from a Sunday lunch or whatever, just use a few veg instead to make a veg stock.

Rallentanda · 13/09/2025 15:49

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/09/2025 15:48

Not picking on you particularly, but Miso is not a UPF. It's a fermented food - one of the things that are recommended that we eat regularly in preference to UPFs.

Oh that's good - thanks! I just assumed.

MyHealthyMission · 13/09/2025 15:49

BogRollBOGOF · 13/09/2025 15:38

A cube of Oxo is not going to transform the quality of an otherwise healthy, nutritious meal made with natural ingredients into a Pot Noodle.

Some things are not worth being overly pedantic about.

We need to be careful about levels of processing and foods that are nutritious, but before mass-scale food production, food was expensive for a balanced diet and there was a major issue with mal-nutriton. It wasn't all a halcyon era of optimal health, especially in urban areas.

To me it just ruins the whole point. May as well eat a tin of Heinz for all the effort, just for it to end up the UPF!

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/09/2025 15:48

Rallentanda · 13/09/2025 14:37

I really don't want to be a smug mumsnetter type but honestly, we never use stock cubes or gravy granules or any of that stuff.

We always put chicken bones on for stock and dh sometimes goes out to buy beef bones for making stock in the pressure cooker.

Gravy is a reduction of the meat juices with a bit of wine or vermouth (UPFs I guess).

For added flavour, I use miso, like a pp said. It's a UPF for sure. An OXO cube is probably not worse.

In terms of things like bread, I just don't eat it much. Occasionally make a brown loaf and add wheatgerm. Or just buy one.

Not picking on you particularly, but Miso is not a UPF. It's a fermented food - one of the things that are recommended that we eat regularly in preference to UPFs.

Throneofgame · 13/09/2025 15:48

There's a reason why the phrase "perfection is the art of good" exists.

Theyreeatingthedogs · 13/09/2025 15:43

MyHealthyMission · 13/09/2025 14:27

But is it? Who has 6 hours free to make a sourdough every few days?!

Me! I bake a sourdough weekly. It's the only bread we eat apart from sourdough flatbreads that I also make. We use stock cubes. It doesn't have to be a 100% UPF free diet to be healthy. Ready meals, biscuits, crisps and their ilk are where you need to avoid UPFs.

GleisZwei · 13/09/2025 15:39

godmum56 · 13/09/2025 15:31

I only like it if it has no rye in it. Ocado do a good white one

No Ocado deliveries anywhere near us, thanks though.
Maybe Sourdough is an acquired taste, but I honestly find it just unpleasant.

Anabla · 13/09/2025 15:39

GleisZwei · 13/09/2025 14:27

It's unrealistic for me, and I can live with that. Overall I'm reasonably healthy.

This. I eat mostly homemade food and plenty fruit and vegetables but I have quite frankly better things to be worrying about and spending my time on than worrying about the health implications of one stock cube and boiling up a load of bones and vegetables every time I need to use stock to make grave.

BogRollBOGOF · 13/09/2025 15:38

A cube of Oxo is not going to transform the quality of an otherwise healthy, nutritious meal made with natural ingredients into a Pot Noodle.

Some things are not worth being overly pedantic about.

We need to be careful about levels of processing and foods that are nutritious, but before mass-scale food production, food was expensive for a balanced diet and there was a major issue with mal-nutriton. It wasn't all a halcyon era of optimal health, especially in urban areas.

ChelseaDetective · 13/09/2025 15:38

Procuring and processing food has since the beginning of humanity been one of our biggest and most time consuming challenges.

The harm you are so worried about is caused by commercially driven efforts to make it cheap and easy. Unless the only shop you have access to is a newsagent you don’t have to give in to it.

M & S do some lovely crisps which are just potatoes, oil, and salt, I adore crisps and for me choosing these 99% of the time over a packet of Frazzles (God I love Frazzles) is good enough.

Peculiah · 13/09/2025 15:37

I’ve come to terms with the fact that I’m actually a peasant, and not in any meaningful way rich despite enjoying a lovely 21st c lifestyle, that would be the envy of an 18th c aristocrat.

It’s built on bad foundations - I can travel the world, buy endless amounts of clothes, eat a wide variety of food from around the world, fill my home with furniture and furnishings and labour saving devices.

But if I want to eat organic, unadulterated, locally sourced, seasonal food, and wear clothes that aren’t made by children working in slave conditions and out of fabrics that destroy the environment, suddenly my money doesn’t stretch as far. Time, energy and labour are limited commodities too.

It’s definitely not easy @MyHealthyMission and it’s not fair that convenience comes at such a high price. Particularly when, for most people, it’s not a person choice between working outside the home or devoting hours to cooking; it’s an economic necessity.

I use the Yuka app when I’m shopping so I can pick from the best of a bad lot, and just do my best where I can. Try not to let perfection be the enemy of better.

R0ckandHardPlace · 13/09/2025 15:35

MyHealthyMission · 13/09/2025 15:12

Because forcing people to eat UPFs which are pretty awful for you, should not be the norm?

Nobody is being forced. Imagine if food wasn’t mass-produced, and contained no preservatives and everyone bought UPF free bread instead. You’d have to visit a bakery every day to buy it because it would go stale after a few hours. It would also cost three times as much because of the labour involved in making it. The alternative is to mass-produce it, but then it must contain preservatives to give it a long shelf life to account for transportation. Or you make it yourself.

Unless you know of some magic science that nobody else has discovered for keeping bread fresh, there’s no alternative.

notnorman · 13/09/2025 15:33

ArcticBlue · 13/09/2025 14:36

Buy the m&s liquid stock, ingredients for the beef one are "Water · Beef Bones · Chicken Bones · Salt · Tomato Purée · Yeast Extract · Onions · Carrots · Leeks · Parsley · Garlic · White Peppercorns · Ground Bay Leaf."

Came here to say this!

soupyspoon · 13/09/2025 15:33

Also food shouldnt really be cheap should it? It takes a lot to grow and cultivate crops and raise livestock.

How cheap and easy was it when we had to hunt our own or wait for it to fatten and grow?

soupyspoon · 13/09/2025 15:31

Bloody sourdough again. I started a thread about this, bloody sick of hearing about the stuff.

Also I dongt use stock cubes, you dont need to

godmum56 · 13/09/2025 15:31

GleisZwei · 13/09/2025 15:20

Am I the only one who finds Sourdough bread revolting? And, before anyone comments, yes it is 'proper' Sourdough made by a local baker and not supermarket 'fake' Sourdough. Give me standard wholegrain any day!

I only like it if it has no rye in it. Ocado do a good white one

godmum56 · 13/09/2025 15:30

Complet · 13/09/2025 15:02

Why ‘should’ it be? It can be, certainly, but some people enjoying taking a lot of time and effort cooking.

Why can’t you have crisps? Choose the ones that are just potatoes and salt. Vegetable soup takes minutes and is cheap and easy if that’s your preference. Roast a chicken and boil the carcass and veg scraps while you’re eating your dinner.

You can make it easier for yourself if that’s your priority. And you can definitely make sourdough in a bread maker.

have you got a recipe please? I know you can make sourfaux which is a sourdough mix with added yeast and there is a method where you switch from cycle to cycle to get the long ferment rise but I'd love a genuine no faff breadmaker sourdough recipe!

phoenixrosehere · 13/09/2025 15:26

MyHealthyMission · 13/09/2025 15:12

Because forcing people to eat UPFs which are pretty awful for you, should not be the norm?

Who is forcing people?

We’re all capable of reading the ingredients of packaging and making a decision on whether or not we want to eat it or not, and if not knowing what something is, looking it up on our phones.

You either make it yourself or pay the bit extra to buy the foods without upfs. There are plenty of options out there.

EmpressaurusKitty · 13/09/2025 15:25

Making sourdough is easy though, it’s nearly all waiting. Or am I missing something?

arethereanyleftatall · 13/09/2025 15:21

My dd eats only whole foods and now we’re used to it, it’s quite easy.
regards to stock, we’ve been blown away by how little the difference is between a stock cube and nothing- well just water.
boiling bones isn’t that hard, she’s got an oxtail stew on the go right now.
will do a chicken after we’ve had a roast etc

Foragingfox · 13/09/2025 15:20

You’re not the only one, my dh absolutely refuses to eat sourdough!

GleisZwei · 13/09/2025 15:20

Am I the only one who finds Sourdough bread revolting? And, before anyone comments, yes it is 'proper' Sourdough made by a local baker and not supermarket 'fake' Sourdough. Give me standard wholegrain any day!

Lifecanbebeautiful12 · 13/09/2025 15:19

It’s very difficult to make your own versions of UPFs but it’s definitely not impossible to eat a UPF free diet. Just eat whole, natural foods ie oats, spelt, lentils, potatoes, vegetables etc. You don’t need to be making your own sourdough breads and beef stocks to be healthy, that’s just unsustainable and unnecessary

Swipe left for the next trending thread