Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Now the Australians are protesting

430 replies

MiddleAgedMusings · 08/09/2025 23:17

Their main target is Indians.
Indians. Who have come legally - not on boats - but on aeroplanes, with the correct visas, who are students seeking further education in order to train as doctors, nurses, or whatever so that they can give back to Australia - Or they are already trained in a profession that the government has outlined has a shortage.

Australia is absolutely solid to get into with specific qualifications or experience being a mandatory requirement and the financial means to support one self. The whole western world constantly puts Australia on a pedestal for not being a soft touch for immigration. How are these protesters questioning the value of this diaspora's contribution to the Australian economy, and how can anybody deny that it's pure racism?

Australia doesn't have a problem luring white British nurses and doctors to their shores with generous repatriation packages, but an Indian nurse or doctor aren't good enough. Australians don't have a problem with their white teenagers or graduates emigrating to western countries for 10 years before fucking off back to Australia when it's time to settle down, but god forbid anybody does it the other way

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2025/sep/05/melbourne-immigration-migrated-indians-targeted-racist-messaging-asking-why-ntwnfbArticle
Link will work without paywall, press downwards arrow.

'Is this the same Melbourne I migrated to?' Indians targeted by racist messaging are asking why them

Shock and concern as ‘peace-loving and law-abiding’ community subjected to ‘hateful behaviour’

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2025/sep/05/melbourne-immigration-migrated-indians-targeted-racist-messaging-asking-why-ntwnfb

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Moonlightbean123 · 09/09/2025 14:42

IllBeLookingAtTheMoon · 09/09/2025 13:59

It's not really like that as you would know if you had spent time there.

Coming from someone who spent alot of time in Melbourne this is exactly how white Australians are! Lots of offensive names they made up too for other groups of non whites or even white ppl from other countries. Massively entitled , hence why Australia has overwhelmingly rejected a plan to give greater political rights to Indigenous people in a referendum. Quoted from the bbc

FirstNationsEnglish · 09/09/2025 14:42

@Starlia Let’s start with reparations for slavery

No, let's not.

TheignT · 09/09/2025 14:40

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:21

Agreed. We’ve all benefitted from slavery, so we should all have paid.

Edited

You think black people should be paying compensation to slave owners.

The world is truly crazy.

TheignT · 09/09/2025 14:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Do you know any of your ancestors who directly suffered at the hands of the Romans or Vikings?

My husband is almost 89. He knew his grandfather who was the first generation in his family born a free man. He was born on the plantation where his family had been slaves. We can look at the stock books from that plantation and see the records of his family because they were recorded as stock like the horses and pigs. Not quite the same is it.

Elbowpatch · 09/09/2025 14:32

MooseLooseAboutTheHoose · 09/09/2025 14:26

No, it’s more likely it was spent to keep their own on side as they were unable to quell the unrest in the colonies, slavery was rightly collapsing and those that ‘owned’ slaves were rich and powerful so had to be kept happy.

I don’t believe for a second it was done out of the goodness of the British heart.

Perhaps do some research into why attitudes to slavery started to change around the end of the 18th century. You might be surprised at what you find.

Slabberon · 09/09/2025 14:28

Itstwelveoclocksomewhere · 09/09/2025 14:03

‘Not this again’?

Really?

The Irish were starved by the British but YOU think the Irish need to get over it???

Oh and the Irish need to remember not to bring it up in a thread about emigration?

I don’t think so.

Edited

exactly! The British history curriculum likes to focus on Elizabeth the first, Industrial Revolution, Skip over to WW1&-2 then Brits wonder why all the other nations who get taught about colonialism, the British man-made famines in Ireland, and how Britain royally fucked up in Africa, Palestine, India, Northern Ireland and everywhere else get pissed off about it.

MooseLooseAboutTheHoose · 09/09/2025 14:26

Elbowpatch · 09/09/2025 14:23

What difference does it make where it came from? It was spent to free slaves. It didn’t have to be.

It was spent to free slaves because slavery had become unpalatable to the majority in Britain.

No, it’s more likely it was spent to keep their own on side as they were unable to quell the unrest in the colonies, slavery was rightly collapsing and those that ‘owned’ slaves were rich and powerful so had to be kept happy.

I don’t believe for a second it was done out of the goodness of the British heart.

Elbowpatch · 09/09/2025 14:26

MooseLooseAboutTheHoose · 09/09/2025 14:23

I know, ridiculous point… all that money was given to slave ‘owners’ as well, not a penny given to the formerly enslaved! And those that were ‘freed’ were actually still forced to work, without pay, for their former enslavers on an apprenticeship’ for many years afterwards… that £20m was literally just money for their boys, not an admirable act to end slavery.

@Elbowpatchi think you’re having a good time with pulling figures out of an AI platform today are you? 😅

No AI used at all.

Historical facts, well documented.

Elbowpatch · 09/09/2025 14:23

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:14

Are you serious? All that money was EARNT from slavery FFS!

What difference does it make where it came from? It was spent to free slaves. It didn’t have to be.

It was spent to free slaves because slavery had become unpalatable to the majority in Britain.

MooseLooseAboutTheHoose · 09/09/2025 14:23

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:14

Are you serious? All that money was EARNT from slavery FFS!

I know, ridiculous point… all that money was given to slave ‘owners’ as well, not a penny given to the formerly enslaved! And those that were ‘freed’ were actually still forced to work, without pay, for their former enslavers on an apprenticeship’ for many years afterwards… that £20m was literally just money for their boys, not an admirable act to end slavery.

@Elbowpatchi think you’re having a good time with pulling figures out of an AI platform today are you? 😅

Rainydayinlondon · 09/09/2025 14:22

Starlia · 09/09/2025 12:37

This is just horrific.

@Starlia what is horrific?

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:21

TheignT · 09/09/2025 14:18

British tax payers were paying off the loans that funded the compensation until 2015. Just think of all the descendants of slaves who were paying off those debts their whole working lives. Of course no compensation for the slaves.

Agreed. We’ve all benefitted from slavery, so we should all have paid.

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:20

Daygloboo · 09/09/2025 13:47

Someone on here mentioned the Sikh people being targeted in this latest incident. This is so unfair. I would like to second what the poster said about the Sikh community. I am white, and I live in England, and I have had many positive encounters with the Sikh community.. They do indeed have a tradition of helping with charitable causes in the community and I think they should be recognised for that. They do not deserve to be targeted at all.

It’s not fair to attack ANY community.

As a British Asian, I have defended my fellow Asians from racism and aggression from white people whatever their religion, whether Muslim, Sikh or Hindu.

Please don’t try and play this divide and conquer game.

TheignT · 09/09/2025 14:18

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:14

Are you serious? All that money was EARNT from slavery FFS!

British tax payers were paying off the loans that funded the compensation until 2015. Just think of all the descendants of slaves who were paying off those debts their whole working lives. Of course no compensation for the slaves.

Coolasfeck · 09/09/2025 14:16

From what I’ve read online my understanding is that Indian people are being targeted in Australia (and Canada) because there’s a belief that in recent years they have dominated/ received preference in regard to immigration into those countries.

There’s also a belief that on top of tech jobs being offshored to India, Indians are also moving to the West to take up jobs in large numbers.

I have also read that there is sentiment among some Australians and Canadian’s that once an Indian national gets a senior position/becomes a hiring manager they implement racist hiring practices to hire other Indians over others.

These are not my opinions, I don’t live in those countries but it’s stuff I’ve seen online. It looks like this has been bubbling under the surface for a while.

nomas · 09/09/2025 14:14

Elbowpatch · 09/09/2025 14:12

There is no need to pretend.

The British spent a huge amount of money preventing slavery. Paying compensation to slave owners and stationing naval forces off the coast of Africa with no other purpose than to police its anti-slavery stance. That cost money, lots of it. Slave owners received approximately £20 million in compensation from the government in 1837. That is equivalent to nearly £2,000,000,000 in today’s money.

You don’t do that if all you are interested in is profit.

Edited

Are you serious? All that money was EARNT from slavery FFS!

TheignT · 09/09/2025 14:13

Daygloboo · 09/09/2025 14:03

Well.of course, but someone said it was the Sikh community that was targeted so.....

So no one should be targeted.

Elbowpatch · 09/09/2025 14:12

nomas · 09/09/2025 12:20

The British ended slavery because it wasn’t as profitable anymore and because of the massive revolts in places like Jamaica.

So please don’t pretend Britain ended slavery for moral reasons.

Britain is what it is due to the blood, sweat and tears of slavery and colonial rule and people need to remember that.

Edited

There is no need to pretend.

The British spent a huge amount of money preventing slavery. Paying compensation to slave owners and stationing naval forces off the coast of Africa with no other purpose than to police its anti-slavery stance. That cost money, lots of it. Slave owners received approximately £20 million in compensation from the government in 1837. That is equivalent to nearly £2,000,000,000 in today’s money.

You don’t do that if all you are interested in is profit.

Itstwelveoclocksomewhere · 09/09/2025 14:03

Violinist64 · 09/09/2025 13:57

Oh, please. Not this again. It was terrible and should never have happened but it was nearly 200 years ago and no one who is alive today had anything to do with it. The British government of the time behaved very badly, we know that, but many, many British people were also living at subsistence level at that time. My ancestors on one side of my family were coal miners in the north of England. They would have had short and very hard lives with not enough to eat.

‘Not this again’?

Really?

The Irish were starved by the British but YOU think the Irish need to get over it???

Oh and the Irish need to remember not to bring it up in a thread about emigration?

I don’t think so.

Daygloboo · 09/09/2025 14:03

TheignT · 09/09/2025 13:51

No one should be targeted.

Well.of course, but someone said it was the Sikh community that was targeted so.....

IllBeLookingAtTheMoon · 09/09/2025 13:59

JJWT · 09/09/2025 13:41

Am I missing something? The white people know their race isn't from Oz, right?! What do the Aboriginal community think? Maybe they'd also "like their country back". You couldn't make it up, could you? People from Europe saying that people from Asia aren't welcome in Australasia. F me. "We stole it first.... "!

It's not really like that as you would know if you had spent time there.

Violinist64 · 09/09/2025 13:57

Itstwelveoclocksomewhere · 09/09/2025 10:02

I think you are not seeing the difference in legal v illegal immigration.

As for why so many Irish emigrated? Have you forgotten the Irish people’s food was taken from them to export to the UK by resulting in famine like consequences for the Irish population?

Oh, please. Not this again. It was terrible and should never have happened but it was nearly 200 years ago and no one who is alive today had anything to do with it. The British government of the time behaved very badly, we know that, but many, many British people were also living at subsistence level at that time. My ancestors on one side of my family were coal miners in the north of England. They would have had short and very hard lives with not enough to eat.

botheredandbewilderedagain · 09/09/2025 13:53

StarlightRobot · 09/09/2025 12:38

@nomas

I strongly disagree that the slave trade was abolished by Britain because it was no longer profitable. How much do you know about Wilberforce and his campaign against the slave trade and against slavery? He fought passionately for it and was instrumental in having this evil practice stopped. His motivation was driven by his faith and the horrors of slavery, and he relied on the evidence others produced which included brutal accounts from sailors and former slaves.

Other nations then followed the UK, although many dragged their feet and continued for decades longer (looking at you- USA, Spain, Portugal, Netherlands, Denmark, etc).

There is a lot of ignorance around the history of this

Have a read of this.

https://www.historyhit.com/reasons-why-britain-abolished-slavery/

Slavery was proving to be an uneconomic model and this, along with other reasons including slave rebellions, led to the abolition of slavery in Britain.

7 Reasons Why Britain Abolished Slavery

On 28 August 1833, the Slavery Abolition Act was given royal assent in Britain. This legislation terminated an institution that, for generations, had...

https://www.historyhit.com/reasons-why-britain-abolished-slavery/

TheignT · 09/09/2025 13:51

Daygloboo · 09/09/2025 13:47

Someone on here mentioned the Sikh people being targeted in this latest incident. This is so unfair. I would like to second what the poster said about the Sikh community. I am white, and I live in England, and I have had many positive encounters with the Sikh community.. They do indeed have a tradition of helping with charitable causes in the community and I think they should be recognised for that. They do not deserve to be targeted at all.

No one should be targeted.

TheignT · 09/09/2025 13:51

JJWT · 09/09/2025 13:41

Am I missing something? The white people know their race isn't from Oz, right?! What do the Aboriginal community think? Maybe they'd also "like their country back". You couldn't make it up, could you? People from Europe saying that people from Asia aren't welcome in Australasia. F me. "We stole it first.... "!

You'd think they'd realise unless they aren't very bright.

Then again in the 70s I worked with a woman who was moaning about waiting In a queue behind black people. She was most indignant as she told me her father fought in WWII to keep this country (England ) white. She was surprised when I told her the Nazis were the racists not the British.

Swipe left for the next trending thread