Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FIL letting DS have a couple of sips of beer

191 replies

GotaQuest · 08/09/2025 09:32

If IABU then fair enough but just wanted to get other people’s opinions.

Yesterday DH took DC to see his parents. When they got back 8yo DS told me that FIL let him have 2 sips of his bottled larger. This also happened a few months ago too and I told DH that I thought it was weird

DH thinks I’m being over the top and maybe I am but it doesn’t really sit right with me.

Would you be bothered about this?

OP posts:
NaiceBalonz · 08/09/2025 11:36

OSTMusTisNT · 08/09/2025 11:30

I wouldn't be impressed with this either. I once witnessed a toddler nephew being encouraged to dip his fingers/lick in everyone's whisky glass after Xmas dinner (30 years ago). Oh how they all laughed..

Not my kid but I told DH if his family ever try that with our kids they'll never be over the threshold again.

You sound lovely..

Comeinupto40 · 08/09/2025 11:34

Flakey99 · 08/09/2025 09:38

I’d be really angry about this as he’s normalising drinking alcohol to a young impressionable child!

Would it be ok if he offered him a drag on his cigarette too?

Edited

But normalising drinking in a healthy and responsible way is a good thing, no?

If you ban alcohol and make it taboo, your child will be curious about it and more likely to rebel as a teen by drinking alcohol to excess.

If you model sensible drinking e.g. one bottle of lager on an afternoon in the garden and let a child take a sip, this demystifies drinking and the child sees it as just another boring thing adults do (show me an 8 year old who liked the taste of lager and I’ll eat my hat!)

OSTMusTisNT · 08/09/2025 11:30

I wouldn't be impressed with this either. I once witnessed a toddler nephew being encouraged to dip his fingers/lick in everyone's whisky glass after Xmas dinner (30 years ago). Oh how they all laughed..

Not my kid but I told DH if his family ever try that with our kids they'll never be over the threshold again.

brunettemic · 08/09/2025 11:29

CRCGran · 08/09/2025 11:14

No... you check your information..... even small sips can affect a child. I don't peddle misinformation!!! And my post wasn't aggressive.... no need for yours to be. You can disagree without being disagreeable !!!!!

You by not adding loads of !!!!! ?

ThePerkyEagle · 08/09/2025 11:29

I think the fact it’s happened without asking your permission is a bit off. I wouldn’t be worried about my 8yo trying a couple of sips but on my terms.

FlayOtters · 08/09/2025 11:27

Flakey99 · 08/09/2025 09:38

I’d be really angry about this as he’s normalising drinking alcohol to a young impressionable child!

Would it be ok if he offered him a drag on his cigarette too?

Edited

oh behave. this isn't the same and you know it.

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 08/09/2025 11:27

My husband sells beer and actually makes beer now. My son has been taught to enjoy it for the taste and not for its alcohol percentage. We have let him taste it and now he's 16 he can have a bottle with his meal. He rarely drinks but appreciates it for the taste.
We had to be sensible about this due to my husbands job.

Goldengirl123 · 08/09/2025 11:24

No

CurtsyFriends · 08/09/2025 11:24

My Dad took me down the pub at a week old and gave me a little bit of beer. I was often allowed a shandy of some sort as a child with a meal. Never an excessive amount and not a weekly thing either.

But I never went out drinking as a teen or snuck alcohol from anywhere and as an adult I rarely drink and have only ever been drunk once in my life (I’m in my 40s) so I don’t think it did me any harm at all.

LadeOde · 08/09/2025 11:23

@OP While a 'one off' few sips of beer with granddad isn't going to harm them, and while many times people say allowing children small sips might demystify alcohol and reduce its allure, scientific evidence does not actually support this. In fact, studies suggest the opposite, that early exposure may normalize drinking behavior and increase long term risk. Introduction to alcohol in childhood is significantly associated with a higher risk of alcohol related problems in later life.

What Parents and Carers can do: (Chief Medical Officer's guidance)
"Parents and carers should ensure that their children maintain an alcohol-free childhood for as long as possible and at the very least up to and including the age of 14 years."
( Guidance on the consumption of Alcohol by children and young people, Page Xiii)

From the British Medical Journal:
Age of first drinking and adult alcohol problems: systematic review of prospective cohort studies | Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health
Conclusion: Early drinking coupled with underlying vulnerabilities e.g., mental health, peer influence shows evidence for increased risk of adult alcohol problems. So while it may not have much impact all things being perfect right now, it does lay the ground for later in life IF @OP's ds has any of thses issues.

Focuses on hospital admission & mortality but includes data on under 18 alcohol specific admissions and reveals a trend in early alcohol related harm. The implication is that early drinking correlates with increased long term causality.
Alcohol profile: short statistical commentary, February 2025 - GOV.UK

Better safe than sorry @OP, I'd stamp that down immediately.

https://jech.bmj.com/content/68/3/268

SwallowsandAmazonians · 08/09/2025 11:22

I do this so not a big deal as far as I'm concerned, kids are curious but the never like it.

But he absolutely shouldn't do it if you've asked him not to.

Ummm and also OBVIOUSLY a whole shot of whiskey regularly to encourage sleep is bad and a whole different thing.

OreoCookay · 08/09/2025 11:19

The bottom line is children process the alcohol differently and it binds with their cells in a way that has been suggested will make them alcohol dependent as they get older.

I believe it. My parents used to drop a shot of whiskey into a hot milk to knock me out when I was under 10 and they wanted me to go to sleep - and it definitely had a long term affect on me.

MageQueen · 08/09/2025 11:19

Um, I think your so all those who think it's ok, you just carry on!!! etc was pretty aggressive.

But mostly, I think your post was ridiculous. and my post wasn't aggressive, it was incredulous.

Your asserts are just blatantly untrue that these are real risks for children having just tiny sips of alcohol.

Give me some stats on how many children are harmed every year from 2 small sips of beer. I'll wait.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/09/2025 11:18

Elephantangel1991 · 08/09/2025 09:44

From my experience children who have little sips of wine and beer with adults tend to get less overexcited by it as teenagers. I'd say it if anything might minimise the risks of binge drinking. They associate it with boring old people stuff.

I remember my friend's mum giving us a try of a cigarette as a young teenager. We thought it was so yucky, never tried one again!

Same. My DF used to give us little sips occasionally - none of us turned into anything like alcoholics! I do remember liking what he called ‘Sticky Green’ (Crème de Menthe) but as for the rest of it, no thanks!

CRCGran · 08/09/2025 11:14

MageQueen · 08/09/2025 10:39

This is so ridiculous. These risks are from significant amounts of alcohol. A child grabbing a glass of red wine and downing it or whatever. Not from a couple of tiny sips.

Be anti alcohol in any amount for young children, that's fine. But peddling ridiculous over the top risks doesn't actually do your argument any good.

No... you check your information..... even small sips can affect a child. I don't peddle misinformation!!! And my post wasn't aggressive.... no need for yours to be. You can disagree without being disagreeable !!!!!

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 08/09/2025 11:13

Mine had tiny sips as children. They grew up with a sensible attitude to alcohol and haven't binge drunk or been involved other alcohol related incidents.

Cherrytree86 · 08/09/2025 11:13

Go no contact with him, OP @GotaQuest

Oriunda · 08/09/2025 11:12

We’re a European family, where attitude to drink can be different. I’ve been letting my DS try my wine when we’re out to dinner since he was 9. I tell him about different grapes and varieties of wine. Now he’s 13, we’ve moved on to offering him sips of cocktails etc, and he enjoyed a champagne tasting with me recently, trying a sip of each and giving me his opinion. We drink very much in moderation; he associates drinking with food.

Quite often we’ll offer him a sip and he declines now. It’s no big deal to him, since it’s not a forbidden thing.

Fluffyblackcat7 · 08/09/2025 11:11

BendingSpoons · 08/09/2025 09:41

DH lets DC have a sip of his alcohol occasionally. They never like it! I found it strange at first. I think his view is that it takes away the 'forbidden' aspect of it

Yes, this is my experience as a mum: my dh began encouraging ds to try a sip of bitter at around that age. I don't consider it to be harmful. All it does is let the child confirm for themselves that it tastes really horrible and they don't want to drink it.

I was OK with this, as it's the way I was brought up. I was even given a very small glass of wine (think shot glass) with Sunday lunch from about that age. My parents saw it as teaching me to drink responsibility in a social context.

I still drank enough to be uncomfortably drunk to the point where the room spun and I vomited a couple of times as an older teenager but then we all have to find our limits and I never did it again.

I almost never drink now as an adult. I don't think it's compatible with parenting but my dh will drink an absolute maximum of 2 pints of beer one night/week when socialising at the pub.

I think that your own attitude to and history with alcohol matters a lot:

If you have family members or are yourself an alcoholic then maybe you fear what happened to Drew Barrimore. Maybe your child does have a pathological potential for alcoholism. In which case, I think you are perfectly justified in asking everyone to keep alcohol out of their reach. Ask them to think about it like a food allergy, except there's no epipen and it could wreck/shorten their life considerably. You are not being unreasonable and should talk to your child in an age appropriate way about why alcohol could be unusually dangerous for them.

If you are teetotal for religious reasons, again you are not being unreasonable in asking people not to give your child alcohol, maybe in the same way as you want adults to discourage your child from swearing or telling lies? I don't know. This isn't my background but I still think it's entirely reasonable and you should talk to your child about your beliefs too so that they understand why they are not offered alcohol.

In both cases, it is quite reasonable to ask uncle to stop allowing your ds sips of alcohol and not allow ds around them unsupervised if you don't trust them to respect your decision.

If it is just a vague feeling of unease with no ethical, religious or health concern then, gently, I think that you might be a little overanxious and you can relax on this one.

Maybe just stipulate no spirits as I think that could genuinely be a health issue.

My elder db was given a dummy dipped in whisky if he couldn't sleep (different times!) and unsurprisingly has a glass of whisky every evening before bed!

As an aside, two generations back an evening glass of whisky was legitimately prescribed to my great uncle by his Harley Street consultant as a cure for stress!

Sorry for the two slightly off topic family anecdotes.

I think you just need to think through your reaction and your reasons for it and act accordingly. If you feel that you do need to forbid the occasional few sips of beer for health or religious reasons, then get your husband onside and make it clear to your relatives. Otherwise, relax, it's really no biggie.

nam3c4ang3 · 08/09/2025 11:10

I don’t particular have an issue with it - my kids have a sip of champagne or Buck’s Fizz at Christmas- they don’t really like it tbf - when my eldest got into secondary school she had a sip of champagne to celebrate. They don’t ask for it. But this is what YOUR comfortable with OP - not us.

Bolognesdiva · 08/09/2025 11:08

I think this is a fairly normal thing to do - my two DS often had a sip of our drinks - one ( like me ) didn’t like the taste , the other - well we have advance warning he is going to like it which gives plenty of time to make sure he understands the down sides .. currently 15

CinnamonBuns67 · 08/09/2025 11:07

I wouldn't be impressed that FIL didn't ask you or Dad if it was alright first but I wouldn't get worked up over it either.

Rainallnight · 08/09/2025 11:05

I would be horrified by this and DS wouldn’t be going back there till a conversation was had.

@namechangedjustforthisthreadtoday is exactly right. The evidence doesn’t support the notion that drinking at home helps children develop a healthier attitude to alcohol. It’s the opposite.

Definitelynotme2022 · 08/09/2025 11:04

CuriousKangaroo · 08/09/2025 09:44

I watched in horror recently, as my brother in law let his 9 year old have a couple of sips of beer, and then two (admittedly very small) glasses of champagne. It is unlikely to cause any physical damage, but it normalises the idea of children drinking alcohol and associating it with being “grown up.” The son was clearly thrilled by the whole thing and kept asking for more. Psychologically I can’t see that can be a good thing.

Ultimately, what is the point anyway? Maybe a tiny glass wine with a meal when they are 16 plus is ok. But there is no good reason to allow children as young as 8 or 9 to have alcohol.

This.... and I'm the first to admit that I've done it with all 4 of my dc's, but I wouldn't ever do it again. You can't go back from it.

My ds is having some behavioural issues, and drinking alcohol has been one of the things he's done. Thinking that I've in some way contributed to normalising it is really tough.

Swipe left for the next trending thread