Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DC skipped their first day. AIBU about DP’s reaction

491 replies

BlondeSpider · 03/09/2025 22:03

I do not even know where to start because my head is all over the place. Today was supposed to be such a big day for us. DS is 14 and was due to start at a 14 plus college after being out of school for more than a year. He stopped going back just after Christmas in year 8. His mental health had been declining for a while before that and then I found out he had been self harming. His anxiety was through the roof and it got to the point where he just could not manage. CAMHS were no help at all. I felt like I was banging my head against a brick wall every time I tried to get support. Eventually I deregistered him from school and homeschooled. It has been very up and down but he is bright and when he is calm he is lovely. I paid privately in the end for an autism assessment because waiting for the NHS was going to take years. He now has a diagnosis which in some ways was a relief but also quite overwhelming.

This summer has been really hard. DS has been difficult to live with. He is angry a lot of the time and everything is an argument. His anxiety is still there and when he is stressed it turns into lashing out verbally and sometimes physically. We have had things thrown, doors slammed, endless shouting matches. It has been exhausting, I think it's mostly due to puberty as he's had a growth spurt recently and his voice has dropped

DD is his twin. She has generally managed better with school and life in general but she has been struggling too, especially with his behaviour. She loves him and worries about him and is quite protective over him. She was supposed to be starting year 10 today which is a big year with GCSEs coming up.

This morning they both set out together for the bus stop. DS was nervous but I felt cautiously hopeful. It felt like maybe this was a turning point. But they never went. They did not get on the bus and they were gone most of the day. They ignored my calls and texts and would not say where they were. When they finally came home later on it all kicked off.

DP was furious. He immediately took their phones off them which caused a huge row. DS completely lost it and hit DP on the arm. DP reacted by shoving him back. It was not hard enough to hurt but it was physical and I just feel really uncomfortable about that. Then DP turned on DD and shouted at her for not making sure DS went in and for covering for him. He told her she had let everyone down. She just stood there crying.

I honestly do not know what to think. I understand why DP was so angry because I was too. We have been through hell trying to get DS back into education and today felt like such an important chance. But at the same time I feel like DP handled it badly. DD should not have had all that responsibility put on her and I do not think shouting at her was fair at all. And even though DS hit him first I still do not like that he shoved him back. The atmosphere in the house is awful now and I feel like we are right back at square one.

AIBU to think DP was too heavy handed and made things worse. Or am I just being soft?

OP posts:
PennywisePoundFoolish · 04/09/2025 09:47

BlondeSpider · 04/09/2025 09:33

It seems posters having read all my replies when asking questions. I still stick by that even if I take him once in the car he'll expect that. For those challenging it, you don't know him and clearly don't have an autistic child, he's all about routine and if he's thrown off that it makes him very anxious and has a meltdown which isn't ideal before college as then he’ll be thrown off for the rest of the day as after a meltdown he usually just wants to go to bed. DP didn't shove him away after being hit, DS hit him and walked off and then DP shoved him. DP is also over 6ft, DS is about 5’5 so he wasn't in danger of being hurt. Yes, he shouldn't hit but shoving him really isn't going to teach him that. I firstly wouldve sat him down and tried to talk to him about why he didn't go (and DD)and what part he was so anxious about instead of going in all guns blazing and taking phones.

DD is good at going to school usually and does well, her behaviour is good too but she does worry about DS. She was having counselling via school as hearing her brother shouting he wants to kill himself at 12 obviously has affected her and likely would at any age. She's not a young carer to him. They play games and watch films but that's normal with siblings, she is protective over him and they'd always been together really in Education, in primary school they were always in the same class and in secondary they had some of the same classes until I deregistered DS. They can't be separated on the bus though as there's only really one they can take, they come once every 45 minutes (though they're so unreliable its normally closer to an hour).

To the people saying they wouldn't let a man who's not their dad rule the house, why do you think I'm planning to leave? He still hasn't given their phones back, I think he's taken them to work. I ended up taking DD to school and DS hasn't gone as he's just lying in bed hiding under his duvet and not talking to any of us which he hasn't been like in ages. So yes, he has made it worse and I'm not going to apologise to DP for blaming him as some have said (haven't even said I blame him to his face either).

Bluntly, your son can't manage independent travel to the college. I know how difficult it is to find work that fits around DC who are EHE/part time attendance/can't manage transport, I've been there and I'm still there.

You know DS is not choosing to be anxious. You're (understandably imo) angry at your DP for him not recognising this. But you also have to accept that you will need to support DS with the travel.

Summerlilly · 04/09/2025 09:44

Everyone is the wrong in different ways.
Taking the phones though. That is an appropriate punishment, neither one of them bothered to call you or even answer when you called them so if they can’t use them for their intended use, they lose them. I would have been so worried if I was in that situation and couldn’t contact either of them.

I find it interesting how you keep trying to avoid any blame here and keep putting this on your DP. You are also at fault here for not taking him to school on the first day. Going back to work soon isn’t an excuse for not stepping up and taking him during what is an incredibly stressful time for him.
Getting him back to school is a hurdle, but it’s not just the first day. It’s multiple hurdles. He has ASD and mental health issues, but it’s disingenuous to say he won’t adjust to going another way after that first time. I’m sure he has adapted plenty over his years of life and he would’ve also with the bus once you put the plans and steps in place.

I wonder if the reason your DP went hard at them is because he knew you wouldn’t dole out any consequences on them at all.
I hope your DD is okay, she didn’t deserve to be yelled at and he absolutely was out of line for that.

Give DD back her phone in the morning and send her to school. Then communicate with your son after they all have gone.
You are their parent if you don’t want DP disciplining them then say something. But you also have out boundaries and consequences in. Then the pair of you need to communicate.

Lovingbooks · 04/09/2025 09:43

You need to focus on DS this is a child who has been school refusing. He now is not in school the second day and you are still blaming your DP by confiscating phones. Surely you understand this was a punishment for them skipping school and not answering when you tried to find out where they were. Lots of issues sound like going on but how you think you are going to hold down a job when your DS is refusing school?

Almostwelsh · 04/09/2025 09:42

It does seem unfair for your daughter to be blamed for her brother not going to school. However a teenage boy who hits people when stressed is going to get a lot more than a shove in future, so it's best he learns that now.

I know it's not a good thing generally to physically discipline children, but I do think teen boys sometimes need a physical demonstration of power from an older man to keep them in check. I'm not suggesting a beating, but a teen boy who lays hands on someone should be left with no illusions that this is an option for him in future. We sometimes hear about older teens who rule over family members with fear due to violence when having meltdowns and it's not acceptable that they have learned this is an option, it needs to be slapped down immediately.

CautiousLurker01 · 04/09/2025 09:41

Anon501178 · 04/09/2025 09:36

Are you sure your partner isn't the cause of at least some of your children's behavioural and emotional difficulties?! He doesn't sound like he manages his own emotions well at all if he is shoving an autistic child, shouting at your daughter and to make it worse doesn't even seem to see any issue with his reaction.Does he usually behave any better?

Was about to post this - I think your priority may be to leave him. I’d speak to Citizen’s Advice about getting on a social housing list to escape an abusive relationship and because your children are at risk.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/09/2025 09:39

User364431 · 04/09/2025 09:07

Imagine the situation was reversed and a mother started a thread about being the sole provider of her unemployed partner and two stepchildren, one of whom is an autistic school refuser. The comments would probably tell her to leave the situation ASAP whilst painting her as a saint for taking on the responsibility of someone else's children for so long.

So, if her DP has been such a saint for taking all of this on, why does OP want to leave him ? I suspect there’s a lot more to this than meets the eye. And I wholeheartedly agree with a pp who said a NT response to an ASD issue is the root of the problem. It sounds to me as though DP doesn’t understand autism and doesn’t want to. Which is a huge problem for the OP.

Anon501178 · 04/09/2025 09:36

BlondeSpider · 03/09/2025 23:29

I gave up work because DS was actively going through a MH crisis so I obviously couldn't leave him home alone. I don't think DP would agree to me staying home just to drive him in as he'd definitely see that as me doing nothing.

I did say that's how he soothes but DP said he doesn't deserve his phone, I have no idea where he's put them. I also told him not to talk to DD like that and he just blanked me. My main focus was making sure both DC were ok.

Are you sure your partner isn't the cause of at least some of your children's behavioural and emotional difficulties?! He doesn't sound like he manages his own emotions well at all if he is shoving an autistic child, shouting at your daughter and to make it worse doesn't even seem to see any issue with his reaction.Does he usually behave any better?

katepilar · 04/09/2025 09:34

BlondeSpider · 04/09/2025 00:27

As soon as they walked in DP was shouting at them etc so no, I don't know what part DS was anxious about as he's now just lying in bed refusing to talk. He won't listen to music any other way. It has to be using his phone and his headphones, it's just part of the routine

It sounds like your husband is acting out of uncontrollable anger and wants to hand out punisments without looking at the bigger picture. I dont like this at all. How do you feel about it? Does he have a form for this controlling bahaviour?

rainbowstardrops · 04/09/2025 09:34

What a shit show. I imagine there’s a lot more going on here than your partner being angry that your children skipped school. What is the relationship like between the three of them usually? Do they like him? You say that you need to work in order to be able to leave him, so what else has been going on?
You’re not working and you know how anxious and the level of his MH issues, so I agree with others, you really should have either driven him in, or gone on the bus with him. You didn’t and now here you are.
Your partner shouldn’t have snatched their phones from them because now they will both shut down and you’re further back than square one. So yeah, a shit show.
You can’t work if your son doesn’t go to college, so that has to be your priority. End of. If that means driving him every day then that’s what you’re going to need to do.
You need to contact the college, explain what happened and ask for support going forward.
And apologise to your poor daughter who is stuck in the middle of this mess.

BlondeSpider · 04/09/2025 09:33

It seems posters having read all my replies when asking questions. I still stick by that even if I take him once in the car he'll expect that. For those challenging it, you don't know him and clearly don't have an autistic child, he's all about routine and if he's thrown off that it makes him very anxious and has a meltdown which isn't ideal before college as then he’ll be thrown off for the rest of the day as after a meltdown he usually just wants to go to bed. DP didn't shove him away after being hit, DS hit him and walked off and then DP shoved him. DP is also over 6ft, DS is about 5’5 so he wasn't in danger of being hurt. Yes, he shouldn't hit but shoving him really isn't going to teach him that. I firstly wouldve sat him down and tried to talk to him about why he didn't go (and DD)and what part he was so anxious about instead of going in all guns blazing and taking phones.

DD is good at going to school usually and does well, her behaviour is good too but she does worry about DS. She was having counselling via school as hearing her brother shouting he wants to kill himself at 12 obviously has affected her and likely would at any age. She's not a young carer to him. They play games and watch films but that's normal with siblings, she is protective over him and they'd always been together really in Education, in primary school they were always in the same class and in secondary they had some of the same classes until I deregistered DS. They can't be separated on the bus though as there's only really one they can take, they come once every 45 minutes (though they're so unreliable its normally closer to an hour).

To the people saying they wouldn't let a man who's not their dad rule the house, why do you think I'm planning to leave? He still hasn't given their phones back, I think he's taken them to work. I ended up taking DD to school and DS hasn't gone as he's just lying in bed hiding under his duvet and not talking to any of us which he hasn't been like in ages. So yes, he has made it worse and I'm not going to apologise to DP for blaming him as some have said (haven't even said I blame him to his face either).

OP posts:
PiggyPigalle · 04/09/2025 09:32

"Today was supposed to be such a big day for us."
Sounds like it was all hyped too much, increasing expectation and creating anxiety.
When my 11 year old had to travel to school by train, we'd already done a trial run. Then on the first day of school, I travelled in the carriage but away from her.
You could do the same on the bus. Be in the queue and on the bus, but apart from him.

After your son was diagnosed privately, was he put on anti-anxiety medication and if so has it helped?
Unless your DP makes it a habit to shout and yell at the children, I've so many parents act that way when their kids turn up safe. I worked in a big London store near the customer service desk where lost children would be reported.
Without fail, whenever the child was reunited with the parent, it would start with a telling off, then would come the hugs and sometimes tears of relief.

Your 14 year kids were missing and uncontactable for a whole day! Your DP's mind was probably in overdrive, thinking county lines etc.

cocoromo · 04/09/2025 09:31

bunnypenny · 03/09/2025 22:23

who on earth thought that it was a good idea for both of them to go to the bus stop alone after the history you’ve detailed?

This with bells on

tinageta · 04/09/2025 09:27

I just wanted to say that MP3 players and dumbphones still exist. I often take them to the beach when I worry my actual phone could get stolen. A dumb Nokia for your daughter will be about 20 pounds, the same for MP3 player for your son.

justasking111 · 04/09/2025 09:27

You need to separate the children ensure that your daughter goes in and lives her own life. She's not the parent and shouldn't have the responsibility.

WitchesofPainswick · 04/09/2025 09:27

OP, you've said you want to work so you can leave your partner.

If this is the situation, you need to leave your partner now. I actually feel you are being enormously unfair to him - he is paying for you all, trying to parent (and sorry, but posts saying you are too soft and unrealistic are correct) - and you are ultimately not invested in this relationship anyway. He's probably desperately trying to get through the next few years and hope that he will have a life with you when they leave home.

Sort yourself out OP. If you want to leave him, then be honest and do so. And then parent the way you think is best, on your own. Good luck.

1543click · 04/09/2025 09:26

The college set up for him sounds great so you need to get him in. I'd be taking him myself for the next few weeks. Then you can start working on strategies so that he will take himself. Breaking it into small steps eg so that after a while you stop going into the gates with him , then you don't get off the bus at the stop with him( get off at the next one and pop back to check he's in) It absolutely can be done and will take a few weeks. But that will be better than home schooling for ever!

Aniedu · 04/09/2025 09:26

BlondeSpider · 03/09/2025 22:23

Even if I took him in just once that'd become the routine to him and I can't always take him in, I'm planning on going back to work which will be shifts so I won't always be around to drive him in. So the bus is the transport he'll be using and he needs to use it from day 1 really. They were getting the same bus except his stop was a few before DD’s right outside the college.

DD said she wasn't going to just leave him at the bus stop so she didn't go in either.

DP isn't their dad. And DS has been lying on his bed not really saying much just that he's not going tomorrow or any other day either. I feel like DP has made it worse, yes it's not ok for DS to have hit but doing it back isn't going to teach him anything? His phone is also a comfort item of his that he uses to listen to music when he's stressed.

I feel like I made the wrong decision with trying to get him back into education

Firstly, he doesn’t need to do it from day 1. From day 1 he needs to get used to being in a school environment again. I think you’ve expected a lot of him, maybe do it in stages- take him to begin with and once he’s settled
he gets the bus.

You’re making excuses with ‘comfort item’ having his phone is a privilege and ignoring calls is a hard line. He can listen to music some other way but I don’t think confiscating his phone is wrong - he needs to know this is serious and unacceptable.

with regards to the shove, I think it’s very hard to expect someone not to react at all when hit - a shove away is very different from a hit back- it depends what it was!

Glowstickparty · 04/09/2025 09:25

Also if he has an ehcp you can get a tutor funded for home. But you would need to be at home. Also look at alternative education provisions in your area.

Throwmoneyatit · 04/09/2025 09:25

Your kids were unable to be located, supposed to be in school and not answering their phones? And it's your partners fault?

With the huge backstory, why on earth didn't YOU take them? They're your children and your responsibility.

You knew that your ds would struggle and you left him to navigate buses and get to school. By sending him with his sister, yes you did put a lot of responsibility on them both.

I know you said you need to work but kids come first. Get a job between school hours.

Hiptothisjive · 04/09/2025 09:24

BlondeSpider · 03/09/2025 22:23

Even if I took him in just once that'd become the routine to him and I can't always take him in, I'm planning on going back to work which will be shifts so I won't always be around to drive him in. So the bus is the transport he'll be using and he needs to use it from day 1 really. They were getting the same bus except his stop was a few before DD’s right outside the college.

DD said she wasn't going to just leave him at the bus stop so she didn't go in either.

DP isn't their dad. And DS has been lying on his bed not really saying much just that he's not going tomorrow or any other day either. I feel like DP has made it worse, yes it's not ok for DS to have hit but doing it back isn't going to teach him anything? His phone is also a comfort item of his that he uses to listen to music when he's stressed.

I feel like I made the wrong decision with trying to get him back into education

OP please take a step back. You are looking at this through the lens of your children did nothing wrong and your DP was at fault.

Their phones needed to be taken and now you are making big excuses. Actions have consequences - skipping school and being physical.

I am not naive to autism and understand this needs to be taken into consideration but it doesn’t exclude all poor behaviour. A lot of kids with autism don’t hit people. Yea they meltdown especially after a hard day of masking, may self harm and may be difficult but they know not to put their hands on other people.

You need to set boundaries and be firm with clear communication and consequences.

No your DD shouldn’t have been responsible but she also skipped school, didnt tell you about DS or her, ignored calls and texts and then didnt like the consequence.

Your DP’s reaction was right and he was parenting - maybe not in the best way but at least tried. You have made excuses, shifted blame and checked out.

FairKoala · 04/09/2025 09:22

CallMeEvelyn · 04/09/2025 08:55

And it's not a good one.

Why isn’t it a good one? What coping/relaxing method would you use.

Fizzer5 · 04/09/2025 09:22

Your DS and DD are separate problems. DD seems to have become her twin brother's carer and she feels responsible for him.
From your post it seems she has taken this on to herself not that you expected it. Because it has become the norm I understand why he wrongly criticised her.
Please convince her not to appoint herself to this role and to live her own life and not be brought down by DS.
Ds and phone, he needs to learn about consequences to his actions.
Your DP is trying to help and support you OP he is in a difficult situation. He does not want you badly treated by your son or DD. Don't condemn everything about him. For one thing he is still with you, he hasn't left.

Glowstickparty · 04/09/2025 09:22

I have experience with dc that sound similar to your son. They can’t just walk into school after a year off without major anxiety. I would ask the school for a part time time table. Also drive them. You need to build up really gradually and understand his anxiety. Your poor dd sounds stuck in the middle. Is it a small school setting as that maybe what he needs. Your dp doesn’t seem to understand what your ds is going through.

waterrat · 04/09/2025 09:22

Have you had SS involvement? AS I think front door for families/ early help could be good here..

You need professional support in the home - not just at college

Y2ker · 04/09/2025 09:22

BlondeSpider · 03/09/2025 22:23

Even if I took him in just once that'd become the routine to him and I can't always take him in, I'm planning on going back to work which will be shifts so I won't always be around to drive him in. So the bus is the transport he'll be using and he needs to use it from day 1 really. They were getting the same bus except his stop was a few before DD’s right outside the college.

DD said she wasn't going to just leave him at the bus stop so she didn't go in either.

DP isn't their dad. And DS has been lying on his bed not really saying much just that he's not going tomorrow or any other day either. I feel like DP has made it worse, yes it's not ok for DS to have hit but doing it back isn't going to teach him anything? His phone is also a comfort item of his that he uses to listen to music when he's stressed.

I feel like I made the wrong decision with trying to get him back into education

You can accompany them on the bus for weeks though - however long is needed.