Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a little heartbroken about having a boy

408 replies

bm2b · 03/09/2025 20:52

I already have a daughter and recently found out that this baby is a boy. I feel incredibly grateful to be pregnant again, and I know how lucky I am to be carrying a healthy baby. I already love him, and I know I’ll adore him completely when he arrives. But I’ve been caught off guard by this quiet feeling of sadness that I didn’t expect.

I’m very close to my mum. We speak every day, go on little trips together, help each other out, and are part of each other’s daily lives. I’ve started to build something similar with my daughter, even though she’s still young, and I suppose I imagined continuing that dynamic with another girl.

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older, especially once they have partners and children of their own. It often ends up being the wife’s parents who are more involved, while his own mum becomes more of an occasional visitor.

Of course there are exceptions. I can think of the odd “friend of a friend’s cousin” whose son stayed close and prioritised both sides of the family equally, or doesn’t automatically side with his partner when she’s being unfair. But in my experience, that feels like the exception rather than the norm.

I also worry about what raising a boy will be like day to day. I know it’s a stereotype, but the boys I’ve been around — nephews, friends’ kids — tend to be more energetic, more physical, and more chaotic. I’m a bit afraid I won’t enjoy that stage as much, or that I won’t know how to connect with him in the same way.

If anyone has felt this way too, I’d love to hear from you. Especially mums of older boys — did the bond end up being just as close, even if it looked a bit different? What parts of having a son surprised you in a good way?

OP posts:
askingaquestion1 · 03/09/2025 23:00

I could have written your post. My husband is not close to his mum and my dad wasn’t a particularly good son to his mum. I’m one of 4 girls (very close to my sisters) and was very close to my mum until she passed. I had two boys and really wanted a daughter, probably to recreate some of my childhood. I am not proud to say when I found out I was having a 3rd boy I cried (slightly exacerbated by it being covid and alone for my scan at a stressful time to be pregnant). I really wanted a girl. But now as a mum of 3 boys, I am SO glad I have 3 boys. Yes younger boys are energetic but they are also incredibly affectionate. They are very sweet and loving-my 7 year old and 10 year old are incredibly cute with their pets. From speaking to friends, girls get very emotional with friendships from around age 7 whereas the boys seem to be friends with most boys in the class. Boys are quite simple-if they are fed, have slept and have had some exercise early on, then the day is quite easy. It’s been an adjustment to me coming from a highly female household to a living in a male dominated one but now I wouldn’t have it any other way.

LayeredlikeanOnion · 03/09/2025 22:57

Boys are wonderful. They adore their mums and its the best relationship.

IcedPurple · 03/09/2025 22:56

ChessorBuckaroo · 03/09/2025 22:53

Just to follow up on this. I said this topic ("heartbroken with a boy"), conditional love based on sex, is an English thing, but that was being too broad (for instance I couldn't imagine Scouse mums being disappointed with their sons or not being close to them throughout their life, for I know they are close). Rather this coldness applies to a certain type of English woman (who also seem to populate this site).

On the closeness of boys to their mums in Ireland, this much loved Irish electricity board advert from the 1980s (showing a son returning home while his mum is waiting for him) is indicative of that bond.

In the 'real world' outside of this forum I've not come across this anti-boy thing in England either. Maybe people won't admit it openly and will only do so in the safety of online anonymity, but I can't say I've ever encountered boys being less welcomed than girls among the British people I know.

Catherine1210 · 03/09/2025 22:56

Mustbethat · 03/09/2025 22:19

That “boy mum” life you describe sounds very much like the relationship I have with my dd.

liking the outdoors, hiking and cycling are not exclusive to boys.

this is exactly the issue.

That’s lovely you have an outdoorsy girl. I also have a step daughter who I love to spend time with but who does not embrace the same things my Sons do.

So for our family it’s very much a thing that has changed since having my Sons. It’s not exclusive to whether they are boy/girls, I was more replying saying I wanted all the “girly” moments like the OP has mentioned but now I actually embrace a new lifestyle that I share with my boys and I don’t crave what the OP has suggested having a girl is like. The OP may surprise herself and embrace things differently than what she is expecting.

LocalHobo · 03/09/2025 22:55

I think everyone is just more welcoming of their own mum. This is just an incorrect statement.
However, if this is what you model/expect it will probably be a self fulfilling prophecy.

AliasGrace47 · 03/09/2025 22:53

Quitelikeit · 03/09/2025 20:55

I was once you but believe me you will absolutely adore your little boy. They are so loving! They are different vibe to
girls as in they can be less over emotional and much more straightforward creatures!

Next has lots of beautiful cute baby boy clothes in you should check out their website!

Think of having a mini version of your husband around……

No need to bash girls as 'over emotional', tho ofc some can be. Boys are great tho, OP is being v unreasonable.

ChessorBuckaroo · 03/09/2025 22:53

ChessorBuckaroo · 03/09/2025 22:06

"Heartbroken" over your own child. God help that poor boy as he will need it.

This topic has to be an English thing as I've never come across this in Ireland. Mumsnet is predominantly made up of English users and is very anti male (I pity any man (glutton for punishment) who comes on here asking for advice) so the responses to the abomination that is "gender disappointment" will be sympathetic on here.

Boys here are cherished. They also stay very close to their mother (which clearly is not an English thing either).

To make loving your child, your own flesh and blood, conditional based on their sex. That's cold. I have sympathy towards English boys (perhaps this coldness they are subjected to would explain why they aren't close to their mums).

Just to follow up on this. I said this topic ("heartbroken with a boy"), conditional love based on sex, is an English thing, but that was being too broad (for instance I couldn't imagine Scouse mums being disappointed with their sons or not being close to them throughout their life, for I know they are close). Rather this coldness applies to a certain type of English woman (who also seem to populate this site).

On the closeness of boys to their mums in Ireland, this much loved Irish electricity board advert from the 1980s (showing a son returning home while his mum is waiting for him) is indicative of that bond.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btqSxlUJyxo

Presseddaisy · 03/09/2025 22:53

I have one of each and am so close to my son (as much as to my daughter). I have friends who have better relationships with their sons than their daughters so I think it may be more about the individual personalities than the gender.

IcedPurple · 03/09/2025 22:52

These threads appear every few weeks and they're awful. And yes, they're always about boys.

Being disappointed would be one thing but 'heartbroken'? Surely you knew when you decided to have a baby that there was a 50% chance of it being - gasp! - a boy? So yes, YABU.

Bridgetjonesheart · 03/09/2025 22:51

I voted not unreasonable. You’re just at the start of a journey and you’re allowed to voice reservations. He’ll bring his own love though and you’ll look back and wonder why you worried.

Impatient6227 · 03/09/2025 22:50

I have one of each and If im completely honest I felt a sense of disappointment when I found out my second was a girl just because i was so used to having a boy! Honestly, as soon as he arrives you'll feel guilty for ever feeling that way!

You do need to watch out for that second child energy though 😂 In my experience the stereotype about boys being boisterous are reversed. My son is relatively calm, very loving and well behaved. My daughter is absolutely wild with zero fear, but also the funniest, brightest energy.

I promise you'll feel different when he's here 😌

Dingalingping · 03/09/2025 22:49

I can relate to this as when I first found out I was having a boy, although I was over the moon, I had a twinge of wanting a girl. But now, 3 years later, I can’t fathom loving any person more in the world than my special little boy. I’m a girly type of person and also can’t imagine having a girl! Things I like - he’s a proper mummas boy and loves spending time together doing anything. He’s so loving and sweet with frequently offered cuddles and kisses, and makes us belly laugh every day with his little comments and observations of the world. He loves animals and will watch an insect on the ground for as long as we would let him, proclaiming how cute it is, bless him.
Hes full of fun and loves tickles and carrying on.

My colleague has an older teen daughter and son, and recently she took her son away for the weekend and her husband took their daughter away. ‘Gendered’ time together doesn’t need to be the status quo and a lot of the time it just comes down to shared interests etc.

Also - I have a sister and our relationship with our mum is vastly different. She calls them every day whereas I could go weeks / probably months without texting / phoning / seeing my mum. Not in a bad way, all is fine when we see each other but we just aren’t all that close. Your own behaviour and effort that you make with your children greatly affects how they will respond to you. I’m sure you will do a great job of this. Congratulations on your little boy and hope the positive posts settle your mind.

WellMaybeYouShouldntBeLivingHeeeeeeee · 03/09/2025 22:48

3pears · 03/09/2025 21:03

My teenage son still gives me a hug every day and tells me he loves me. I have a son and a daughter. Both equally loving, wonderful people.

its sad you feel heartbroken over your beautiful baby boy

My experience has been exactly like this too 💕

OP, I think/hope that when you meet your baby, you will honestly look back on this feeling you’ve been having as impossible to relate to.

Gustavo1 · 03/09/2025 22:48

Aw, as a mum of boys and girls I can tell you that having a baby boy is wonderful.

I know there is this romanticised version of life where mothers and daughters are close and mothers and sons aren’t but to be honest, that is so outdated. Simply, there is no way to know what the future holds for any family. Children grow and change and build their own lives as they become adults. How present or involved a parent is in that life is down to so many environmental factors outside of gender.

Grammarnut · 03/09/2025 22:45

A son is a son till he takes him a wife, a daughter is a daughter for the whole of her life.
An old saw with a lot of truth - but not the whole truth. There are sons who remain close to their mothers and daughters who are not.

Boys love their mums just as much as girls and can be as close. As to upbringing, raise both DC the same - sex is important but that does not mean you should treat a boy differently from a girl. A bit stereotypical to suggest boys are more boisterous, some are not, some girls are.

Tippexy · 03/09/2025 22:45

There is one of these threads Every Single Week.

About how having a healthy baby boy is the worst thing in the world.

🙄

treesocks23 · 03/09/2025 22:45

100% get what you're saying. I'm so glad I didn't find out because I would have felt the same way. I just couldn't see it. But I had my son first, and then I couldn't imagine having a girl! But then I had her and adored her, both in totally different ways. I'm so pleased I've got one of each because it stops any comparison too. My son is 19 and we are so close. He will be going out to have his own life but I love that he keeps choosing to come back and ask questions, call me when he's cooking at uni, text for no reason etc etc. We have a fab relationship. You'll love your son just the same. I promise!

Soukmyfalafel · 03/09/2025 22:44

I have two boys. Both were incredibly loving (if a bit clingy) when little. One has SLD and is still incredibly cuddly because of this. The other NT child is more distant, but I still get (reluctant) cuddles. I love our chats the most though. He is smart and sensitive (as you'd expect a girl to be) and has a wicked sense of humour. I appreciate this because other child has high needs and is non verbal. I don't mean to be patronising, but if both of your kids develop normally and don't have additional needs you are very lucky. When kids are young, there isn't a huge amount of difference between boys and girls. They need the same things and are equally as inquisitive and loving.

Dundonia · 03/09/2025 22:44

Here they are, all the needy boy moms with their lovely huggy boys 😂

The best ones are the ones like my boy is woooooonderful he hugs me allllll the time and oh yeah i have a girl she’s cool too.

TATT2 · 03/09/2025 22:42

I have a 14yo DS. He can be great fun and though he has never liked kisses, and doesn't express affection verbally, he is VERY huggy 🤗 There is never any drama or fallouts amongst his friends. They are very loyal to each other.
Personally I loved "boys toys" too, when he was little.

Rosieposy89 · 03/09/2025 22:40

Check your privilege!!! I am 2.5 years into secondary infertility. I would love my dd to have a sibling...of any kind.

Alexandrine · 03/09/2025 22:38

biscuitsandabreak · 03/09/2025 20:57

I’m normally quite sympathetic to GD threads. I do get it when the woman loves her boy(s) but just really wants to have a daughter. But … you have a DD. So really, you just … don’t want a boy at all. And yes, I do think that’s both unreasonable and unpleasant.

2nd post nails it. I’m also more sympathetic than many to most GD threads even though they are nearly always about wanting a girl - because I do appreciate that as a woman, especially if you are very close to your own mum, it can seem easier to have a girl as you expect/hope the relationship will be similar. I don’t think it always works out that way, but I do get the psychology behind it - it’s understandable to be attracted to what we feel we know and fear more what we don’t.

BUT you have already been lucky enough to have a girl! You must have known there was a 50/50 chance it would be a boy next time. You are really lucky to have a second child and to be able to give your daughter a sibling, with all the high and lows that entails whether it’s a brother or a sister.

I must admit that as a woman who feels lucky to have my only child - an amazing toddler boy as it happens, but who due to age/infertility has no hope of having any more children at all (whatever their sex), I am struggling harder to be sympathetic this time…

You’ve got your girl, please try to enjoy raising your son exactly the same way you have your daughter. Of course there will be differences, as there are between all children whatever their sex, but many would be happy to have the opportunity to appreciate those differences (or to have a second child at all - including another boy).

And don’t assume raising a son will be THAT different to your daughter. Yes, in my experience (at toddler groups and with my own son) many young boys do seem to be more “active and energetic” than the girls and I admit my son does fit that stereotype 🤣 BUT there are always exceptions. In every group there is also nearly always calmer and quieter boy/s and a hell raising/“active and energetic” girl or two as well. It really is down to personality type as well as their sex.

Wemdubz · 03/09/2025 22:38

You feel a little heartbroken about having a boy? I feel more than a little heartbroken for him.

mswales · 03/09/2025 22:37

I have an older boy and younger girl and my son is the completely sensitive loving cuddly one, whereas my daughter is totally self-sufficient and not touchy feely at all! My sister told me boys were the cuddly ones and I didn’t believe her but it’s certainly proved true for me. My nephew is 18 and still extremely cuddly with his mum.

I was also apprehensive when I found out I was having a boy but really your child's sex has no bearing on how close your relationship with them will be.

DramaLlamacchiato · 03/09/2025 22:37

Oh and my boys are 16 and 19 and they’re great. I’ve got a great relationship with them especially with my eldest who’s just a male version of myself 🤣

My sister married someone who is one of a large family of boys and the boys have always been really close to their parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread